Separate canonical BD_GUIDE.md from AGENTS.md

Create architectural separation between bd-specific instructions and project-specific instructions.

## Problem
Currently AGENTS.md mixes:
- bd tool documentation (changes with bd upgrades)
- Project-specific workflow (stable, manually maintained)

This makes it hard to update bd instructions without touching project docs.

## Solution
1. Generate .beads/BD_GUIDE.md from 'bd onboard' output
2. Mark it as auto-generated (never manually edit)
3. Version-stamp header with bd version
4. AGENTS.md references it instead of duplicating content
5. Auto-update BD_GUIDE.md when bd version changes

## Implementation
- Add 'bd onboard --output .beads/BD_GUIDE.md' option
- Detect version changes and offer to regenerate
- Add header: '<!-- Auto-generated by bd v0.24.2 - DO NOT EDIT -->'
- Update AGENTS.md to reference BD_GUIDE.md

## Benefits
- Clear separation of concerns
- Deterministic updates (no agent LLM involved)
- Git-trackable diffs show exactly what changed
- Progressive disclosure (agents read when needed)

## Acceptance Criteria
- BD_GUIDE.md auto-generated and version-stamped
- AGENTS.md references it appropriately
- Upgrade workflow auto-updates BD_GUIDE.md
- Git diffs clearly show bd instruction changes


Write Agent Mail integration guide

Comprehensive guide for setting up and using Agent Mail with Beads.

Acceptance Criteria:
- Installation instructions
- Configuration (environment variables)
- Architecture diagram
- Benefits and tradeoffs
- When to use vs not use
- Troubleshooting section
- Migration from git-only mode

File: docs/AGENT_MAIL.md

Sections:
- Quick start
- How it works
- Integration points
- Graceful degradation
- Multi-machine deployment
- FAQ


Issue with labels


Refactor path canonicalization into helper function

The path canonicalization logic (filepath.Abs + EvalSymlinks) is duplicated in 3 places:
- beads.go:131-137 (BEADS_DIR handling)
- cmd/bd/main.go:446-451 (--no-db cleanup)
- cmd/bd/nodb.go:26-31 (--no-db initialization)

Refactoring suggestion:
Extract to a helper function like:
  func canonicalizePath(path string) string

This would:
- Reduce code duplication
- Make the logic easier to maintain
- Ensure consistent behavior across all path handling

Related to bd-e16b implementation.


Extract daemon server functions to daemon_server.go


Add `bd merge` command wrapping 3-way merge logic

Implement CLI command to invoke beads-merge functionality.

**Interface**:
```bash
bd merge <output> <base> <left> <right>
bd merge --debug <output> <base> <left> <right>
```

**Behavior**:
- Exit code 0 on clean merge
- Exit code 1 if conflicts (write conflict markers)
- Support --debug flag for verbose output
- Match beads-merge's existing behavior

**File**: `cmd/bd/merge.go`


Add 'When to use daemon mode' decision tree to daemon.md

**Problem:**
Users (especially local-only developers) see daemon-related messages but don't understand:
- What daemon mode does (git sync automation)
- Whether they need it
- Why they see "daemon_unsupported" messages

Related to issue #349 item #3.

**Current state:**
commands/daemon.md explains WHAT daemon does but not WHEN to use it.

**Proposed addition:**
Add a "When to Use Daemon Mode" section after line 20 in commands/daemon.md with clear decision criteria:

**✅ You SHOULD use daemon mode if:**
- Working in a team with git remote sync
- Want automatic commit/push of issue changes
- Need background auto-sync (5-second debounce)
- Making frequent bd commands (performance benefit)

**❌ You DON'T need daemon mode if:**
- Solo developer with local-only tracking
- Working in git worktrees (use --no-daemon)
- Running one-off commands/scripts
- Debugging database issues

**Local-only users:** Direct mode is perfectly fine. Daemon mainly helps with git sync automation. You can use `bd sync` manually when needed.

**Files to modify:**
- commands/daemon.md (add section after line 20)


UX nightmare: multiple ways daemon can fail with misleading messages


Auto-configure git merge driver during `bd init`

Enhance `bd init` to optionally set up beads-merge as git merge driver.

**Tasks**:
- Prompt user to install git merge driver
- Configure `.git/config`: `merge.beads.driver "bd merge %A %O %L %R"`
- Create/update `.gitattributes`: `.beads/beads.jsonl merge=beads`
- Add `--skip-merge-driver` flag for non-interactive use
- Update AGENTS.md onboarding section

**Files**:
- `cmd/bd/init.go`
- `.gitattributes` template


Export deduplication breaks when JSONL and export_hashes table diverge

## Problem

The export deduplication feature (timestamp-only skipping) breaks when the JSONL file and export_hashes table get out of sync, causing exports to skip issues that aren't actually in the file.

## Symptoms

- `bd export` reports "Skipped 128 issue(s) with timestamp-only changes"
- JSONL file only has 38 lines but DB has 149 issues
- export_hashes table has 149 entries
- Auto-import doesn't trigger (hash matches despite missing data)
- Two repos on same commit show different issue counts

## Root Cause

shouldSkipExport() in autoflush.go compares current issue hash with stored export_hashes entry. If they match, it skips export assuming the issue is already in the JSONL.

This assumption fails when:
1. Git operations (pull, reset, checkout) change JSONL without clearing export_hashes
2. Manual JSONL edits or corruption
3. Import operations that modify DB but don't update export_hashes
4. Partial exports that update export_hashes but don't complete

## Impact

- **Critical data loss risk**: Issues appear to be tracked but aren't persisted to git
- Breaks multi-repo sync (root cause of today's debugging session)
- Auto-import fails to detect staleness (hash matches despite missing data)
- Silent data corruption (no error messages, just missing issues)

## Reproduction

1. Have DB with 149 issues, all in export_hashes table
2. Truncate JSONL to 38 lines (simulate git reset or corruption)
3. Run `bd export` - it skips 128 issues
4. JSONL still has only 38 lines but export thinks it succeeded

## Current Workaround

```bash
sqlite3 .beads/beads.db "DELETE FROM export_hashes"
bd export -o .beads/beads.jsonl
```

## Proposed Solutions

**Option 1: Verify JSONL integrity before skipping**
- Count lines in JSONL, compare with export_hashes count
- If mismatch, clear export_hashes and force full export
- Safe but adds I/O overhead

**Option 2: Hash-based JSONL validation**
- Store hash of entire JSONL file in metadata
- Before export, check if JSONL hash matches
- If mismatch, clear export_hashes
- More efficient, detects any JSONL corruption

**Option 3: Disable timestamp-only deduplication**
- Remove the feature entirely
- Always export all issues
- Simplest and safest, but creates larger git commits

**Option 4: Clear export_hashes on git operations**
- Add post-merge hook to clear export_hashes
- Clear on any import operation
- Defensive approach but may over-clear

## Recommended Fix

Combination of Options 2 + 4:
1. Store JSONL file hash in metadata after export
2. Check hash before export, clear export_hashes if mismatch
3. Clear export_hashes on import operations
4. Add `bd validate` check for JSONL/export_hashes sync

## Files Involved

- cmd/bd/autoflush.go (shouldSkipExport)
- cmd/bd/export.go (export with deduplication)
- internal/storage/sqlite/metadata.go (export_hashes table)

## Recovery Session (2025-10-29 21:30)

### What Happened
- Created 14 new hash ID issues (bd-f8b764c9 through bd-f8b764c9.1)
- bd sync appeared to succeed
- Canonical repo (~/src/beads): 162 issues in DB + JSONL ✓
- Secondary repo (fred/beads): Only 145 issues vs 162 in canonical ✗
- Both repos on same git commit but different issue counts!

### Bug Manifestation During Recovery

1. **Initial state**: fred/beads had 145 issues, 145 lines in JSONL, 145 export_hashes entries

2. **After git reset --hard origin/main**:
   - JSONL: 162 lines (from git)
   - DB: 150 issues (auto-import partially worked)
   - Auto-import failed with UNIQUE constraint error

3. **After manual import --resolve-collisions**:
   - DB: 160 issues
   - JSONL: Still 162 lines
   - export_hashes: 159 entries

4. **After bd export**:
   - **JSONL reduced to 17 lines!** ← The bug in action
   - export_hashes: 159 entries (skipped exporting 142 issues)
   - Silent data loss - no error message

5. **After clearing export_hashes and re-export**:
   - JSONL: 159 lines (missing 3 issues still)
   - DB: 159 issues
   - Still diverged from canonical

### The Bug Loop
Once export_hashes and JSONL diverge:
- Export skips issues already in export_hashes
- But those issues aren't actually in JSONL
- This creates corrupt JSONL with missing issues
- Auto-import can't detect the problem (file hash matches what was exported)
- Data is lost with no error messages

### Recovery Solution
Couldn't break the loop with export alone. Had to:
1. Copy .beads/beads.db from canonical repo
2. Clear export_hashes
3. Full re-export
4. Finally converged to 162 issues

### Key Learnings

1. **The bug is worse than we thought**: It can create corrupt exports (17 lines instead of 162!)

2. **Auto-import can't save you**: Once export is corrupt, auto-import just imports the corrupt data

3. **Silent failure**: No warnings, no errors, just missing issues

4. **Git operations trigger it**: git reset, git pull, etc. change JSONL without clearing export_hashes

5. **Import operations populate export_hashes**: Even manual imports update export_hashes, setting up future export failures

### Immediate Action Required

**DISABLE EXPORT DEDUPLICATION NOW**

This feature is fundamentally broken and causes data loss. Should be disabled until properly fixed.

Quick fix options:
- Set environment variable to disable feature
- Comment out shouldSkipExport check
- Always clear export_hashes before export
- Add validation that DB count == JSONL line count before allowing export

### Long-term Fix

Need Option 2 + 4 from proposed solutions:
1. Store JSONL file hash after every successful export
2. Before export, verify JSONL hash matches expected
3. If mismatch, log WARNING and clear export_hashes
4. Clear export_hashes on every import operation
5. Add git post-merge hook to clear export_hashes
6. Add `bd validate` command to detect divergence


CRDT-based architecture for guaranteed convergence (v2.0)

## Vision
Redesign beads around Conflict-Free Replicated Data Types (CRDTs) to provide mathematical guarantees for N-way collision resolution at arbitrary scale.

