fix(routing): complete bd init --contributor routing (bd-6x6g) (#1088)

Implements the missing contributor routing logic so bd init --contributor actually works. Contributors' issues automatically route to ~/.beads-planning/ while maintainers' issues stay local.
This commit is contained in:
Peter Chanthamynavong
2026-01-14 20:50:56 -08:00
committed by GitHub
parent b9d2799d29
commit 31239495f1
6 changed files with 1211 additions and 21 deletions
+103
View File
@@ -256,6 +256,26 @@ bd migrate plan-42 --to .
This creates a new issue in the target repo with a reference to the original.
## Sync Mode Interactions
Contributor routing works independently of the project repo's sync configuration. The planning repo has its own sync behavior:
| Sync Mode | Project Repo | Planning Repo | Notes |
|-----------|--------------|---------------|-------|
| **Direct** | Uses `.beads/` directly | Uses `~/.beads-planning/.beads/` | Both use direct storage, no interaction |
| **Sync-branch** | Uses separate branch for beads | Uses direct storage | Planning repo does NOT inherit `sync.branch` config |
| **No-db mode** | JSONL-only operations | Routes JSONL operations to planning repo | Planning repo still uses database |
| **Daemon mode** | Background auto-sync | Daemon bypassed for routed issues | Planning repo operations are synchronous |
| **Local-only** | No git remote | Works normally | Planning repo can have its own git remote independently |
| **External (BEADS_DIR)** | Uses separate repo via env var | BEADS_DIR takes precedence over routing | If `BEADS_DIR` is set, routing config is ignored |
### Key Principles
1. **Separate databases**: Planning repo is completely independent - it has its own `.beads/` directory
2. **No config inheritance**: Planning repo does not inherit project's `sync.branch`, `no-db`, or daemon settings
3. **BEADS_DIR precedence**: If `BEADS_DIR` environment variable is set, it overrides routing configuration
4. **Daemon bypass**: Issues routed to planning repo bypass daemon mode to avoid connection staleness
## Configuration Reference
### Contributor Setup (Recommended)
@@ -295,6 +315,89 @@ export BEADS_DIR=~/.beads-planning
bd create "My task" -p 1
```
## Troubleshooting
### Routing Not Working
**Symptom**: Issues appear in `./.beads/issues.jsonl` instead of planning repo
**Diagnosis**:
```bash
# Check routing configuration
bd config get routing.mode
bd config get routing.contributor
# Check detected role
git config beads.role # If set, this overrides auto-detection
git remote get-url --push origin # Should show HTTPS for contributors
```
**Solutions**:
1. Verify `routing.mode` is set to `auto`
2. Verify `routing.contributor` points to planning repo path
3. Check that `BEADS_DIR` is NOT set (it overrides routing)
4. If using SSH URL but want contributor behavior, set `git config beads.role contributor`
### BEADS_DIR Conflicts with Routing
**Symptom**: Warning message about BEADS_DIR overriding routing config
**Explanation**: `BEADS_DIR` environment variable takes precedence over all routing configuration. This is intentional for backward compatibility.
**Solutions**:
1. **Unset BEADS_DIR** if you want routing to work: `unset BEADS_DIR`
2. **Keep BEADS_DIR** and ignore routing config (BEADS_DIR will be used)
3. **Use explicit --repo flag** to override both: `bd create "task" -p 1 --repo /path/to/repo`
### Planning Repo Not Initialized
**Symptom**: Error when creating issue: "failed to initialize target repo"
**Diagnosis**:
```bash
ls -la ~/.beads-planning/.beads/ # Should exist
```
**Solution**:
```bash
# Reinitialize planning repo
bd init --contributor # Wizard will recreate if missing
```
### Prefix Mismatch Between Repos
**Symptom**: Planning repo issues have different prefix than expected
**Explanation**: Planning repo inherits the project repo's prefix during initialization. If you want a different prefix:
**Solution**:
```bash
# Configure planning repo prefix
cd ~/.beads-planning
bd config set db.prefix plan # Use "plan-" prefix for planning issues
cd - # Return to project repo
```
### Config Keys Not Found (Legacy)
**Symptom**: Old docs or scripts reference `contributor.auto_route` or `contributor.planning_repo`
**Explanation**: Config keys were renamed in v0.48.0:
- `contributor.auto_route` → `routing.mode` (value: `auto` or `explicit`)
- `contributor.planning_repo` → `routing.contributor`
**Solution**: Use new keys. Legacy keys still work for backward compatibility but are deprecated.
```bash
# Old (deprecated but still works)
bd config set contributor.auto_route true
bd config set contributor.planning_repo ~/.beads-planning
# New (preferred)
bd config set routing.mode auto
bd config set routing.contributor ~/.beads-planning
```
## Pollution Detection Heuristics
For `bd preflight`, we can detect pollution by checking: