bd import fails on duplicate external_ref with no resolution options

When JSONL contains duplicate external_ref values (e.g., two issues both have external_ref='BS-170'), bd import fails entirely with no resolution options.

User must manually edit JSONL to remove duplicates, which is error-prone.

Example error:
```
batch import contains duplicate external_ref values:
external_ref 'BS-170' appears in issues: [opal-39 opal-43]
```

Should handle this similar to duplicate issue detection - offer to merge, pick one, or clear duplicates.


Latency test manual


Extract daemon sync functions to daemon_sync.go


Issue to reopen with reason


Add orphan detection migration

Create migration to detect orphaned children in existing databases. Query: SELECT id FROM issues WHERE id LIKE '%.%' AND substr(id, 1, instr(id || '.', '.') - 1) NOT IN (SELECT id FROM issues). Log results, let user decide action (delete orphans or convert to top-level).


Document deletions manifest in AGENTS.md and README

Parent: bd-imj

## Task
Add documentation about the deletions manifest feature.

## Locations to Update

### AGENTS.md
- Explain that deletions.jsonl is tracked in git
- Document that `bd delete` records to the manifest
- Explain cross-clone propagation mechanism

### README.md
- Brief mention in .beads directory structure section
- Link to detailed docs if needed

### docs/deletions.md (new file)
- Full technical documentation
- Format specification
- Pruning policy
- Git history fallback
- Troubleshooting

## Acceptance Criteria
- AGENTS.md updated with deletion workflow
- README.md mentions deletions.jsonl purpose
- New docs/deletions.md with complete reference


WASM integration testing

Comprehensive testing of WASM build. Child of epic bd-44d0.

## Tasks
- [ ] Unit tests for WASM module
- [ ] Integration tests with real JSONL files
- [ ] Test all bd commands for parity
- [ ] Performance benchmarks
- [ ] Test in actual Claude Code Web sandbox
- [ ] Document any limitations

## Test Coverage Target
- >90% of bd CLI commands work identically


Unit tests for FileWatcher

Test watcher detects JSONL changes. Test git ref changes trigger import. Test debounce integration. Test watcher recovery from file removal/rename.


Refactor sqlite.go into focused modules

Split sqlite.go (2,298 lines) into focused modules: migrations.go, ids.go, issues.go, events.go, dirty.go, db.go. This will improve maintainability and reduce cognitive load.


BG's issue to reopen


purgeDeletedIssues still writes to deletions.jsonl during git-history-backfill

In purgeDeletedIssues (lines 929-939), when a deletion is recovered from git history, we:
1. Append to deletions.jsonl (backfill)
2. Create a tombstone in DB

With the tombstone approach, writing to deletions.jsonl is redundant since the tombstone will be exported to JSONL. Consider removing the deletions.jsonl backfill once we're confident in the tombstone approach.

This is related to the Phase 2 migration (bd-vw8) - we should stop writing to deletions.jsonl entirely.


Git history fallback doesn't escape regex special chars in IDs

## Problem

In `batchCheckGitHistory`, IDs are directly interpolated into a regex pattern:

```go
patterns = append(patterns, fmt.Sprintf(\`"id":"%s"\`, id))
searchPattern := strings.Join(patterns, "|")
cmd := exec.Command("git", "log", "--all", "-G", searchPattern, ...)
```

If an ID contains regex special characters (e.g., `bd-foo.bar` or `bd-test+1`), the pattern will be malformed or match unintended strings.

## Location
`internal/importer/importer.go:923-926`

## Impact
- False positives: IDs with `.` could match any character
- Regex errors: IDs with `[` or `(` could cause git to fail
- Security: potential for regex injection (low risk since IDs are validated)

## Fix
Escape regex special characters:

```go
import "regexp"

escapedID := regexp.QuoteMeta(id)
patterns = append(patterns, fmt.Sprintf(\`"id":"%s"\`, escapedID))
```


Fix FindBeadsDir to prioritize main repo .beads for worktrees

The FindBeadsDir function should prioritize finding .beads in the main repository root when accessed from a worktree, rather than finding worktree-local .beads directories. This ensures proper sharing of the database across all worktrees.


Add tests for internal/utils package

Currently 0.0% coverage. Need tests for utility functions including issue ID parsing and validation.


Audit and consolidate collision test coverage

The codebase has 2,019 LOC of collision detection tests across 3 files. Run coverage analysis to identify redundant test cases and consolidate.

Test files:
- `cmd/bd/import_collision_test.go` - 974 LOC
- `cmd/bd/autoimport_collision_test.go` - 750 LOC
- `cmd/bd/import_collision_regression_test.go` - 295 LOC

Total: 2,019 LOC of collision tests

Analysis steps:
1. Run coverage analysis
2. Identify redundant tests
3. Document findings

Consolidation strategy:
- Keep regression tests for critical bugs
- Merge overlapping table-driven tests
- Remove redundant edge case tests covered elsewhere
- Ensure all collision scenarios still tested

Expected outcome: Reduce to ~1,200 LOC (save ~800 lines) while maintaining coverage

Impact: Faster test runs, easier maintenance, clearer test intent


Consider extracting error handling helpers

Evaluate creating FatalError() and WarnError() helpers as suggested in ERROR_HANDLING.md to reduce boilerplate and enforce consistency. Prototype in a few files first to validate the approach.


bd-hv01: Storage backend extensibility broken by type assertion

Problem: deletion_tracking.go:69-82 uses type assertion for DeleteIssue which breaks if someone adds a new storage backend.

Fix: Check capability before starting merge or add DeleteIssue to Storage interface.

Files: cmd/bd/deletion_tracking.go:69-82, internal/storage/storage.go


Add external_ref change tracking and auditing

Currently we don't track when external_ref is added, removed, or changed. This would be useful for debugging and auditing.

Proposed features:
- Log event when external_ref changes
- Track in events table with old/new values
- Add query to find issues where external_ref changed
- Add metrics: issues with external_ref vs without

Use cases:
- Debugging import issues
- Understanding which issues are externally managed
- Auditing external system linkage

Related: bd-1022


Improve bd doctor output formatting for better readability

The current bd doctor output is a wall of text that's hard to process. Consider improvements like:
- Grouping related checks into collapsible sections
- Using color/bold for section headers
- Showing only failures/warnings by default with --verbose for full output
- Better visual hierarchy between major sections
- Summary line at top (e.g., '24 checks passed, 0 warnings, 0 errors')


Add tests for daemon sync module


Audit Current Cache Usage

Understand exactly what code depends on the storage cache

AUDIT COMPLETE

getStorageForRequest() callers: 17 production + 11 test
- server_issues_epics.go: 8 calls
- server_labels_deps_comments.go: 4 calls
- server_export_import_auto.go: 2 calls
- server_compact.go: 2 calls
- server_routing_validation_diagnostics.go: 1 call
- server_eviction_test.go: 11 calls (DELETE entire file)

Pattern everywhere: store, err := s.getStorageForRequest(req) → store := s.storage

req.Cwd usage: Only for multi-repo routing. Local daemon always serves 1 repo, so routing is unused.

MCP server: Uses separate daemons per repo (no req.Cwd usage found). NOT affected by cache removal.

Cache env vars to deprecate:
- BEADS_DAEMON_MAX_CACHE_SIZE (used in server_core.go:63)
- BEADS_DAEMON_CACHE_TTL (used in server_core.go:72)
- BEADS_DAEMON_MEMORY_THRESHOLD_MB (used in server_cache_storage.go:47)

Server struct fields to remove:
- storageCache, cacheMu, maxCacheSize, cacheTTL, cleanupTicker, cacheHits, cacheMisses

Tests to delete:
- server_eviction_test.go (entire file - 9 tests)
- limits_test.go cache assertions

Special consideration: ValidateDatabase endpoint uses findDatabaseForCwd() outside cache. Verify if used, then remove or inline.

Safe to proceed with removal - cache always had 1 entry in local daemon model.


bd doctor should recommend bd prime migration for existing repos

bd doctor should detect old beads integration patterns and recommend migrating to bd prime approach.

## Current behavior
- bd doctor checks if Claude hooks are installed globally
- Doesn't check project-level integration (AGENTS.md, CLAUDE.md)
- Doesn't recommend migration for repos using old patterns

## Desired behavior
bd doctor should detect and suggest:

1. **Old slash command pattern detected**
   - Check for /beads:* references in AGENTS.md, CLAUDE.md
   - Suggest: These slash commands are deprecated, use bd prime hooks instead

2. **No agent documentation**
   - Check if AGENTS.md or CLAUDE.md exists
   - Suggest: Run 'bd onboard' or 'bd setup claude' to document workflow

3. **Old MCP-only pattern**
   - Check for instructions to use MCP tools but no bd prime hooks
   - Suggest: Add bd prime hooks for better token efficiency

4. **Migration path**
   - Show: 'Run bd setup claude to add SessionStart/PreCompact hooks'
   - Show: 'Update AGENTS.md to reference bd prime instead of slash commands'

## Example output

⚠ Warning: Old beads integration detected in CLAUDE.md
  Found: /beads:* slash command references (deprecated)
  Recommend: Migrate to bd prime hooks for better token efficiency
  Fix: Run 'bd setup claude' and update CLAUDE.md

💡 Tip: bd prime + hooks reduces token usage by 80-99% vs slash commands
  MCP mode: ~50 tokens vs ~10.5k for full MCP scan
  CLI mode: ~1-2k tokens with automatic context recovery

## Benefits
- Helps existing repos adopt new best practices
- Clear migration path for users
- Better token efficiency messaging


Add bd init --contributor wizard

Interactive wizard for OSS contributor setup. Guides user through: fork workflow setup, separate planning repo configuration, auto-detection of fork relationships, examples of common OSS workflows.


bd init UX Improvements

bd init leaves users with incomplete setup, requiring manual bd doctor --fix. Issues found: (1) git hooks not installed if user declines prompt, (2) no auto-migration when CLI is upgraded, (3) stale merge driver configs from old versions. Fix by making bd init more robust with better defaults and auto-migration.


wish: a 'continue' or similar cmd/flag which means alter last issue

so many time I create an issue and then have another thought: 'oh, before I did X and it crashed there was ZZZ happening' or 'actually that is P4 not P2'. It would be nice if when `bd {cmd}` is used without a {title} or {id} it just adds or updates the most recently touched issue.


Test parent issue


Investigate jujutsu VCS as potential solution for conflict-free merging

## Context
Current N-way collision resolution struggles with Git line-based merge model. When 5+ clones create issues with same ID, Git merge conflicts require manual resolution, and our collision resolver can fail during convergence rounds.

## Research Question
Could jujutsu (jj) provide better conflict handling for JSONL files?

## Jujutsu Overview
- Next-gen VCS built on libgit2
- Designed to handle conflicts as first-class citizens
- Supports conflict-free replicated data types (CRDTs) in some scenarios
- Better handling of concurrent edits
- Can work with Git repos (compatible with existing infrastructure)

## Investigation Tasks
1. JSONL Merge Behavior - How does jj handle line-by-line JSONL conflicts?
2. Integration Feasibility - Can beads use jj as backend while maintaining Git compatibility?
3. Conflict Resolution Model - Does jj conflict model map to our collision resolution?
4. Operational Transform Support - Does jj implement operational transforms?

## Deliverables
1. Technical report on jj merge algorithm for JSONL
2. Proof-of-concept: 5-clone collision test using jj instead of Git
3. Performance comparison: Git vs jj for beads workload
4. Recommendation: Adopt, experiment further, or abandon

## References
- https://github.com/martinvonz/jj
- Related to bd-e6d71828, bd-7a2b58fc


Detect and warn about outdated git hooks

Users may have outdated git hooks installed that reference removed flags (e.g., --resolve-collisions). bd should detect this and warn users to reinstall.


Add AI planning docs management guidance to bd onboard (GH-196)

Enhanced bd onboard command to provide guidance for managing AI-generated planning documents (Claude slop).