## Current Limitations
- Content-hash based collision resolution fails at 5+ clones
- Non-deterministic convergence in multi-round scenarios
- UNIQUE constraint violations during rename operations
- No formal proof of convergence properties

## CRDT Benefits
- Provably convergent (Strong Eventual Consistency)
- Commutative/Associative/Idempotent operations
- No coordination required between clones
- Scales to 100+ concurrent workers
- Well-understood mathematical foundations

## Proposed Architecture

### 1. UUID-Based IDs
Replace sequential IDs with UUIDs:
- Current: bd-1c63eb84, bd-9063acda, bd-4d80b7b1
- CRDT: bd-a1b2c3d4-e5f6-7890-abcd-ef1234567890
- Human aliases maintained separately: #42 maps to UUID

### 2. Last-Write-Wins (LWW) Elements
Each field becomes an LWW register:
- title: (timestamp, clone_id, value)
- status: (timestamp, clone_id, value)
- Deterministic conflict resolution via Lamport timestamp + clone_id tiebreaker

### 3. Operation Log
Track all operations as CRDT ops:
- CREATE(uuid, timestamp, clone_id, fields)
- UPDATE(uuid, field, timestamp, clone_id, value)
- DELETE(uuid, timestamp, clone_id) - tombstone, not hard delete

### 4. Sync as Merge
Syncing becomes merging two CRDT states:
- No merge conflicts possible
- Deterministic merge function
- Guaranteed convergence

## Implementation Phases

### Phase 1: Research & Design (4 weeks)
- Study existing CRDT implementations (Automerge, Yjs, Loro)
- Design schema for CRDT-based issue tracking
- Prototype LWW-based Issue CRDT
- Benchmark performance vs current system

### Phase 2: Parallel Implementation (6 weeks)
- Implement CRDT storage layer alongside SQLite
- Build conversion tools: SQLite ↔ CRDT
- Maintain backward compatibility with v1.x format
- Migration path for existing databases

### Phase 3: Testing & Validation (4 weeks)
- Formal verification of convergence properties
- Stress testing with 100+ clone scenario
- Performance profiling and optimization
- Documentation and examples

### Phase 4: Migration & Rollout (4 weeks)
- Release v2.0-beta with CRDT backend
- Gradual migration from v1.x
- Monitoring and bug fixes
- Final v2.0 release

## Risks & Mitigations

**Risk 1: Performance overhead**
- Mitigation: Benchmark early, optimize hot paths
- CRDTs can be slower than append-only logs
- May need compaction strategy

**Risk 2: Storage bloat**
- Mitigation: Implement operation log compaction
- Tombstone garbage collection for deleted issues
- Periodic snapshots to reduce log size

**Risk 3: Breaking changes**
- Mitigation: Maintain v1.x compatibility layer
- Gradual migration tools
- Dual-mode operation during transition

**Risk 4: Complexity**
- Mitigation: Use battle-tested CRDT libraries
- Comprehensive documentation
- Clear migration guide

## Success Criteria
- 100-clone collision test passes without failures
- Formal proof of convergence properties
- Performance within 2x of current system
- Zero manual conflict resolution required
- Backward compatible with v1.x databases

## Timeline
18-20 weeks total (4-5 months)

## References
- Automerge: https://automerge.org
- Yjs: https://docs.yjs.dev
- Loro: https://loro.dev
- CRDT theory: Shapiro et al, A comprehensive study of CRDTs
- Related issues: bd-0dcea000, bd-4d7fca8a, bd-6221bdcd


Add sync.branch configuration

Add configuration layer to support sync.branch setting via config file, environment variable, or CLI flag.

Tasks:
- Add sync.branch field to config schema
- Add BEADS_SYNC_BRANCH environment variable
- Add --branch flag to bd init
- Add bd config get/set sync.branch commands
- Validation (branch name format, conflicts)
- Config migration for existing users

Estimated effort: 1-2 days


Delete collision resolution code

Remove ~2,100 LOC of ID collision detection and resolution code (no longer needed with hash IDs).

## Files to Delete Entirely
```
internal/storage/sqlite/collision.go              (~800 LOC)
internal/storage/sqlite/collision_test.go         (~300 LOC)
cmd/bd/autoimport_collision_test.go               (~400 LOC)
```

## Code to Remove from Existing Files

### internal/importer/importer.go
Remove:
- `DetectCollisions()` calls
- `ScoreCollisions()` logic
- `RemapCollisions()` calls
- `handleRename()` function
- All collision-related error handling

Keep:
- Basic import logic
- Exact match detection (idempotent import)

### beads_twoclone_test.go
Remove:
- `TestTwoCloneCollision` (bd-71107098)
- `TestThreeCloneCollision` (bd-cbed9619)
- `TestFiveCloneCollision` (bd-a40f374f)
- All N-way collision tests

### cmd/bd/import.go
Remove:
- `--resolve-collisions` flag
- `--dry-run` collision preview
- Collision reporting

## Issues Closed by This Change
- bd-71107098: Add test for symmetric collision
--89: Content-hash collision resolution
- bd-cbed9619: N-way collision resolution epic
- bd-cbed9619.5: Add ScoreCollisions (already done but now unnecessary)
- bd-cbed9619.4: Make DetectCollisions read-only
- bd-cbed9619.3: ResolveNWayCollisions function
- bd-cbed9619.2: Multi-round import convergence
- bd-cbed9619.1: Multi-round convergence for N-way collisions
- bd-e6d71828: Transaction + retry logic for collisions
- bd-70419816: Test case for symmetric collision

## Verification Steps
1. `grep -r "collision" --include="*.go"` → should only find alias conflicts
2. `go test ./...` → all tests pass
3. `go build ./cmd/bd` → clean build
4. Check LOC reduction: `git diff --stat`

## Expected Metrics
- **Files deleted**: 3
- **LOC removed**: ~2,100
- **Test coverage**: Should increase (less untested code)
- **Binary size**: Slightly smaller

## Caution
Do NOT delete:
- Alias conflict resolution (new code in bd-f8b764c9.6)
- Duplicate detection (bd-581b80b3, bd-149) - different from ID collisions
- Merge conflict resolution (bd-7e7ddffa.1, bd-5f483051) - git conflicts, not ID collisions

## Files to Modify
- internal/importer/importer.go (remove collision handling)
- cmd/bd/import.go (remove --resolve-collisions flag)
- beads_twoclone_test.go (remove collision tests)
- Delete: internal/storage/sqlite/collision.go
- Delete: internal/storage/sqlite/collision_test.go
- Delete: cmd/bd/autoimport_collision_test.go

## Testing
- Ensure all remaining tests pass
- Manual test: create issue on two clones, sync → no collisions
- Verify error if somehow hash collision occurs (extremely unlikely)


Create Go adapter library (optional)

For agents written in Go, provide native adapter library instead of shelling out to curl.

Acceptance Criteria:
- agentmail.Client struct
- HTTP client with timeout/retry logic
- Same API as Python adapter
- Example usage in examples/go-agent/
- Unit tests

File: pkg/agentmail/client.go

Note: Lower priority - can shell out to curl initially


Document protected branch workflow

Create comprehensive documentation for protected branch workflow.

Tasks:
- Add "Protected Branch Workflow" section to AGENTS.md
- Create docs/PROTECTED_BRANCHES.md guide
- Update README.md quick start
- Add examples to examples/protected-branch/
- Update bd init --help documentation
- Add troubleshooting guide
- Add migration guide for existing users
- Record demo video (optional)

Estimated effort: 2-3 days

Completed protected branch workflow documentation. Created comprehensive guide (docs/PROTECTED_BRANCHES.md), updated AGENTS.md with workflow section, added feature to README.md, and created working example (examples/protected-branch/). All commands verified working (bd init --branch, bd sync --status, bd sync --merge, bd config get/set sync.branch).


Add migration guide for library consumers

The contributor-workflow-analysis.md has excellent migration examples for CLI users (lines 508-549) but lacks examples for library consumers like VC that use beadsLib in Go/TypeScript code.

Library consumers need to know:
- Whether their existing code continues to work unchanged (backward compatibility)
- How config.toml is automatically read (transparent hydration)
- When and how to use explicit multi-repo configuration
- What happens if config.toml doesn't exist (defaults)

Example needed:
```go
// Before (v0.17.3)
store, err := beadsLib.NewSQLiteStorage(".beads/vc.db")

// After (v0.18.0 with multi-repo) - still works!
store, err := beadsLib.NewSQLiteStorage(".beads/vc.db")
// Automatically reads .beads/config.toml if present

// Explicit multi-repo (if needed)
cfg := beadsLib.Config{
    Primary: ".beads/vc.db",
    Additional: []string{"~/.beads-planning"},
}
store, err := beadsLib.NewStorageWithConfig(cfg)
```


Investigate and optimize test suite performance

Test suite is taking very long to run (>45s for cmd/bd tests, full suite timing unknown but was cancelled).

This impacts development velocity and CI/CD performance.

Investigation needed:
- Profile which tests are slowest
- Identify bottlenecks (disk I/O, network, excessive setup/teardown?)
- Consider parallelization opportunities
- Look for redundant test cases
- Check if integration tests can be optimized


Document bd-wasm installation and usage

Create documentation for bd-wasm:
- Update README with npm installation instructions
- Add troubleshooting section for WASM-specific issues
- Document known limitations vs native bd
- Add examples for Claude Code Web sandbox usage
- Update INSTALLING.md with bd-wasm option


Extract migration functions to migrations.go

Move migrateDirtyIssuesTable, migrateExternalRefColumn, migrateCompositeIndexes, migrateClosedAtConstraint, migrateCompactionColumns, migrateSnapshotsTable, migrateCompactionConfig, migrateCompactedAtCommitColumn, migrateExportHashesTable, migrateContentHashColumn to a separate migrations.go file


Add Claude setup tip with dynamic priority

Add a predefined tip that suggests running `bd setup claude` when Claude Code is detected but not configured. This tip should have higher priority (shown more frequently) until the setup is complete.


Add multi-repo support to export metadata updates

## Problem
The bd-ymj fix only updates metadata for the main jsonlPath, but the codebase supports multi-repo mode where exports write to multiple JSONL files.

Other daemon_sync operations handle multi-repo correctly:
- Lines 509-518: Snapshots captured for all multi-repo paths
- Lines 578-587: Deletions applied for all multi-repo paths

But metadata updates are missing!

## Investigation Needed
Metadata is stored globally in database (`last_import_hash`, `last_import_mtime`), but multi-repo has per-repo JSONL files. Current schema may not support tracking multiple JSONL files.

Options:
1. Store metadata per-repo (new schema)
2. Store combined hash of all repos
3. Document that multi-repo doesn't need this metadata (why?)

## Solution (if needed)
```go
// After export
if multiRepoPaths := getMultiRepoJSONLPaths(); multiRepoPaths != nil {
    // Multi-repo mode: update metadata for each JSONL
    for _, path := range multiRepoPaths {
        updateExportMetadata(exportCtx, store, path, log)
    }
} else {
    // Single-repo mode: update metadata for main JSONL
    updateExportMetadata(exportCtx, store, jsonlPath, log)
}
```

## Files
- cmd/bd/daemon_sync.go (createExportFunc, createSyncFunc)
- Possibly: internal/storage/sqlite/metadata.go (schema changes)

## Related
Depends on bd-ar2.1 (extract helper function first)


bd-hv01: Silent partial deletion failures cause DB inconsistency

Problem: deletion_tracking.go:76-77 logs deletion errors as warnings but continues. If deletion fails midway (database locked, disk full), some issues delete but others don't. System thinks all deletions succeeded.

Impact: Database diverges from JSONL, silent corruption, issues may resurrect on next sync.

Fix: Collect errors and fail the operation:
var deletionErrors []error
for _, id := range acceptedDeletions {
    if err := d.DeleteIssue(ctx, id); err != nil {
        deletionErrors = append(deletionErrors, fmt.Errorf("issue %s: %w", id, err))
    }
}
if len(deletionErrors) > 0 {
    return false, fmt.Errorf("deletion failures: %v", deletionErrors)
}

Files: cmd/bd/deletion_tracking.go:73-82


Add ON DELETE CASCADE to child_counters schema

Update schema.go child_counters table foreign key with ON DELETE CASCADE. When parent deleted, child counter should also be deleted. If parent is resurrected, counter gets recreated from scratch. Add migration for existing databases.


