gt spawn: polecats report success but no work actually happens

## Problem

gt spawn polecats have multiple silent failure modes:

### Failure Mode 1: No gt prime
- Claude starts at prompt and waits for input
- SessionStart hook doesn't auto-run 'gt prime'
- Without gt prime, polecats don't pick up work

### Failure Mode 2: No git push (CRITICAL)
- Polecat commits code locally
- Polecat closes the beads issue
- Polecat sends POLECAT_DONE
- **But code is never pushed to remote branch**
- When worktree is cleaned up, commits are lost forever
- Issue appears closed but no code exists

## Evidence

testcat on bd-d28c:
- Reported 'Work Complete' with commits 7d3447b9, cd87e541
- Closed bd-d28c
- Submitted MR bd-yx22
- But: `grep -r 'TestCreateTombstone' cmd/bd/*.go` returns nothing
- No polecat/testcat branch on remote

## Required Fixes

1. Polecats MUST push their branch before closing issues
2. Witness MUST verify branch exists on remote before cleanup
3. gt spawn should auto-nudge 'gt prime'
4. Consider: Polecat handoff should fail if unpushed commits exist

## Verification Protocol for Witness

Before accepting POLECAT_DONE:
```bash
# 1. Verify branch pushed
git branch -r | grep polecat/<name>

# 2. Verify code exists
grep -r '<expected_function>' path/to/files

# 3. Only then cleanup
```


Generate handoff summary

Summarize this patrol cycle for digest.

Include:
- Workers inspected (count, names)
- Nudges sent (count, to whom)
- Sessions killed (count, names)
- Escalations (count, issues)
- Issues found (brief descriptions)
- Actions pending for next cycle

This becomes the digest when the patrol wisp is squashed.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 14: quiet


Extract timing constants to constants package

Extract hardcoded timing values to named constants.

## Files to modify
- internal/constants/constants.go (add constants)
- internal/cmd/start.go (use constants)
- internal/tmux/tmux.go (use constants)

## Implementation
Add to constants.go:
```go
const (
    ShutdownNotifyDelay  = 500 * time.Millisecond
    ClaudeStartTimeout   = 15 * time.Second
    ShellReadyTimeout    = 5 * time.Second
    DefaultDebounceMs    = 100
    DefaultDisplayMs     = 5000
)
```

## Acceptance criteria
- [ ] 5 timing constants added to constants.go
- [ ] start.go uses ShutdownNotifyDelay, ClaudeStartTimeout, ShellReadyTimeout
- [ ] tmux.go uses DefaultDebounceMs, DefaultDisplayMs
- [ ] go build ./... passes
- [ ] go test ./... passes


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 2: inbox empty, all agents healthy, fixed 1 orphan process


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 13: Quiet


mol-deacon-patrol

Mayor's daemon patrol loop.

The Deacon is the Mayor's background process that runs continuously, handling callbacks, monitoring rig health, and performing cleanup. Each patrol cycle runs these steps in sequence, then loops or exits.

## Second-Order Monitoring

Witnesses send WITNESS_PING messages to verify the Deacon is alive. This
prevents the "who watches the watchers" problem - if the Deacon dies,
Witnesses detect it and escalate to the Mayor.

The Deacon's agent bead last_activity timestamp is updated during each patrol
cycle. Witnesses check this timestamp to verify health.


Witness: detect polecat completion and trigger merge

## Problem
When polecat pushes completed work, witness needs to detect it and signal refinery.

## ZFC-Compliant Solution
Add step to `mol-witness-patrol.formula.toml`:

```toml
[[step]]
id = "check-ready-branches"
title = "Check for branches ready to merge"
description = """
1. List polecat branches: git branch -r | grep origin/polecat/
2. For each branch ahead of main:
   - Check if polecat session is done (no session or at handoff prompt)
   - Check if bead is closed: bd show <bead-id>
3. For ready branches, mail refinery:
   gt mail send <rig>/refinery -s "MERGE_READY: polecat/<name>" -m "Branch ready for merge"
"""
depends_on = ["survey-polecats"]
```

## Alternative: Polecat signals explicitly
Add to polecat workflow (end of work):
```
gt mail send <rig>/refinery -s "MERGE_READY" -m "polecat/<name> ready"
gt mail send <rig>/witness -s "WORK_COMPLETE" -m "<bead-id> done"
```

## Why This Works
- Witness/polecat agents make decisions
- Mail is the coordination primitive
- No daemon code needed

## Files
- formulas/mol-witness-patrol.formula.toml
- formulas/mol-polecat-work.formula.toml (add completion signal)


gt doctor: add Claude settings.json validation

Add a new doctor check to validate Claude Code settings in worker directories:

**Check for:**
1. .claude/settings.json exists in polecats/*, crew/*, witness/rig, refinery/rig
2. SessionStart hook has 'gt prime' command
3. Autonomous roles (polecat, witness, refinery) have 'gt mail check --inject' in SessionStart
4. Interactive roles (crew, mayor) have mail check in UserPromptSubmit only

**Auto-fix capability:**
Use internal/claude.EnsureSettingsForRole() to create missing settings files.

Context: The spawn priming race condition fix (gt-6957) added embedded settings templates. Doctor should validate these are in place.


Phase 1.3: mol-deacon-patrol definition

Define the Deacon patrol molecule in builtin_molecules.go.

## Steps
1. inbox-check - Handle callbacks from agents
2. health-scan - Ping Witnesses and Refineries
3. plugin-run - Execute registered plugins
4. orphan-check - Find abandoned work
5. session-gc - Clean dead sessions
6. context-check - Check own context limit
7. loop-or-exit - Burn and let daemon respawn, or exit if context high

## Implementation
- Add DeaconPatrolMolecule() to builtin_molecules.go
- Add to BuiltinMolecules() list
- Test with bd mol show mol-deacon-patrol


Clarify Mayor vs Witness cleanup responsibilities

Document the cleanup authority model: Witness owns ALL per-worker cleanup, Mayor never involved.

## The Rule

**Witness handles ALL per-worker cleanup. Mayor is never involved.**

## Why This Matters

1. Separation of concerns: Mayor strategic, Witness operational
2. Reduced coordination overhead: No back-and-forth for routine cleanup
3. Faster shutdown: Witness kills workers immediately upon verification
4. Cleaner escalation: Mayor only hears about problems

## What Witness Handles

- Verifying worker git state before kill
- Nudging workers to fix dirty state
- Killing worker sessions
- Updating worker state (sleep/wake)
- Logging verification results

## What Mayor Handles

- Receiving swarm complete notifications
- Deciding whether to start new swarms
- Handling escalations (stuck workers after 3 retries)
- Cross-rig coordination

## Escalation Path

Worker stuck -> Witness nudges (up to 3x) -> Witness escalates to Mayor -> Mayor decides: force kill, reassign, or human

## Anti-Patterns

DO NOT: Mayor asks Witness if worker X is clean
DO: Witness reports swarm complete, all workers verified

DO NOT: Mayor kills worker sessions directly
DO: Mayor tells Witness to abort swarm, Witness handles cleanup

DO NOT: Workers report done to Mayor
DO: Workers report to Witness, Witness aggregates and reports up


gt crew at: auto-prime when exec'ing Claude in-session

When running 'gt crew at <name>' from inside the target session, we exec Claude directly. But this means we can't send 'gt prime' afterward since we ARE the process.

Possible solutions:
1. Claude startup hook that runs gt prime
2. Pass prompt as argument to claude CLI
3. Wrapper script approach

Related: crew resume prompt also can't be sent in this path.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 9: All green


Test message

Testing GGT mail system


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 6: clear


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 20: All healthy - final patrol


Documentation humility pass

Update documentation with humble framing.

## Changes Needed

### README.md

- Add "Experimental" or "Alpha" badge
- Clarify current state vs future vision
- List what works vs what is planned
- Include honest limitations section

### Architecture docs

- Mark autonomous features as "planned"
- Distinguish implemented from designed
- Add "Current Status" sections

### CLAUDE.md files

- Remove claims about autonomous operation (where not true)
- Add "v0.1" qualifiers to features
- Be honest about manual steps required

## Tone

NOT: "Gas Town automatically manages agent lifecycles"
YES: "Gas Town provides infrastructure for agent lifecycle management.
     v0.1 requires some manual coordination."

NOT: "The Refinery processes merges autonomously"
YES: "The Refinery is designed for autonomous merge processing.
     v0.1 demonstrates the pattern with manual triggering."

## Files to Review

- README.md
- docs/architecture.md
- docs/quickstart.md (if exists)
- CLAUDE.md files for all roles


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 1: inbox clear, witness/refinery healthy, no orphans, no plugins


Merge: gt-83k0

branch: polecat/furiosa
target: main
source_issue: gt-83k0
rig: gastown


Merge: gt-7923

branch: polecat/rictus
target: main
source_issue: gt-7923
rig: gastown


load-context

Run gt prime and bd prime. Verify issue assignment.
Check inbox for any relevant messages.

Read the assigned issue (gt-test123) and understand the requirements.
Identify any blockers or missing information.


Deacon initialization with patrol molecule

Ensure Deacon always has mol-deacon-patrol on hook.

## The Problem

When Deacon starts fresh, it needs:
1. mol-deacon-patrol bonded
2. Molecule pinned to hook
3. Ready to execute

## Solution: Bootstrap in gt prime

When gt prime runs for role=deacon:

1. Check if mol-deacon-patrol exists on hook
2. If not: bond it and pin it
3. Then show execution prompt

```go
// In prime.go for deacon role
if role == "deacon" && !hasPatrolOnHook() {
    // Bond the patrol formula
    bondDeaconPatrol()
    // Pin to hook
    pinToHook("deacon", patrolMolID)
}
```

## Alternative: Deacon Startup Hook

Or handle in Deacon SessionStart hook:
- Check hook
- If empty: gt mol bond mol-deacon-patrol && gt mol pin

## Files

- cmd/gt/prime.go (if handling in prime)
- deacon/hooks/session-start.sh (if handling in hook)


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol cycle 1: All healthy - witnesses, refineries running. No callbacks, no orphans, no pending spawns.


Machine registry: Store and manage machine configs

Registry for managing remote machines in federation.