Addresses GitHub issue #196: https://github.com/steveyegge/beads/issues/196

Changes:
- Added Managing AI-Generated Planning Documents section to bd onboard
- Recommends using history/ directory for ephemeral planning files
- Updated AGENTS.md to demonstrate the pattern
- Added comprehensive tests

Commit: d46177d


Implement hash ID generation in CreateIssue

Replace sequential ID generation with hash-based IDs in CreateIssue function.

## Current Behavior (internal/storage/sqlite/sqlite.go)
```go
func (s *SQLiteStorage) CreateIssue(ctx context.Context, issue *types.Issue) error {
    // ID comes from auto-increment counter
    // Collisions possible across clones
}
```

## New Behavior
```go
func (s *SQLiteStorage) CreateIssue(ctx context.Context, issue *types.Issue) error {
    // Generate hash ID if not provided
    if issue.ID == "" {
        issue.ID = idgen.GenerateHashID(
            issue.Title,
            issue.Description,
            time.Now(),
            s.workspaceID,
        )
    }

    // Assign next alias
    issue.Alias = s.getNextAlias()

    // Insert with hash ID + alias
    // ...
}
```

## Workspace ID Generation
Add to database initialization:
```go
// Generate stable workspace ID (persisted in .beads/workspace_id)
workspaceID := getOrCreateWorkspaceID()
```

Options for workspace ID:
1. Hostname + random suffix
2. UUID (random)
3. Git remote URL hash (deterministic per repo)

Recommended: Option 3 (git remote hash) for reproducibility

## Hash Collision Detection
```go
// On insert, check for collision (unlikely but possible)
existing, err := s.GetIssue(ctx, issue.ID)
if err == nil {
    // Hash collision! Add random suffix and retry
    issue.ID = issue.ID + "-" + randomSuffix(4)
}
```

## Files to Create/Modify
- internal/types/id_generator.go (new)
- internal/storage/sqlite/sqlite.go (CreateIssue)
- internal/storage/sqlite/workspace.go (new - workspace ID management)
- .beads/workspace_id (new file, git-ignored)

## Testing
- Test hash ID generation is deterministic
- Test collision detection and retry
- Test workspace ID persistence
- Benchmark: hash generation performance (<1μs)


Extract duplicated validation logic from CLI commands

~150 lines of identical validation logic duplicated between cmd_create.go and cmd_update.go

Duplication found:
- validateBeadFields(): 2 identical copies (50+ lines each)
- parseTimeWithDefault(): 2 identical copies (30 lines each)
- Flag definitions: 15+ duplicate registrations

Solution: Extract to shared packages:
- internal/validation/bead.go - Centralized validation
- internal/utils/time.go - Consolidate time parsing (already exists)
- cmd/bd/flags.go - Shared flag registration

Impact: Changes require touching 2+ files; high risk of inconsistency; steep learning curve

Effort: 4-6 hours


Updated title


Extract batch operations to batch_ops.go

Move validateBatchIssues, generateBatchIDs, bulkInsertIssues, bulkRecordEvents, bulkMarkDirty, CreateIssues to batch_ops.go


Extract validation functions to validators.go

Move validatePriority, validateStatus, validateIssueType, validateTitle, validateEstimatedMinutes, validateFieldUpdate to validators.go


bd init overwrites existing git hooks without detection or chaining

GH #254: bd init silently overwrites existing git hooks (like pre-commit framework) without detecting them, backing them up, or offering to chain. This breaks workflows and can result in committed code with failing tests.

Fix: Detect existing hooks, prompt user with options to chain/overwrite/skip.


YABB: Spurious issue updates during normal operations

Issue bd-627d was updated during config refactoring session without any actual changes to it. Only timestamps and content_hash changed.

Observed: Running various bd commands (list, create, etc.) caused bd-627d updated_at to change from 14:14 to 14:31.

Expected: Issues should only be updated when explicitly modified.

This causes:
- Dirty JSONL after every session
- False conflicts in git
- Confusing git history

Likely culprit: Daemon auto-import/export cycle or database migration touching all issues.

Investigated thoroughly - unable to reproduce. The import logic has IssueDataChanged() checks before calling UpdateIssue (importer/importer.go:458). All tests pass. May have been fixed by recent refactorings. Closing as cannot reproduce - please reopen with specific repro steps if it occurs again.


Document protected branch workflow

Create comprehensive documentation for protected branch workflow.

Tasks:
- Add "Protected Branch Workflow" section to AGENTS.md
- Create docs/PROTECTED_BRANCHES.md guide
- Update README.md quick start
- Add examples to examples/protected-branch/
- Update bd init --help documentation
- Add troubleshooting guide
- Add migration guide for existing users
- Record demo video (optional)

Estimated effort: 2-3 days

Completed protected branch workflow documentation. Created comprehensive guide (docs/PROTECTED_BRANCHES.md), updated AGENTS.md with workflow section, added feature to README.md, and created working example (examples/protected-branch/). All commands verified working (bd init --branch, bd sync --status, bd sync --merge, bd config get/set sync.branch).


Test child daemon mode


Update bash-agent example with Agent Mail integration

Add Agent Mail integration to examples/bash-agent/agent.sh using curl for HTTP calls.

Acceptance Criteria:
- Health check function using curl
- Reserve issue before claiming
- Send notifications on status change
- Release on completion
- Graceful degradation if curl fails
- No bash errors when Agent Mail unavailable

File: examples/bash-agent/agent.sh


[CRITICAL] Sync validation false positive - legitimate deletions trigger 'data loss detected'

Sync preflight validation incorrectly detects 'data loss' when legitimate deletions occur. This blocks all syncs and is the highest priority fix.


Add test for legacy deletions.jsonl to tombstone conversion

The importer now converts legacy deletions.jsonl entries to tombstones (bd-dve), but there's no dedicated test that:
1. Creates a deletions.jsonl with entries
2. Imports issues (some in deletions, some not)
3. Verifies the converted tombstones have correct fields from the deletion record

The existing TestImportIssues_TombstoneNotFilteredByDeletionsManifest tests that tombstones bypass the filter, but doesn't verify the conversion of legacy deletions to tombstones.

Add a test: TestImportIssues_LegacyDeletionsConvertedToTombstones


Implement bd stale command to find abandoned/forgotten issues

Add bd stale command to surface issues that haven't been updated recently and may need attention.

Use cases:
- In-progress issues with no recent activity (may be abandoned)
- Open issues that have been forgotten
- Issues that might be outdated or no longer relevant

Query logic should find non-closed issues where updated_at exceeds a time threshold.

Should support:
- --days N flag (default 30-90 days)
- --status filter (e.g., only in_progress)
- --json output for automation

References GitHub issue #184 where user expected this command to exist.


Optimize cmd/bd test suite performance (currently 30+ minutes)

CLI test suite is extremely slow (~30+ minutes for full run). Tests are poorly designed and need performance optimization before expanding coverage.

Current coverage: 24.8% (improved from 20.2%)

**Problem**: Tests take far too long to run, making development iteration painful.

**Priority**: Fix test performance FIRST, then consider increasing coverage.

**Investigation needed**:
- Profile test execution to identify bottlenecks
- Look for redundant git operations, database initialization, or daemon operations
- Identify opportunities for test parallelization
- Consider mocking or using in-memory databases where appropriate
- Review test design patterns

**Related**: bd-ktng mentions 13 CLI tests with redundant git init calls (31s total)

**Goal**: Get full test suite under 1-2 minutes before adding more tests.


Pre-push hook and daemon export produce different JSONL

After committing and pushing, git status shows .beads/beads.jsonl as dirty. Investigation shows:

1. Pre-push hook ran successfully and exported DB → JSONL
2. Push completed
3. Shortly after, daemon exported DB → JSONL again with different content
4. Diff shows comments added to old issues (bd-23a8, bd-6049, bd-87a0)

Timeline:
- Commit c731c45 "Update beads JSONL"
- Pre-push hook exported JSONL
- Push succeeded
- Daemon PID 33314 exported again with different content

Questions:
1. Did someone run a command between commit and daemon export?
2. Is there a timing issue where pre-push hook doesn't capture all DB changes?
3. Should pre-commit hook flush daemon changes before committing?

The comments appear to be from Nov 5 (created_at: 2025-11-05T08:38:46Z) but are only appearing in JSONL now. This suggests the DB had these comments but they weren't exported during pre-push.

Possible causes:
- Pre-push hook uses BEADS_NO_DAEMON=1 which might skip pending writes
- Daemon has unflushed changes in memory
- Race condition between pre-push export and daemon's periodic export

Improved fix based on oracle code review:
1. Pre-push now flushes pending changes first (prevents debounce race)
2. Uses git status --porcelain to catch all change types
3. Handles both beads.jsonl and issues.jsonl
4. Works even if bd not installed (git-only check)


Add 'When to use daemon mode' decision tree to daemon.md

**Problem:**
Users (especially local-only developers) see daemon-related messages but don't understand:
- What daemon mode does (git sync automation)
- Whether they need it
- Why they see "daemon_unsupported" messages

Related to issue #349 item #3.

**Current state:**
commands/daemon.md explains WHAT daemon does but not WHEN to use it.

**Proposed addition:**
Add a "When to Use Daemon Mode" section after line 20 in commands/daemon.md with clear decision criteria:

**✅ You SHOULD use daemon mode if:**
- Working in a team with git remote sync
- Want automatic commit/push of issue changes
- Need background auto-sync (5-second debounce)
- Making frequent bd commands (performance benefit)

**❌ You DON'T need daemon mode if:**
- Solo developer with local-only tracking
- Working in git worktrees (use --no-daemon)
- Running one-off commands/scripts
- Debugging database issues

**Local-only users:** Direct mode is perfectly fine. Daemon mainly helps with git sync automation. You can use `bd sync` manually when needed.

**Files to modify:**
- commands/daemon.md (add section after line 20)


Migration tool: sequential → hash IDs

Create migration tool to convert existing sequential-ID databases to hash-ID format.

## Command: bd migrate --hash-ids

```bash
bd migrate --hash-ids [--dry-run]
```

## Migration Process

### 1. Backup Database
```bash
cp .beads/beads.db .beads/beads.db.backup-1761798384
echo "✓ Backup created: .beads/beads.db.backup-1234567890"
```

### 2. Generate Hash IDs for Existing Issues
```go
func migrateToHashIDs(db *SQLiteStorage) error {
    // Read all issues
    issues, err := db.ListIssues(ctx, ListOptions{Status: "all"})

    // Generate mapping: old ID → new hash ID
    mapping := make(map[string]string)
    for _, issue := range issues {
        hashID := GenerateHashID(
            issue.Title,
            issue.Description,
            issue.CreatedAt,
            db.workspaceID,
        )
        mapping[issue.ID] = hashID
    }

    // Detect hash collisions (extremely rare)
    if hasCollisions(mapping) {
        return fmt.Errorf("hash collision detected, aborting")
    }

    return nil
}
```

### 3. Update Database Schema
```sql
-- Add alias column
ALTER TABLE issues ADD COLUMN alias INTEGER UNIQUE;

-- Populate aliases from old IDs
UPDATE issues SET alias = CAST(SUBSTR(id, 4) AS INTEGER)
  WHERE id LIKE 'bd-%' AND SUBSTR(id, 4) GLOB '[0-9]*';

-- Create new issues_new table with hash IDs
CREATE TABLE issues_new (
    id TEXT PRIMARY KEY,  -- Hash IDs now
    alias INTEGER UNIQUE,
    title TEXT NOT NULL,
    -- ... rest of schema
);

-- Copy data with ID mapping
INSERT INTO issues_new SELECT
    <new_hash_id>,  -- From mapping
    alias,
    title,
    -- ...
FROM issues;

-- Drop old table, rename new
DROP TABLE issues;
ALTER TABLE issues_new RENAME TO issues;
```

### 4. Update Dependencies
```sql
-- Update depends_on_id using mapping
UPDATE dependencies
SET issue_id = <new_hash_id>,
    depends_on_id = <new_depends_on_hash_id>
FROM mapping;
```

