johno/beads
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

docs: rewrite MOLECULES.md with workflow-first structure (bd-ul59)

Browse Source 
Completely rewrote the molecular chemistry doc to be more practical:
- Start with execution semantics (what users care about)
- TL;DR section at top with 5 key concepts
- Explain dependency types and blocking behavior
- Clarify molecules = epics (no special types needed)
- Move chemistry metaphor to secondary section
- Add common patterns (sequential, fanout, dynamic bonding)
- Keep agent pitfalls and quick reference

The doc now reads like a reference manual with examples rather than
a philosophical treatise on work composition.

Filed gt-qe9w for Gas Town docs to follow same pattern.

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Steve Yegge
2025-12-24 19:52:01 -08:00
parent 5e971bd90a
commit 5f16d10634
1 changed files with 219 additions and 235 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
docs/MOLECULES.md
+219 -235
View File
@@ -1,302 +1,286 @@
# Molecular Chemistry in Beads # Molecules: Work Graphs in Beads
This document explains beads' molecular chemistry metaphor for template-based workflows. This doc explains how beads structures and executes work. Start here if you're building workflows.
## The Layer Cake ## TL;DR
Beads has a layered architecture where each layer builds on the one below: 1. **Work = issues with dependencies.** That's it. No special types needed.
2. **Dependencies control execution.** `blocks` = sequential. No dep = parallel.
3. **Molecules are just epics.** Any epic with children is a molecule. Templates are optional.
4. **Bonding = adding dependencies.** `bd mol bond A B` creates a dependency between work graphs.
5. **Agents execute until blocked.** When all ready work is done, the workflow is complete.
## The Execution Model
### How Work Flows
An agent picks up a molecule (epic with children). They execute ready children in parallel until everything closes:
``` ```
Formulas (YAML compile-time macros) epic-root (assigned to agent)
↓ ├── child.1 (no deps → ready) ← execute in parallel
Protos (template issues, read-only) ├── child.2 (no deps → ready) ← execute in parallel
↓ ├── child.3 (needs child.1) → blocked until child.1 closes
Molecules (pour, bond, squash, burn) └── child.4 (needs child.2, child.3) → blocked until both close
↓
Epics (parent-child, dependencies) ← DATA PLANE
↓
Issues (JSONL, git-backed) ← STORAGE
``` ```
**Key insight:** Molecules work without protos. You can create ad-hoc molecules (epics with children) directly. Protos are templates FOR molecules, not the other way around. **Ready work:** `bd ready` shows issues with no open blockers.
**Blocked work:** `bd blocked` shows what's waiting.
## Phase Metaphor ### Dependency Types That Block
The chemistry metaphor uses phase transitions to describe where work lives: | Type | Semantics | Use Case |
|------|-----------|----------|
| `blocks` | B can't start until A closes | Sequencing work |
| `parent-child` | If parent blocked, children blocked | Hierarchy (children parallel by default) |
| `conditional-blocks` | B runs only if A fails | Error handling paths |
| `waits-for` | B waits for all of A's children | Fanout gates |
| Phase | State | Storage | Synced | Use Case | **Non-blocking types:** `related`, `discovered-from`, `replies-to` - these link issues without affecting execution.
|-------|-------|---------|--------|----------|
| **Solid** | Proto | `.beads/` | Yes | Reusable templates | ### Default Parallelism
| **Liquid** | Mol | `.beads/` | Yes | Persistent work |
**Children are parallel by default.** Only explicit dependencies create sequence:
```bash
# These three tasks run in PARALLEL (no deps between them)
bd create "Task A" -t task
bd create "Task B" -t task
bd create "Task C" -t task
# Add dependency to make B wait for A
bd dep add <B-id> <A-id> # B depends on A (B needs A)
```
### Multi-Day Execution
An agent works through a molecule by:
1. Getting ready work (`bd ready`)
2. Claiming it (`bd update <id> --status in_progress`)
3. Doing the work
4. Closing it (`bd close <id>`)
5. Repeat until molecule is done
If the molecule is blocked by another molecule:
- Agent either waits, or
- Agent continues into the blocking molecule (compound execution)
**Bonding enables compound execution:** When you bond molecule A to molecule B, the agent can traverse both as one logical unit of work.
## Molecules vs Epics
**They're the same thing.** A molecule is just an epic (parent + children) with workflow semantics.
| Term | Meaning | When to Use |
|------|---------|-------------|
| **Epic** | Parent issue with children | General term for hierarchical work |
| **Molecule** | Epic with execution intent | When discussing workflow traversal |
| **Proto** | Epic with `template` label | Reusable pattern (optional) |
You can create molecules without protos - just create an epic and add children:
```bash
bd create "Feature X" -t epic
bd create "Design" -t task --parent <epic-id>
bd create "Implement" -t task --parent <epic-id>
bd create "Test" -t task --parent <epic-id>
bd dep add <implement-id> <design-id> # implement needs design
bd dep add <test-id> <implement-id> # test needs implement
```
## Bonding: Connecting Work Graphs
**Bond = create a dependency between two work graphs.**
```bash
bd mol bond A B # B depends on A (sequential by default)
bd mol bond A B --type parallel # Organizational link, no blocking
bd mol bond A B --type conditional # B runs only if A fails
```
### What Bonding Does
| Operands | What Happens |
|----------|--------------|
| epic + epic | Creates dependency edge between them |
| proto + epic | Spawns proto as new issues, attaches to epic |
| proto + proto | Creates compound template |
### The Key Insight
**Bonding lets agents traverse compound workflows.** When A blocks B:
- Completing A unblocks B
- Agent can continue from A into B seamlessly
- The compound work graph can span days
This is how Gas Town runs autonomous workflows - agents follow the dependency graph, handing off between sessions, until all work closes.
## Phase Metaphor (Templates)
For reusable workflows, beads uses a chemistry metaphor:
| Phase | Name | Storage | Synced | Purpose |
|-------|------|---------|--------|---------|
| **Solid** | Proto | `.beads/` | Yes | Frozen template |
| **Liquid** | Mol | `.beads/` | Yes | Active persistent work |
| **Vapor** | Wisp | `.beads-wisp/` | No | Ephemeral operations | | **Vapor** | Wisp | `.beads-wisp/` | No | Ephemeral operations |
### Phase Transitions ### Phase Commands
```
Proto (solid) ──pour──→ Mol (liquid) # Persistent instantiation
Proto (solid) ──wisp──→ Wisp (vapor) # Ephemeral instantiation
Wisp (vapor) ──squash──→ Digest (solid) # Compress to permanent record
Wisp (vapor) ──burn──→ (nothing) # Discard without trace
```
## Core Concepts
### Protos (Templates)
A proto is an issue with the `template` label. It defines a reusable pattern of work:
```bash ```bash
# List available protos bd pour <proto> # Proto → Mol (persistent instance)
bd mol catalog bd wisp create <proto> # Proto → Wisp (ephemeral instance)
bd mol squash <id> # Mol/Wisp → Digest (permanent record)
# Show proto structure bd mol burn <id> # Wisp → nothing (discard)
bd mol show <proto-id>
``` ```
Protos can contain: ### When to Use Each Phase
- Template variables using `{{variable}}` syntax
- Hierarchical child issues (subtasks)
- Dependencies between children
### Molecules (Instances) | Use Case | Phase | Why |
|----------|-------|-----|
| Feature work | Mol (pour) | Persists across sessions, audit trail |
| Patrol cycles | Wisp | Routine, no audit value |
| One-shot ops | Wisp | Scaffolding, not the work itself |
| Important discovery during wisp | Mol (--pour) | "This matters, save it" |
A molecule is a spawned instance of a proto (or an ad-hoc epic). When you "pour" a proto, you create real issues from the template: ## Common Patterns
### Sequential Pipeline
```bash ```bash
# Pour: proto → persistent mol (liquid phase) bd create "Pipeline" -t epic
bd pour <proto-id> --var key=value bd create "Step 1" -t task --parent <pipeline>
bd create "Step 2" -t task --parent <pipeline>
# The mol lives in .beads/ and is synced with git bd create "Step 3" -t task --parent <pipeline>
bd dep add <step2> <step1>
bd dep add <step3> <step2>
``` ```
### Wisps (Ephemeral Molecules) ### Parallel Fanout with Gate
Wisps are ephemeral molecules for operational workflows that shouldn't accumulate:
```bash ```bash
# Wisp: proto → ephemeral wisp (vapor phase) bd create "Process files" -t epic
bd wisp create <proto-id> --var key=value bd create "File A" -t task --parent <epic>
bd create "File B" -t task --parent <epic>
# The wisp lives in .beads-wisp/ and is NOT synced bd create "File C" -t task --parent <epic>
bd create "Aggregate" -t task --parent <epic>
# Aggregate needs all three (waits-for gate)
bd dep add <aggregate> <fileA> --type waits-for
``` ```
Use wisps for: ### Dynamic Bonding (Christmas Ornament)
- Patrol cycles (deacon, witness)
- Health checks and monitoring
- One-shot orchestration runs
- Routine operations with no audit value
### Bonding (Combining Work) When the number of children isn't known until runtime:
The `bond` command polymorphically combines protos and molecules:
```bash ```bash
# proto + proto → compound proto (reusable template) # In a survey step, discover polecats and bond arms dynamically
bd mol bond mol-feature mol-deploy for polecat in $(gt polecat list); do
bd mol bond mol-polecat-arm $PATROL_ID --ref arm-$polecat --var name=$polecat
# proto + mol → spawn proto, attach to molecule done
bd mol bond mol-review bd-abc123
# mol + mol → join into compound molecule
bd mol bond bd-abc123 bd-def456
``` ```
Bond types: Creates:
- `sequential` (default) - B runs after A completes ```
- `parallel` - B runs alongside A patrol-x7k (wisp)
- `conditional` - B runs only if A fails ├── preflight
├── survey-workers
Phase control for bonding: │ ├── patrol-x7k.arm-ace (dynamically bonded)
```bash │ ├── patrol-x7k.arm-nux (dynamically bonded)
# Force spawn as liquid (persistent), even when attaching to wisp │ └── patrol-x7k.arm-toast (dynamically bonded)
bd mol bond mol-critical-bug wisp-patrol --pour └── aggregate (waits for all arms)
# Force spawn as vapor (ephemeral), even when attaching to mol
bd mol bond mol-temp-check bd-feature --wisp
``` ```
### Squashing (Compressing) ## Agent Pitfalls
Squash compresses a wisp's execution into a permanent digest: ### 1. Temporal Language Inverts Dependencies
**Wrong:** "Phase 1 comes before Phase 2" → `bd dep add phase1 phase2`
**Right:** "Phase 2 needs Phase 1" → `bd dep add phase2 phase1`
Use requirement language. Verify with `bd blocked`.
### 2. Assuming Order = Sequence
Numbered steps don't create sequence. Dependencies do:
```bash ```bash
# Squash wisp → permanent digest # These run in PARALLEL despite names
bd mol squash <wisp-id> bd create "Step 1" ...
bd create "Step 2" ...
bd create "Step 3" ...
# With agent-provided summary # Add deps to sequence them
bd mol squash <wisp-id> --summary "Brief description of what was done" bd dep add step2 step1
bd dep add step3 step2
# Preview what would be squashed
bd mol squash <wisp-id> --dry-run
``` ```
### Burning (Discarding) ### 3. Forgetting to Close Work
Burn deletes a wisp without creating any digest: Blocked issues stay blocked forever if their blockers aren't closed. Always close completed work:
```bash ```bash
# Delete wisp with no trace bd close <id> --reason "Done"
bd mol burn <wisp-id>
# Preview what would be deleted
bd mol burn <wisp-id> --dry-run
``` ```
## Lifecycle Patterns ### 4. Orphaned Wisps
### Patrol Cycle (Ephemeral) Wisps accumulate if not squashed/burned:
```
1. bd wisp create mol-patrol # Create ephemeral wisp
2. (execute patrol steps) # Work through children
3. bd mol squash <id> # Compress to digest
# or
bd mol burn <id> # Discard without trace
```
### Feature Work (Persistent)
```
1. bd pour mol-feature --var name=auth # Create persistent mol
2. (implement feature) # Work through children
3. bd close <children> # Complete subtasks
4. bd close <root> # Complete the feature
```
### Dynamic Bonding (Christmas Ornament Pattern)
Attach work dynamically using custom IDs:
```bash ```bash
# Spawn per-worker arms on a patrol bd wisp list # Check for orphans
bd mol bond mol-polecat-arm bd-patrol --ref arm-{{name}} --var name=ace bd mol squash <id> # Create digest
# Creates: bd-patrol.arm-ace (and children like bd-patrol.arm-ace.capture) bd mol burn <id> # Or discard
bd wisp gc # Garbage collect old wisps
``` ```
## Progress Tracking ## Layer Cake Architecture
Molecule progress is **computed, not stored**: For reference, here's how the layers stack:
- `progress.Completed` = count of closed children ```
- `progress.Total` = count of all children Formulas (YAML compile-time macros) ← optional, for complex composition
↓
Protos (template issues) ← optional, for reusable patterns
↓
Molecules (bond, squash, burn) ← workflow operations
↓
Epics (parent-child, dependencies) ← DATA PLANE (the core)
↓
Issues (JSONL, git-backed) ← STORAGE
```
This means: **Most users only need the bottom two layers.** Protos and formulas are for reusable patterns and complex composition.
- No state to get out of sync
- Dynamic fanout works automatically (new children increase Total)
- Closing children increases Completed
## Parallelism Model ## Commands Quick Reference
**Default: Parallel.** Issues without `depends_on` relationships run in parallel. ### Execution
**Opt-in Sequential:** Add blocking dependencies to create sequence:
```bash ```bash
# phase-2 depends on phase-1 (phase-1 must complete first) bd ready # What's ready to work
bd dep add phase-2 phase-1 bd blocked # What's blocked
bd update <id> --status in_progress
bd close <id>
``` ```
**Cognitive trap:** Temporal language ("Phase 1 comes before Phase 2") inverts dependencies. Think requirements: "Phase 2 **needs** Phase 1." ### Dependencies
## Common Agent Pitfalls
### 1. Temporal Language Inverting Dependencies
**Wrong thinking:** "Phase 1 comes before Phase 2" → `bd dep add phase1 phase2`
**Right thinking:** "Phase 2 needs Phase 1" → `bd dep add phase2 phase1`
**Solution:** Use requirement language, not temporal language. Verify with `bd blocked`.
### 2. Confusing Protos with Molecules
- **Proto** = Template (has `template` label, read-only pattern)
- **Molecule** = Instance (real work, created by pour/wisp)
You can create molecules without protos (ad-hoc epics). Protos are just reusable patterns.
### 3. Forgetting to Squash/Burn Wisps
Wisps accumulate in `.beads-wisp/` if not cleaned up. At session end:
```bash ```bash
bd wisp list # Check for orphaned wisps bd dep add <issue> <depends-on> # issue needs depends-on
bd mol squash <id> --summary "" # Compress to digest bd dep tree <id> # Show dependency tree
# or
bd mol burn <id> # Discard if not needed
# or
bd wisp gc # Garbage collect old wisps
``` ```
### 4. Thinking Phases Imply Sequence ### Molecules
Phases, steps, or numbered items in a plan do NOT create sequence. Only dependencies do.
```bash ```bash
# These tasks run in PARALLEL (no dependencies) bd pour <proto> --var k=v # Template → persistent mol
bd create "Step 1: Do X" ... bd wisp create <proto> # Template → ephemeral wisp
bd create "Step 2: Do Y" ... bd mol bond A B # Connect work graphs
bd create "Step 3: Do Z" ... bd mol squash <id> # Compress to digest
bd mol burn <id> # Discard without record
# Add dependencies to create sequence
bd dep add step2 step1 # step2 needs step1
bd dep add step3 step2 # step3 needs step2
``` ```
## Orphan vs Stale Matrix ## Related Docs
A molecule can be in one of four states based on two dimensions: - [CLI_REFERENCE.md](CLI_REFERENCE.md) - Full command reference
- [ARCHITECTURE.md](ARCHITECTURE.md) - System internals
| | Assigned | Unassigned | - [../CLAUDE.md](../CLAUDE.md) - Quick agent reference
|---|---|---|
| **Blocking** | Active work | Orphaned (needs pickup) |
| **Not blocking** | In progress | Stale (complete but unclosed) |
- **Orphaned:** Complete-but-unclosed molecules blocking other assigned work
- **Stale:** Complete-but-unclosed molecules not blocking anything
Graph pressure (blocking other work) determines urgency, not time.
## Commands Reference
### Proto/Template Commands
```bash
bd mol catalog # List available protos
bd mol show <id> # Show proto/molecule structure
bd mol distill <epic-id> # Extract proto from ad-hoc epic
```
### Phase Transition Commands
```bash
bd pour <proto> --var k=v # Proto → Mol (liquid)
bd wisp create <proto> --var k=v # Proto → Wisp (vapor)
bd mol squash <id> # Wisp → Digest (solid)
bd mol burn <id> # Wisp → nothing
```
### Bonding Commands
```bash
bd mol bond <A> <B> # Polymorphic combine
bd mol bond <A> <B> --type parallel
bd mol bond <A> <B> --pour # Force persistent
bd mol bond <A> <B> --wisp # Force ephemeral
bd mol bond <A> <B> --ref <ref> # Dynamic child ID
```
### Wisp Management
```bash
bd wisp list # List all wisps
bd wisp list --all # Include closed
bd wisp gc # Garbage collect orphaned wisps
bd wisp gc --age 24h # Custom age threshold
```
## Related Documentation
- [ARCHITECTURE.md](ARCHITECTURE.md) - Overall bd architecture
- [CLI_REFERENCE.md](CLI_REFERENCE.md) - Complete command reference
- [../CLAUDE.md](../CLAUDE.md) - Quick reference for agents