## Data Model

```go
type Machine struct {
    Name     string `json:"name"`
    Type     string `json:"type"`      // "local", "ssh", "gcp"
    Host     string `json:"host"`      // for ssh: user@host
    KeyPath  string `json:"key_path"`  // SSH key path
    TownPath string `json:"town_path"` // Path to town on remote
}
```

## Interface

```go
type MachineRegistry struct {
    path     string  // config/federation.json
    machines map[string]*Machine
}

func NewMachineRegistry(configPath string) *MachineRegistry
func (r *MachineRegistry) Get(name string) (*Machine, error)
func (r *MachineRegistry) Add(m *Machine) error
func (r *MachineRegistry) Remove(name string) error
func (r *MachineRegistry) List() []*Machine
func (r *MachineRegistry) Connection(name string) (Connection, error)
```

## Storage

federation.json in config/:
```json
{
  "version": 1,
  "machines": {
    "local": {"type": "local"},
    "gcp-vm-1": {
      "type": "ssh",
      "host": "user@10.0.0.1",
      "key_path": "~/.ssh/gcp_key",
      "town_path": "/home/user/ai"
    }
  }
}
```

## Connection Factory

```go
func (r *MachineRegistry) Connection(name string) (Connection, error) {
    m := r.machines[name]
    switch m.Type {
    case "local":
        return NewLocalConnection(), nil
    case "ssh":
        return NewSSHConnection(m.Host, m.KeyPath), nil
    }
}
```


Mail should use wisps for ephemeral orchestration messages

## Problem

Town HQ beads are polluted with lifecycle orchestration messages:
- POLECAT_STARTED notifications
- Work assignments to polecats
- "Start work" nudges
- Test messages

These should never have been persistent beads. They accumulate forever.

## Analysis

Mail serves two purposes:
1. **Durable messages** - Handoffs, escalations, human-agent comms (need persistence)
2. **Ephemeral signals** - Lifecycle pings, work assignments, nudges (should be wisps)

## Options

### Option A: Dual-inbox architecture
- `gt mail inbox` checks both `.beads/` and `.beads-wisp/`
- Sender specifies `--ephemeral` flag for transient messages
- Ephemeral messages auto-expire or squash to digests

### Option B: All mail becomes wisps
- Default to wisp storage for all mail
- Important messages explicitly promoted to persistent
- Simpler model but loses audit trail for some messages

### Option C: Message type determines storage
- `message` type beads go to wisps by default
- `handoff` type stays persistent
- Automatic routing based on content

## Recommendation

Option A (dual-inbox) seems cleanest:
- Explicit control via `--ephemeral`
- Backwards compatible
- Clear mental model

## Acceptance Criteria

- Lifecycle pings (POLECAT_STARTED, etc.) go to wisps
- Work assignments go to wisps
- Handoffs stay persistent
- `gt mail inbox` shows both
- Wisps auto-cleanup on patrol squash

## Blocks

This blocks reliable swarm operations - every spawn pollutes HQ indefinitely.


Nudge newly spawned polecats

Nudge newly spawned polecats that are ready for input.

When polecats are spawned, their Claude session takes 10-20 seconds to initialize. The spawn command returns immediately without waiting. This step finds spawned polecats that are now ready and sends them a trigger to start working.

**ZFC-Compliant Observation** (AI observes AI):

```bash
# View pending spawns with captured terminal output
gt deacon pending
```

For each pending session, analyze the captured output:
- Look for Claude's prompt indicator "> " at the start of a line
- If prompt is visible, Claude is ready for input
- Make the judgment call yourself - you're the AI observer

For each ready polecat:
```bash
# 1. Trigger the polecat
gt nudge <session> "Begin."

# 2. Clear from pending list
gt deacon pending <session>
```

This triggers the UserPromptSubmit hook, which injects mail so the polecat sees its assignment.

**Bootstrap mode** (daemon-only, no AI available):
The daemon uses `gt deacon trigger-pending` with regex detection. This ZFC violation is acceptable during cold startup when no AI agent is running yet.


mol-deacon-patrol

Mayor's daemon patrol loop.

The Deacon is the Mayor's background process that runs continuously, handling callbacks, monitoring rig health, and performing cleanup. Each patrol cycle runs these steps in sequence, then loops or exits.


Standardize error handling and warning output patterns

Inconsistent patterns across codebase:

Error wrapping:
- Some: fmt.Errorf("context: %w", err) (good)
- Some: return err (loses context)
- Some: fmt.Errorf("message", rigName) without wrapping original

Exit handling in Cobra commands:
- Some use os.Exit(1) inside RunE (bad - loses error chain)
- Some properly return errors

Warning output styles:
- fmt.Printf("%s Warning: ...", style.Dim.Render("⚠"))
- fmt.Printf("Warning: %s", ...)
- fmt.Fprintf(os.Stderr, "warning: ...")

Suggestion:
1. Always wrap errors with %w
2. Never call os.Exit() in RunE handlers
3. Standardize on style.Warning.Render("Warning:") pattern


Witness Role Definition

You are the Witness - per-rig worker monitor. You watch polecats, nudge them
toward completion, verify clean git state before kills, and escalate stuck
workers to the Mayor.

You do NOT do implementation work. Your job is oversight, not coding.

default_molecule: mol-witness-patrol
capabilities:
  - monitor_workers
  - nudge_stuck
  - pre_kill_verify
  - session_lifecycle
  - escalation

## Core Responsibilities

1. Monitor workers: Track polecat health and progress
2. Nudge: Prompt slow workers toward completion
3. Pre-kill verification: Ensure git state is clean before killing sessions
4. Session lifecycle: Kill sessions, update worker state
5. Self-cycling: Hand off to fresh session when context fills
6. Escalation: Report stuck workers to Mayor

Key principle: You own ALL per-worker cleanup. Mayor is never involved in
routine worker management.

## Propulsion Principle

If you find something on your hook, YOU RUN IT.

Your work is defined by the mol-witness-patrol molecule. Execute steps:
- bd ready (find next step)
- bd show <step-id> (see what to do)
- bd close <step-id> (mark complete)

## Nudge Protocol

Progress through stages. Track nudge count per worker per issue.
- First Nudge (10+ min idle): Gentle inquiry
- Second Nudge (15 min): Direct question
- Third Nudge (20 min): Final warning
After 3 nudges with no progress -> escalate to Mayor

## Pre-Kill Verification

Before killing ANY polecat session:
1. gt polecat git-state <name> - Must be clean
2. Check for uncommitted work
3. Check for unpushed commits
4. Verify issue closed
5. Verify PR submitted (if applicable)

## Commands

- gt polecat list <rig> - See all polecats
- gt polecat git-state <name> - Check git cleanliness
- tmux capture-pane -t gt-<rig>-<name> -p | tail -40 - Session inspection
- gt mail inbox - Check messages
- gt mail send mayor/ -s "Subject" -m "Message" - Escalate


Phase 4: Polish and observability

Production readiness.

## Commands
- gt patrol status - Show patrol state for all agents
- gt patrol history - Recent patrol activity

## Observability
- Metrics collection
- Alert thresholds
- Dashboard (optional)

## Tuning
- Cooldown optimization
- Wake SLA verification
- Error threshold tuning

Depends: Phase 3


Deacon patrol: Janitorial cleanup patterns

Patterns discovered during town cleanup that could be automated in Deacon's patrol step:

## Stale Issue Detection

1. **Stale in_progress issues** - Issues marked in_progress for >N days without activity
   - Example: 9 issues in_progress, some likely complete
   - Action: Report list, optionally nudge assignee

2. **Duplicate issues** - Same title with different IDs
   - Example: gt-87jz and gt-qp2w both 'mol-witness-patrol'
   - Action: Flag for human review

3. **Orphaned issues** - Referenced in commits but still open
   - bd doctor already detects: 'hq-65jk (commit f9e9034d)'
   - Action: Report, suggest closing

4. **Stale test messages** - Messages with 'test' in title older than N days
   - Example: gt-54kn, gt-1ero, gt-nriy, gt-wrw2, gt-pnu4, gt-g1ud, gt-b5sh
   - Action: Auto-close or flag

## File System Cleanup

5. **Log file accumulation** - daemon.log and rotated .log.gz files
   - Found 8+ log files across rigs
   - Action: Rotate, compress, delete old (>7 days)

6. **Beads directory size** - Town .beads/ is 65MB
   - Action: Monitor growth, alert on threshold

## Database Health

7. **Legacy database fingerprints** - Older DBs without fingerprint
   - bd doctor warns about this
   - Action: Report, suggest migration

## Cross-Reference Integrity

8. **Gastown↔Beads issue sync** - Issues filed in wrong project
   - Example: gt-8tmz.* describes Beads work but no bd-* issues
   - Action: Detect cross-references, verify both sides exist

## Implementation Notes

These could be added to mol-deacon-patrol.formula.yaml as cleanup substeps:
- Daily: Log rotation, stale issue report
- Weekly: Duplicate detection, orphan check
- Monthly: Size monitoring, archive old closed issues


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol OK: 0 polecats, 6 core sessions up, town quiet


Work on gt-role-template: Refine witness/CLAUDE.md role t...

Work on gt-role-template: Refine witness/CLAUDE.md role template. See issue for details. Run 'bd show gt-role-template' to see the full issue.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 14: All healthy


bd mol install: Install formula from GitHub

Fetch and install a formula from a GitHub repository.

Usage: bd mol install github.com/org/repo[@version]

Should:
- Clone/fetch the formula.json from the repo
- Validate the formula structure
- Store in local catalog
- Track installation in .beads/installed.json


README: Update Install section for homebrew/npm

README currently shows:
  go install github.com/steveyegge/gastown/cmd/gt@latest

But users will install via homebrew or npm. Update to show:
  brew install gastown
  # or
  npm install -g @anthropic/gastown

Also add prerequisites section (tmux, Claude Code CLI).


gt handoff: Unified agent lifecycle command

## Summary

Unified `gt handoff` command for ALL agent types to request lifecycle actions.