### 5. Update Text References
```go
// Update all text fields that mention old IDs
func updateTextReferences(db *SQLiteStorage, mapping map[string]string) error {
    for oldID, newID := range mapping {
        // Update description, notes, design, acceptance_criteria
        db.Exec(`UPDATE issues SET
            description = REPLACE(description, ?, ?),
            notes = REPLACE(notes, ?, ?),
            design = REPLACE(design, ?, ?),
            acceptance_criteria = REPLACE(acceptance_criteria, ?, ?)
        `, oldID, newID, oldID, newID, oldID, newID, oldID, newID)
    }
}
```

### 6. Export to JSONL
```bash
bd export  # Writes hash IDs to .beads/issues.jsonl
git add .beads/issues.jsonl
git commit -m "Migrate to hash-based IDs"
```

## Output
```bash
$ bd migrate --hash-ids
Migrating to hash-based IDs...
✓ Backup created: .beads/beads.db.backup-1730246400
✓ Generated 150 hash IDs
✓ No hash collisions detected
✓ Updated issues table schema
✓ Updated 150 issue IDs
✓ Updated 87 dependencies
✓ Updated 234 text references
✓ Exported to .beads/issues.jsonl
✓ Migration complete!

Next steps:
  1. Test: bd list, bd show #1, etc.
  2. Commit: git commit -m "Migrate to hash-based IDs"
  3. Push: git push origin main
  4. Notify collaborators to pull and re-init
```

## Dry Run Mode
```bash
$ bd migrate --hash-ids --dry-run
[DRY RUN] Would migrate 150 issues:
  bd-1c63eb84   → bd-af78e9a2  (alias: #1)
  bd-9063acda   → bd-e5f6a7b8  (alias: #2)
  ...
  bd-150 → bd-9a8b7c6d  (alias: #150)

[DRY RUN] Would update:
  - 150 issue IDs
  - 87 dependencies
  - 234 text references in descriptions/notes

No changes made. Run without --dry-run to apply.
```

## Files to Create
- cmd/bd/migrate.go (new command)
- internal/storage/sqlite/migrations/hash_ids.go

## Testing
- Test migration on small database (10 issues)
- Test migration on large database (1000 issues)
- Test hash collision detection (inject collision artificially)
- Test text reference updates
- Test rollback (restore from backup)
- Test migrated database works correctly

## Rollback Procedure
```bash
# If migration fails or has issues
mv .beads/beads.db.backup-1234567890 .beads/beads.db
bd export  # Restore JSONL from backup DB
```

## Multi-Clone Coordination
**Important**: All clones must migrate before syncing:

1. Coordinator sends message: "Migrating to hash IDs on 2025-10-30 at 10:00 UTC"
2. All collaborators pull latest changes
3. All run: `bd migrate --hash-ids`
4. All push changes
5. New work can continue with hash IDs

**Do NOT**:
- Mix sequential and hash IDs in same database
- Sync before all clones migrate


Test graceful degradation when server unavailable

Verify that agents continue working normally when Agent Mail server is stopped or unreachable.

Acceptance Criteria:
- Agent detects server unavailable on startup
- Logs "falling back to Beads-only mode"
- All bd commands work normally
- Agent can claim issues (no reservations, like today)
- Git sync operates as normal
- No errors or crashes

Success Metric: Zero functional difference when Agent Mail unavailable


Test child issue


Issue 1


Delete skipped tests for "old buggy behavior"

Three test functions are permanently skipped with comments indicating they test behavior that was fixed in GH#120. These tests will never run again and should be deleted.

Test functions to remove:

1. `cmd/bd/import_collision_test.go:228`
   ```go
   t.Skip("Test expects old buggy behavior - needs rewrite for GH#120 fix")
   ```

2. `cmd/bd/import_collision_test.go:505`
   ```go
   t.Skip("Test expects old buggy behavior - needs rewrite for GH#120 fix")
   ```

3. `internal/storage/sqlite/collision_test.go:919`
   ```go
   t.Skip("Test expects old buggy behavior - needs rewrite for GH#120 fix")
   ```

Impact: Removes ~150 LOC of permanently skipped tests


Update documentation for hash IDs and aliases

Update all documentation to explain hash-based IDs and aliasing system.

## Files to Update

### 1. README.md
Add section explaining hash IDs:
```markdown
## Issue IDs

Beads uses **hash-based IDs** for collision-free distributed issue tracking:

- **Hash ID**: `bd-af78e9a2` (8-char SHA256 prefix, immutable, globally unique)
- **Alias**: `#42` (sequential number, mutable, human-friendly)

### Using IDs
```bash
bd show bd-af78e9a2   # Use hash ID
bd show #42           # Use alias
bd show 42            # Use alias (shorthand)
```

### Why Hash IDs?
- **Collision-free**: Work offline without ID conflicts
- **Distributed**: No coordination needed between clones
- **Git-friendly**: Different IDs = different JSONL lines, fewer merge conflicts

### Aliases
Aliases are workspace-local shortcuts for hash IDs. They're:
- Automatically assigned on issue creation
- Reassigned deterministically on sync (if conflicts)
- Can be manually controlled with `bd alias` commands
```

### 2. AGENTS.md
Update agent workflow:
```markdown
## Hash-Based IDs (v2.0+)

Beads v2.0 uses hash-based IDs to eliminate collision problems:

**When creating issues**:
```bash
bd create "Fix bug" -p 1
# → Creates bd-af78e9a2 with alias #1
```

**When referencing issues**:
- In text: Use hash IDs (stable): "See bd-af78e9a2 for details"
- In CLI: Use aliases (readable): `bd update #42 --status done`

**After sync**:
- Alias conflicts resolved automatically (content-hash ordering)
- No ID collisions possible
- No remapping needed

**Migration from v1.x**:
```bash
bd migrate --hash-ids  # One-time migration
```
```

### 3. QUICKSTART.md (if exists)
Show alias usage in examples:
```bash
# Create issue (gets hash ID + alias)
bd create "Fix authentication bug" -p 1
# → Created bd-af78e9a2 (alias: #1)

# Reference by alias
bd show #1
bd update #1 --status in_progress
bd close #1 --reason "Fixed"
```

### 4. ADVANCED.md
Add section on hash ID internals:
```markdown
## Hash ID Generation

Hash IDs are generated deterministically:

```go
SHA256(title || description || timestamp || workspace_id)[:8]
```

**Collision probability**:
- 8 hex chars = 2^32 space = ~4 billion IDs
- Birthday paradox: 50% collision probability at ~65,000 issues
- For typical projects (<10,000 issues), collision risk is negligible

**Collision detection**:
If a hash collision occurs (extremely rare), beads:
1. Detects on insert (UNIQUE constraint)
2. Appends random suffix: `bd-af78e9a2-a1b2`
3. Retries insert

## Alias Conflict Resolution

When multiple clones assign same alias to different issues:

**Strategy**: Content-hash ordering (deterministic)
- Sort conflicting issue IDs lexicographically
- Lowest hash ID keeps the alias
- Others reassigned to next available aliases

**Example**:
```
Clone A: Assigns #42 to bd-a1b2c3d4
Clone B: Assigns #42 to bd-e5f6a7b8
After sync: bd-a1b2c3d4 keeps #42 (lower hash)
            bd-e5f6a7b8 gets #100 (next available)
```
```

### 5. MIGRATION.md (new file)
```markdown
# Migrating to Hash-Based IDs (v2.0)

## Overview
Beads v2.0 introduces hash-based IDs to eliminate collision problems. This is a **breaking change** requiring migration.

## Migration Steps

### 1. Backup
```bash
cp -r .beads .beads.backup
git commit -am "Pre-migration backup"
```

### 2. Run Migration
```bash
# Dry run first
bd migrate --hash-ids --dry-run

# Apply migration
bd migrate --hash-ids
```

### 3. Commit Changes
```bash
git add .beads/issues.jsonl
git commit -m "Migrate to hash-based IDs (v2.0)"
git push origin main
```

### 4. Coordinate with Collaborators
All clones must migrate before syncing:
1. Notify team: "Migrating to v2.0 on [date]"
2. All collaborators pull latest
3. All run `bd migrate --hash-ids`
4. All push changes
5. Resume normal work

## Rollback
```bash
# Restore backup
mv .beads.backup .beads
bd export  # Regenerate JSONL
git checkout .beads/issues.jsonl
```

## FAQ

**Q: Can I mix v1.x and v2.0 clones?**
A: No. All clones must be on same version.

**Q: Will my old issue IDs work?**
A: No, but aliases preserve the numbers: bd-1c63eb84 → #1

**Q: What happens to links like "see bd-cb64c226.3"?**
A: Migration updates all text references automatically.
```

### 6. CHANGELOG.md
```markdown
## v2.0.0 (YYYY-MM-DD)

### Breaking Changes
- **Hash-based IDs**: Issues now use collision-free hash IDs (bd-af78e9a2)
  instead of sequential IDs (bd-1c63eb84, bd-9063acda)
- **Aliasing system**: Human-friendly aliases (#42) for hash IDs
- **Migration required**: Run `bd migrate --hash-ids` to convert v1.x databases

### Added
- `bd alias` command for manual alias control
- `bd migrate --hash-ids` migration tool
- Alias conflict resolution (deterministic, content-hash ordering)

### Removed
- ID collision detection and resolution (~2,100 LOC)
- `bd import --resolve-collisions` flag (no longer needed)

### Benefits
- ✅ Zero ID collisions in distributed workflows
- ✅ Simpler codebase (-1,350 net LOC)
- ✅ Better git merge behavior
- ✅ True offline-first operation
```

## Testing
- Build docs locally (if using doc generator)
- Check all links work
- Verify examples are correct
- Spellcheck

## Files to Create/Modify
- README.md (hash ID section)
- AGENTS.md (workflow updates)
- ADVANCED.md (internals)
- MIGRATION.md (new)
- CHANGELOG.md (v2.0 entry)
- docs/ (any other docs)


Test issue 2


Implement CLI command (cmd/bd/reset.go)

Wire up the reset command with Cobra CLI.

## Responsibilities
- Define command and all flags
- User confirmation prompt (unless --force)
- Display impact summary before confirmation
- Colored output and progress indicators
- Call core reset package
- Handle errors with user-friendly messages
- Register command with rootCmd in init()

## Flags
```go
--hard       bool   "Also remove from git and commit"
--force      bool   "Skip confirmation prompt"
--backup     bool   "Create backup before reset"
--dry-run    bool   "Preview what would happen"
--skip-init  bool   "Do not re-initialize after reset"
--verbose    bool   "Show detailed progress output"
```

## Output Format
```
⚠  This will reset beads to a clean state.

Will be deleted:
  • 47 issues (23 open, 24 closed)
  • 12 tombstones

Continue? [y/N] y

→ Stopping daemons... ✓
→ Removing .beads/... ✓
→ Initializing fresh... ✓

✓ Reset complete. Run 'bd onboard' to set up hooks.
```

## Implementation Notes
- Confirmation logic lives HERE, not in core package
- Use color package (github.com/fatih/color) for output
- Follow patterns from other commands (init.go, doctor.go)
- Add to rootCmd in init() function

## File Location
`cmd/bd/reset.go`


UX nightmare: multiple ways daemon can fail with misleading messages


Jira export script (jsonl2jira.py)

Create a Python script to push beads issues to Jira.

**Requires**: Jira import script to be complete first (need external_ref matching logic working)

**Features needed**:
- Create new Jira issues from beads issues without external_ref
- Update existing Jira issues matched by external_ref
- Map beads fields back to Jira fields
- Handle Jira workflow transitions (status changes may need transitions)
- Support custom field mapping for design/acceptance_criteria/notes

**Challenges**:
- Jira status changes often require workflow transitions, not direct updates
- Need to discover valid transitions via API
- Custom fields vary by Jira instance

**Usage**:
```bash
bd export | python jsonl2jira.py --create-only  # Only create, don't update
bd export | python jsonl2jira.py                 # Create and update
```

**After creation**: Sets external_ref on beads issue to link back


Test label


SearchIssues N+1 query causes context timeout with GetLabels

scanIssues() calls GetLabels in a loop for every issue, causing N+1 queries and context deadline exceeded errors when used with short timeouts or in-memory databases. This is especially problematic since SearchIssues already supports label filtering via SQL WHERE clauses.


bd init resets metadata.json jsonl_export to beads.jsonl, ignoring existing issues.jsonl

When running 'bd init --prefix bd' in a repo that already has .beads/issues.jsonl, the init command overwrites metadata.json and sets jsonl_export back to 'beads.jsonl' instead of detecting and respecting the existing issues.jsonl file.