Integration Testing

Verify cache removal doesn't break any workflows


Support local-only git repos without remote origin

Daemon crashes when working with local git repos that don't have origin remote configured. Should gracefully degrade to local-only mode: skip git pull/push operations but maintain daemon features (RPC server, auto-flush, JSONL export).


Add migration registry and simplify New()

Create migrations.go with Migration type and registry. Change New() to: openDB -> initSchema -> RunMigrations(db). This removes 8+ separate migrate functions from New().


Run final validation and cleanup checks

Final validation pass to ensure all cleanup objectives met and no regressions introduced.

Validation checklist:
1. Dead code verification: `go run golang.org/x/tools/cmd/deadcode@latest -test ./...`
2. Test coverage: `go test -cover ./...`
3. Build verification: `go build ./cmd/bd/`
4. Linting: `golangci-lint run`
5. Integration tests
6. Metrics verification
7. Git clean check

Final metrics to report:
- LOC removed: ~____
- Files deleted: ____
- Files created: ____
- Test coverage: ____%
- Build time: ____ (before/after)
- Test run time: ____ (before/after)

Impact: Confirms all cleanup objectives achieved successfully

## Validation Results (Oct 31, 2025)

**Dead Code:** ✅ Removed 5 unreachable functions (~200 LOC)
- computeIssueContentHash, shouldSkipExport (autoflush.go)
- addDependencyUnchecked, removeDependencyIfExists (dependencies.go)
- isUniqueConstraintError (util.go)

**Tests:** ✅ All pass
**Coverage:**
- Main package: 39.6%
- cmd/bd: 19.5%
- internal/daemon: 37.8%
- internal/storage/sqlite: 58.1%
- internal/rpc: 58.6%

**Build:** ✅ Clean (24.5 MB binary)
**Linting:** 247 issues (mostly errcheck on defer/Close statements)
**Integration Tests:** ✅ All pass
**Metrics:** 55,622 LOC across 200 Go files
**Git:** 3 files modified (dead code removal)


Need comprehensive daemon health check command (bd daemon doctor?)


Clean up linter errors (914 total issues)

The codebase has 914 linter issues reported by golangci-lint. While many are documented as baseline in LINTING.md, we should clean these up systematically to improve code quality and maintainability.

Reduced from 56 to 41 issues locally, then to 0 issues.

**Fixed in commits:**
- c2c7eda: Fixed 15 actual errors (dupl, gosec, revive, staticcheck, unparam)
- 963181d: Configured exclusions to get to 0 issues locally

**Current status:**
- ✅ Local: golangci-lint reports 0 issues
- ❌ CI: Still failing (see [deleted:bd-cb64c226.1])

**Problem:**
Config v2 format or golangci-lint-action@v8 compatibility issue causing CI to fail despite local success.

**Next:** Debug [deleted:bd-cb64c226.1] to fix CI/local discrepancy


Test issue 1


Add label-based filtering to bd ready command

Allow filtering ready work by labels to help organize work by sprint, week, or category.

Example usage:
  bd ready --label week1-2
  bd ready --label frontend,high-priority

This helps teams organize work into batches and makes it easier for agents to focus on specific categories of work.

Implementation notes:
- Add --label flag to ready command
- Support comma-separated labels (AND logic)
- Should work with existing ready work logic (unblocked issues)


Add TestNWayCollision for 5+ clones

## Overview
Add comprehensive tests for N-way (5+) collision resolution to verify the solution scales beyond 3 clones.

## Purpose
While TestThreeCloneCollision validates the basic N-way case, we need to verify:
1. Solution scales to arbitrary N
2. Performance is acceptable with more clones
3. Convergence time is bounded
4. No edge cases in larger collision groups

## Implementation Tasks

### 1. Create TestFiveCloneCollision
File: beads_twoclone_test.go (or new beads_nway_test.go)

```go
func TestFiveCloneCollision(t *testing.T) {
    // Test with 5 clones creating same ID with different content
    // Verify all 5 clones converge after sync rounds

    t.Run("SequentialSync", func(t *testing.T) {
        testNCloneCollision(t, 5, "A", "B", "C", "D", "E")
    })

    t.Run("ReverseSync", func(t *testing.T) {
        testNCloneCollision(t, 5, "E", "D", "C", "B", "A")
    })

    t.Run("RandomSync", func(t *testing.T) {
        testNCloneCollision(t, 5, "C", "A", "E", "B", "D")
    })
}
```

### 2. Implement generalized testNCloneCollision
Generalize the 3-clone test to handle arbitrary N:

```go
func testNCloneCollision(t *testing.T, numClones int, syncOrder ...string) {
    t.Helper()

    if len(syncOrder) != numClones {
        t.Fatalf("syncOrder length (%d) must match numClones (%d)",
            len(syncOrder), numClones)
    }

    tmpDir := t.TempDir()

    // Setup remote and N clones
    remoteDir := setupBareRepo(t, tmpDir)
    cloneDirs := make(map[string]string)

    for i := 0; i < numClones; i++ {
        name := string(rune('A' + i))
        cloneDirs[name] = setupClone(t, tmpDir, remoteDir, name)
    }

    // Each clone creates issue with same ID but different content
    for name, dir := range cloneDirs {
        createIssue(t, dir, fmt.Sprintf("Issue from clone %s", name))
    }

    // Sync in specified order
    for _, name := range syncOrder {
        syncClone(t, cloneDirs[name], name)
    }

    // Final pull for convergence
    for name, dir := range cloneDirs {
        finalPull(t, dir, name)
    }

    // Verify all clones have all N issues
    expectedTitles := make(map[string]bool)
    for i := 0; i < numClones; i++ {
        name := string(rune('A' + i))
        expectedTitles[fmt.Sprintf("Issue from clone %s", name)] = true
    }

    for name, dir := range cloneDirs {
        titles := getTitles(t, dir)
        if !compareTitleSets(titles, expectedTitles) {
            t.Errorf("Clone %s missing issues: expected %v, got %v",
                name, expectedTitles, titles)
        }
    }

    t.Log("✓ All", numClones, "clones converged successfully")
}
```

### 3. Add performance benchmarks
Test convergence time and memory usage:

```go
func BenchmarkNWayCollision(b *testing.B) {
    for _, n := range []int{3, 5, 10, 20} {
        b.Run(fmt.Sprintf("N=%d", n), func(b *testing.B) {
            for i := 0; i < b.N; i++ {
                // Run N-way collision and measure time
                testNCloneCollisionBench(b, n)
            }
        })
    }
}
```

### 4. Add convergence time tests
Verify bounded convergence:

```go
func TestConvergenceTime(t *testing.T) {
    // Test that convergence happens within expected rounds
    // For N clones, should converge in at most N-1 sync rounds

    for n := 3; n <= 10; n++ {
        t.Run(fmt.Sprintf("N=%d", n), func(t *testing.T) {
            rounds := measureConvergenceRounds(t, n)
            maxExpected := n - 1
            if rounds > maxExpected {
                t.Errorf("Convergence took %d rounds, expected ≤ %d",
                    rounds, maxExpected)
            }
        })
    }
}
```

### 5. Add edge case tests
Test boundary conditions:
- All N clones have identical content (dedup works)
- N-1 clones have same content, 1 differs
- All N clones have unique content
- Mix of collisions and non-collisions

## Acceptance Criteria
- TestFiveCloneCollision passes with all sync orders
- All 5 clones converge to identical content
- Performance is acceptable (< 5 seconds for 5 clones)
- Convergence time is bounded (≤ N-1 rounds)
- Edge cases handled correctly
- Benchmarks show scalability to 10+ clones

## Files to Create/Modify
- beads_twoclone_test.go or beads_nway_test.go
- Add helper functions for N-clone setup

## Testing Strategy

### Test Matrix
| N Clones | Sync Orders | Expected Result |
|----------|-------------|-----------------|
| 3        | A→B→C       | Pass            |
| 3        | C→B→A       | Pass            |
| 5        | A→B→C→D→E   | Pass            |
| 5        | E→D→C→B→A   | Pass            |
| 5        | Random      | Pass            |
| 10       | Sequential  | Pass            |

### Performance Targets
- 3 clones: < 2 seconds
- 5 clones: < 5 seconds
- 10 clones: < 15 seconds

## Dependencies
- Requires bd-cbed9619.5, bd-cbed9619.4, bd-cbed9619.3, bd-dcd6f14b to be completed
- TestThreeCloneCollision must pass first

## Success Metrics
- All tests pass for N ∈ {3, 5, 10}
- Convergence time scales linearly (O(N))
- Memory usage reasonable (< 100MB for 10 clones)
- No data corruption or loss in any scenario


Update LINTING.md with current baseline

After cleanup, document the remaining acceptable baseline in LINTING.md so we can track regression.


Document -short flag in testing guide

Add documentation about the -short flag and how it's used to skip slow tests. Should explain that developers can run 'go test -short ./...' for fast iteration and 'go test ./...' for full coverage.


Cache getMultiRepoJSONLPaths() result during sync to avoid redundant calls

From bd-xo6b code review: getMultiRepoJSONLPaths() is called 3x per sync cycle.

**Current behavior:**
daemon_sync.go calls getMultiRepoJSONLPaths() three times per sync:
- Line 505: Snapshot capture before pull
- Line 575: Merge/prune after pull
- Line 613: Base snapshot update after import

**Cost per call:**
- Config lookup (likely cached, but still overhead)
- Path construction: O(N) where N = number of repos
- String allocations: (N + 1) × filepath.Join() calls

**Total per sync:** 3N path constructions + 3 config lookups + 3 slice allocations

**Impact:**
- For N=3 repos: Negligible (< 1ms)
- For N=10 repos: Still minimal
- For N=100+ repos: Wasteful

**Solution:**
Call once at sync start, reuse result:

```go
func createSyncFunc(...) func() {
    return func() {
        // ... existing setup ...

        // Call once at start
        multiRepoPaths := getMultiRepoJSONLPaths()

        // Snapshot capture
        if multiRepoPaths != nil {
            for _, path := range multiRepoPaths {
                if err := captureLeftSnapshot(path); err != nil { ... }
            }
        }

        // ... later ...

        // Merge/prune - reuse same paths
        if multiRepoPaths != nil {
            for _, path := range multiRepoPaths { ... }
        }

        // ... later ...

        // Base snapshot update - reuse same paths
        if multiRepoPaths != nil {
            for _, path := range multiRepoPaths { ... }
        }
    }
}
```

**Files:**
- cmd/bd/daemon_sync.go:449-636 (createSyncFunc)

**Note:** This is a performance optimization, not a correctness fix. Low priority unless multi-repo usage scales significantly.


Measure notification latency vs git sync

Benchmark end-to-end latency for status updates to propagate between agents using both methods.