## Usage

gt handoff              # Context-aware default
gt handoff --shutdown   # Terminate, cleanup, don't restart
gt handoff --cycle      # Restart with handoff mail
gt handoff --restart    # Fresh restart, no handoff

## Context-Aware Defaults

| Agent Type | Default | Reason |
|------------|---------|--------|
| Polecat | --shutdown | Ephemeral, work is done |
| Witness | --cycle | Long-running, context full |
| Refinery | --cycle | Long-running, context full |
| Mayor | --cycle | Long-running, context full |
| Crew | (sends mail only) | Human-managed |

## What gt handoff Does

1. **Verify safe to stop**
   - Git state clean (no uncommitted changes)
   - Work handed off (PR exists for polecats)

2. **Send handoff mail to self** (for cycle/restart)
   - Captures current state
   - New session will read this

3. **Send lifecycle request to manager**
   - Polecats/Refinery → Witness
   - Witness/Mayor → Daemon
   - Format: mail to <manager> with action type

4. **Set state: requesting_<action>**
   - Lifecycle manager checks this before acting

5. **Wait for termination**
   - Don't self-exit - let manager kill session
   - Ensures clean handoff

## Lifecycle Request Flow

Agent                           Lifecycle Manager
  |                                    |
  | 1. gt handoff --cycle              |
  |    a. Verify git clean             |
  |    b. Send handoff mail to self    |
  |    c. Set requesting_cycle=true    |
  |    d. Send lifecycle request       |
  |------------------------------------→|
  |                                    |
  |                   2. Receive request
  |                   3. Verify state  |
  |                   4. Kill session  |
  |                   5. Start new     |
  |                      (for cycle)   |
  |                                    |
  |         New session reads handoff  |
  |         Resumes work               |

## Who Manages Whom

| Agent | Sends lifecycle request to |
|-------|---------------------------|
| Polecat | <rig>/witness |
| Refinery | <rig>/witness |
| Witness | daemon/ |
| Mayor | daemon/ |

## Implementation

1. Detect current role (polecat, witness, refinery, mayor, crew)
2. Apply context-aware default if no flag specified
3. Run pre-flight checks (git clean, work handed off)
4. Send handoff mail to self (if cycling)
5. Send lifecycle request to appropriate manager
6. Set requesting_<action> in state.json
7. Wait (manager will kill us)

## For Polecats (--shutdown)

Additional cleanup after kill:
- Witness removes worktree
- Witness deletes polecat branch
- Polecat ceases to exist

## Related Issues

- gt-99m: Daemon (handles Mayor/Witness lifecycle)
- gt-7ik: Ephemeral polecats (polecat cleanup)
- gt-eu9: Witness session cycling


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 20: routine, all healthy


gt-witness-gastown

Witness - per-rig polecat monitor for gastown.

role_type: witness
rig: gastown
agent_state: idle
hook_bead: null
role_bead: gt-witness-role


bd mol update: Check and update installed formulas

Check for and apply updates to installed formulas.

Usage: bd mol update [formula-name]

Should:
- Check GitHub for newer versions/commits
- Show available updates
- Apply updates when requested
- Track update history


Merge: rictus-1766959789036

branch: polecat/rictus-1766959789036
target: main
source_issue: rictus-1766959789036
rig: gastown


MQ config schema: merge_queue section in rig config.json

Define and implement merge_queue configuration in rig config.

Schema:
{
  "merge_queue": {
    "enabled": true,
    "target_branch": "main",
    "integration_branches": true,
    "on_conflict": "assign_back",  // or "auto_rebase"
    "run_tests": true,
    "test_command": "go test ./...",
    "delete_merged_branches": true,
    "retry_flaky_tests": 1,
    "poll_interval": "30s",
    "max_concurrent": 1
  }
}

Implement:
- Config loading in rig package
- Default values
- Validation

Reference: docs/merge-queue-design.md#configuration


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 5: All healthy.


Direct landing integration: gt land uses MR or bypasses

Integrate direct landing with merge queue.

'gt land --direct' should:
1. Check if MR exists for the polecat's work
2. If MR exists: process it directly (skip queue)
3. If no MR: create temporary MR, process, close

Options:
- --direct: bypass queue (existing)
- --via-queue: ensure goes through queue (new)
- --force: skip safety checks (existing)

This ensures direct landing still creates proper records.

Reference: docs/merge-queue-design.md#direct-landing-bypass-queue


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol cycle 18: All healthy


Create Refinery role template

Add Refinery template to internal/templates/roles/:
- refinery.md.tmpl with full role context
- Variables: rig name, working directory, handoff bead ID
- Update SeedRoleTemplates to include it
- gt prime uses this template for Refinery context


Test Patrol Parent

[RESURRECTED] This issue was deleted but recreated as a tombstone to preserve hierarchical structure.

Original description:
Test parent for Christmas Ornament pattern


Work on gt-role-template: Refine witness/CLAUDE.md role template. Run 'bd show gt-role-template' to see the full issue.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol #17


implement

Implement the solution for gt-test123. Follow codebase conventions.
File discovered work as new issues with bd create.

Make regular commits with clear messages.
Keep changes focused on the assigned issue.

Depends: load-context


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 6: Nominal


Swarm learning: Spawn should auto-notify polecats

town spawn assigns issues but doesn't notify polecats. Required separate 'town session send' to inject prompts. This should be one atomic operation - spawn assigns AND pokes the polecat to start working.


Add Deacon heartbeat mechanism

Deacon writes deacon/heartbeat.json on each wake. Go daemon reads it to decide whether to poke. Add heartbeat read/write helpers.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 2: all healthy, no events


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 19: Routine


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 1: All healthy, no lifecycle requests, 8 active sessions


Update polecat CLAUDE.md with molecule workflow

Add molecule execution guidance to polecat context:

## What to Add

### Molecule Awareness
- Polecats execute Wisps (ephemeral molecule instances)
- The work assignment mail includes molecule context
- Current step is tracked in the wisp

### Workflow Protocol
1. Read assignment (includes molecule ID and current step)
2. Execute current step
3. Update step status via bd mol step
4. Generate summary when all steps complete
5. Run bd mol squash to compress wisp into digest

### Key Commands
- bd mol show <wisp-id> - view current molecule state
- bd mol step <wisp-id> --status=complete - mark step done
- bd mol squash <wisp-id> --summary='...' - complete molecule

### Summary Generation
When completing work, generate a summary that:
- Lists what was accomplished
- Notes any deviations from the plan
- Captures key decisions made
- This becomes the permanent digest


Pick next branch. Rebase on current main.

```bash
git checkout -b temp origin/<polecat-branch>
git rebase origin/main
```

If rebase conflicts and unresolvable:
- git rebase --abort
- Notify polecat to fix and resubmit
- Skip to loop-check for next branch

instantiated_from: mol-refinery-patrol
step: process-branch


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol complete: no inbox, no polecats, cleaned 3 stale locks, witnesses/refineries intentionally stopped


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 20: all healthy, new polecats spawning


Day 4.4: Witness calls nuke after MERGED signal

When refinery sends MERGED:
1. Witness receives MERGED mail
2. Witness calls gt polecat nuke
3. Full sandbox cleanup
4. Agent bead removed

Parent: gt-4a2qt


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol cycle 4: All healthy


town handoff command (optional)

CLI commands for session handoff workflow (optional convenience).

## Commands

### gt handoff
Generate handoff interactively.
```
gt handoff [--send]
```
- Collects current state (status, inbox, beads)
- Prompts for additional notes
- --send: Mail to self and exit

### gt resume
Check for and display pending handoff.
```
gt resume
```
- Checks inbox for handoff message
- Displays formatted handoff if found
- Suggests next actions

## Implementation

These are convenience wrappers. The same workflow can be done manually:
```bash
# Manual handoff
town status > /tmp/handoff
town inbox >> /tmp/handoff
bd ready >> /tmp/handoff
# Edit and send
town mail send mayor/ -s "Session Handoff" -f /tmp/handoff
```

## Priority

P2 - Optional. Manual workflow works fine. Nice to have for UX.

## Notes

Part of session cycling workflow designed in [deleted:gt-u82].


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol #14


gt doctor: Check and fix beads routing configuration

## Summary

`gt doctor` should check that all rigs with beads have proper routing entries
in `~/gt/.beads/routes.jsonl`, and offer to fix any missing entries.

## Checks to Add

### Check: routes.jsonl exists
- Verify `~/gt/.beads/routes.jsonl` exists
- If missing, create with entries for all known rigs

### Check: All rigs have routing entries
For each rig in town:
1. Find the rig's beads prefix (from config.yaml or sample issue)
2. Check if routes.jsonl has an entry for that prefix
3. If missing, report and offer to add

### Check: Routes point to valid locations
For each route in routes.jsonl:
1. Verify the path exists and has a .beads directory
2. Verify the .beads directory has a beads.db
3. If invalid, report and offer to remove

## Fix Actions

- `--fix` should automatically add missing routes
- `--fix` should remove invalid routes (or prompt)
- Should handle redirect files when validating paths

## Example Output

```
Checking beads routing...
  [!] Rig 'myproject' (prefix: mp-) has no routing entry
      Run: gt doctor --fix to add routing

Routes health:
  [OK] gt- -> gastown/mayor/rig
  [OK] bd- -> beads/mayor/rig
  [!]  mp- -> myproject/mayor/rig (MISSING)
```


save-state

Update handoff bead with new state.

Persist nudge counts and pending actions.

Needs: execute-actions


Hook system for event extensibility

GGT needs hook system for extensibility like PGT.

## Event Types
```go
type Event string
const (
    EventPreSessionStart  Event = "pre-session-start"
    EventPostSessionStart Event = "post-session-start"
    EventPreShutdown      Event = "pre-shutdown"
    EventPostShutdown     Event = "post-shutdown"
    EventOnPaneOutput     Event = "on-pane-output"
    EventSessionIdle      Event = "session-idle"
    EventMailReceived     Event = "mail-received"
    EventWorkAssigned     Event = "work-assigned"
)
```

## Hook Configuration
File: .claude/hooks.json or .gastown/hooks.json
```json
{
  "hooks": {
    "pre-shutdown": [
      {"type": "command", "cmd": "./scripts/pre-shutdown.sh"}
    ],
    "on-pane-output": [
      {"type": "command", "cmd": "./scripts/activity-monitor.sh"}
    ]
  }
}
```

## Hook Types
1. **Command**: Execute external script
2. **Built-in**: Internal Go functions (pre-shutdown checks)

## Hook Interface
```go
type HookRunner struct {
    config *HookConfig
}

type HookResult struct {
    Success bool
    Message string
    Block   bool  // For pre-* hooks: should operation be blocked?
}

func (r *HookRunner) Fire(event Event, ctx *HookContext) []HookResult
```

## CLI Commands
```
gt hooks list [<event>]    # List registered hooks
gt hooks fire <event>      # Manually fire for testing
gt hooks test [--all]      # Validate hook config
```

## Integration Points
- internal/session/manager.go: Fire pre/post session hooks
- internal/mail/router.go: Fire mail-received hook

## New Package
internal/hooks/
├── types.go    # Event, HookConfig, HookResult
├── runner.go   # HookRunner, Fire()
└── builtin.go  # Built-in hooks (pre-shutdown checks)

## PGT Reference
gastown-py/src/gastown/hooks/

## Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Hook config loading from JSON
- [ ] Command hooks execute subprocess
- [ ] Pre-shutdown hook integration with session stop
- [ ] CLI for listing and testing hooks


Cook patrol formulas into proto beads

Use bd cook to transform formula YAML into proto beads with proper child beads for each step.