Steps to reproduce:
1. Have a repo with .beads/issues.jsonl (canonical) and metadata.json pointing to issues.jsonl
2. Delete beads.db and run 'bd init --prefix bd'
3. Check metadata.json - it now says jsonl_export: beads.jsonl

Expected: Init should detect existing issues.jsonl and use it.

Workaround: Manually edit metadata.json after init.


Create multi-agent race condition test

Automated test that runs 2+ agents simultaneously to verify collision prevention.

Acceptance Criteria:
- Script spawns 2 agents in parallel
- Both try to claim same issue
- Only one succeeds (via reservation)
- Other agent skips to different work
- Verify in JSONL that no duplicate claims
- Test with Agent Mail enabled/disabled

File: tests/integration/test_agent_race.py

Success Metric: Zero duplicate claims with Agent Mail, collisions without it


Add git operations for --hard reset

Implement git integration for hard reset mode.

## Operations Needed
1. `git rm -rf .beads/*.jsonl` - remove data files from index
2. `git commit -m 'beads: reset to clean state'` - commit removal
3. After re-init: `git add .beads/` and commit fresh state

## Edge Cases to Handle
- Uncommitted changes in .beads/ - warn or error
- Detached HEAD state - warn, maybe block
- Git not initialized - skip git ops, warn
- Git operations fail mid-way - clear error messaging

## Interface
```go
type GitState struct {
    IsRepo       bool
    IsDirty      bool   // uncommitted changes in .beads/
    IsDetached   bool   // detached HEAD
    Branch       string // current branch name
}

func CheckGitState(beadsDir string) (*GitState, error)
func GitRemoveBeads(beadsDir string) error
func GitCommitReset(message string) error
func GitAddAndCommit(beadsDir, message string) error
```

## Location
`internal/reset/git.go` - keep with reset package for now

Note: Codebase has no central git package. internal/compact/git.go is compact-specific.
Future refactoring could extract shared git utilities, but YAGNI for now.


bd message: Implement full message reading functionality

The `bd message read` command is incomplete and doesn't actually fetch or display message content.

**Location:** cmd/bd/message.go:413-441

**Current Behavior:**
- Only marks message as read
- Prints placeholder text
- Doesn't fetch message body

**Expected:**
- Fetch full message from Agent Mail resource API
- Display sender, subject, timestamp, body
- Consider markdown rendering

**Blocker:** Core feature for message system MVP


Create tip system infrastructure for contextual hints

Implement a tip/hint system that shows helpful contextual messages after successful commands. This is different from the existing error-path "Hint:" messages - tips appear on success paths to educate users about features they might not know about.


Centralize error handling patterns in storage layer

80+ instances of inconsistent error handling across sqlite.go with mix of %w, %v, and no wrapping.

Location: internal/storage/sqlite/sqlite.go (throughout)

Problem:
- Some use fmt.Errorf("op failed: %w", err) - correct wrapping
- Some use fmt.Errorf("op failed: %v", err) - loses error chain
- Some return err directly - no context
- Hard to debug production issues
- Can't distinguish error types

Solution: Create internal/storage/sqlite/errors.go:
- Define sentinel errors (ErrNotFound, ErrInvalidID, etc.)
- Create wrapDBError(op string, err error) helper
- Convert sql.ErrNoRows to ErrNotFound
- Always wrap with operation context

Impact: Lost error context; inconsistent messages; hard to debug

Effort: 5-7 hours


Refactor duplicate JSONL-from-git parsing code

Both readFirstIssueFromGit() in init.go and importFromGit() in autoimport.go have similar code patterns for:
1. Running git show <ref>:<path>
2. Scanning the output with bufio.Scanner
3. Parsing JSON lines

Could be refactored to share a helper like:
- readJSONLFromGit(gitRef, path string) ([]byte, error)
- Or a streaming version: streamJSONLFromGit(gitRef, path string) (io.Reader, error)

Files:
- cmd/bd/autoimport.go:225-256 (importFromGit)
- cmd/bd/init.go:1212-1243 (readFirstIssueFromGit)

Priority is low since code duplication is minimal and both functions work correctly.


Support --parent flag in daemon mode

Added support for hierarchical child issue creation using --parent flag in daemon mode. Previously only worked in direct mode.


Extract daemon config functions to daemon_config.go


Fix N-way collision convergence

Epic to fix the N-way collision convergence problem documented in n-way-collision-convergence.md.

## Problem Summary
The current collision resolution implementation works correctly for 2-way collisions but does not converge for 3-way (and by extension N-way) collisions. TestThreeCloneCollision demonstrates this with reproducible failures.

## Root Causes Identified
1. Pairwise resolution doesn't scale - each clone makes local decisions without global context
2. DetectCollisions modifies state during detection (line 83-86 in collision.go)
3. No remapping history - can't track transitive remap chains (test-1 → test-2 → test-3)
4. Import-time resolution is too late - happens after git merge

## Solution Architecture
Replace pairwise resolution with deterministic global N-way resolution using:
- Content-addressable identity (content hashing)
- Global collision resolution (sort all versions by hash)
- Read-only detection phase (separate from modification)
- Idempotent imports (content-first matching)

## Success Criteria
- TestThreeCloneCollision passes without skipping
- All clones converge to identical content after final pull
- No data loss (all issues present in all clones)
- Works for N workers (test with 5+ clones)
- Idempotent imports (importing same JSONL multiple times is safe)

## Implementation Phases
See child issues for detailed breakdown of each phase.


Investigate and optimize test suite performance

Test suite is taking very long to run (>45s for cmd/bd tests, full suite timing unknown but was cancelled).

This impacts development velocity and CI/CD performance.

Investigation needed:
- Profile which tests are slowest
- Identify bottlenecks (disk I/O, network, excessive setup/teardown?)
- Consider parallelization opportunities
- Look for redundant test cases
- Check if integration tests can be optimized


mergePriority: negative priorities not handled consistently


Centralize BD_DEBUG logging into debug package

The codebase has 43 scattered instances of `if os.Getenv("BD_DEBUG") != ""` debug checks across 6 files. Centralize into a debug logging package.

Current locations:
- `cmd/bd/main.go` - 15 checks
- `cmd/bd/autoflush.go` - 6 checks
- `cmd/bd/nodb.go` - 4 checks
- `internal/rpc/server.go` - 2 checks
- `internal/rpc/client.go` - 5 checks
- `cmd/bd/daemon_autostart.go` - 11 checks

Target structure:
```
internal/debug/
└── debug.go
```

Benefits:
- Centralized debug logging
- Easier to add structured logging later
- Testable (can mock debug output)
- Consistent debug message format

Impact: Removes 43 scattered checks, improves code clarity


Rapid 2


Imperator lacks mail hooks for automatic notification


Add functional tests for FlushManager correctness verification


Create examples for common workflows

Add examples/ subdirectories: OSS contributor workflow, team branch workflow, multi-phase development, multiple personas (architect/implementer). Each with README and sample configs.


Add tests for helper functions (GetDirtyIssueHash, GetAllDependencyRecords, export hashes)

Several utility functions have 0% coverage:
- GetDirtyIssueHash (dirty.go)
- GetAllDependencyRecords (dependencies.go)
- GetExportHash, SetExportHash, ClearAllExportHashes (hash.go)

These are lower priority but should have basic coverage.


Test issue 0


Add MCP server functions for repair commands

Expose new repair commands via MCP server for agent access:

Functions to add:
- beads_repair_deps()
- beads_detect_pollution()
- beads_validate()
- beads_resolve_conflicts() (when implemented)

Update integrations/beads-mcp/src/beads_mcp/server.py

See repair_commands.md lines 803-884 for design.


GH#243: Recurring stale daemon.lock causes 5s delays

User reports daemon.lock keeps becoming stale after running Claude with beads.

Symptom:
- bd ready takes 5 seconds (exact)
- daemon.lock exists but socket is missing
- bd daemons killall temporarily fixes it
- Problem recurs after using beads with AI agents

User on v0.22.0, Macbook M2, 132 issues (89 closed)

Hypothesis: Daemon is crashing or exiting uncleanly during agent sessions, leaving stale lock file.

Need to:
1. Add crash logging to daemon to understand why it's exiting
2. Improve cleanup on daemon exit (ensure lock is always removed)
3. Add automatic stale lock detection/cleanup
4. Consider making daemon more resilient to crashes

Oracle analysis complete. Converting to epic with 5 focused sub-issues:
1. RPC fast-fail with socket stat + short timeouts (P0)
2. Standardize daemon detection with lock probe (P1)
3. Crash recovery improvements (P2)
4. Self-heal stale artifacts (P2)
5. Diagnostics and debugging (P3)


Final validation test


Frontend task


Multi-repo hydration layer

Build core infrastructure to hydrate database from N repos (N≥1), with smart caching via file mtime tracking and routing writes to correct JSONL based on source_repo metadata.


Modify CreateIssue to support parent resurrection

Update internal/storage/sqlite/sqlite.go:182-196 to call TryResurrectParent before failing on missing parent. Coordinate with EnsureIDs changes for consistent behavior. Handle edge case where parent never existed in JSONL (fail gracefully).


Fix unparam unused parameter in cmd/bd/doctor.go:1879

Linting issue: checkGitHooks - path is unused (unparam) at cmd/bd/doctor.go:1879:20. Error: func checkGitHooks(path string) doctorCheck {


bd info shows 'auto_start_disabled' even when daemon is crashed/missing


bd message: Add HTTP client timeout to prevent hangs

HTTP client in `sendAgentMailRequest` uses default http.Post with no timeout.

**Location:** cmd/bd/message.go:181

**Problem:**
- Can hang indefinitely if server is unresponsive
- No way to cancel stuck requests
- Poor UX in flaky networks

**Fix:**
```go
client := &http.Client{Timeout: 30 * time.Second}
resp, err := client.Post(url, "application/json", bytes.NewReader(reqBody))
```

**Impact:** Production reliability and security issue


bd import silently succeeds when database matches working tree but not git HEAD

**Critical**: bd import reports '0 created, 0 updated' when database matches working tree JSONL, even when working tree is ahead of git HEAD. This gives false confidence that everything is synced with the source of truth.

## Reproduction

1. Start with database synced to working tree .beads/issues.jsonl (376 issues)
2. Git HEAD has older version of .beads/issues.jsonl (354 issues)
3. Run: bd import .beads/issues.jsonl
4. Output: 'Import complete: 0 created, 0 updated'

## Problem

User expects 'bd import' after 'git pull' to sync database with committed state, but:
- Command silently succeeds because DB already matches working tree
- No warning that working tree has uncommitted changes
- User falsely believes everything is synced with git
- Violates 'JSONL in git is source of truth' principle

## Expected Behavior

When .beads/issues.jsonl differs from git HEAD, bd import should:
1. Detect uncommitted changes: git diff --quiet HEAD .beads/issues.jsonl
2. Warn user: 'Warning: .beads/issues.jsonl has uncommitted changes (376 lines vs 354 in HEAD)'
3. Clarify status: 'Import complete: 0 created, 0 updated (already synced with working tree)'
4. Recommend: 'Run git diff .beads/issues.jsonl to review uncommitted work'

## Impact

- Users can't trust 'bd import' status messages
- Silent data loss risk if user assumes synced and runs git checkout
- Breaks mental model of 'JSONL in git = source of truth'
- Critical for VC's landing-the-plane workflow


sync tries to create worktree in .git file

example: bd sync --no-daemon
→ Exporting pending changes to JSONL...
→ Committing changes to sync branch 'worktree-db-fail'...
Error committing to sync branch: failed to create worktree: failed to create worktree parent directory: mkdir /var/home/matt/dev/beads/worktree-db-fail/.git: not a directory


Feature with design

This is a description


Add index usage verification test for external_ref lookups

Currently we test that idx_issues_external_ref index exists, but we don't verify that it's actually being used by the query planner.

Proposed solution:
- Add test using EXPLAIN QUERY PLAN
- Verify that 'SEARCH TABLE issues USING INDEX idx_issues_external_ref' appears in plan
- Ensures O(1) lookup performance is maintained

Related: bd-1022
Files: internal/storage/sqlite/external_ref_test.go:260


Migration guide documentation

Write comprehensive migration guide covering: OSS contributor workflow, team workflow, multi-phase development, multiple personas. Include step-by-step instructions, troubleshooting, and backward compatibility notes.


Bug P0


Update bd compact to prune expired tombstones

Modify compaction to identify and remove expired tombstones from issues.jsonl. Report count of removed tombstones. Per design bd-1r5.


Deletion propagation via deletions manifest

## Problem

When `bd cleanup -f` or `bd delete` removes issues in one clone, those deletions don't propagate to other clones. The import logic only creates/updates, never deletes. This causes "resurrection" where deleted issues reappear.

## Root Cause

Import sees DB issues not in JSONL and assumes they're "local unpushed work" rather than "intentionally deleted upstream."

## Solution: Deletions Manifest

Add `.beads/deletions.jsonl` - an append-only log of deleted issue IDs with metadata.

### Format
```jsonl
{"id":"bd-xxx","ts":"2025-11-25T10:00:00Z","by":"stevey"}
{"id":"bd-yyy","ts":"2025-11-25T10:05:00Z","by":"claude","reason":"duplicate of bd-zzz"}
```

### Fields
- `id`: Issue ID (required)
- `ts`: ISO 8601 UTC timestamp (required)
- `by`: Actor who deleted (required)
- `reason`: Optional context ("cleanup", "duplicate of X", etc.)

### Import Logic
```
For each DB issue not in JSONL:
  1. Check deletions manifest → if found, delete from DB
  2. Fallback: check git history → if found, delete + backfill manifest
  3. Neither → keep (local unpushed work)
```

### Conflict Resolution
Simultaneous deletions from multiple clones are handled naturally:
- Append-only design means both clones append their deletion records
- On merge, file contains duplicate entries (same ID, different timestamps)
- `LoadDeletions` deduplicates by ID (keeps any/first entry)
- Result: deletion propagates correctly, duplicates are harmless

### Pruning Policy
- Default retention: 7 days (configurable via `deletions.retention_days`)
- Auto-compact during `bd sync` is **opt-in** (disabled by default)
- Hard cap: `deletions.max_entries` (default 50000)
- Git fallback handles pruned entries (self-healing)

### Self-Healing
When git fallback catches a resurrection (pruned entry), it backfills the manifest. One-time git scan cost, then fast again.

### Size Estimates
- ~80 bytes/entry
- 7-day retention with 100 deletions/day = ~56KB
- Git compressed: ~10KB

## Benefits
- ✅ Deletions propagate across clones
- ✅ O(1) lookup (no git scan in normal case)
- ✅ Works in shallow clones
- ✅ Survives history rewrite
- ✅ Audit trail (who deleted what when)
- ✅ Self-healing via git fallback
- ✅ Bounded size via time-based pruning

## References
- Investigation session: 2025-11-25
- Related: bd-2q6d (stale database warnings)


Add --lock-timeout global flag

Add new global flag to control SQLite busy_timeout.

## Implementation
1. Add to cmd/bd/main.go:
   - `lockTimeout time.Duration` global variable
   - Register flag: `--lock-timeout=<duration>` (default 30s)

2. Add config support in internal/config/config.go:
   - `v.SetDefault("lock-timeout", "30s")`
   - Read from config.yaml if not set via flag

3. Pass timeout to sqlite.New() - see next task

## Acceptance Criteria
- `bd --lock-timeout=0 list` fails immediately if DB is locked
- `bd --lock-timeout=100ms list` waits max 100ms
- Config file setting works: `lock-timeout: 100ms`
- Default remains 30s for backward compatibility

Part of bd-olc1

recovered from git history (pruned from manifest)


Support --reason flag in daemon mode for reopen command

The reopen.go command has a TODO at line 61 to add reason as a comment once RPC supports AddComment. Currently --reason flag is ignored in daemon mode with a warning.


Implement content-hash based collision resolution for deterministic convergence

The current collision resolution uses creation timestamps to decide which issue to keep vs. remap. This is non-deterministic when two clones create issues at nearly the same time.

Root cause of bd-71107098:
- Clone A creates test-1="Issue from clone A" at T0
- Clone B creates test-1="Issue from clone B" at T0+30ms
- Clone B syncs first, remaps Clone A's to test-2
- Clone A syncs second, sees collision, remaps Clone B's to test-2
- Result: titles are swapped between clones

Solution:
- Use content-based hashing (title + description + priority + type)
- Deterministic winner: always keep issue with lower hash
- Same collision on different clones produces same result (idempotent)

Implementation:
- Modify ScoreCollisions in internal/storage/sqlite/collision.go
- Replace timestamp-based scoring with content hash comparison
- Ensure hash function is stable across platforms

Rename detection successfully implemented and tested!

**What was implemented:**
1. Content-hash based rename detection in DetectCollisions
2. When importing JSONL, if an issue has different ID but same content as DB issue, treat as rename
3. Delete old ID and accept new ID from JSONL
4. Added post-import re-export in sync command to flush rename changes
5. Added post-import commit to capture rename changes

**Test results:**
TestTwoCloneCollision now shows full convergence:
- Clone A: test-2="Issue from clone A", test-1="Issue from clone B"
- Clone B: test-1="Issue from clone B", test-2="Issue from clone A"

Both clones have **identical content** (titles match IDs correctly). Only timestamps differ (expected).

**What remains:**
- Test still expects exact JSON match including timestamps
- Could normalize timestamp comparison, but content convergence is the critical success metric
- The two-clone collision workflow now works without data corruption!


Implement topological sort for import ordering

Refactor upsertIssues() to sort issues by hierarchy depth before batch creation. Ensures parents are created before children, fixing latent bug where parent-child pairs in same batch can fail if ordered wrong. Sort by dot count, create in depth-order batches (0→1→2→3).


Add 'bd message send' command for Agent Mail messaging

Agent Mail server supports messaging between agents, but bd CLI only uses it for file reservations. Add commands for inter-agent messaging.

## Background
- Agent Mail server running at http://127.0.0.1:8765
- 12 workspaces configured across 3 channels (beads.dev, vc.dev, wyvern.dev)
- Current integration: file reservations only
- Gap: no way to send messages from bd CLI

## Proposed Commands

```bash
# Send message to another agent
bd message send <to-agent> <message> [options]
  --subject <subject>
  --thread-id <thread-id>     # Optional - group related messages
  --project-id <project>      # Defaults to BEADS_PROJECT_ID

# List inbox messages
bd message inbox [options]
  --limit <N>
  --unread-only

# Read specific message
bd message read <message-id>

# Mark message as acknowledged
bd message ack <message-id>
```

## Example Usage

```bash
# Send message to agent in same channel
bd message send cino-beads-stevey-macbook "Working on bd-z0yn, need your review" \
  --subject "Review request" \
  --thread-id bd-z0yn

# Check inbox
bd message inbox --unread-only

# Read and acknowledge
bd message read msg-abc123
bd message ack msg-abc123
```

## Design Notes
- Use same env vars (BEADS_AGENT_MAIL_URL, BEADS_AGENT_NAME, BEADS_PROJECT_ID)
- Graceful degradation if Agent Mail unavailable
- JSON output support for all commands
- Consider integrating with bd update/close (auto-notify on status changes)

## References
- Agent Mail README: ~/src/mcp_agent_mail/README.md
- Beads integration docs: docs/AGENT_MAIL.md

## Implementation Summary

Added four new commands to bd CLI for Agent Mail messaging:

1. `bd message send <to-agent> <message>` - Send messages to other agents
   - Flags: --subject, --thread-id, --importance, --ack-required
   - Supports markdown content
   - Thread conversations by issue ID

2. `bd message inbox` - List inbox messages
   - Flags: --limit, --unread-only, --urgent-only, --json
   - Shows subject, sender, age, importance
   - Highlights unread and ACK-required messages

3. `bd message read <message-id>` - Read and mark message as read
   - Automatically marks message as read
   - Shows message content

4. `bd message ack <message-id>` - Acknowledge a message
   - Marks message as acknowledged
   - Also marks as read if not already

## Implementation Details

- Uses JSON-RPC over HTTP to communicate with Agent Mail server
- Configuration via environment variables (BEADS_AGENT_MAIL_URL, BEADS_AGENT_NAME, BEADS_PROJECT_ID)
- Graceful error messages when Agent Mail not configured
- Full JSON output support for programmatic use
- Follows same patterns as existing bd commands

## Documentation

Updated:
- docs/AGENT_MAIL.md - Added "Messaging Commands" section with examples and best practices
- README.md - Added "Messaging (Agent Mail)" section in Usage

## Testing

- Compiles successfully
- Help output works correctly
- Ready for integration testing with Agent Mail server


Vendor and integrate beads-merge tool

Incorporate @neongreen's beads-merge 3-way merge tool into bd to solve:
- Multi-workspace deletion sync (bd-hv01)
- Git merge conflicts in JSONL
- Field-level intelligent merging

**Repository**: https://github.com/neongreen/mono/tree/main/beads-merge

**Integration approach**: Vendor the Go code with attribution, pending @neongreen's approval (GitHub issue #240)

**Benefits**:
- Prevents deletion resurrection bug
- Smart dependency merging (union + dedup)
- Timestamp handling (max wins)
- Detects deleted-vs-modified conflicts
- Works as git merge driver

**Acceptance criteria**:
- beads-merge code vendored into bd codebase
- Available as `bd merge` command
- Git merge driver setup during `bd init`
- Tests verify 3-way merge logic
- Documentation updated
- @neongreen credited


Implement global N-way collision resolution algorithm

## Overview
Phase 3: Replace pairwise collision resolution with global N-way resolution that produces deterministic results regardless of sync order.

## Current Problem
ScoreCollisions (collision.go:228) compares issues pairwise:
```go
collision.RemapIncoming = existingHash < incomingHash
```

This works for 2-way but fails for 3+ way because:
- Each clone makes local decisions without global context
- No guarantee intermediate states are consistent
- Remapping decisions depend on sync order
- Can't detect transitive remap chains (test-1 → test-2 → test-3)

## Solution
Implement global resolution that:
1. Collects ALL versions of same logical issue
2. Sorts by content hash (deterministic)
3. Assigns sequential IDs based on sorted order
4. All clones converge to same assignments

## Implementation Tasks

### 1. Create ResolveNWayCollisions function
File: internal/storage/sqlite/collision.go

Replace ScoreCollisions with:
```go
// ResolveNWayCollisions handles N-way collisions deterministically.
// Groups all versions with same base ID, sorts by content hash,
// assigns sequential IDs. Returns mapping of old ID → new ID.
func ResolveNWayCollisions(ctx context.Context, s *SQLiteStorage,
    collisions []*CollisionDetail, incoming []*types.Issue) (map[string]string, error) {

    if len(collisions) == 0 {
        return make(map[string]string), nil
    }

    // Group by base ID pattern (e.g., test-1, test-2 → base "test-1")
    groups := groupCollisionsByBaseID(collisions)

    idMapping := make(map[string]string)

    for baseID, versions := range groups {
        // 1. Collect all unique versions by content hash
        uniqueVersions := deduplicateVersionsByContentHash(versions)

        // 2. Sort by content hash (deterministic!)
        sort.Slice(uniqueVersions, func(i, j int) bool {
            return uniqueVersions[i].ContentHash < uniqueVersions[j].ContentHash
        })

        // 3. Assign sequential IDs based on sorted order
        prefix := extractPrefix(baseID)
        baseNum := extractNumber(baseID)

        for i, version := range uniqueVersions {
            targetID := fmt.Sprintf("%s-%d", prefix, baseNum+i)

            // Map this version to its deterministic ID
            if version.ID != targetID {
                idMapping[version.ID] = targetID
            }
        }
    }

    return idMapping, nil
}
```