Acceptance Criteria:
- Measure git sync latency (commit → push → pull → import)
- Measure Agent Mail latency (send_message → fetch_inbox)
- Document latency distribution (p50, p95, p99)
- Verify <100ms claim for Agent Mail
- Compare against 1-5s baseline for git

Success Metric: Agent Mail latency < 100ms, git sync latency > 1000ms

Latency benchmark completed. Results documented in latency_results.md:
- Git sync: 2000-5000ms (full cycle with network)
- Agent Mail: <100ms (HTTP API round-trip)
- Confirms 20-50x latency reduction claim


Update Metrics and Health Endpoints

Remove cache-related metrics from health/metrics endpoints


Improve Beads test coverage from 46% to 80%


CLI accepts both hash IDs and aliases

Update all CLI commands to accept both hash IDs (bd-af78e9a2) and aliases (#42, or just 42).

## Parsing Logic
```go
// internal/utils/id_parser.go
func ParseIssueID(input string) (issueID string, err error) {
    // Hash ID: bd-af78e9a2
    if strings.HasPrefix(input, "bd-") {
        return input, nil
    }

    // Alias: #42 or 42
    aliasStr := strings.TrimPrefix(input, "#")
    alias, err := strconv.Atoi(aliasStr)
    if err != nil {
        return "", fmt.Errorf("invalid issue ID: %s", input)
    }

    // Resolve alias to hash ID
    return storage.GetIssueIDByAlias(alias)
}
```

## Commands to Update
All commands that accept issue IDs:

### 1. bd show
```bash
bd show bd-af78e9a2        # Hash ID
bd show #42                # Alias
bd show 42                 # Alias (shorthand)
bd show bd-af78e9a2 #42    # Mixed (multiple IDs)
```

### 2. bd update
```bash
bd update #42 --status in_progress
bd update bd-af78e9a2 --priority 1
```

### 3. bd close
```bash
bd close #42 --reason "Done"
```

### 4. bd dep add/tree
```bash
bd dep add #42 #1 --type blocks
bd dep tree bd-af78e9a2
```

### 5. bd label add/remove
```bash
bd label add #42 critical
```

### 6. bd merge
```bash
bd merge #42 #43 --into #41
```

## Display Format
Default to showing aliases in output:
```bash
$ bd list
#1   Fix authentication bug          P1  open
#2   Add logging to daemon           P2  open
#42  Investigate jujutsu integration P3  open
```

With `--format=hash` flag:
```bash
$ bd list --format=hash
bd-af78e9a2  Fix authentication bug          P1  open
bd-e5f6a7b8  Add logging to daemon           P2  open
bd-1a2b3c4d  Investigate jujutsu integration P3  open
```

## Files to Modify
- internal/utils/id_parser.go (new)
- cmd/bd/show.go
- cmd/bd/update.go
- cmd/bd/close.go
- cmd/bd/reopen.go
- cmd/bd/dep.go
- cmd/bd/label.go
- cmd/bd/merge.go
- cmd/bd/list.go (add --format flag)

## Testing
- Test hash ID parsing
- Test alias parsing (#42, 42)
- Test mixed IDs in single command
- Test error on invalid ID
- Test alias resolution failure


Auto-migrate database on CLI version bump

When CLI is upgraded (e.g., 0.24.0 → 0.24.1), database version becomes stale. Add auto-migration in PersistentPreRun or daemon startup. Check dbVersion != CLIVersion and run bd migrate automatically. Fixes recurring UX issue where bd doctor shows version mismatch after every CLI upgrade.


Add date and priority filters to bd search

Add filter parity with bd list for consistent querying.

**Missing filters to add:**
- --priority, --priority-min, --priority-max
- --created-after, --created-before
- --updated-after, --updated-before
- --closed-after, --closed-before
- --empty-description, --no-assignee, --no-labels
- --desc-contains, --notes-contains

**Files to modify:**
- cmd/bd/search.go
- internal/rpc/protocol.go (SearchArgs)
- internal/storage/storage.go (Search method)

**Testing:**
- All filter combinations
- Date format parsing
- Daemon and direct mode


Makefile Integration for Benchmarks

Add a single 'bench' target to the Makefile for running performance benchmarks.

Target:
.PHONY: bench

bench:
	go test -bench=. -benchtime=3s -tags=bench \
		-cpuprofile=cpu.prof -memprofile=mem.prof \
		./internal/storage/sqlite/
	@echo ""
	@echo "Profiles generated. View flamegraph:"
	@echo "  go tool pprof -http=:8080 cpu.prof"

Features:
- Single simple target, no complexity
- Always generates CPU and memory profiles
- Clear output on how to view results
- 3 second benchmark time for reliable results
- Uses bench build tag for heavy benchmarks

Usage:
  make bench                              # Run all benchmarks
  go test -bench=BenchmarkGetReadyWork... # Run specific benchmark


Add security tests for WriteFile permissions in doctor command

Test coverage gap identified by automated analysis (vc-217).

**Original Issue:** [deleted:[deleted:bd-da96-baseline-lint]]

In cmd/bd/doctor/gitignore.go:98, os.WriteFile uses 0644 permissions, flagged by gosec G306 as potentially too permissive.

Add tests to verify:
- File is created with appropriate permissions (0600 or less)
- Existing file permissions are not loosened
- File ownership is correct
- Sensitive data handling if .gitignore contains secrets

This ensures .gitignore files are created with secure permissions to prevent unauthorized access.

_This issue was automatically created by AI test coverage analysis._


Help agents understand version changes with bd info --whats-new

**Problem** (from GH Discussion #239 by @maphew):
Weekly major versions mean agents need to adapt workflows, but currently there's no efficient way to communicate "what changed that affects you."

**Proposed solutions:**

1. **bd info --whats-new** - Show agent-actionable changes since last version
   ```
   Since v0.20.1:
   • Hash IDs eliminate collisions - remove ID coordination workarounds
   • Event-driven daemon (opt-in) - add BEADS_DAEMON_MODE=events
   • Merge driver auto-configured - conflicts rarer
   ```

2. **Version-aware bd onboard** - Detect version changes and show diff of agent-relevant changes

3. **AGENTS.md top section** - "🆕 Recent Changes (Last 3 Versions)" with workflow impacts

**Why agents need this:**
- Raw CHANGELOG is token-heavy and buried in release details
- Full bd onboard re-run wasteful if only 2-3 things changed
- Currently requires user to manually explain updates

**Related:** https://github.com/steveyegge/beads/discussions/239


bd doctor should recommend bd prime migration for existing repos

bd doctor should detect old beads integration patterns and recommend migrating to bd prime approach.

## Current behavior
- bd doctor checks if Claude hooks are installed globally
- Doesn't check project-level integration (AGENTS.md, CLAUDE.md)
- Doesn't recommend migration for repos using old patterns

## Desired behavior
bd doctor should detect and suggest:

1. **Old slash command pattern detected**
   - Check for /beads:* references in AGENTS.md, CLAUDE.md
   - Suggest: These slash commands are deprecated, use bd prime hooks instead

2. **No agent documentation**
   - Check if AGENTS.md or CLAUDE.md exists
   - Suggest: Run 'bd onboard' or 'bd setup claude' to document workflow

3. **Old MCP-only pattern**
   - Check for instructions to use MCP tools but no bd prime hooks
   - Suggest: Add bd prime hooks for better token efficiency

4. **Migration path**
   - Show: 'Run bd setup claude to add SessionStart/PreCompact hooks'
   - Show: 'Update AGENTS.md to reference bd prime instead of slash commands'

## Example output

⚠ Warning: Old beads integration detected in CLAUDE.md
  Found: /beads:* slash command references (deprecated)
  Recommend: Migrate to bd prime hooks for better token efficiency
  Fix: Run 'bd setup claude' and update CLAUDE.md

💡 Tip: bd prime + hooks reduces token usage by 80-99% vs slash commands
  MCP mode: ~50 tokens vs ~10.5k for full MCP scan
  CLI mode: ~1-2k tokens with automatic context recovery

## Benefits
- Helps existing repos adopt new best practices
- Clear migration path for users
- Better token efficiency messaging


Add external_ref change tracking and auditing

Currently we don't track when external_ref is added, removed, or changed. This would be useful for debugging and auditing.

Proposed features:
- Log event when external_ref changes
- Track in events table with old/new values
- Add query to find issues where external_ref changed
- Add metrics: issues with external_ref vs without

Use cases:
- Debugging import issues
- Understanding which issues are externally managed
- Auditing external system linkage

Related: bd-1022


Test parent issue


Auto-repair stale merge driver configs with invalid placeholders

Old bd versions (<0.24.0) installed merge driver with invalid placeholders %L %R instead of %A %B. Add detection to bd doctor --fix: check if git config merge.beads.driver contains %L or %R, auto-repair to 'bd merge %A %O %A %B'. One-time migration for users who initialized with old versions.


Rapid 2


bd doctor should validate metadata.json version tracking

bd doctor should check that metadata.json has the LastBdVersion field and that it's valid.

Checks to add:
- metadata.json exists and is valid JSON
- LastBdVersion field is present
- LastBdVersion is a valid semver-like string (or empty on first run)
- Optionally warn if LastBdVersion is very old (> 10 versions behind)

This helps ensure version tracking (bd-loka) is working correctly.

Related: bd-loka


Refactor daemon.go into internal/daemonrunner

Extract daemon runtime from daemon.go (1,565 lines) into internal/daemonrunner with focused modules: config.go, daemon.go, process.go, rpc_server.go, sync.go, git.go. Keep cobra command thin.


Publish official devcontainer configuration

Devcontainer configuration implemented. Manual testing required in actual devcontainer environment (Codespaces or VSCode Remote Containers). All code changes complete, tests pass, linting clean.


Make two-clone workflow actually work (no hacks)

TestTwoCloneCollision proves beads CANNOT handle two independent clones filing issues simultaneously. This is the basic collaborative workflow and it must work cleanly.

Test location: beads_twoclone_test.go

The test creates two git clones, both file issues with same ID (test-1), --resolve-collisions remaps clone B's to test-2, but after sync:
- Clone A has test-1="Issue from clone A", test-2="Issue from clone B"
- Clone B has test-1="Issue from clone B", test-2="Issue from clone A"

The TITLES are swapped! Both clones have 2 issues but with opposite title assignments.

We've tried many fixes (per-project daemons, auto-sync, lamport hashing, precommit hooks) but nothing has made the test pass.

Goal: Make the test pass WITHOUT hacks. The two clones should converge to identical state after sync.

**Major progress achieved!** The two-clone workflow now converges correctly.

**What was fixed:**
--3d844c58: Implemented content-hash based rename detection
- bd-64c05d00.1: Fixed test to compare content not timestamps
- Both clones now converge to identical issue databases
- test-1 and test-2 have correct titles in both clones
- No more title swapping!

**Current status (VERIFIED):**
✅ Acceptance criteria 1: TestTwoCloneCollision passes (confirmed Oct 28)
✅ Acceptance criteria 2: Both clones converge to identical issue database (content matches)
✅ Acceptance criteria 3: No manual conflict resolution required (automatic)
✅ Acceptance criteria 4: Git status clean
✅ Acceptance criteria 5: bd ready output identical (timestamps are expected difference)

**ALL ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA MET!** This issue is complete and can be closed.


Add circular dependency detection to bd doctor

Added cycle detection as Check #10 in bd doctor command. Uses same recursive CTE query as DetectCycles() to find circular dependencies. Reports error status with count and fix suggestion if cycles found.