Verify with bd mol show that protos have all children.


mol-polecat-work

Full polecat lifecycle from assignment to decommission.

This proto enables nondeterministic idempotence for polecat work.
A polecat that crashes after any step can restart, read its molecule state,
and continue from the last completed step. No work is lost.

Variables:
- gt-test - The source issue ID being worked on


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 10: All agents healthy


mol-deacon-patrol

Mayor's daemon patrol loop.

The Deacon is the Mayor's background process that runs continuously, handling callbacks, monitoring rig health, and performing cleanup. Each patrol cycle runs these steps in sequence, then loops or exits.

## Second-Order Monitoring

Witnesses send WITNESS_PING messages to verify the Deacon is alive. This
prevents the "who watches the watchers" problem - if the Deacon dies,
Witnesses detect it and escalate to the Mayor.

The Deacon's agent bead last_activity timestamp is updated during each patrol
cycle. Witnesses check this timestamp to verify health.


gt sling --on flag for wisp scaffolding

Add --on flag to gt sling for applying forms to existing work:
  gt sling shiny gastown/Toast --on gt-abc123

When --on is specified, implies --wisp (scaffolding existing work).
The form shapes execution of the target bead.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 16


Phase 2.2: gt prime shows ephemeral molecule context

Update gt prime to detect and display ephemeral molecule state.

## Detection

1. Check for active ephemeral molecule assigned to current identity
2. Parse molecule progress (current step, total steps)
3. Show in prime output

## Output

```
🔧 Polecat furiosa, checking in.

📦 Molecule: mol-polecat-work (eph-abc123)
   Step 3/8: do-work
   Source: gt-rixa
   Started: 10 minutes ago

Run 'bd mol status' for full molecule state.
```


Audit hardcoded 'gastown' references in codebase

## Problem

Gas Town should work for ANY rig - not assume 'gastown' (our OSS project) is installed. Found during audit:

### Known Issue (Closed - gt-ci84)
- Deacon patrol wisps were incorrectly using `gastown/mayor/rig/.beads/` instead of town-level beads
- Status: Fixed (implemented town-level wisp storage)

### Remaining Issues

1. **log.go:272** - Fallback path heuristic:
   ```go
   possibleRoots := []string{
       home + "/gt",
       home + "/gastown",  // <-- Assumes user might have gastown as town
   }
   ```
   Should be removed or use a config-based approach.

2. **Help text examples** - Many commands use 'gastown' as the example rig:
   - `gt sling gt-abc gastown`
   - `gt witness start gastown`
   - etc.
   Consider using a generic name like 'myproject' or '<rig>'

3. **Polecat name pool** - 'gastown' is in the Mad Max themed name list.
   This is acceptable (just a name, not a path assumption).

## Tasks
1. Remove `home + "/gastown"` fallback from log.go
2. Consider updating help examples to use generic rig names
3. Full code audit to ensure no other hardcoded assumptions

## Context
Gas Town is the orchestration framework. 'gastown' is just our OSS project that happens to use it. Users installing Gas Town for their own projects should never see anything that assumes 'gastown' rig exists.


gt polecat add: should handle existing branch gracefully

## Problem

`gt polecat add gastown Nux` fails if the branch `polecat/Nux` already exists.

## Current Behavior

```
fatal: a branch named 'polecat/Nux' already exists
```

## Expected Behavior

Should either:
1. Reuse the existing branch
2. Or prompt to delete/recreate
3. Or auto-suffix: polecat/Nux-2

## Context

Branch may exist from previous polecat that was removed but branch wasn't cleaned up.


Test Patrol for Bonding

Parent issue for mol bond CLI test


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 6: Routine


Track operational stats as entity/audit beads

Witness and refinery track operational stats in JSON files:
- total_merged, today_merged, total_failed (refinery)
- total_checks, total_nudges, total_escalations (witness)

For HOP entity CV tracking, these could become:
- type=audit beads (daily roll-ups of operational metrics)
- Entity chain entries showing validator activity

This provides observability and contributes to entity reputation tracking (e.g., refinery X has merged 500 PRs with 2% failure rate).

Not critical for launch but aligns with HOP Platform of Platforms vision.


Fix out-of-sync molecule test expectations

Tests in builtin_molecules_test.go have hardcoded expectations that no longer match actual molecules:
- TestBuiltinMolecules: expects 9 molecules, got 11
- TestPolecatWorkMolecule: step refs out of sync
- TestDeaconPatrolMolecule: step count and refs out of sync

This is pre-existing on main, not introduced by any polecat work.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol cycle 17: nominal


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 7: quiet


mol-deacon-patrol


attached_args: Refactor runStartCrew into focused helper functions

Break up the 155-line runStartCrew function in start.go.

## Files to modify
- internal/cmd/start.go

## Current structure (lines 638-792)
runStartCrew does:
1. Parse crew target (rig/name)
2. Load rig config
3. Get/create crew workspace
4. Create/attach tmux session
5. Set environment variables
6. Apply theming
7. Start Claude

## Refactoring plan
Extract these helpers:
```go
func parseCrewTarget(args []string) (rigName, crewName string, err error)
func ensureCrewWorkspace(rig *rig.Rig, crewName string) (*crew.CrewWorker, error)
func startCrewSession(worker *crew.CrewWorker, opts CrewStartOpts) error
```

## Acceptance criteria
- [ ] runStartCrew reduced to <60 lines
- [ ] 3 helper functions extracted
- [ ] Each helper is <50 lines
- [ ] No change in behavior
- [ ] go test ./internal/cmd/... passes
- [ ] Manual test: gt start crew works correctly


mol progress: track dynamically bonded children

Extend `gt mol progress` to show dynamically bonded children.

## Current Behavior

```
gt mol progress gt-abc
```

Shows progress through pre-defined steps from InstantiateMolecule.

## New Behavior

Also show dynamically bonded children:

```
📊 Progress: mol-witness-patrol (gt-abc)

  Steps (9):
    ✓ inbox-check
    ✓ check-refinery
    ✓ load-state
    ◐ survey-workers (bonded 3 children)
    ○ aggregate (WaitsFor: all-children)
    ○ save-state
    ○ generate-summary
    ○ context-check
    ○ burn-or-loop

  Bonded Children (3):
    ✓ arm-toast (5/5 steps)
    ◐ arm-nux (3/5 steps)
    ○ arm-furiosa (0/5 steps)

  Progress: 4/9 steps, 3 arms (1 complete, 1 in-progress, 1 pending)
```

## Implementation

1. Find children with bonded_to: <parent-id> in description
2. Recursively get progress for each bonded child
3. Aggregate into parent progress display


Day 1.1b: Add type=role to bead schema

Add role as a valid bead type in the schema.

Role beads define agent behavior:
- Priming instructions (from current CLAUDE.md content)
- default_molecule field
- capabilities list

This enables Day 1.5 (creating role beads from CLAUDE.md).

Must be done alongside type=agent schema work.


Day 3.7: Witness pings Deacon for second-order monitoring

Add second-order monitoring: Witnesses monitor the Deacon.

Problem: Who monitors the Deacon? If Deacon dies, the whole town stalls.

Solution:
1. Each Witness periodically sends a ping to Deacon during patrol:
   ```bash
   gt mail send deacon/ -s "WITNESS_PING" -m "{\"rig\": \"gastown\"}"
   ```

2. Deacon patrol (inbox-check) aggregates witness pings as health signals

3. If Witness doesn't get Deacon response for 2 cycles:
   - Escalate to Mayor: "Deacon unresponsive"
   - Mayor can restart Deacon via daemon

This creates overlapping patrols:
- Deacon monitors Witnesses/Refineries
- Witnesses monitor Deacon (collectively)
- Mayor is escalation target for both

Add to mol-witness-patrol after survey-workers step.


gt refinery start: doesn't actually start a session

## Problem

`gt refinery start gastown` reports success but doesn't start a tmux session.

## Evidence

```
$ gt refinery start gastown
Starting refinery for gastown...
✓ Refinery started for gastown

$ tmux list-sessions | grep refinery
(nothing)

$ gt refinery status gastown
State: ○ stopped
```

## Expected

Should start a tmux session (e.g., gt-gastown-refinery) with Claude processing the merge queue.

## Related

- gt-kcee: Witness commands also need implementation
- The refinery 'start' may just be updating state.json without spawning a session


Day 1.4c: Create polecat agent bead lifecycle

Define ephemeral polecat agent bead lifecycle.

Polecats need agent beads for ZFC compliance (self-report state).

Lifecycle:
1. On spawn: Create agent bead
   ```yaml
   id: gt-polecat-<rig>-<name>
   type: agent
   role_type: polecat
   rig: <rig>
   state: spawning
   hook_bead: <assigned-issue>
   ```

2. On Claude ready: Update state=working

3. On completion: Update state=done

4. On nuke: Delete agent bead

Commands needed:
- gt polecat spawn creates agent bead
- gt polecat nuke deletes agent bead
- Polecat updates own state via bd agent state

Note: This ensures Witness can read polecat state from beads instead of tmux scraping.

Implemented polecat agent bead lifecycle: spawn creates bead with state=spawning, nuke deletes bead. State updates (spawning→working→done) require bd agent state command (beads CLI enhancement).


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 3: Quiet, all agents healthy


gt spawn: add --polecat flag for explicit worker selection

Currently gt spawn requires positional arg format:
```
gt spawn gastown/Angharad --issue gt-xyz
```

But I tried the more intuitive flag form:
```
gt spawn --issue gt-xyz --polecat Angharad
```

This failed with 'unknown flag: --polecat'.

The flag form is more discoverable and consistent with other commands. Add --polecat flag as alternative to positional arg.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

P11: stable


ensure-beads-witness

Start the beads rig Witness.