### 2. Implement helper functions

```go
// groupCollisionsByBaseID groups collisions by their logical base ID
func groupCollisionsByBaseID(collisions []*CollisionDetail) map[string][]*types.Issue {
    groups := make(map[string][]*types.Issue)
    for _, c := range collisions {
        baseID := c.ID  // All share same ID (that's why they collide)
        groups[baseID] = append(groups[baseID], c.ExistingIssue, c.IncomingIssue)
    }
    return groups
}

// deduplicateVersionsByContentHash keeps one issue per unique content hash
func deduplicateVersionsByContentHash(issues []*types.Issue) []*types.Issue {
    seen := make(map[string]*types.Issue)
    for _, issue := range issues {
        if _, found := seen[issue.ContentHash]; !found {
            seen[issue.ContentHash] = issue
        }
    }
    result := make([]*types.Issue, 0, len(seen))
    for _, issue := range seen {
        result = append(result, issue)
    }
    return result
}
```

### 3. Update handleCollisions in importer
File: internal/importer/importer.go

Replace ScoreCollisions call with:
```go
// OLD:
if err := sqlite.ScoreCollisions(ctx, sqliteStore, collisionResult.Collisions, allExistingIssues); err != nil {
    return nil, fmt.Errorf("failed to score collisions: %w", err)
}

// NEW:
idMapping, err := sqlite.ResolveNWayCollisions(ctx, sqliteStore,
    collisionResult.Collisions, issues)
if err != nil {
    return nil, fmt.Errorf("failed to resolve collisions: %w", err)
}
```

### 4. Update RemapCollisions
RemapCollisions currently uses collision.RemapIncoming field. Update to use idMapping directly:
- Remove RemapIncoming logic
- Use idMapping to determine what to remap
- Simplify to just apply the computed mapping

### 5. Add comprehensive tests

Test cases:
1. 3-way collision with different content → 3 sequential IDs
2. 3-way collision with 2 identical content → 2 IDs (dedupe works)
3. Sync order independence (A→B→C vs C→A→B produce same result)
4. Content hash ordering is respected
5. Works with 5+ clones

## Acceptance Criteria
- ResolveNWayCollisions implemented and replaces ScoreCollisions
- Groups all versions of same ID together
- Deduplicates by content hash
- Sorts by content hash deterministically
- Assigns sequential IDs starting from base ID
- Returns complete mapping (old ID → new ID)
- All clones converge to same ID assignments
- Works for arbitrary N-way collisions
- TestThreeCloneCollision passes (or gets much closer)

## Files to Modify
- internal/storage/sqlite/collision.go (new function, helpers)
- internal/importer/importer.go (call new function)
- internal/storage/sqlite/collision_test.go (comprehensive tests)

## Testing Strategy

### Unit Tests
- groupCollisionsByBaseID correctly groups
- deduplicateVersionsByContentHash removes duplicates
- Sorting by hash is stable and deterministic
- Sequential ID assignment is correct

### Integration Tests
- 3-way collision resolves to 3 issues
- Sync order doesn't affect final IDs
- Content hash ordering determines winner

### Property Tests
- For any N clones with same content, all converge to same IDs
- Idempotent: running resolution twice produces same result

## Dependencies
- Requires bd-cbed9619.5 (ContentHash field) to be completed first
- Requires bd-cbed9619.4 (read-only detection) for clean integration

## Notes
This is the core algorithm that enables convergence. The key insight:
**Sort by content hash globally, not pairwise comparison.**


Update AGENTS.md with Agent Mail workflow

Update agent workflow section to include Agent Mail coordination as optional step.

Acceptance Criteria:
- Add Agent Mail to recommended workflow
- Show both with/without examples
- Update "Multi-Agent Patterns" section
- Cross-reference to AGENT_MAIL.md

File: AGENTS.md (lines 468-475)


Add cancellation and timeout tests

Add comprehensive tests for context cancellation and timeout behavior.

## Context
Part of context propagation work. Validates that bd-rtp and bd-yb8 work correctly.

## Test Coverage Needed

### 1. Cancellation Tests
- [ ] Import operation cancelled mid-stream
- [ ] Export operation cancelled mid-stream
- [ ] Database query cancelled during long operation
- [ ] No corruption after cancellation
- [ ] Proper cleanup (defers execute, connections closed)

### 2. Timeout Tests
- [ ] Operations respect context deadlines
- [ ] Appropriate error messages on timeout
- [ ] State remains consistent after timeout

### 3. Signal Handling Tests
- [ ] SIGINT (Ctrl+C) triggers cancellation
- [ ] SIGTERM triggers graceful shutdown
- [ ] Multiple signals handled correctly

## Implementation Approach
```go
func TestImportCancellation(t *testing.T) {
    ctx, cancel := context.WithCancel(context.Background())

    // Start import in goroutine
    go func() {
        err := runImport(ctx, largeFile)
        assert.Error(err, context.Canceled)
    }()

    // Cancel after short delay
    time.Sleep(100 * time.Millisecond)
    cancel()

    // Verify database integrity
    assertDatabaseConsistent(t, store)
}
```

## Files to Create/Update
- cmd/bd/import_test.go - cancellation tests
- cmd/bd/export_test.go - cancellation tests
- internal/storage/sqlite/*_test.go - context timeout tests

## Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] All critical operations have cancellation tests
- [ ] Tests verify database integrity after cancellation
- [ ] Signal handling tested (if feasible)
- [ ] Test coverage >80% for context paths


Priority 0 in merge may incorrectly win over set priorities

In mergePriority(), priority 0 (which may mean 'unset' due to Go's zero value) beats any explicitly set priority like P1, P2, etc. Should probably treat 0 as 'no priority set' and not let it win conflicts.


Add bd reset command for clean slate restart

Implement a command to reset beads to a clean starting state.

**Context:** GitHub issue #479 - users sometimes get beads into an invalid state after updates, and there's no clean way to start fresh. The git backup/restore mechanism that protects against accidental deletion also makes it hard to intentionally reset.

**Current workaround** (from maphew):
```bash
bd daemons killall
git rm .beads/*.jsonl
git commit -m 'remove old issues'
rm .beads/*
bd init
bd onboard
```

**Desired:** A proper `bd reset` command that handles this cleanly and safely.


Update docs for import bug fix

Update AGENTS.md, README.md, TROUBLESHOOTING.md with import.orphan_handling config documentation. Document resurrection behavior, tombstones, config modes. Add troubleshooting section for import failures with deleted parents.


Add bd migrate-tombstones command

Create migration command to convert existing deletions.jsonl entries to tombstones. Support --dry-run and --verbose flags. Archive old file with .migrated suffix. Per design bd-dli.


Add unit tests for import ordering

Test topological sort: import [child, parent] should succeed, import [parent.1.2, parent, parent.1] should sort correctly. Verify depth-based batching works. Test max depth limits.


bd sync should not stage gitignored snapshot files

## Problem

`gitCommitBeadsDir` in `cmd/bd/sync.go` runs `git add .beads/` which stages all files in the directory, including snapshot files that are listed in `.beads/.gitignore`.

If a snapshot file (e.g., `beads.left.meta.json`) was ever committed before being added to `.gitignore`, git continues to track it. This causes merge conflicts when multiple polecats run `bd sync` concurrently, since each one modifies and commits these temporary files.

## Root Cause

Line ~568 in sync.go:
```go
addCmd := exec.CommandContext(ctx, "git", "add", beadsDir)
```

This stages everything in `.beads/`, but `.gitignore` only prevents *untracked* files from being added - it doesn't affect already-tracked files.

## Suggested Fix

Option A: After `git add .beads/`, run `git reset` on snapshot files:
```go
exec.Command("git", "reset", "HEAD", ".beads/beads.*.jsonl", ".beads/*.meta.json")
```

Option B: Stage only specific files instead of the whole directory:
```go
exec.Command("git", "add", ".beads/issues.jsonl", ".beads/deletions.jsonl", ".beads/metadata.json")
```

Option C: Detect and untrack snapshot files if they're tracked:
```go
// Check if file is tracked: git ls-files --error-unmatch <file>
// If tracked, run: git rm --cached <file>
```

Option B is probably cleanest - explicitly add only the files that should be committed.


Add .beads/README.md during 'bd init' for project documentation and promotion

When 'bd init' is run, automatically generate a .beads/README.md file that:

1. Briefly explains what Beads is (AI-native issue tracking that lives in your repo)
2. Links to the main repository: https://github.com/steveyegge/beads
3. Provides a quick reference of essential commands:
   - bd create: Create new issues
   - bd list: View all issues
   - bd update: Modify issue status/details
   - bd show: View issue details
   - bd sync: Sync with git remote
4. Highlights key benefits for AI coding agents and developers
5. Encourages developers to try it out

The README should be enthusiastic and compelling to get open source contributors excited about using Beads for their AI-assisted development workflows.


bd doctor should check for multiple DBs, multiple JSONLs, daemon health


Add index on deleted_at for TTL queries

Per bd-2m7 design: 'Index for efficient tombstone filtering' was recommended. The current implementation does NOT add an index on deleted_at.

For TTL cleanup queries like 'SELECT * FROM issues WHERE deleted_at < datetime(now, -30 days)', this will require a full table scan.

Add to migration or new migration:
CREATE INDEX IF NOT EXISTS idx_issues_deleted_at ON issues(deleted_at) WHERE deleted_at IS NOT NULL


Fix bd doctor --fix recursive message for deletions manifest

When running bd doctor --fix, if the deletions manifest check fails but there are no deleted issues in git history, the fix succeeds but doesn't create the file. The check then runs again and tells user to run bd doctor --fix - the same command they just ran.

Fix: Create empty deletions.jsonl when hydration finds no deletions, and recognize empty file as valid in the check.

Fixes: https://github.com/steveyegge/beads/issues/403


Add tombstone doctor checks

Add bd doctor checks for: unmigrated deletions.jsonl, stale deletions.jsonl in Phase 3, tombstones expiring soon. Per design bd-dli.


Config option sync.require_confirmation_on_mass_delete

Add config option for paranoid users who want confirmation before pushing after mass deletion.

Option: sync.require_confirmation_on_mass_delete
Default: false

When enabled AND safety check triggers:
- Prompt user for confirmation before pushing
- Show them what would be pushed

For users who have been burned and want extra safety. Most users will not need this.

Location: internal/config/ and internal/syncbranch/worktree.go
Parent issue: bd-3s8


Refactor sqlite.go (2298 lines)

Break down internal/storage/sqlite/sqlite.go into smaller, more focused modules. The file is currently 2298 lines and should be split into logical components.


getLocalSyncBranch YAML parsing is fragile

The getLocalSyncBranch() function in autoimport.go uses a simple line-by-line YAML parser that could fail on:
- Indented sync-branch: (nested in a section)
- Comments containing sync-branch:
- Multi-line values
- Values with special characters

Current implementation at autoimport.go:161-172 does:
```go
for _, line := range strings.Split(string(data), "\n") {
    line = strings.TrimSpace(line)
    if strings.HasPrefix(line, "sync-branch:") {
        value := strings.TrimPrefix(line, "sync-branch:")
        ...
    }
}
```

The reason we can't use viper's cached config is that it's initialized at process startup from the main repo's CWD, not from the current directory at runtime. This causes issues in tests where t.Chdir() changes the directory.

Options:
1. Accept the limitation (sync-branch must be top-level, unquoted)
2. Use a proper YAML library (gopkg.in/yaml.v3) to parse just this value
3. Refactor config package to support re-initialization per directory


Update documentation after code health cleanup

Update all documentation to reflect code structure changes after cleanup phases complete.

Documentation to update:
1. **AGENTS.md** - Update file structure references
2. **CONTRIBUTING.md** (if exists) - Update build/test instructions
3. **Code comments** - Update any outdated references
4. **Package documentation** - Update godoc for reorganized packages

New documentation to add:
1. **internal/util/README.md** - Document shared utilities
2. **internal/debug/README.md** - Document debug logging
3. **internal/rpc/README.md** - Document new file organization
4. **internal/storage/sqlite/migrations/README.md** - Migration system docs

Impact: Keeps documentation in sync with code


Auto-configure git merge driver during `bd init`

Enhance `bd init` to optionally set up beads-merge as git merge driver.