Fix Nix flake build test failures

Nix build is failing during test phase with same test errors as Windows.

**Error:**
```
error: Cannot build '/nix/store/rgyi1j44dm6ylrzlg2h3z97axmfq9hzr-beads-0.9.9.drv'.
Reason: builder failed with exit code 1.
FAIL github.com/steveyegge/beads/cmd/bd 16.141s
```

This may be related to test environment setup or the same issues affecting Windows tests.


Add built-in version tracking to bd

Enhance bd to automatically track its own version in metadata.json and detect upgrades.

## Features to Implement
1. Auto-update metadata.json with 'last_bd_version' field on every bd command
2. Add 'bd upgrade status' - check if version changed since last run
3. Add 'bd upgrade review' - show what's new since last-seen version (not just last 3)
4. Add 'bd upgrade ack' - mark current version as acknowledged
5. Smart detection output when version changes (show hint on bd ready, bd list, etc.)

## Implementation Details
- Store last_bd_version in metadata.json
- Store last_version_check timestamp
- Compare on every bd command (cached check, low overhead)
- Only show notification once per session until ack'd

## Example Output
```
$ bd ready
🔄 bd upgraded from v0.23.0 to v0.24.2 since last use
💡 Run 'bd upgrade review' to see what changed

Ready work: 5 issues
...
```

## Acceptance Criteria
- Version automatically tracked in metadata.json
- Upgrade detection works across sessions
- New bd upgrade subcommands functional
- Non-intrusive notifications (show once, then quiet)


Fix `bd sync` failure due to daemon auto-export timestamp skew

`bd sync` fails with false-positive "JSONL is newer than database" after daemon auto-export.
Root Cause: Daemon exports local changes to JSONL, updating its timestamp. `bd sync` sees JSONL.mtime > DB.mtime and assumes external changes, blocking export.
Proposed Fixes:
1. `bd sync` auto-imports if timestamp matches but content differs (or just auto-imports).
2. Content-based comparison instead of timestamp only.


Fix row iterator resource leak in recursive dependency queries

Critical resource leak in findAllDependentsRecursive() where rows.Close() is called AFTER early return on error, never executing.

Location: internal/storage/sqlite/sqlite.go:1131-1136

Problem:
- rows.Close() placed after return statement
- On scan error, iterator never closed
- Can exhaust SQLite connections under moderate load

Fix: Move defer rows.Close() to execute on all code paths

Impact: Connection exhaustion during dependency traversal


Document CLI + hooks as recommended approach over MCP

Update documentation to position CLI + bd prime hooks as the primary recommended approach over MCP server, explaining why minimizing context matters even with large context windows (compute cost, energy, environment, latency).


Use -short flag in CI for PR checks

Update CI configuration to use -short flag for PR checks, run full tests nightly.

The slow tests already support testing.Short() and will be skipped.

Expected savings: ~20 seconds for PR checks (fast tests only)

Implementation:
- Update .github/workflows/ci.yml to add -short flag for PR tests
- Create/update nightly workflow for full test runs
- Update README/docs about test strategy

File: .github/workflows/ci.yml:30


Debug test 2


Phase 2: Implement sandbox auto-detection for GH #353

Implement automatic sandbox detection to improve UX for users in sandboxed environments (e.g., Codex).

**Tasks:**
1. Implement sandbox detection heuristic using syscall.Kill permission checks
2. Auto-enable --sandbox mode when sandbox is detected
3. Display informative message when sandbox is detected

**Implementation:**
- Add isSandboxed() function in cmd/bd/main.go
- Auto-set sandboxMode = true in PersistentPreRun when detected
- Show: 'ℹ  Sandbox detected, using direct mode'

**References:**
- docs/GH353_INVESTIGATION.md (Solution 3, lines 120-160)
- Depends on: Phase 1 (bd-???)

**Acceptance Criteria:**
- Codex users don't need to manually specify --sandbox
- No false positives in normal environments
- Clear messaging when auto-detection triggers


Complete remaining sync branch daemon tests

4 remaining test scenarios in daemon_sync_branch_test.go need completion:

⚠ MINOR FIXES (apply same pattern as TestSyncBranchCommitAndPush_Success):
1. TestSyncBranchCommitAndPush_NoChanges
   - Reorder: call initMainBranch() BEFORE creating JSONL
   - Pattern: init branch → create issue → export JSONL → test

2. TestSyncBranchCommitAndPush_WorktreeHealthCheck
   - Same reordering needed
   - Verify worktree corruption detection and auto-repair

🔧 MORE WORK NEEDED (remote branch setup):
3. TestSyncBranchPull_Success
   - Issue: remote doesn't have sync branch after push
   - Need to verify branch is pushed to remote correctly
   - Then test pull from clone2

4. TestSyncBranchIntegration_EndToEnd
   - Full workflow: Agent A commits → Agent B pulls → Agent B commits → Agent A pulls
   - Same remote branch issue

Pattern to apply (from TestSyncBranchCommitAndPush_Success):
- Call initMainBranch(t, dir) BEFORE creating issues/JSONL
- This ensures sync branch worktree has changes to commit

Acceptance:
- All 7 tests pass
- go test -v -run TestSyncBranch ./cmd/bd/ succeeds


Test parent issue


Address gosec security warnings (102 issues)

Security linter warnings: file permissions (0755 should be 0750), G304 file inclusion via variable, G204 subprocess launches. Many are false positives but should be reviewed.


Pre-push hook and daemon export produce different JSONL

After committing and pushing, git status shows .beads/beads.jsonl as dirty. Investigation shows:

1. Pre-push hook ran successfully and exported DB → JSONL
2. Push completed
3. Shortly after, daemon exported DB → JSONL again with different content
4. Diff shows comments added to old issues (bd-23a8, bd-6049, bd-87a0)

Timeline:
- Commit c731c45 "Update beads JSONL"
- Pre-push hook exported JSONL
- Push succeeded
- Daemon PID 33314 exported again with different content

Questions:
1. Did someone run a command between commit and daemon export?
2. Is there a timing issue where pre-push hook doesn't capture all DB changes?
3. Should pre-commit hook flush daemon changes before committing?

The comments appear to be from Nov 5 (created_at: 2025-11-05T08:38:46Z) but are only appearing in JSONL now. This suggests the DB had these comments but they weren't exported during pre-push.

Possible causes:
- Pre-push hook uses BEADS_NO_DAEMON=1 which might skip pending writes
- Daemon has unflushed changes in memory
- Race condition between pre-push export and daemon's periodic export

Improved fix based on oracle code review:
1. Pre-push now flushes pending changes first (prevents debounce race)
2. Uses git status --porcelain to catch all change types
3. Handles both beads.jsonl and issues.jsonl
4. Works even if bd not installed (git-only check)


Add template support for issue creation

Support creating issues from predefined templates to streamline common workflows like epics, bug reports, or feature proposals.

Example usage:
  bd create --from-template epic "Phase 3 Features"
  bd create --from-template bug "Login failure"
  bd template list
  bd template create epic

Templates should include:
- Pre-filled description structure
- Suggested priority and type
- Common labels
- Design/acceptance criteria sections

Implementation notes:
- Store templates in .beads/templates/ directory
- Support YAML or JSON format
- Ship with built-in templates (epic, bug, feature)
- Allow custom project-specific templates


Document code review findings for bd-0a43 refactoring

Code review completed successfully with minor suggestions for future improvements


Daemon crash recovery: panic handler + socket cleanup

Improve daemon cleanup on unexpected exit:
1. Add top-level recover() in runDaemonLoop to capture panics
2. Write daemon-error file with stack trace on panic
3. Prefer return over os.Exit where possible (so defers run)
4. In stopDaemon forced-kill path, also remove stale socket if present

This ensures better diagnostics and cleaner state after crashes.


Import overwrites newer local issues with older remote versions

## Problem

During git pull + import, local issues with newer updated_at timestamps get overwritten by older versions from remote JSONL.

## What Happened

Timeline:
1. 17:52 - Closed bd-df190564 and bd-b501fcc1 locally (updated_at: 2025-10-31)
2. 17:51 - Remote pushed same issues with status=open (updated_at: 2025-10-30)
3. 17:52 - Local sync pulled remote commit and imported JSONL
4. Result: Issues reverted to open despite local version being newer

## Root Cause

DetectCollisions (internal/storage/sqlite/collision.go:67-79) compares fields but doesn't check timestamps:

```go
conflictingFields := compareIssues(existing, incoming)
if len(conflictingFields) == 0 {
    result.ExactMatches = append(result.ExactMatches, incoming.ID)
} else {
    // Same ID, different content - treats as UPDATE
    result.Collisions = append(result.Collisions, &CollisionDetail{...})
}
```

Import applies incoming version regardless of which is newer.

## Expected Behavior

Import should:
1. Compare updated_at timestamps when collision detected
2. Skip update if local version is newer
3. Apply update only if remote version is newer
4. Warn on timestamp conflicts

## Solution

Add timestamp checking to DetectCollisions or importIssues:

```go
if len(conflictingFields) > 0 {
    // Check timestamps
    if !incoming.UpdatedAt.After(existing.UpdatedAt) {
        // Local is newer or same - skip update
        result.ExactMatches = append(result.ExactMatches, incoming.ID)
        continue
    }
    // Remote is newer - apply update
    result.Collisions = append(result.Collisions, &CollisionDetail{...})
}
```

## Files
- internal/storage/sqlite/collision.go
- internal/importer/importer.go

## References
- Discovered during bd-df190564, bd-b501fcc1 re-opening


Debug MCP Agent Mail tool execution errors

**EXTERNAL WORK**: Debug the standalone MCP Agent Mail server (separate from beads integration).

The Agent Mail server runs as an independent service at ~/src/mcp_agent_mail. This is NOT beads code - it's a separate GitHub project we're evaluating for optional coordination features.

Current Issue:
- MCP API endpoint returns errors when calling ensure_project tool
- Error: "Server encountered an unexpected error while executing tool"
- Core HTTP server works, web UI functional, but tool wrapper layer fails

Server Details:
- Location: ~/src/mcp_agent_mail (separate repo)
- Repository: https://github.com/Dicklesworthstone/mcp_agent_mail
- Runs on: http://127.0.0.1:8765
- Bearer token: In .env file

Investigation Steps:
1. Check tool execution logs for full stack trace
2. Verify Git storage initialization at ~/.mcp_agent_mail_git_mailbox_repo
3. Review database setup (storage.sqlite3)
4. Test with simpler MCP tools if available
5. Compare with working test cases in tests/

Why This Matters:
- Blocks [deleted:bd-6hji] (testing file reservations)
- Need working MCP API to validate Agent Mail benefits
- Proof of concept for lightweight beads integration later

Note: The actual beads integration (bd-wfmw) will be lightweight HTTP client code only.


Test database naming


Code Review Sweep: thorough

Perform thorough code review sweep based on accumulated activity.

**AI Reasoning:**
Significant code activity with 7608 lines added and 120 files changed indicates substantial modifications. Multiple high-churn areas (cmd/bd, internal/rpc) suggest potential for subtle issues and emerging patterns that warrant review.