## Action
```bash
gt witness start beads
```

## Verify
1. Session exists: `tmux has-session -t beads-witness 2>/dev/null`
2. Not stalled: `gt peek beads/witness` does NOT show "> Try" prompt
3. Heartbeat fresh: Last patrol cycle < 5 min ago

## OnStall
```bash
gt nudge beads/witness "Start patrol."
sleep 30
# Re-verify
```

## OnFail
Log error. Rig polecats will be unmonitored until Witness recovers.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 12: Mayor OK, 11 sessions


Remove dead code: splitLines first loop, unused methods.

## Dead code locations

### 1. internal/cmd/polecat.go (lines 1093-1106)
splitLines function has unreachable first loop:
```go
func splitLines(s string) []string {
    var lines []string
    for _, line := range filepath.SplitList(s) {  // DEAD: wrong function
        ...
    }
    lines = nil  // Discards above
    for _, line := range strings.Split(s, "\n") {  // This is what runs
        lines = append(lines, line)
    }
    return lines
}
```
**Fix:** Remove first loop and reset.

### 2. internal/townlog/logger.go (lines 277-279)
```go
func (e Event) JSON() ([]byte, error) {
    return json.Marshal(e)
}
```
**Fix:** Remove unused method.

### 3. internal/lock/lock.go (line 27)
```go
ErrStaleLock = errors.New("stale lock detected")
```
**Fix:** Remove unused error variable.

### 4. internal/witness/types.go (line 19)
```go
StatePaused State = "paused"
```
**Fix:** Remove unused state constant.

### 5. internal/refinery/manager.go (lines 527-538)
```go
func (m *Manager) getTestCommand() string { ... }
```
**Fix:** Remove unused method.

## Acceptance criteria
- [ ] polecat.go: Dead loop removed from splitLines
- [ ] townlog/logger.go: Event.JSON() method removed
- [ ] lock/lock.go: ErrStaleLock removed
- [ ] witness/types.go: StatePaused removed
- [ ] refinery/manager.go: getTestCommand removed
- [ ] go build ./... passes
- [ ] go test ./... passes


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol cycle 8: All healthy


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 14: All clear


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol complete: no callbacks, all agents healthy, no orphans, doctor 24/28


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 10: Routine


test pin fix


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol @ 2025-12-24 19:43

Patrol 3: All healthy


Remove bd sync instruction from polecat startup workflow

Polecats are instructed to run `bd sync --from-main` on startup (spawn.go:634).

## Problem
- Spawn command already syncs beads before spawning (line 239)
- Polecats share rig-level beads via `.beads/redirect`
- Multiple polecats starting simultaneously all try to sync same shared beads
- This causes git conflicts/failures when many polecats spawn at once

## Observed
User reported: 'all polecats failing on beads sync on startup in one run'

## Fix
Remove line 634 from buildWorkAssignmentMail():
```
body.WriteString("2. Run \`bd sync --from-main\` to get fresh beads\n")
```

Polecats only need to sync at END of work (already in steps 5/7).

## Files
- internal/cmd/spawn.go: buildWorkAssignmentMail() and buildSpawnContext()


Town root .beads has schema mismatch with bd

The .beads directory at town root (/Users/stevey/gt/.beads) has an incompatible schema:

```
Error: failed to open database: failed to initialize schema: sqlite3: SQL logic error: no such column: thread_id
```

Meanwhile, gastown/.beads (symlinked to mayor/rig/.beads) works fine.

## Impact

- gt mail inbox fails at town root
- gt handoff sends mail to broken db
- Daemon can't check its inbox

## Options

1. Delete town root .beads/beads.db and let it recreate
2. Symlink town root .beads to gastown/.beads
3. Run schema migration on existing db

## Root Cause

Likely a beads version upgrade that added thread_id column, but the town root db was created before that.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 10: all quiet


Self-review

Review your own changes. Look for:
- Bugs and edge cases
- Style issues
- Missing error handling
- Security concerns

Fix any issues found before proceeding.


mol-deacon-patrol

Mayor's daemon patrol loop.

The Deacon is the Mayor's background process that runs continuously,
handling callbacks, monitoring rig health, and performing cleanup.
Each patrol cycle runs these steps in sequence, then loops or exits.


Merge conflicts: Buzzard/mq-status, Dementus/harness-docs


Interrupt vs Queue mail semantics

Add priority/delivery semantics to mail messages.

## Semantics

| Type | Delivery | Use Case |
|------|----------|----------|
| Interrupt | tmux send-keys | Lifecycle, URGENT, stuck detection |
| Queue | Create message only | Normal mail, status, heartbeat |

## Implementation

- `bd mail send --interrupt` uses tmux send-keys notification
- Default is queue (agent checks with `gt mail check`)
- Urgent flag on messages for interrupt delivery

## Agent Side

- `gt mail check --quiet` - non-blocking check for queued mail
- `gt mail wait` - block until mail arrives (for idle agents)
- Heartbeats become queued, agent checks at natural breakpoints


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 19: all healthy


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 10: All healthy.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol complete: all agents healthy, no callbacks, cleaned 1 stale lock


Fix blocking bugs (gt-dsfi, gt-n7z7, gm-c6b)

Fix bugs blocking Witness functionality:

1. gt-dsfi: handoff deadlock
   - Polecats hang when trying to exit
   - Blocks shutdown request handler

2. gt-n7z7: refinery foreground race condition
   - Sometimes detects parent as already running
   - Blocks reliable Refinery startup

3. gm-c6b: mail coordination
   - Cross-rig mail should use town-level database
   - Affects Witness <-> Mayor communication

These should be fixed early as they'll block integration testing.

Fixed gt-dsfi and gt-n7z7. Issue gm-c6b not found in database.


gt-mayor

gt-mayor

role_type: mayor
rig: null
agent_state: stopped
hook_bead: null
role_bead: gt-mayor-role
cleanup_status: null


Fix potential race conditions in state file operations

Non-atomic state file operations could cause data loss:

All packages with state files (witness, refinery, crew, swarm):
State is loaded, modified, and saved without locking:
  ref, err := m.loadState()
  // ... modify ref ...
  return m.saveState(ref)

If two processes modify state simultaneously, one update may be lost.

internal/polecat/namepool.go (lines 179-194):
Save() uses RLock() but performs file I/O - should use write lock.

internal/swarm/manager.go:
swarms map[string]*Swarm accessed without mutex but multiple goroutines could call Create/GetSwarm.

Suggestion:
1. Use file locking (flock) for critical state updates
2. Or use atomic write pattern (write to temp, then rename)
3. Add mutex to swarm.Manager.swarms map


Enhance gt status with role hierarchy view

Show identity and role hierarchy in gt status:

## Current Output
Flat list of agents by rig, no clear role hierarchy.

## Desired Output
Tree structure showing:
- Town-level roles (Mayor, Deacon)
- Per-rig role slots with their role_bead references
- Each agent slot with pinned work

Example:
```
Town: gt
├── 🎩 Mayor (gt-mayor-role)
│   └── gt-mayor [running] → gt-u7dxq
├── 🔔 Deacon
│   └── gt-deacon [running]
└── Rigs
    └── gastown/
        ├── 👁 Witness (gt-witness-role)
        │   └── gt-witness-gastown [running]
        ├── 🏭 Refinery (gt-refinery-role)
        │   └── gt-refinery-gastown [running] → (work)
        ├── 👷 Crew
        │   ├── jack [running] → gt-xxxx
        │   └── joe [running]
        └── 😺 Polecats
            └── (none)
```

## Key Changes
1. Use tree-style indentation (├── └──)
2. Group agents by role type
3. Show role_bead for each role category
4. Use emojis for quick visual scanning


Remove polecat state derivation from issue status

**File:** polecat/manager.go (lines 556-599)

**Current behavior:**
- Switch on issue.Status to derive polecat state
- Go decides: open/in_progress → Working, closed → Done

**Fix:**
- Polecat state comes from polecat, not inferred by Go
- Polecat signals state via mail or explicit field
- Or: remove state derivation entirely, just report issue status

**Lines to refactor:**
- manager.go:576-588 (switch statement)

**Priority:** P2 - less critical than daemon/heartbeat logic


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 7: Routine


Add godoc comments to exported functions

Several exported functions lack godoc comments. While not critical, adding documentation would improve code maintainability. Focus on:

- Public API functions in each package
- Exported types and their methods
- Functions that have non-obvious behavior

Can be addressed incrementally as code is touched.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 12: All agents healthy


ensure-refineries

Parallel container: Start all rig refineries.

## Execution
Children execute in parallel. Container completes when all children complete.

## Children
- ensure-gastown-refinery
- ensure-beads-refinery

## Verify
All child refinery steps pass verification.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 2 complete: all healthy, no issues


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 11: All agents healthy, cleaned 18 stale wisps


Epic: Fix swarm orchestration - witness/refinery/polecat lifecycle

## Problem Statement

The bd-9115 swarm execution required excessive manual intervention from Mayor. The witness, refinery, and polecat lifecycle components didn't coordinate automatically.

## What Should Have Happened

```
Mayor slings 6 beads to rig
    ↓
Polecats auto-spawn with synced beads, work pinned
    ↓
Polecats work autonomously
    ↓
Witness monitors progress, nudges stuck polecats
    ↓
Polecat completes → pushes branch → signals completion
    ↓
Refinery detects ready branch → rebases → merges → deletes branch
    ↓
Witness detects merge → nukes polecat worktree
    ↓
When all done → Witness notifies Mayor
```

## What Actually Happened

1. **gt sling failed to pin beads** - polecat worktrees had stale JSONL
2. **Manual intervention** - had to checkout latest JSONL, pin, nudge each polecat
3. **Witness was passive** - never nudged or checked on polecats
4. **Refinery waited for requests** - didn't detect completed branches
5. **Manual lifecycle** - Mayor had to close beads, nuke polecats
6. **Manual merge coordination** - had to mail refinery with merge order

## Root Cause: Branch Hysteresis

Polecat branches persist across runs and drift from main/beads-sync:
- `polecat/foo` created weeks ago from old main
- New work slung to `polecat/foo`
- JSONL in branch doesn't have new beads
- Pin fails

## Open Questions

### Q1: Fresh branches per run?
Should each polecat spawn create a NEW branch from latest main/beads-sync?
```
gt sling bd-xxx rig
  → creates polecat/foo-20251227-1630 from origin/main
  → ensures JSONL is current
  → after merge, branch deleted forever
```
Pros: No drift, always current
Cons: Branch proliferation, naming complexity

### Q2: Rebase existing branches?
Or should we rebase persistent polecat branches before work?
```
gt sling bd-xxx rig/foo
  → git fetch origin
  → git rebase origin/main
  → now JSONL is current
```
Pros: Keeps simple naming
Cons: Rebase can fail with conflicts

### Q3: Just cherry-pick JSONL?
Minimal fix - grab latest JSONL before pinning:
```
git checkout origin/beads-sync -- .beads/issues.jsonl
bd import  # refresh DB
bd pin bd-xxx
```
Pros: Simple, surgical
Cons: Doesn't fix code drift, just beads

### Q4: Shared beads DB?
Could polecats share a DB (via symlink or sqlite over network)?
Pros: Always consistent
Cons: Locking complexity, daemon conflicts

### Q5: Who owns polecat lifecycle?
- Witness? (current assumption)
- Refinery? (after merge)
- gt sling? (on spawn)
- New "foreman" role?

## Proposed Solutions

See child issues for implementation details. Need to resolve open questions first.


Add logging for silently ignored errors

attached_args: Add logging for silently ignored errors

Add logging for silently ignored errors.

## Problem
Many places use `_ =` pattern to ignore errors without any logging, making debugging difficult.

## Files to modify
- internal/cmd/start.go (lines 167, 322-323, 429, 747-753, 886-888)
- internal/cmd/polecat.go (search for `_ =`)
- internal/session/manager.go (lines 140-154)
- internal/refinery/manager.go (line 399)
- internal/keepalive/keepalive.go (document as intentional)

## Implementation options

### Option A: Add comments explaining safety
```go
_ = m.saveState(ref) // Non-fatal: state will be recreated on next run
```

### Option B: Log warnings (preferred for important operations)
```go
if err := m.saveState(ref); err != nil {
    log.Printf("warning: failed to save state: %v", err)
}
```

## Guidelines
- Use logging for: state saves, config writes, cleanup operations
- Use comments for: truly benign operations (e.g., closing already closed file)
- keepalive is intentionally best-effort - add package-level comment

## Acceptance criteria
- [ ] All `_ =` in start.go have comment OR logging
- [ ] All `_ =` in session/manager.go have comment OR logging
- [ ] refinery/manager.go:399 has logging
- [ ] keepalive package has doc comment explaining best-effort design
- [ ] grep '`_ =`' shows all have justification
- [ ] go build ./... passes


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Test patrol cycle - first run, no actual work done


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 16: Quiet


Self-mail should suppress tmux notification

When sending mail to yourself (e.g., mayor sending to mayor/), the tmux notification shouldn't fire.

**Rationale:**
- Self-mail is intended for future-you (next session handoff)
- Present-you just sent it, so you already know about it
- The notification is redundant/confusing in this case

**Fix:**
Suppress tmux notification when sender == recipient address.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 8: All healthy.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol: no callbacks, no polecats, all agents healthy, cleaned 2 orphan processes + 2 stale locks


Test Patrol Parent

[RESURRECTED] This issue was deleted but recreated as a tombstone to preserve hierarchical structure.

Original description:
Test parent for Christmas Ornament pattern


Implement

Implement the solution for gt-gmqe. Follow codebase conventions.
File discovered work as new issues with bd create.

Make regular commits with clear messages.
Keep changes focused on the assigned issue.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 13: All clear


Add tmux crash detection hooks

Use tmux hooks to detect when agent panes die unexpectedly.

## tmux Hooks to Use
- pane-died: fires when a pane exits
- session-closed: fires when session ends

## Implementation
```bash
set-hook -g pane-died 'run-shell "gt log pane-died #{pane_id} #{pane_dead_status}"'
set-hook -g session-closed 'run-shell "gt log session-closed #{session_name}"'
```

## Integration
- gt spawn should set these hooks on agent sessions
- Distinguish expected exits (handoff, done) from crashes
- Capture last N lines of output on crash
- Record exit code/signal for forensics

## gt log crash command
- Parse pane-died events
- Show crash history
- Filter by agent, time range


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol @ 2025-12-24 19:25

Patrol 10: quiet


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 9: all clear


gt spawn --issue should auto-attach mol-polecat-work

When spawning a polecat with --issue but no --molecule, the polecat gets an issue assigned and work assignment mail, but no molecule on their hook. They check 'gt mol status', see nothing, and are stuck.

Fix: If --issue is provided but --molecule is not, auto-attach mol-polecat-work (or a configurable default) to the polecat's hook.

Current behavior:
- Issue assigned in beads ✓
- Mail sent ✓
- No molecule attached ✗

Expected:
- Issue assigned in beads ✓
- Mail sent ✓
- mol-polecat-work attached to hook ✓


test sling pinned


mol-polecat-lease

Semaphore tracking a single polecat's lifecycle.
Vars: {{polecat}}, {{issue}}

Used by Witness to track polecat lifecycle during patrol. The Witness bonds
this proto for each active polecat, creating a lease that tracks the polecat
from spawn through work to cleanup.

## Step: boot
Spawned. Verify it starts working.

Check if the polecat is alive and working:
```bash
gt peek {{polecat}}
```

If idle for too long, nudge:
```bash
gt nudge {{polecat}} "Please start working on your assigned issue."
```

Timeout: 60s before escalation to Mayor.

## Step: working
Actively working. Monitor for stuck.

The polecat is processing its assigned issue ({{issue}}).
Monitor via peek. Watch for:
- Progress on commits
- Status updates in beads
- SHUTDOWN mail when done

Wait for SHUTDOWN signal from the polecat.
Needs: boot

## Step: done
Exit received. Ready for cleanup.

The polecat has completed its work and sent SHUTDOWN.
Perform cleanup:
```bash
gt session kill {{polecat}}
gt worktree prune {{polecat}}
```

Update beads state and close the lease.
Needs: working


Burn-or-loop step execution

Fix step completion detection in patrol formulas. Ensure done() properly clears the molecule and triggers burn. Currently wisps accumulate because this step doesn't complete.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol cycle 15: All healthy


mol-deacon-patrol

Mayor's daemon patrol loop.

The Deacon is the Mayor's background process that runs continuously, handling callbacks, monitoring rig health, and performing cleanup. Each patrol cycle runs these steps in sequence, then loops or exits.

## Second-Order Monitoring

Witnesses send WITNESS_PING messages to verify the Deacon is alive. This
prevents the "who watches the watchers" problem - if the Deacon dies,
Witnesses detect it and escalate to the Mayor.

The Deacon's agent bead last_activity timestamp is updated during each patrol
cycle. Witnesses check this timestamp to verify health.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 12: All green


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol complete: 6 msgs archived, all agents healthy, cleaned 29 stale mols


Test Patrol Parent


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

P14: stable


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 10: Quiet, 8 sessions healthy


Wire up --wisp flag for ephemeral molecules

The --wisp flag exists in gt sling but isn't wired through to bd mol.

Need:
1. bd mol run --wisp - spawn to .beads-wisp/ instead of .beads/
2. Automatic burn on molecule completion
3. Optional squash to digest for audit trail

Currently:
- sling.go sets thing.IsWisp but never uses it
- bd mol run has no --wisp flag
- .beads-wisp/ exists but nothing writes to it


TIDY UP: Your previous work (gt-odvf: bd mol CLI docs) wa...

TIDY UP: Your previous work (gt-odvf: bd mol CLI docs) was already merged to main. Check your git status is clean, sync beads, and if nothing to do, just run 'gt done'.


CLI cleanup: Remove duplicate mol commands from gt

## Problem
gt mol has commands that duplicate bd mol functionality:
- `gt mol catalog` (duplicate of `bd formula list`)
- `gt mol show` (duplicate of `bd mol show`)
- `gt mol squash` (duplicate of `bd mol squash`)
- `gt mol burn` (duplicate of `bd mol burn`)
- `gt mol bond` (duplicate of `bd mol bond`)

## Principle
- **bd** = beads operations (issues, molecules, formulas)
- **gt** = agent operations (sessions, communication, work dispatch)

gt should delegate to bd for beads operations, not duplicate them.

## Proposed Changes
Keep gt mol commands that are agent-specific:
- `gt mol status` - what is on MY hook
- `gt mol attach/detach` - hook management
- `gt mol current` - what should I work on
- `gt mol progress` - my progress through workflow

Remove/delegate to bd:
- `gt mol catalog` → use `bd formula list`
- `gt mol show` → use `bd mol show`
- `gt mol squash` → use `bd mol squash`
- `gt mol burn` → use `bd mol burn`
- `gt mol bond` → use `bd mol bond`

## Alternative
Keep as thin wrappers that just call bd, for convenience.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 4: All healthy, no messages


Mol Mall: Formula Package Registry

A package registry for sharing and discovering formulas, schematics, and protocols.

## Concept

Like npm/Maven/Go modules but for workflow definitions.

```
mol-mall.io/
├── @gastown/           # Official Gas Town formulas
│   ├── shiny
│   ├── polecat-work
│   └── release
├── @acme-corp/         # Enterprise org (private)
│   └── compliance-review
├── @linus/             # Individual publisher
│   └── kernel-review
└── community/          # Unscoped public formulas
    └── towers-of-hanoi
```

## Resolution Hierarchy

```
1. Project:  ./.beads/formulas/          # Project-specific
2. Rig:      ~/gt/<rig>/.formulas/       # Rig-wide
3. Town:     ~/gt/.formulas/             # Town-wide (mayor stdlib)
4. User:     ~/.gastown/formulas/        # Personal collection
5. Mall:     mol-mall.io/                # Published packages
```

## Package Manifest

```toml
[package]
name = "shiny"
version = "1.2.0"
description = "Engineer in a Box"
authors = ["Gas Town <gastown@example.com>"]
license = "MIT"

[dependencies]
"@gastown/review-patterns" = "^2.0"
```

## Distribution Scenarios

1. **Celebrity Formulas**: Expert-curated workflows (e.g., Linus kernel review)
2. **Enterprise Compliance**: Private company formulas
3. **Standard Library**: @gastown/* blessed defaults
4. **Community Ecosystem**: Varying quality, needs ratings/verification

## Open Questions

1. Versioning semantics - SemVer? Breaking change rules?
2. Security model - sandboxing? signing? permissions?
3. Private registries - self-hosted? authentication?
4. Lock files - formulas.lock format?

## Related

- docs/formula_evolution.md - package ecosystem parallel section
- gt-8ws7o - Schematic (can be published)
- gt-y3jb9 - Protocol (can be published)


Refinery tmux status: show merge queue length

Add refinery-specific status line showing:
- MQ length (pending merges)
- Currently processing item (if any)
- Maybe: success/failure counts

Implement in runRefineryStatusLine() in internal/cmd/statusline.go


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 4: Routine


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Quick patrol: no messages, all healthy


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol complete: checked inbox (0 msgs), gates (0), polecats (0), health OK, GC'd 6 old wisps


Immediate daemon notification on lifecycle request

When gt handoff sends a lifecycle request to the daemon (via bd mail send deacon/), the daemon only discovers it on its next heartbeat poll (every 5 min). Workers wait unnecessarily for retirement.

## Current Behavior
1. Worker runs gt handoff
2. Lifecycle mail sent to deacon/ via beads
3. Worker blocks waiting for retirement
4. Daemon heartbeat runs (up to 5 min later)
5. Daemon processes lifecycle request and kills session

## Expected Behavior
Lifecycle requests should be processed immediately, not on poll interval.

## Proposed Solutions

### Option A: SIGUSR1 Signal (simplest)
1. Add SIGUSR1 handler in daemon that calls ProcessLifecycleRequests()
2. gt handoff reads daemon.pid and sends SIGUSR1 after mail send

### Option B: Unix Socket
1. Daemon listens on ~/gt/daemon/lifecycle.sock
2. gt handoff connects and sends 'process' message

### Option C: Watchfile + fsnotify
1. gt handoff touches ~/gt/daemon/lifecycle.trigger
2. Daemon uses fsnotify to detect and process

Recommend Option A for simplicity.

## Affected Files
- internal/daemon/daemon.go - add signal handler
- internal/cmd/handoff.go - send signal after mail


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 2: All healthy, fixed 1 stale lock


Remove daemon heartbeat staleness logic

**Files:** daemon/daemon.go (lines 272-325), daemon/backoff.go

**Current behavior:**
- Hardcoded 2min/5min thresholds classify agent health
- Exponential backoff decides nudge intervals
- Go decides "is this agent stuck?" based on timestamps

**Fix:**
- Remove staleness classification from Go
- Remove backoff algorithm
- Daemon becomes pure message router
- Deacon molecule step checks agent health instead

**Lines to remove/refactor:**
- daemon.go:272-274 (staleness thresholds)
- daemon.go:282-295 (poke decision logic)
- daemon.go:317-325 (conditional nudging)
- backoff.go:108-120 (backoff calculations)


plugin-run

Execute plugins from ~/gt/plugins/. Check gates, run eligible plugins.


Mol Mall: Formula marketplace and aspect composition

## Summary

A marketplace for sharing molecule formulas using GitHub as backend, plus a new
**aspect composition** capability for cooking that allows formulas to be applied
as cross-cutting transformations to existing mols.

## Key Insight

Formulas aren't just standalone workflows—they're **transformations** you can
apply to other mols. This enables patterns like:
- "Apply Rule of Five code review to any coding task"
- "Wrap any epic with security review steps"
- "Add logging/metrics to any patrol molecule"

## Architecture

```
Remote Formulas (GitHub)
        ↓ install
Local Formulas (~/.gt/formulas/ or .beads/formulas/)
        ↓ cook --with
Mols (beads, git-tracked)
        ↓ pour/sling
Execution (ephemeral or tracked)
```

## Formula Types

1. **Standalone** - Complete workflows (mol-polecat-work, mol-deacon-patrol)
2. **Aspects** - Cross-cutting concerns woven into other mols (rule-of-five)
3. **Adapters** - Wrappers that make things runnable

## Aspect Composition (New Cooking Capability)

```bash
bd cook my-epic --with rule-of-five,security-review
```

Aspects declare injection points:

```yaml
# rule-of-five.formula.yaml
kind: aspect
name: rule-of-five
version: 1.2.0

inject_after:
  tag: generates-code  # matches any step with this tag

steps:
  - id: review-correctness
    title: "Review: Correctness"
  - id: review-edge-cases
    title: "Review: Edge Cases"
  - id: review-performance
    title: "Review: Performance"
  - id: review-security
    title: "Review: Security"
  - id: review-maintainability
    title: "Review: Maintainability"
```

Injection modes:
- `inject_after: <step-id or tag>` - insert steps after
- `inject_before: <step-id or tag>` - insert steps before
- `wrap: <step-id or tag>` - insert before AND after
- `replace: <step-id or tag>` - substitute entirely

## The Mall Index

A well-known repo maps short names to full references:

```yaml
# steveyegge/gt-mall/index.yaml
formulas:
  rule-of-five:
    repo: steveyegge/gt-formulas
    path: aspects/rule-of-five.formula.yaml
    version: v1.2.0
    description: "Five-lens code review"
    tags: [review, quality]
```

Commands:
- `gt mol search review` - search the index
- `gt mol install rule-of-five` - fetch from GitHub
- `gt mol install github.com/acme/formulas/custom@v1` - direct URL

## Implementation Phases

### Phase 1: Aspect Composition (Cooking)
- Extend `bd cook` to accept `--with aspect1,aspect2`
- Aspect application during mol generation
- Local aspects in `.beads/formulas/`

### Phase 2: Mall Index
- Create gt-mall repo with index.yaml
- `gt mol search` queries the index
- `gt mol install` fetches and caches formulas

### Phase 3: Publishing
- `gt mol publish` pushes to your formula repo
- PR workflow to add to mall index

### Phase 4: Refinements
- Aspect ordering and conflict detection
- Aspect dependencies (`requires: [other-aspect]`)
- Private formula repos (enterprise)
- Local overrides/forks

## Open Questions

1. **Ordering conflicts**: Two aspects inject after same step—which goes first?
2. **Aspect dependencies**: Aspect A requires aspect B?
3. **Compile-time vs runtime**: Aspects are compile-time (baked into mol).
   Wisps remain runtime (slung dynamically).

## Deferred Until

Gas Town patrols operational. Prerequisites:
- [ ] Patrol system working (Deacon, Witness, Refinery)
- [ ] Basic spawn/work/merge cycle
- [ ] Activity feed showing work progress

Then the mall becomes valuable for sharing patrol customizations.

## Supersedes

This replaces gt-uzf2l which had the original marketplace concept but lacked
the aspect composition insight.

## Related

- Cooking system (bd cook)
- Formula definitions (.formula.yaml)
- Wisp architecture (runtime molecules)

See docs/formula_evolution.md for expanded thinking on: formula resolution hierarchy, combinators (>>, |, wrap, inject, extends), algebraic properties, higher abstractions, Mol Mall registry predictions, distribution scenarios, and open questions. The aspect composition in this design corresponds to the Wrapping (AOP) and Injection combinators in that doc.


gt-polecat-gastown-ace

gt-polecat-gastown-ace

role_type: polecat
rig: gastown
agent_state: running
hook_bead: gt-795e8
role_bead: null


Multiple merge/landing models documented without clarification

Architecture describes three different merge models:

1. Refinery-only model (traditional)
2. Direct landing model (Mayor bypass)
3. Swarm integration branch model (internal/swarm)

These appear to conflict. Documentation should clarify:
- Which model is canonical?
- When to use which model?
- Or are some deprecated?

This is confusing for users trying to understand the system.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 12: quiet


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 16: all healthy


Max expansion depth limit (default 5)

Add maxExpansionDepth config (default 5) to prevent runaway nested expansions. This still allows massive work generation but with a safety bound. Note: distinguish compile-time cooking (produces proto with placeholders) vs runtime cooking (produces mol with real issue IDs). Compile-time is for modeling/estimation/contractor handoff.


mol-polecat-arm: Add nudge_text variable definition

The mol-polecat-arm formula references `{{nudge_text}}` in the execute step but doesn't define it in the variables section.

## Current variables section

```yaml
variables:
  - name: polecat_name
    required: true
  - name: rig
    required: true
```

## Missing

```yaml
  - name: nudge_text
    required: false
    default: "How's progress? Need any help?"
    description: Text to send when nudging the polecat
```

## Usage in formula

```bash
tmux send-keys -t gt-{{rig}}-{{polecat_name}} "{{nudge_text}}" Enter
```

## Fix

Add nudge_text to the variables section with a sensible default.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

P7: stable


Add Gas Town theory of operation to all role primings

All roles (Mayor, Witness, Refinery, Polecat) should get basic GT architecture context: harness, rigs, agents, mail, beads workflow


mol-deacon-patrol

Mayor's daemon patrol loop.

The Deacon is the Mayor's background process that runs continuously, handling callbacks, monitoring rig health, and performing cleanup. Each patrol cycle runs these steps in sequence, then loops or exits.

## Second-Order Monitoring

Witnesses send WITNESS_PING messages to verify the Deacon is alive. This
prevents the "who watches the watchers" problem - if the Deacon dies,
Witnesses detect it and escalate to the Mayor.

The Deacon's agent bead last_activity timestamp is updated during each patrol
cycle. Witnesses check this timestamp to verify health.


Complete gt crew commands (list, attach, remove, refresh, status)

Add remaining crew subcommands to internal/cmd/crew.go:

1. gt crew list - List crew workspaces with status
2. gt crew at/attach - Start tmux session in crew workspace
3. gt crew remove - Remove crew workspace (with safety checks)
4. gt crew refresh - Context cycling with mail-to-self handoff
5. gt crew status - Show detailed workspace status

Build on existing crew add implementation in internal/cmd/crew.go.
Reference closed issues gt-cik.3-7 for original requirements.


Patrol agent state.json not updated on activity

Witness and Refinery state.json files show last_active from Dec 19 even though sessions have been running. The state should update each patrol cycle.

Evidence:
```
$ cat beads/witness/state.json
{"role": "witness", "last_active": "2025-12-19T17:50:00Z"}

$ cat beads/refinery/state.json
{"role": "refinery", "last_active": "2025-12-19T17:50:00Z"}
```

Expected: last_active should update each time the agent runs a patrol cycle.

Impact: Can't tell if patrol agents are actually active vs just having an open tmux session.


Document how to configure a Gas Town Harness

Create docs explaining what a harness is (private repo containing GT installation with rigs gitignored), why you'd want one, and how to set it up with beads redirects


Role templates: rename 'Dependency Trap' to 'Gotchas when Filing Beads'

The 'Dependency Trap' heading is too specific. Rename to something like 'Gotchas when Filing Beads' or 'Beads Filing Tips'. Applies to all role templates (polecat, crew, mayor, witness, refinery, deacon).