**Tasks**:
- Prompt user to install git merge driver
- Configure `.git/config`: `merge.beads.driver "bd merge %A %O %L %R"`
- Create/update `.gitattributes`: `.beads/beads.jsonl merge=beads`
- Add `--skip-merge-driver` flag for non-interactive use
- Update AGENTS.md onboarding section

**Files**:
- `cmd/bd/init.go`
- `.gitattributes` template


Fix Windows-specific test failures in CI

Several tests are failing on Windows but passing on Linux:

**Failing tests:**
- TestFindDatabasePathEnvVar
- TestHashIDs_MultiCloneConverge
- TestHashIDs_IdenticalContentDedup
- TestDatabaseReinitialization (all 5 subtests):
  - fresh_clone_auto_import
  - database_removal_scenario
  - legacy_filename_support
  - precedence_test
  - init_safety_check
- TestFindBeadsDir_NotFound
- TestMetricsSnapshot/uptime (in internal/rpc)

**CI Run:** https://github.com/steveyegge/beads/actions/runs/19015638968

These are likely path separator or filesystem behavior differences between Windows and Linux.

Fixed all Windows path issues:
1. TestFindDatabasePathEnvVar - expects canonicalized paths ✅
2. TestHashIDs tests - use platform-specific bd.exe command ✅
3. TestMetricsSnapshot/uptime - enforce minimum 1 second uptime ✅
4. TestFindBeadsDir_NotFound - allow finding .beads in parent dirs ✅
5. TestDatabaseReinitialization - fix git path conversion on Windows (git returns /c/Users/... but filepath needs C:\Users\...) ✅

CI run in progress to verify all fixes.


Improve CheckStaleness error handling

## Problem

CheckStaleness returns 'false' (not stale) for multiple error conditions instead of returning errors. This masks problems.

**Location:** internal/autoimport/autoimport.go:253-285

## Edge Cases That Return False

1. **Invalid last_import_time format** (line 259-262)
2. **No JSONL file found** (line 267-277)
3. **JSONL stat fails** (line 279-282)

## Fix

Return errors for abnormal conditions:

```go
lastImportTime, err := time.Parse(time.RFC3339, lastImportStr)
if err != nil {
    return false, fmt.Errorf("corrupted last_import_time: %w", err)
}

if jsonlPath == "" {
    return false, fmt.Errorf("no JSONL file found")
}

stat, err := os.Stat(jsonlPath)
if err != nil {
    return false, fmt.Errorf("cannot stat JSONL: %w", err)
}
```

## Impact
Medium - edge cases are rare but should be handled

## Effort
30 minutes - requires updating callers in RPC server


Deletions not propagated across multi-workspace sync

## Problem

When working with multiple beads workspaces (clones) sharing the same git remote, deleted issues keep coming back.

## Reproduction

1. Clone A deletes issue `bd-xyz` via `bd delete bd-xyz --force`
2. Clone A daemon syncs and pushes to GitHub
3. Clone B still has `bd-xyz` in its database
4. Clone B daemon exports and pushes its JSONL
5. Clone A pulls and imports → `bd-xyz` comes back!

## Root Cause

**No deletion tracking mechanism.** The system has no way to distinguish between:
- "Issue doesn't exist in JSONL because it was deleted"
- "Issue doesn't exist in JSONL because the export is stale"

Import treats missing issues as "not in this export" rather than "explicitly deleted."

## Solution Options

1. **Tombstone records** - Keep deleted issues in JSONL with `"status":"deleted"` or `"deleted_at"` field
2. **Deletion log** - Separate `.beads/deletions.jsonl` file tracking all deleted IDs
3. **Three-way merge** - Import compares: DB state, old JSONL, new JSONL
4. **Manual conflict resolution** - Detect resurrection and prompt user

## Related

- Similar to resurrection logic for orphaned children (bd-cc4f)
- beads-merge tool handles this better with 3-way merge


Auto-repair stale merge driver configs with invalid placeholders

Old bd versions (<0.24.0) installed merge driver with invalid placeholders %L %R instead of %A %B. Add detection to bd doctor --fix: check if git config merge.beads.driver contains %L or %R, auto-repair to 'bd merge %A %O %A %B'. One-time migration for users who initialized with old versions.


Git history fallback has incorrect logic for detecting deletions

## Problem

The `wasInGitHistory` function in `internal/importer/importer.go:891` returns true if the ID is found **anywhere** in git history. But finding an ID in history doesn't necessarily mean it was deleted - it could mean:

1. The issue was added (appears in a commit adding it)
2. The issue was modified (appears in commits updating it)
3. The issue was deleted (appears in a commit removing it)

The current logic incorrectly treats all three cases as 'deleted'.

## Correct Logic

`git log -S` with `--oneline` shows commits where the string was added OR removed. To detect deletion specifically:

1. ID appears in git history (was once in JSONL)
2. ID is NOT currently in JSONL

The second condition is already checked by the caller (`purgeDeletedIssues`), so technically the logic is correct in context. But the function name and doc comment are misleading.

## Fix Options

1. **Rename function** to `wasEverInJSONL` and update doc comment to clarify
2. **Add explicit check** for current JSONL state in the function itself

Option 1 is simpler and correct since caller already filters.


Imperator does not know its own mail identity


Use external_ref as primary matching key for import updates

Enable re-syncing from external systems (Jira, GitHub, Linear) by using external_ref as the primary matching key during imports. Currently imports treat any content change as a collision, making it impossible to sync updates from external systems without creating duplicates.

See GH #142 for detailed proposal and implementation plan.

Key changes needed:
1. Add findByExternalRef() query function
2. Update DetectCollisions() to match by external_ref first
3. Update import_shared.go to update existing issues when external_ref matches
4. Add index on external_ref for performance
5. Preserve local issues (no external_ref) from being overwritten

This enables hybrid workflows: import external backlog, break down with local tasks, re-sync anytime.

## Code Review Complete ✅

**Overall Assessment**: EXCELLENT - Production ready

### Implementation Quality
- ✓ Clean architecture with proper interface extension
- ✓ Dual backend support (SQLite + Memory)
- ✓ Smart matching priority: external_ref → ID → content hash
- ✓ O(1) lookups with database index
- ✓ Timestamp-based conflict resolution
- ✓ Comprehensive test coverage (11 test cases)

### Follow-up Issues Filed
High Priority (P2):
- bd-897a: Add UNIQUE constraint on external_ref column
- bd-7315: Add validation for duplicate external_ref in batch imports

Medium Priority (P3):
- bd-f9a1: Add index usage verification test
- bd-3f6a: Add concurrent import race condition tests

Low Priority (P4):
- bd-e166: Improve timestamp comparison readability
- bd-9e23: Optimize Memory backend with index
- bd-537e: Add external_ref change tracking
- bd-df11: Add import metrics
- bd-9f4a: Document external_ref in content hash

### Key Features
✅ External systems (Jira, GitHub, Linear) can re-sync without duplicates
✅ Hybrid workflows: import external backlog, add local tasks, re-sync anytime
✅ Local issues protected from being overwritten
✅ Timestamp checking ensures only newer updates applied
✅ Performance optimized with database index

**Confidence Level**: 95% - Ship it! 🚀


Channel isolation test - beads

Resetting stale in_progress status from old executor run (13 days old)


Add tests for Integration Layer Implementation

While implementing bd-wfmw, noticed missing tests

Reviewed existing coverage:
- Basic test coverage exists in lib/test_beads_mail_adapter.py
- Integration tests cover failure scenarios in tests/integration/test_mail_failures.py
- Good coverage of: enabled/disabled modes, graceful degradation, 409 conflicts, HTTP errors, config
- Missing: authorization headers detail, request body structure validation, concurrent reservation timing, TTL edge cases


Refactor create_test.go to use shared DB setup

Convert TestCreate_* functions to use test suites with shared database setup.

Example transformation:
- Before: 10 separate tests, each with newTestStore()
- After: 1 TestCreate() with 10 t.Run() subtests sharing one DB

Estimated speedup: 10x faster (1 DB setup instead of 10)


bd ready taking 5 seconds with 132 issues (89 closed)

User reports bd ready is annoyingly slow on M2 Mac - 5 seconds for 132 issues (89 closed). Started noticing after hash-based IDs update. Need to investigate performance regression. Reported in GH #243.

Root cause identified: Not a query performance issue, but stale daemon locks causing 5s timeout delays.

Fixed in bd-ndyz (closed) via 5 sub-issues:
- bd-expt: Fast-fail socket checks (200ms timeout)
- bd-wgu4: Lock probe before RPC attempts
- bd-1mzt: Self-heal stale artifacts
- bd-vcg5: Panic recovery + socket cleanup
- bd-j7e2: RPC diagnostics (BD_RPC_DEBUG)

All fixes merged. Ready for v0.22.2 release.


Fragile no-db detection uses strings.Contains instead of YAML parsing

Two locations use `strings.Contains(string(configData), "no-db: true")` to detect JSONL-only mode:

1. **cmd/bd/main.go:310** - Auto-enabling no-db mode
2. **cmd/bd/doctor.go:863** - Database status check

This is fragile because it could match:
- Comments: `# no-db: true for testing`
- Nested keys: `settings:\n  no-db: true`
- String values: `note: "set no-db: true to disable"`

Should use proper YAML parsing like we did for sync-branch in bd-0rh:

```go
type noDbConfig struct {
    NoDb bool `yaml:"no-db"`
}

var cfg noDbConfig
if err := yaml.Unmarshal(configData, &cfg); err == nil {
    isNoDbMode = cfg.NoDb
}
```

Related: bd-0rh (fixed similar issue for sync-branch)


bd export should detect and prevent stale database exports

## Problem

When `bd export` is run with a stale database (older than issues.jsonl), it silently overwrites the JSONL file with stale data, causing data loss.

## What Happened (vc project)

1. Agent A created 4 new issues and exported to issues.jsonl (commit 99a9d58)
2. Agent A closed an issue and exported again (commit 58b4613) - JSONL now has 4 epics
3. Agent B had stale database (from before step 1)
4. Agent B worked on unrelated issue and exported (commit 0609233)
5. Agent B's export **overwrote issues.jsonl**, removing the 4 epics created by Agent A
6. Required manual recovery by re-exporting from Agent A's correct database

## Expected Behavior

`bd export` should detect that the database is stale and either:
- **Refuse to export** with error message explaining the issue
- **Warn prominently** and require explicit --force flag to override
- **Auto-import first** to sync database before exporting

## How to Detect Staleness

Compare modification times (similar to VC's ValidateDatabaseFreshness):
1. Check .db, .db-wal, .db-shm timestamps (use newest for WAL mode)
2. Check issues.jsonl timestamp
3. If JSONL is newer by >1 second: database is stale

## Suggested Fix

Add staleness check in `bd export`:

```go
func Export(dbPath, jsonlPath string, force bool) error {
    // Check if database is stale
    if !force {
        if err := checkDatabaseFreshness(dbPath, jsonlPath); err != nil {
            return fmt.Errorf("database is stale: %w\n" +
                "Run 'bd import %s' first to sync, or use --force to override",
                err, jsonlPath)
        }
    }

    // Proceed with export...
}
```

## Impact

- **Severity**: High (silent data loss)
- **Frequency**: Happens in multi-agent workflows when agents don't sync
- **Workaround**: Manual recovery (re-export from correct database)

## References

- VC issue tracker: commits 58b4613 -> 0609233 -> c41c638
- VC has similar check: `storage.ValidateDatabaseFreshness()`
- Tolerance: 1 second (handles filesystem timestamp precision)

Fixed with ID-based comparison instead of just count. Now detects:
1. DB has fewer issues than JSONL (count check)
2. DB has different issues than JSONL (ID comparison)

Both scenarios now properly refuse export unless --force is used.

Implementation uses getIssueIDsFromJSONL() to build a set of IDs from JSONL, then checks if any JSONL IDs are missing from DB. Shows specific missing issue IDs in error message.