**Scope:** thorough
**Target Areas:** cmd/bd, internal/rpc, .beads
**Estimated Files:** 12
**Estimated Cost:** $5

**Task:**
Review files for non-obvious issues that agents miss during focused work:
- Inefficiencies (algorithmic, resource usage)
- Subtle bugs (race conditions, off-by-one, copy-paste)
- Poor patterns (coupling, complexity, duplication)
- Missing best practices (error handling, docs, tests)
- Unnamed anti-patterns

File discovered issues with detailed reasoning and suggestions.


TestHooksCheckGitHooks failing - version mismatch (0.23.0 vs 0.23.1)

The test is checking embedded hook versions and expecting 0.23.1, but got 0.23.0. This appears to be a version consistency issue that needs investigation.

Test output:
```
Hook pre-commit version mismatch: got 0.23.0, want 0.23.1
Hook post-merge version mismatch: got 0.23.0, want 0.23.1
Hook pre-push version mismatch: got 0.23.0, want 0.23.1
```

This is blocking the landing of GH #274 fix.


Stress test: event storm handling

Simulate 100+ rapid JSONL writes. Verify debouncer batches to single import. Verify no data loss. Test daemon stability.


Add unit tests for import ordering

Test topological sort: import [child, parent] should succeed, import [parent.1.2, parent, parent.1] should sort correctly. Verify depth-based batching works. Test max depth limits.


Update docs for import bug fix

Update AGENTS.md, README.md, TROUBLESHOOTING.md with import.orphan_handling config documentation. Document resurrection behavior, tombstones, config modes. Add troubleshooting section for import failures with deleted parents.


Add t.Parallel() to slow hash multiclone tests

Add t.Parallel() to TestHashIDs_MultiCloneConverge and TestHashIDs_IdenticalContentDedup so they run concurrently.

Expected savings: ~10 seconds (from 20s to ~11s)

Implementation:
- Add t.Parallel() call at start of each test function
- Verify tests don't share resources that would cause conflicts
- Run tests to confirm they work in parallel

File: beads_hash_multiclone_test.go:34, :101


Test Epic 2

## Overview

[Describe the high-level goal and scope of this epic]

## Success Criteria

- [ ] Criteria 1
- [ ] Criteria 2
- [ ] Criteria 3

## Background

[Provide context and motivation]

## Scope

**In Scope:**
- Item 1
- Item 2

**Out of Scope:**
- Item 1
- Item 2


bd delete fails to find closed issues

## Steps to Reproduce
1. Close some issues with `bd close`
2. Try to delete them with `bd delete <ids> --force`
3. Get error "issues not found"

## Expected Behavior
Should delete the closed issues

## Actual Behavior
```
Error: issues not found: bd-74ee, bd-9b13, bd-72w, bd-149, bd-5iv, bd-78w
```

But `bd list --status closed --json` shows they exist.

## Root Cause
Likely the delete command is only looking for open issues, or there's a race condition with auto-import.


Modify EnsureIDs to support parent resurrection

Update internal/storage/sqlite/ids.go:189-202 to call TryResurrectParent before failing on missing parent. Add resurrection mode flag, log resurrected parents for transparency. Maintain backwards compatibility with strict validation mode.


Add transaction helper to replace manual COMMIT/ROLLBACK

Create tx.go with withTx helper that handles transaction lifecycle. Replace manual transaction blocks in create/insert/update paths.

Refactoring complete:
- Created withTx() helper in util.go
- Added ExecInTransaction() as deprecated wrapper for backward compatibility
- Refactored all manual transaction blocks to use withTx():
  - events.go: AddComment
  - dirty.go: MarkIssuesDirty, ClearDirtyIssuesByID
  - labels.go: executeLabelOperation
  - dependencies.go: AddDependency, RemoveDependency
  - compact.go: ApplyCompaction
- All tests pass successfully


Investigate and upgrade to modernc.org/sqlite 1.39.1+

We had to pin modernc.org/sqlite to v1.38.2 due to a FOREIGN KEY constraint regression in v1.39.1 (SQLite 3.50.4).

**Issue:** [deleted:bd-47], GH #144

**Symptom:** CloseIssue fails with "FOREIGN KEY constraint failed (787)" when called via MCP/daemon, but works fine via CLI.

**Root Cause:** Unknown - likely stricter FK enforcement in SQLite 3.50.4 or modernc.org wrapper changes.

**Workaround:** Pinned to v1.38.2 (SQLite 3.49.x)

**TODO:**
1. Monitor modernc.org/sqlite releases for fixes
2. Check SQLite 3.50.5+ changelogs for FK-related fixes
3. Investigate why daemon mode fails but CLI succeeds (connection reuse? transaction isolation?)
4. Consider filing upstream issue with reproducible test case
5. Upgrade when safe


Add mermaid output format for bd dep tree

Add visual dependency graph output using Mermaid format for better visualization of issue relationships.

Example usage:
  bd dep tree --format mermaid <issue-id>
  bd dep tree --format mermaid bd-42 > graph.md

This would output Mermaid syntax that can be rendered in GitHub, documentation sites, or Mermaid live editor.

Implementation notes:
- Add --format flag to dep tree command
- Support 'text' (default) and 'mermaid' formats
- Mermaid graph should show issue IDs, titles, and dependency types
- Consider using flowchart LR or graph TD syntax


Add integration tests for adapter library

Test suite for beads_mail_adapter.py covering all scenarios.

Acceptance Criteria:
- Test enabled mode (server available)
- Test disabled mode (server unavailable)
- Test graceful degradation (server dies mid-operation)
- Test reservation conflicts
- Test message sending/receiving
- Mock HTTP server for testing
- 90%+ code coverage

File: lib/test_beads_mail_adapter.py

Test suite completed with 29 comprehensive tests covering:
- Enabled mode (server available): 10 tests
- Disabled mode (server unavailable): 2 tests
- Graceful degradation: 4 tests
- Reservation conflicts: 2 tests
- Configuration: 5 tests
- Health check scenarios: 3 tests
- HTTP error handling: 3 tests

**Performance**: All tests run in 10ms (fast!)

**Coverage highlights**:
✅ Server health checks (ok, degraded, error, timeout)
✅ All API operations (reserve, release, notify, check_inbox, get_reservations)
✅ HTTP errors (404, 409 conflict, 500, 503)
✅ Network errors (timeout, connection refused)
✅ Malformed responses (bad JSON, empty body, plain text errors)
✅ Environment variable configuration
✅ Graceful degradation when server dies mid-operation
✅ Conflict handling with both JSON and plain text errors
✅ Dict wrapper responses ({"messages": [...]} and {"reservations": [...]})
✅ Custom TTL for reservations
✅ Default agent name fallback

No external dependencies, no slow integration tests, just fast unit tests with mocks.


Deletions not propagated across multi-workspace sync

## Problem

When working with multiple beads workspaces (clones) sharing the same git remote, deleted issues keep coming back.

## Reproduction

1. Clone A deletes issue `bd-xyz` via `bd delete bd-xyz --force`
2. Clone A daemon syncs and pushes to GitHub
3. Clone B still has `bd-xyz` in its database
4. Clone B daemon exports and pushes its JSONL
5. Clone A pulls and imports → `bd-xyz` comes back!

## Root Cause

**No deletion tracking mechanism.** The system has no way to distinguish between:
- "Issue doesn't exist in JSONL because it was deleted"
- "Issue doesn't exist in JSONL because the export is stale"

Import treats missing issues as "not in this export" rather than "explicitly deleted."

## Solution Options

1. **Tombstone records** - Keep deleted issues in JSONL with `"status":"deleted"` or `"deleted_at"` field
2. **Deletion log** - Separate `.beads/deletions.jsonl` file tracking all deleted IDs
3. **Three-way merge** - Import compares: DB state, old JSONL, new JSONL
4. **Manual conflict resolution** - Detect resurrection and prompt user

## Related

- Similar to resurrection logic for orphaned children (bd-cc4f)
- beads-merge tool handles this better with 3-way merge


Update FAQ: How does OpenSpec/spec-driven development relate to Beads?

Answer the question raised in GH discussion #240 about OpenSpec integration.

Answer Summary:
- Single-agent: OpenSpec → Beads → Code
- Multi-agent swarm: Use Gastown as coordination layer
- Gastown provides OpenSpec-style planning infrastructure
- Planning agents create specs, distribute as Beads issues
- 'Gastown plans, Beads remembers, Agents execute'

Action Items:
1. Add FAQ entry explaining the architecture layers
2. Link to Gastown planning design (gt-cke)
3. Reference discussion #240 and rbergman's insights
4. Clarify: Beads focuses on execution memory, not planning

Cross-Reference:
- Gastown issue gt-cke: Design OpenSpec-style planning layer
- GH discussion #240: https://github.com/steveyegge/beads/discussions/240

Keep FAQ concise - detailed architecture lives in Gastown docs.


Implement content-first idempotent import

## Overview
Phase 4: Refactor import to be content-first and idempotent, ensuring importing same JSONL multiple times always converges correctly.

## Current Problem
Current import is ID-first:
1. Look up by ID
2. If exists, update
3. If not exists, create

This causes issues when:
- Same content arrives with different IDs (renames not detected)
- Multiple rounds of import needed for convergence
- Import order affects final state

## Solution
Make import content-first and idempotent:
1. Hash all incoming and existing issues
2. Match by content hash first (detect renames)
3. Handle ID conflicts second (using global resolution)
4. Ensure importing same data multiple times = no-op

## Implementation Tasks

### 1. Refactor ImportIssues to be content-first
File: internal/importer/importer.go

```go
func ImportIssues(ctx context.Context, dbPath string, store storage.Storage,
    issues []*types.Issue, opts Options) (*Result, error) {

    result := &Result{...}

    sqliteStore, needCloseStore, err := getOrCreateStore(ctx, dbPath, store)
    if err != nil {
        return nil, err
    }
    if needCloseStore {
        defer func() { _ = sqliteStore.Close() }()
    }

    // Phase 1: Compute content hashes for all incoming issues
    for _, issue := range issues {
        issue.ContentHash = issue.ComputeContentHash()
    }

    // Phase 2: Build content hash maps
    incomingByHash := buildHashMap(issues)
    dbIssues, _ := sqliteStore.SearchIssues(ctx, "", types.IssueFilter{})
    dbByHash := buildHashMap(dbIssues)
    dbByID := buildIDMap(dbIssues)

    // Phase 3: Content-first matching
    var newIssues []*types.Issue
    var idConflicts []*CollisionDetail

    for hash, incoming := range incomingByHash {
        if existing, found := dbByHash[hash]; found {
            // Same content exists
            if existing.ID == incoming.ID {
                // Exact match - idempotent case
                result.Unchanged++
            } else {
                // Same content, different ID - rename detected
                // Delete old ID, keep new ID (incoming is canonical)
                if err := handleRename(ctx, sqliteStore, existing, incoming); err != nil {
                    return nil, err
                }
                result.Updated++
            }
        } else {
            // New content - check for ID collision
            if existingWithID, found := dbByID[incoming.ID]; found {
                // ID exists but different content - collision
                idConflicts = append(idConflicts, &CollisionDetail{
                    ID:            incoming.ID,
                    IncomingIssue: incoming,
                    ExistingIssue: existingWithID,
                })
            } else {
                // Truly new issue
                newIssues = append(newIssues, incoming)
            }
        }
    }

    // Phase 4: Resolve ID conflicts using global algorithm
    if len(idConflicts) > 0 {
        if !opts.ResolveCollisions {
            return nil, fmt.Errorf("collision detected")
        }

        idMapping, err := sqlite.ResolveNWayCollisions(ctx, sqliteStore,
            idConflicts, issues)
        if err != nil {
            return nil, err
        }

        if err := applyIDMapping(ctx, sqliteStore, idMapping); err != nil {
            return nil, err
        }

        result.IDMapping = idMapping
        result.Collisions = len(idConflicts)
    }

    // Phase 5: Create new issues
    if len(newIssues) > 0 {
        if err := sqliteStore.CreateIssues(ctx, newIssues, "import"); err != nil {
            return nil, err
        }
        result.Created = len(newIssues)
    }

    // Phase 6: Import dependencies, labels, comments (existing logic)
    // ...

    return result, nil
}
```

