Harden issueDataChanged with type-safe comparisons

Based on code review feedback:
- Remove unsafe type assertions that could panic
- Add robust type conversion helpers (strFrom, intFrom, equalStatus, equalIssueType)
- Support multiple numeric types for priority (int, int32, int64, float64)
- Treat empty string and nil as equal for optional fields
- Add default case to detect unknown fields (conservative)
- Add comprehensive unit tests for all edge cases
- Test coverage: enums as strings, numeric conversions, nil/empty handling

Amp-Thread-ID: https://ampcode.com/threads/T-225f8c56-0710-46e9-9db2-dbf90cf91911
Co-authored-by: Amp <amp@ampcode.com>
This commit is contained in:
Steve Yegge
2025-10-23 18:41:54 -07:00
parent 0b169312f0
commit 22cf66a416
2 changed files with 295 additions and 43 deletions

View File

@@ -15,88 +15,136 @@ import (
// issueDataChanged checks if any fields in the updates map differ from the existing issue
// Returns true if any field changed, false if all fields match
func issueDataChanged(existing *types.Issue, updates map[string]interface{}) bool {
// Helper to safely compare string values (handles empty vs nil)
strMatch := func(existingVal string, newVal interface{}) bool {
if newVal == nil {
return existingVal == ""
// Helper to safely extract string from interface (handles string and *string)
strFrom := func(v interface{}) (string, bool) {
switch t := v.(type) {
case string:
return t, true
case *string:
if t == nil {
return "", true
}
return *t, true
case nil:
return "", true
default:
return "", false
}
valStr, ok := newVal.(string)
if !ok {
return false
}
return existingVal == valStr
}
// Helper to safely compare pointer string values
ptrStrMatch := func(ptr *string, val interface{}) bool {
if val == nil {
return ptr == nil || *ptr == ""
}
valStr, ok := val.(string)
// Helper to compare string field (treats empty and nil as equal)
equalStr := func(existingVal string, newVal interface{}) bool {
s, ok := strFrom(newVal)
if !ok {
return false
return false // Type mismatch means changed
}
if ptr == nil {
return valStr == ""
return existingVal == s
}
// Helper to compare *string field (treats empty and nil as equal)
equalPtrStr := func(existing *string, newVal interface{}) bool {
s, ok := strFrom(newVal)
if !ok {
return false // Type mismatch means changed
}
if existing == nil {
return s == ""
}
return *existing == s
}
// Helper to safely extract int from interface
intFrom := func(v interface{}) (int64, bool) {
switch t := v.(type) {
case int:
return int64(t), true
case int32:
return int64(t), true
case int64:
return t, true
case float64:
// Only accept whole numbers
if t == float64(int64(t)) {
return int64(t), true
}
return 0, false
default:
return 0, false
}
}
// Helper to compare Status field
equalStatus := func(existing types.Status, newVal interface{}) bool {
switch t := newVal.(type) {
case types.Status:
return existing == t
case string:
return string(existing) == t
default:
return false // Unknown type means changed
}
}
// Helper to compare IssueType field
equalIssueType := func(existing types.IssueType, newVal interface{}) bool {
switch t := newVal.(type) {
case types.IssueType:
return existing == t
case string:
return string(existing) == t
default:
return false // Unknown type means changed
}
return *ptr == valStr
}
// Check each field in updates map
for key, newVal := range updates {
switch key {
case "title":
if existing.Title != newVal.(string) {
if !equalStr(existing.Title, newVal) {
return true
}
case "description":
if existing.Description != newVal.(string) {
if !equalStr(existing.Description, newVal) {
return true
}
case "status":
if newStatus, ok := newVal.(types.Status); ok {
if existing.Status != newStatus {
return true
}
} else if newStatusStr, ok := newVal.(string); ok {
if string(existing.Status) != newStatusStr {
return true
}
if !equalStatus(existing.Status, newVal) {
return true
}
case "priority":
if existing.Priority != newVal.(int) {
p, ok := intFrom(newVal)
if !ok || existing.Priority != int(p) {
return true
}
case "issue_type":
if newType, ok := newVal.(types.IssueType); ok {
if existing.IssueType != newType {
return true
}
} else if newTypeStr, ok := newVal.(string); ok {
if string(existing.IssueType) != newTypeStr {
return true
}
if !equalIssueType(existing.IssueType, newVal) {
return true
}
case "design":
if !strMatch(existing.Design, newVal) {
if !equalStr(existing.Design, newVal) {
return true
}
case "acceptance_criteria":
if !strMatch(existing.AcceptanceCriteria, newVal) {
if !equalStr(existing.AcceptanceCriteria, newVal) {
return true
}
case "notes":
if !strMatch(existing.Notes, newVal) {
if !equalStr(existing.Notes, newVal) {
return true
}
case "assignee":
if !strMatch(existing.Assignee, newVal) {
if !equalStr(existing.Assignee, newVal) {
return true
}
case "external_ref":
if !ptrStrMatch(existing.ExternalRef, newVal) {
if !equalPtrStr(existing.ExternalRef, newVal) {
return true
}
default:
// Unknown field - treat as changed to be conservative
// This prevents skipping updates when new fields are added
return true
}
}