Issue 2 to reopen


bd export only outputs 1 issue after auto-import corrupts database

When auto-import runs and purges issues (due to git history backfill bug), subsequent 'bd export' only exports 1 issue even though the database should have many.

Reproduction:
1. Have issues.jsonl with 55 issues
2. Auto-import triggers and purges all issues via git history backfill
3. Run 'bd export' - only exports 1 issue (the last one created before corruption)

The database gets into an inconsistent state where most issues are purged but export doesn't realize this.

Workaround: Rebuild database from scratch with 'rm .beads/beads.db && bd init --prefix bd'


Daemon crash recovery: panic handler + socket cleanup

Improve daemon cleanup on unexpected exit:
1. Add top-level recover() in runDaemonLoop to capture panics
2. Write daemon-error file with stack trace on panic
3. Prefer return over os.Exit where possible (so defers run)
4. In stopDaemon forced-kill path, also remove stale socket if present

This ensures better diagnostics and cleaner state after crashes.


bd init creates nested .beads directories

bd init sometimes creates .beads/.beads/ nested directories, which should never happen. This occurs fairly often and can cause confusion about which .beads directory is active. Need to add validation to detect if already inside a .beads directory and either error or use the parent .beads location.


Design tombstone merge semantics

Define how tombstones participate in 3-way merge. Key question: does tombstone always win over live issue (like current deletion-wins rule), or should we use updated_at comparison? Consider: tombstone with older timestamp vs live issue with newer edits. Recommendation: tombstone wins unless expired, matching current behavior but with longer TTL window.


Add tests for tombstone edge cases

Missing test coverage for tombstone implementation:

1. Test tombstone validation (deleted_at requirement)
2. Test GetReadyWork excludes tombstones
3. Test SearchIssues behavior with tombstones
4. Integration test for creating/retrieving a tombstone via the delete command
5. Test that status=tombstone update is rejected


Implement fs bridge layer for WASM (Go syscall/js to Node.js fs)

Go's os package in WASM returns 'not implemented on js' for mkdir and other file operations. Need to create a bridge layer that:

1. Detects WASM environment (GOOS=js)
2. Uses syscall/js to call Node.js fs module functions
3. Implements wrappers for:
   - os.MkdirAll
   - os.ReadFile / os.WriteFile
   - os.Open / os.Create
   - os.Stat / os.Lstat
   - filepath operations

Approach:
- Create internal/wasm/fs_bridge.go with //go:build js && wasm
- Export Node.js fs functions to Go using global.readFileSync, global.writeFileSync, etc.
- Wrap in Go API that matches os package signatures
- Update beads.go and storage layer to use bridge when in WASM

This unblocks bd-4462 (basic WASM testing) and [deleted:bd-5bbf] (feature parity testing).


Fix G104 errors unhandled in internal/storage/sqlite/queries.go:1181

Linting issue: G104: Errors unhandled (gosec) at internal/storage/sqlite/queries.go:1181:4. Error: rows.Close()


Exclude tombstones from SearchIssues by default

SearchIssues() returns tombstones if they match search criteria. Per design, users generally shouldn't see deleted issues in search results.

Location: internal/storage/sqlite/queries.go:1155-1311 and transaction.go:887-1044

Options:
1. Add default tombstone exclusion unless explicitly filtering for them
2. Add IncludeTombstones field to IssueFilter

Recommendation: Add 'status != tombstone' to WHERE clause unless filter.Status == StatusTombstone


Design hash ID generation algorithm

Design and specify the hash-based ID generation algorithm.

## Requirements
- Deterministic: same inputs → same ID
- Collision-resistant: ~2^32 space for 8-char hex
- Fast: <1μs per generation
- Includes timestamp for uniqueness
- Includes creator/workspace for distributed uniqueness

## Proposed Algorithm
```go
func GenerateIssueID(title, desc string, created time.Time, workspaceID string) string {
    h := sha256.New()
    h.Write([]byte(title))
    h.Write([]byte(desc))
    h.Write([]byte(created.Format(time.RFC3339Nano)))
    h.Write([]byte(workspaceID))
    hash := hex.EncodeToString(h.Sum(nil))
    return "bd-" + hash[:8]  // 8-char prefix = 2^32 space
}
```

## Open Questions
1. 8 chars (2^32) or 16 chars (2^64) for collision resistance?
2. Include priority/type in hash? (Pro: more entropy. Con: immutable)
3. How to handle workspace ID generation? (hostname? UUID?)
4. What if title+desc change? (Answer: ID stays same - hash only used at creation)

## Deliverables
- Design doc: docs/HASH_ID_DESIGN.md
- Collision probability analysis
- Performance benchmarks
- Prototype implementation in internal/types/id_generator.go


CRDT-based architecture for guaranteed convergence (v2.0)

## Vision
Redesign beads around Conflict-Free Replicated Data Types (CRDTs) to provide mathematical guarantees for N-way collision resolution at arbitrary scale.

## Current Limitations
- Content-hash based collision resolution fails at 5+ clones
- Non-deterministic convergence in multi-round scenarios
- UNIQUE constraint violations during rename operations
- No formal proof of convergence properties

## CRDT Benefits
- Provably convergent (Strong Eventual Consistency)
- Commutative/Associative/Idempotent operations
- No coordination required between clones
- Scales to 100+ concurrent workers
- Well-understood mathematical foundations

## Proposed Architecture

### 1. UUID-Based IDs
Replace sequential IDs with UUIDs:
- Current: bd-1c63eb84, bd-9063acda, bd-4d80b7b1
- CRDT: bd-a1b2c3d4-e5f6-7890-abcd-ef1234567890
- Human aliases maintained separately: #42 maps to UUID

### 2. Last-Write-Wins (LWW) Elements
Each field becomes an LWW register:
- title: (timestamp, clone_id, value)
- status: (timestamp, clone_id, value)
- Deterministic conflict resolution via Lamport timestamp + clone_id tiebreaker

### 3. Operation Log
Track all operations as CRDT ops:
- CREATE(uuid, timestamp, clone_id, fields)
- UPDATE(uuid, field, timestamp, clone_id, value)
- DELETE(uuid, timestamp, clone_id) - tombstone, not hard delete

### 4. Sync as Merge
Syncing becomes merging two CRDT states:
- No merge conflicts possible
- Deterministic merge function
- Guaranteed convergence

## Implementation Phases

### Phase 1: Research & Design (4 weeks)
- Study existing CRDT implementations (Automerge, Yjs, Loro)
- Design schema for CRDT-based issue tracking
- Prototype LWW-based Issue CRDT
- Benchmark performance vs current system

### Phase 2: Parallel Implementation (6 weeks)
- Implement CRDT storage layer alongside SQLite
- Build conversion tools: SQLite ↔ CRDT
- Maintain backward compatibility with v1.x format
- Migration path for existing databases

### Phase 3: Testing & Validation (4 weeks)
- Formal verification of convergence properties
- Stress testing with 100+ clone scenario
- Performance profiling and optimization
- Documentation and examples

### Phase 4: Migration & Rollout (4 weeks)
- Release v2.0-beta with CRDT backend
- Gradual migration from v1.x
- Monitoring and bug fixes
- Final v2.0 release

## Risks & Mitigations

**Risk 1: Performance overhead**
- Mitigation: Benchmark early, optimize hot paths
- CRDTs can be slower than append-only logs
- May need compaction strategy

**Risk 2: Storage bloat**
- Mitigation: Implement operation log compaction
- Tombstone garbage collection for deleted issues
- Periodic snapshots to reduce log size

**Risk 3: Breaking changes**
- Mitigation: Maintain v1.x compatibility layer
- Gradual migration tools
- Dual-mode operation during transition

**Risk 4: Complexity**
- Mitigation: Use battle-tested CRDT libraries
- Comprehensive documentation
- Clear migration guide

## Success Criteria
- 100-clone collision test passes without failures
- Formal proof of convergence properties
- Performance within 2x of current system
- Zero manual conflict resolution required
- Backward compatible with v1.x databases

## Timeline
18-20 weeks total (4-5 months)

## References
- Automerge: https://automerge.org
- Yjs: https://docs.yjs.dev
- Loro: https://loro.dev
- CRDT theory: Shapiro et al, A comprehensive study of CRDTs
- Related issues: bd-0dcea000, bd-4d7fca8a, bd-6221bdcd


Test SQLite WASM compatibility

Verify modernc.org/sqlite works in WASM target. Child of epic bd-44d0.

## Tasks
- [ ] Compile minimal SQLite test to WASM
- [ ] Test database create/open operations
- [ ] Test query execution
- [ ] Test JSONL import/export
- [ ] Benchmark performance vs native

## Decision Point
If modernc.org/sqlite issues, evaluate ncruces/go-sqlite3 alternative.


Add template support for issue creation

Support creating issues from predefined templates to streamline common workflows like epics, bug reports, or feature proposals.

Example usage:
  bd create --from-template epic "Phase 3 Features"
  bd create --from-template bug "Login failure"
  bd template list
  bd template create epic

Templates should include:
- Pre-filled description structure
- Suggested priority and type
- Common labels
- Design/acceptance criteria sections

Implementation notes:
- Store templates in .beads/templates/ directory
- Support YAML or JSON format
- Ship with built-in templates (epic, bug, feature)
- Allow custom project-specific templates


Test issue


Need comprehensive daemon health check command (bd daemon doctor?)


Registry has cross-process race condition

The global daemon registry (~/.beads/registry.json) can be corrupted when multiple daemons from different workspaces write simultaneously.

**Root cause:**
- Registry uses an in-process mutex but no file-level locking
- Register() and Unregister() release the mutex between read and write
- Multiple daemon processes can interleave their read-modify-write cycles

**Evidence:**
Found registry.json with double closing bracket: `]]` instead of `]`

**Fix options:**
1. Use file locking (flock/fcntl) around the entire read-modify-write cycle
2. Use atomic write pattern (write to temp file, rename)
3. Both (belt and suspenders)

**Files:**
- internal/daemon/registry.go:46-64 (readEntries)
- internal/daemon/registry.go:67-87 (writeEntries)
- internal/daemon/registry.go:90-108 (Register - the race window)


Fix: --parent flag doesn't create parent-child dependency

When using `bd create --parent <id>`, the code generates a hierarchical child ID (e.g., bd-123.1) but never creates a parent-child dependency. This causes `bd epic status` to show zero children even though child issues exist.

Root cause: create.go generates child ID using store.GetNextChildID() but never calls store.AddDependency() with type parent-child.

Fix: After creating the issue when parentID is set, automatically add a parent-child dependency linking child -> parent.


Refactor: deduplicate FindJSONLInDir and FindJSONLPath

## Background

After fixing bd-tqo, we now have two nearly identical functions for finding the JSONL file:
- `autoimport.FindJSONLInDir(dbDir string)` in internal/autoimport/autoimport.go
- `beads.FindJSONLPath(dbPath string)` in internal/beads/beads.go

Both implement the same logic:
1. Prefer issues.jsonl
2. Fall back to beads.jsonl for legacy support
3. Skip deletions.jsonl and merge artifacts
4. Default to issues.jsonl if nothing found

## Problem

Code duplication means bug fixes need to be applied in multiple places (as we just experienced with bd-tqo).

## Proposed Solution

Extract shared logic to a utility package that both can import. Options:
1. Create `internal/jsonlpath` package with the core logic
2. Have `autoimport` import `beads` and call `FindJSONLPath` (but APIs differ slightly)
3. Move to `internal/utils` if appropriate

Need to verify no import cycles would be created.

## Affected Files
- internal/autoimport/autoimport.go
- internal/beads/beads.go


Add unit tests for hasJSONLChanged() function

The hasJSONLChanged() function has no unit tests. Should test:
- Normal case: hash matches
- Normal case: hash differs
- Edge case: empty file
- Edge case: missing metadata (first run)
- Edge case: corrupted metadata
- Edge case: file read errors
- Edge case: invalid hash format in metadata

Also add performance benchmarks for large JSONL files.


Add integration test for cross-clone deletion propagation