### 2. Implement helper functions

```go
// buildHashMap creates a map of content hash → issue
func buildHashMap(issues []*types.Issue) map[string]*types.Issue {
    result := make(map[string]*types.Issue)
    for _, issue := range issues {
        result[issue.ContentHash] = issue
    }
    return result
}

// buildIDMap creates a map of ID → issue
func buildIDMap(issues []*types.Issue) map[string]*types.Issue {
    result := make(map[string]*types.Issue)
    for _, issue := range issues {
        result[issue.ID] = issue
    }
    return result
}

// handleRename handles content match with different IDs
func handleRename(ctx context.Context, s *SQLiteStorage,
    existing *types.Issue, incoming *types.Issue) error {

    // Delete old ID
    if err := s.DeleteIssue(ctx, existing.ID); err != nil {
        return fmt.Errorf("failed to delete old ID %s: %w", existing.ID, err)
    }

    // Create with new ID
    if err := s.CreateIssue(ctx, incoming, "import-rename"); err != nil {
        return fmt.Errorf("failed to create renamed issue %s: %w",
            incoming.ID, err)
    }

    // Update references from old ID to new ID
    idMapping := map[string]string{existing.ID: incoming.ID}
    return updateReferences(ctx, s, idMapping)
}
```

### 3. Add idempotency tests

Test cases:
1. Import same JSONL twice → second import reports all Unchanged
2. Import, modify DB, import again → reports Updated
3. Import with rename, import again → idempotent
4. Import with collision resolution, import again → idempotent

### 4. Update handleCollisions to use new flow
Current handleCollisions in importer.go needs to be updated to:
- Use content-first matching
- Call new ResolveNWayCollisions
- Apply results using ApplyCollisionResolution

## Acceptance Criteria
- Import matches by content hash before checking IDs
- Importing same JSONL multiple times is idempotent (reports Unchanged)
- Rename detection works (same content, different ID)
- ID conflicts resolved using global algorithm
- Result.Unchanged correctly tracks idempotent imports
- TestThreeCloneCollision passes
- All existing import tests still pass

## Testing Strategy

### Unit Tests
- buildHashMap correctly indexes by content hash
- buildIDMap correctly indexes by ID
- handleRename deletes old, creates new, updates references

### Integration Tests
- Import same data twice → idempotent
- Import renamed issue → handled correctly
- Import with collision → resolved globally
- Final pull after 3-way collision → all clones converge

### Property Tests
- Idempotency: Import(x); Import(x) ≡ Import(x)
- Commutativity: Import(a); Import(b) ≡ Import(b); Import(a) (for non-colliding issues)
- Convergence: After N rounds of sync, all clones identical

## Files to Modify
- internal/importer/importer.go (major refactor of ImportIssues)
- internal/importer/importer_test.go (new tests)
- cmd/bd/import_bug_test.go (update for new behavior)

## Dependencies
- Requires bd-cbed9619.5 (ContentHash field)
- Requires bd-cbed9619.4 (read-only detection)
- Requires bd-cbed9619.3 (global resolution)

## Risk Mitigation
Major refactor of import logic. Recommend:
1. Comprehensive tests before modifying
2. Feature flag to enable/disable
3. Keep old import code path for rollback
4. Test with all existing import tests
5. Manual testing with real repositories

## Success Metrics
After this phase:
- TestThreeCloneCollision should PASS
- All clones converge after final pull
- Import is demonstrably idempotent
- No data loss in N-way scenarios


Implement health checks in daemon event loop

Add health checks to checkDaemonHealth() function in daemon_event_loop.go:170:
- Database integrity check
- Disk space check
- Memory usage check

Currently it's just a no-op placeholder.


Propagate context through command handlers

Thread context from signal-aware parent through all command handlers.

## Context
Part of context propagation work. Builds on bd-rtp (signal-aware contexts).

## Current State
Many command handlers create their own context.Background() locally instead of receiving context from parent.

## Implementation
1. Add context parameter to command handler functions
2. Pass context from cobra command Run/RunE closures
3. Update all storage operations to use propagated context

## Example Pattern
```go
// Before
Run: func(cmd *cobra.Command, args []string) {
    ctx := context.Background()
    store.GetIssues(ctx, ...)
}

// After
Run: func(cmd *cobra.Command, args []string) {
    // ctx comes from parent signal-aware context
    store.GetIssues(ctx, ...)
}
```

## Files to Update
- All cmd/bd/*.go command handlers
- Ensure context flows from main -> cobra -> handlers -> storage

## Benefits
- Commands respect cancellation signals
- Consistent context handling
- Enables timeouts and deadlines

## Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] All command handlers use propagated context
- [ ] No new context.Background() calls in command handlers
- [ ] Context flows from signal handler to storage layer


Investigate why test issues persist in database

Test issues (bd-0do3, bd-cjxp, bd-phr2, etc.) keep appearing in ready/list output, cluttering real work. These appear to be leftover test data from test runs.

Need to investigate:
1. Why are test issues not being cleaned up after tests?
2. Are tests creating issues in the main database instead of test databases?
3. Should we add better test isolation or cleanup hooks?
4. Can we add a label/prefix to distinguish test issues from real issues?

These test issues have characteristics:
- Empty descriptions
- Generic titles like "Test issue 0", "Bug P0", "Issue to reopen with reason"
- Created around 2025-11-07 19:00-19:07
- Some assigned to test users like "alice", "bob", "testuser"

## Root Cause Analysis

**Problem**: Python MCP integration tests created test issues in production `.beads/beads.db` instead of isolated test databases.

**Evidence**:
- 29 test issues created on Nov 7, 2025 at 19:00-19:07
- Patterns: "Bug P0", "Test issue X", assignees "alice"/"bob"/"testuser"
- Git commit 0e8936b shows test issues committed to .beads/beads.jsonl
- Tests were being fixed for workspace isolation around the same time

**Why It Happened**:
1. Before commit 0e8936b, `test_client_lazy_initialization()` didn't set `BEADS_WORKING_DIR`
2. Tests fell back to discovering `.beads/` in the project root directory
3. Auto-sync committed test issues to production database

**Resolution**:
1. ✅ Closed 29 test pollution issues (bd-0do3, bd-cjxp, etc.)
2. ✅ Added `failIfProductionDatabase()` guard in Go test helpers
3. ✅ Added production pollution checks in RPC test setup
4. ✅ Created `conftest.py` with pytest safety checks for Python tests
5. ✅ Added `BEADS_TEST_MODE` env var to mark test execution
6. ✅ Tests now fail fast if they detect production database usage

**Prevention**:
- All test helper functions now verify database paths are in temp directories
- Python tests fail immediately if BEADS_DB points to production
- BEADS_TEST_MODE flag helps identify test vs production execution
- Clear error messages guide developers to use proper test isolation

**Files Modified**:
- cmd/bd/test_helpers_test.go - Added failIfProductionDatabase()
- internal/rpc/rpc_test.go - Added temp directory verification
- integrations/beads-mcp/tests/conftest.py - New file with pytest safeguards


Test Issue


Implement transaction retry logic for SQLITE_BUSY

BEGIN IMMEDIATE fails immediately on SQLITE_BUSY instead of retrying with exponential backoff.

Location: internal/storage/sqlite/sqlite.go:223-225

Problem:
- Under concurrent write load, BEGIN IMMEDIATE can fail with SQLITE_BUSY
- Current implementation fails immediately instead of retrying
- Results in spurious failures under normal concurrent usage

Solution: Implement exponential backoff retry:
- Retry up to N times (e.g., 5)
- Backoff: 10ms, 20ms, 40ms, 80ms, 160ms
- Check for context cancellation between retries
- Only retry on SQLITE_BUSY/database locked errors

Impact: Spurious failures under concurrent write load

Effort: 3 hours


Implement content-hash based collision resolution for deterministic convergence

The current collision resolution uses creation timestamps to decide which issue to keep vs. remap. This is non-deterministic when two clones create issues at nearly the same time.

Root cause of bd-71107098:
- Clone A creates test-1="Issue from clone A" at T0
- Clone B creates test-1="Issue from clone B" at T0+30ms
- Clone B syncs first, remaps Clone A's to test-2
- Clone A syncs second, sees collision, remaps Clone B's to test-2
- Result: titles are swapped between clones

Solution:
- Use content-based hashing (title + description + priority + type)
- Deterministic winner: always keep issue with lower hash
- Same collision on different clones produces same result (idempotent)

Implementation:
- Modify ScoreCollisions in internal/storage/sqlite/collision.go
- Replace timestamp-based scoring with content hash comparison
- Ensure hash function is stable across platforms


Integration Layer Implementation

Build the adapter layer that makes Agent Mail optional and non-intrusive.

Progress: bd-m9th (Python adapter library) completed with full test coverage. Next: bd-fzbg (update python-agent example with Agent Mail integration).


Measure git operation reduction

Quantify the reduction in git operations (pulls, commits, pushes) when using Agent Mail for coordination.

Acceptance Criteria:
- Baseline: count git ops for 10 issues without Agent Mail
- With Agent Mail: count git ops for 10 issues
- Document reduction percentage
- Verify 70-80% reduction claim
- Measure impact on .git directory size growth

Success Metric: ≥70% reduction in git operations


Document bd info --whats-new in AGENTS.md

Add prominent documentation about bd info --whats-new to help agents discover upgrade changes.

## Changes Needed
1. Add to 'What's New' section (line 13-28): Emphasize running bd info --whats-new after upgrades
2. Add to 'Pro Tips for Agents' section (line 474-486): Include version check in session startup routine
3. Document the bd hooks install command for keeping hooks in sync

## Implementation
- Update AGENTS.md with clear examples
- Show both human-readable and --json output options
- Link to the discussion #239 as motivation

## Acceptance Criteria
- Agents know to run bd info --whats-new after upgrades
- Clear guidance on when/why to use it
- Examples showing both output formats


Database pollution in ~/src/dave/vc: 895 issues vs canonical 310

~/src/dave/vc/.beads/beads.db has 895 total issues (675 open, 149 closed), but canonical ~/src/vc/.beads/vc.db has only 310 issues (230 open). This is 585 extra issues - likely pollution from other repositories.

Need to:
1. Identify which issues are polluted (use detect-pollution)
2. Compare issue IDs between dave/vc and canonical vc databases
3. Determine pollution source (beads repo? other repos?)
4. Clean up polluted database
5. Root cause: why did pollution occur?

Investigation findings so far:
- Polluted DB (~/src/dave/vc/.beads/beads.db): 241 issues (180 open, 43 closed)
- Canonical DB (~/src/vc/.beads/vc.db): 310 issues (230 open, 62 closed)
- Contradiction: Polluted has FEWER issues, not more (241 < 310, diff of 69)
- Only 1 unique ID in polluted: vc-55fi
- All source_repo fields are set to "." in both databases
- Issue description claims 895 issues in polluted vs 310 canonical - numbers don't match current state
- Possible: Pollution was already partially cleaned, or issue description refers to different database?


Add upgrade notification system to bd ready/list


Import validation falsely reports data loss on collision resolution

## Problem

Post-import validation reports 'data loss detected!' when import count reduces due to legitimate collision resolution.

## Example

```
Import complete: 1 created, 8 updated, 142 unchanged, 19 skipped, 1 issues remapped
Post-import validation failed: import reduced issue count: 165 → 164 (data loss detected!)
```

This was actually successful collision resolution (bd-70419816 duplicated → remapped to-70419816), not data loss.

## Impact

- False alarms waste investigation time
- Undermines confidence in import validation
- Confuses users/agents about sync health

## Solution

Improve validation to distinguish:
- Collision-resolution merges (expected count reduction)
- Actual data loss (unexpected disappearance)

Track remapped issue count and adjust expected post-import count accordingly.


Q4 Platform Improvements

## Overview

[Describe the high-level goal and scope of this epic]

## Success Criteria

- [ ] Criteria 1
- [ ] Criteria 2
- [ ] Criteria 3

## Background

[Provide context and motivation]

## Scope

**In Scope:**
- Item 1
- Item 2

**Out of Scope:**
- Item 1
- Item 2


bd-hv01: Multi-repo mode not tested with deletion tracking

Problem: Test suite has no coverage for multi-repo mode. ExportToMultiRepo creates multiple JSONL files but snapshot files are hardcoded to single JSONL location.

Impact: Deletion tracking likely silently broken for multi-repo users, could cause data loss.

Fix: Add test and update snapshot logic to handle multiple JSONL files.

Files: cmd/bd/deletion_tracking_test.go, cmd/bd/deletion_tracking.go, cmd/bd/daemon_sync.go:24-34


Change default JSONL filename from beads.jsonl back to issues.jsonl throughout codebase


Code review follow-up for bd-dvd and bd-ymj fixes

Track improvements and issues identified during code review of parent resurrection (bd-dvd) and export metadata (bd-ymj) bug fixes.

## Context
Code review identified several areas for improvement:
- Code duplication in metadata updates
- Missing multi-repo support
- Test coverage gaps
- Potential race conditions

## Related Issues
Original bugs fixed: bd-dvd, bd-ymj

## Goals
- Eliminate code duplication
- Add multi-repo support where needed
- Improve test coverage
- Address edge cases


Test exclusive file reservations with two agents

Simulate two agents racing to claim the same issue and verify that exclusive reservations prevent collision.

Acceptance Criteria:
- Agent A reserves bd-123 → succeeds
- Agent B tries to reserve bd-123 → fails with clear error message
- Agent B can see who has the reservation
- Reservation expires after TTL
- Agent B can claim after expiration

Successfully tested file reservations:
- Agent BrownBear reserved bd-123 → granted
- Agent ChartreuseHill tried same → conflicts returned
- System correctly prevents collision


AI-supervised database migrations for safer schema evolution

## Problem

Database migrations can lose user data through edge cases that are hard to anticipate (e.g., GH #201 where bd migrate failed to set issue_prefix, or bd-d355a07d false positive data loss warnings). Since beads is designed to be run by AI agents, we should leverage AI to make migrations safer.

## Current State

Migrations run blindly with:
- No pre-flight validation
- No data integrity verification
- No rollback on failure
- Limited post-migration testing

Recent issues:
- GH #201: Migration didn't set issue_prefix config, breaking commands
- bd-d355a07d: False positive "data loss" warnings on collision resolution
- Users reported migration data loss (fixed but broader problem remains)

## Proposal: AI-Supervised Migration Framework

Use AI to supervise migrations through structured verification:

### 1. Pre-Migration Analysis
- AI reads migration code and current schema
- Identifies potential data loss scenarios
- Generates validation queries to verify assumptions
- Creates snapshot queries for before/after comparison

### 2. Migration Execution
- Take database backup/snapshot
- Run validation queries (pre-state)
- Execute migration in transaction
- Run validation queries (post-state)

### 3. Post-Migration Verification
- AI compares pre/post snapshots
- Verifies data integrity invariants
- Checks for unexpected data loss
- Validates config completeness (like issue_prefix)

### 4. Rollback on Anomalies
- If AI detects data loss, rollback transaction
- Present human-readable error report
- Suggest fix before retrying

## Example Flow

```
$ bd migrate

→ Analyzing migration plan...
→ AI identified 3 potential data loss scenarios
→ Generating validation queries...
→ Creating pre-migration snapshot...
→ Running migration in transaction...
→ Verifying post-migration state...
✓ All 247 issues accounted for
✓ Config table complete (issue_prefix: "mcp")
✓ Dependencies intact (342 relationships verified)
→ Migration successful!
```

If something goes wrong:
```
$ bd migrate

→ Analyzing migration plan...
→ AI identified issue: Missing issue_prefix config after migration
→ Recommendation: Add prefix detection step
→ Aborting migration - database unchanged
```

## Implementation Ideas

### A. Migration Validator Tool
Create `bd migrate --validate` that:
- Simulates migration on copy of database
- Uses AI to verify data integrity
- Reports potential issues before real migration

### B. Migration Test Generator
AI generates test cases for migrations:
- Edge cases (empty DB, large DB, missing config)
- Data integrity checks
- Regression tests

### C. Migration Invariants
Define invariants that AI checks:
- Issue count should not decrease (unless collision resolution)
- All required config keys present
- Foreign key relationships intact
- No orphaned dependencies

### D. Self-Healing Migrations
AI detects incomplete migrations and suggests fixes:
- Missing config values (like GH #201)
- Orphaned data
- Index inconsistencies

## Benefits

1. **Catch edge cases**: AI explores scenarios humans miss
2. **Self-documenting**: AI explains what migration does
3. **Agent-friendly**: Agents can run migrations confidently
4. **Fewer rollbacks**: Detect issues before committing
5. **Better testing**: AI generates comprehensive test suites

## Open Questions

1. Which AI model? (Fast: Haiku, Thorough: Sonnet/GPT-4)
2. How to balance safety vs migration speed?
3. Should AI validation be required or optional?
4. How to handle offline scenarios (no API access)?
5. What invariants should always be checked?

## Related Work

- bd-b245: Migration registry (makes migrations introspectable)
- GH #201: issue_prefix migration bug (motivating example)
- bd-d355a07d: False positive data loss warnings

## Progress

### ✅ Phase 1: Migration Invariants (COMPLETED)

**Implemented:**
- Created internal/storage/sqlite/migration_invariants.go with 3 invariants
- Updated RunMigrations() to verify invariants after migrations
- All tests pass ✓

### ✅ Phase 2: Inspection Tools (COMPLETED & PUSHED)

**Commit:** 1abe4e7 - "Add migration inspection tools for AI agents (bd-627d Phase 2)"

**Implemented:**
1. ✅ bd migrate --inspect --json - Shows migration plan
2. ✅ bd info --schema --json - Returns schema details
3. ✅ Migration warnings system
4. ✅ Documentation updated in AGENTS.md
5. ✅ All tests pass

### ✅ Phase 3: MCP Tools (COMPLETED & PUSHED)

**Commit:** 2493693 - "Add MCP tools for migration inspection (bd-627d Phase 3)"

**Implemented:**
1. ✅ inspect_migration(workspace_root) tool in beads-mcp
2. ✅ get_schema_info(workspace_root) tool in beads-mcp
3. ✅ Abstract methods in BdClientBase
4. ✅ CLI client implementations
5. ✅ All tests pass

**All phases complete!** Migration inspection fully integrated into MCP server.


Add import.orphan_handling config option

Add configuration option to control orphan handling behavior: 'strict' (fail on missing parent, current behavior), 'resurrect' (auto-resurrect from JSONL, recommended default), 'skip' (skip orphaned issues with warning), 'allow' (import orphans without validation). Update CONFIG.md documentation.


Improve compact/daemon/merge documentation and UX

Multiple documentation and UX issues encountered:
1. "bd compact --analyze" fails with misleading "requires SQLite storage" error when daemon is running. Needs --no-daemon or better error.
2. "bd merge" help text is outdated (refers to 3-way merge instead of issue merging).
3. Daemon mode purpose isn't clear to local-only users.
4. Compact/cleanup commands are hard to discover.

Proposed fixes:
- Fix compact+daemon interaction or error message.
- Update "bd merge" help text.
- Add "when to use daemon" section to docs.
- Add maintenance section to quickstart.


Review and merge open PRs


Ready issue


bd init UX Improvements

bd init leaves users with incomplete setup, requiring manual bd doctor --fix. Issues found: (1) git hooks not installed if user declines prompt, (2) no auto-migration when CLI is upgraded, (3) stale merge driver configs from old versions. Fix by making bd init more robust with better defaults and auto-migration.


Fixture Generator for Realistic Test Data

Create internal/testutil/fixtures/fixtures.go with functions to generate realistic test data at scale.

Functions:
- LargeSQLite(storage) - 10K issues, native SQLite
- XLargeSQLite(storage) - 20K issues, native SQLite
- LargeFromJSONL(storage) - 10K issues imported from JSONL
- XLargeFromJSONL(storage) - 20K issues imported from JSONL

Data characteristics:
- Epic hierarchies (depth 4): Epic → Feature → Task → Subtask
- Cross-linked dependencies (tasks blocking across epics)
- Realistic status/priority/label distribution
- Representative assignees and temporal data

Implementation:
- Single file: internal/testutil/fixtures/fixtures.go
- No config structs, simple direct functions
- Seeded RNG for reproducibility
- Reusable by both benchmarks and tests


Remove obsolete stale.go command (executor tables never implemented)


Test numeric 1


bd message: Add input validation for --importance flag

The --importance flag accepts any string without validation, leading to confusing server errors.

**Location:** cmd/bd/message.go:256-258

**Fix:**
- Add flag validation for: low, normal, high, urgent
- Add shell completion support
- Validate in runMessageSend before sending

**Impact:** Better UX, prevents confusing errors


Fix validatePreExport to use content hash instead of mtime

validatePreExport() in integrity.go:70 still uses isJSONLNewer() (mtime-based), creating inconsistent behavior. Auto-import correctly uses hasJSONLChanged() (hash-based) but export validation still uses the old mtime approach. This can cause false positive blocks after git operations.

Fix: Replace isJSONLNewer() call with hasJSONLChanged() in validatePreExport().

Impact: Without this fix, the bd-khnb solution is incomplete - we prevent resurrection but still have export blocking issues.