Test Patrol Parent

[RESURRECTED] This issue was deleted but recreated as a tombstone to preserve hierarchical structure.

Original description:
[RESURRECTED] This issue was deleted but recreated as a tombstone to preserve hierarchical structure.

Original description:
Test parent for Christmas Ornament pattern


Add gt decommission command for clean swarm/worker shutdown

Single command to cleanly shut down a swarm and its workers: cancel swarm, stop sessions, optionally remove polecats. E.g. gt decommission gt-hw6 --cleanup


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 20: quiet, handoff threshold reached


Day 1.5: Create role beads from CLAUDE.md content

Create role beads from existing CLAUDE.md files:
- gt-mayor-role (from mayor CLAUDE.md)
- gt-witness-role (from witness CLAUDE.md)
- gt-refinery-role (from refinery CLAUDE.md)

Each role bead contains priming instructions and default_molecule.

Parent: gt-d0jqp


Add WaitsFor parsing to molecule steps

Add WaitsFor field to MoleculeStep struct and parse 'WaitsFor: all-children' (and future variants) from molecule descriptions.

This enables:
- mol progress to understand fanout patterns
- Validation that WaitsFor references valid constructs
- Future automated orchestration

Implementation:
1. Add WaitsFor []string to MoleculeStep struct
2. Add waitsForLineRegex to parse 'WaitsFor: ...' lines
3. Update ParseMoleculeSteps to extract WaitsFor
4. Update tests


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 2: routine, all healthy


Patrol lifecycle integration test

Verify patrol runs 3+ cycles without wisp accumulation. bd wisp list should show <5 wisps. Context cycles cleanly produce handoff mail. Test with Deacon patrol.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 20: All healthy - handoff threshold reached


Polecat Arm (arm-toast)

Single polecat inspection and action cycle.

This molecule is bonded dynamically by mol-witness-patrol's survey-workers step.
Each polecat being monitored gets one arm that runs in parallel with other arms.

## Variables

| Variable | Required | Description |
|----------|----------|-------------|
| polecat_name | Yes | Name of the polecat to inspect |
| rig | Yes | Rig containing the polecat |

## Step: capture
Capture recent tmux output for toast.

```bash
tmux capture-pane -t gt-gastown-toast -p | tail -50
```

Record:
- Last activity timestamp (when was last tool call?)
- Visible errors or stack traces
- Completion indicators ("Done", "Finished", etc.)

## Step: assess
Categorize polecat state based on captured output.

States:
- **working**: Recent tool calls, active processing
- **idle**: At prompt, no recent activity
- **error**: Showing errors or stack traces
- **requesting_shutdown**: Sent LIFECYCLE/Shutdown mail
- **done**: Showing completion indicators

Calculate: minutes since last activity.
Needs: capture

## Step: load-history
Read nudge history for toast from patrol state.

```
nudge_count = state.nudges[toast].count
last_nudge_time = state.nudges[toast].timestamp
```

This data was loaded by the parent patrol's load-state step and passed
to the arm via the bonding context.
Needs: assess

## Step: decide
Apply the nudge matrix to determine action for toast.

| State | Idle Time | Nudge Count | Action |
|-------|-----------|-------------|--------|
| working | any | any | none |
| idle | <10min | any | none |
| idle | 10-15min | 0 | nudge-1 (gentle) |
| idle | 15-20min | 1 | nudge-2 (direct) |
| idle | 20+min | 2 | nudge-3 (final) |
| idle | any | 3 | escalate |
| error | any | any | assess-severity |
| requesting_shutdown | any | any | pre-kill-verify |
| done | any | any | pre-kill-verify |

Nudge text:
1. "How's progress? Need any help?"
2. "Please wrap up soon. What's blocking you?"
3. "Final check. Will escalate in 5 min if no response."

Record decision and rationale.
Needs: load-history

## Step: execute
Take the decided action for toast.

**nudge-N**:
```bash
tmux send-keys -t gt-gastown-toast "{{nudge_text}}" Enter
```

**pre-kill-verify**:
```bash
cd polecats/toast
git status                    # Must be clean
git log origin/main..HEAD     # Check for unpushed
bd show <assigned-issue>      # Verify closed/deferred
```
If clean: kill session, remove worktree, delete branch
If dirty: record failure, retry next cycle

**escalate**:
```bash
gt mail send mayor/ -s "Escalation: toast stuck" -m "..."
```

**none**: No action needed.

Record: action taken, result, updated nudge count.
Needs: decide

## Output

The arm completes with:
- action_taken: none | nudge-1 | nudge-2 | nudge-3 | killed | escalated
- result: success | failed | pending
- updated_state: New nudge count and timestamp for toast

This data feeds back to the parent patrol's aggregate step.
---
bonded_from: mol-polecat-arm
bonded_to: gt-5glf
bonded_ref: arm-toast
bonded_at: 2025-12-23T10:00:00Z


Refinery not processing merge-requests - stale MRs accumulating

Discovered 15 stale merge-request issues in beads rig that were never processed by the refinery. These appear to be from polecat branches that completed work but the refinery didn't pick up the merge-requests.

Closed issues:
- bd-r06v, bd-bhg7, bd-754r, bd-fcl1, bd-3zzh
- bd-bijf, bd-5rj1, bd-kptp, bd-rdzk, bd-ibl9
- bd-gfo3, bd-aq3s, bd-x2bd, bd-s1pz, bd-h27p

Need to investigate:
1. Why refinery isn't picking up merge-requests
2. Whether the polecat branches have valid work to merge
3. Add monitoring/alerting for stale MRs


check-refinery

Ensure the refinery is alive and processing merge requests.

Needs: inbox-check


Pillar 2: Patrol Ignition

Witness and Refinery patrol loops fire reliably.

Key deliverables:
- Witness patrol reads agent beads for polecat state
- Witness sends MERGE_READY to refinery on completion
- Refinery processes MERGE_READY mail
- Both send completion signals

Subsumes existing work:
- gt-6qyt1: Refinery event-driven merge queue
- gt-qpwv4: Witness detect completion
- gt-dtw9u: Witness active monitoring

Reference: ~/gt/docs/liftoff-plan.md

Parent: gt-oki8p


Refinery needs branch visibility: Convert to worktree or push branches

The refinery cannot see polecat branches because it is a separate clone, not a worktree.

## Problem
- Polecats are worktrees of mayor/rig (correct, per gt-4u5z)
- Refinery is still a separate clone at refinery/rig (not converted)
- Polecat branches are local to mayor/rig, invisible to refinery

## Decision (2025-12-25)
**Use a shared bare repo as the single git source of truth.**

```
gastown/
├── .repo.git/           ← Bare repo (no working tree, invisible base)
├── mayor/rig/           ← Worktree (human workspace)
├── polecats/
│   └── Toast/           ← Worktree on polecat/Toast
├── refinery/rig/        ← Worktree on main (can see all branches!)
└── crew/max/            ← Worktree or separate clone (TBD)
```

**Why bare repo:**
- No working directory to accidentally work in
- Standard git pattern (how servers work)
- All worktrees share branch visibility
- Refinery on main can merge polecat branches directly

## Implementation
1. Create `.repo.git` as bare clone
2. Convert refinery to worktree of .repo.git on main
3. Convert polecats to worktrees of .repo.git
4. Optionally convert mayor/rig (or keep as worktree)
5. Update gt rig init for new rigs
6. Write migration for existing rigs

## Evidence
Tracer bullet 2025-12-23: Refinery could not see polecat/tracer until pushed to origin.


Define constants for magic strings

Several magic strings are hardcoded throughout the codebase:
- "mayor" appears in 20+ places as a path component
- "main" branch name appears in 20+ places
- "beads-sync" branch name in multiple files
- "rigs.json" filename

These should be constants in a central location for maintainability.


Witness should verify polecat submitted before stopping session

## Problem

Witness stopped dementus's session before it could call `gt done`, losing the MR submission. I had to manually push and submit the branch.

## Root Cause

Witness cleanup is triggered by nudge/manual check rather than by receiving POLECAT_DONE message. When Witness cleans up based on issue status (closed), it doesn't wait for the polecat to complete its shutdown sequence.

## Expected Behavior

Witness should only stop a polecat session after:
1. Receiving POLECAT_DONE message from that polecat, OR
2. Timeout waiting for POLECAT_DONE after issue is closed

## Current Behavior

Witness stops sessions immediately when asked to check for completions, even if polecat hasn't called `gt done` yet.

## Fix

In mol-witness-patrol inbox-check step:
- Only clean up polecats that have sent POLECAT_DONE
- For polecats with closed issues but no DONE message, nudge them to complete
- Add timeout before force-killing


gt handoff: Deadlock in waitForRetirement


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 4: routine checks all clear


gt-polecat-gastown-morsov

gt-polecat-gastown-morsov

role_type: polecat
rig: gastown
agent_state: done
hook_bead: null
role_bead: null


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 9: routine, all healthy


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 16: All healthy.


Check Witness and Refinery health

Check Witness and Refinery health for each rig.

**ZFC Principle**: You (Claude) make the judgment call about what is "stuck" or "unresponsive" - there are no hardcoded thresholds in Go. Read the signals, consider context, and decide.

For each rig, run:
```bash
gt witness status <rig>
gt refinery status <rig>
```

**Signals to assess:**

| Component | Healthy Signals | Concerning Signals |
|-----------|-----------------|-------------------|
| Witness | State: running, recent activity | State: not running, no heartbeat |
| Refinery | State: running, queue processing | Queue stuck, merge failures |

**Tracking unresponsive cycles:**

Maintain in your patrol state (persisted across cycles):
```
health_state:
  <rig>:
    witness:
      unresponsive_cycles: 0
      last_seen_healthy: <timestamp>
    refinery:
      unresponsive_cycles: 0
      last_seen_healthy: <timestamp>
```

**Decision matrix** (you decide the thresholds based on context):

| Cycles Unresponsive | Suggested Action |
|---------------------|------------------|
| 1-2 | Note it, check again next cycle |
| 3-4 | Attempt restart: gt witness restart <rig> |
| 5+ | Escalate to Mayor with context |

**Restart commands:**
```bash
gt witness restart <rig>
gt refinery restart <rig>
```

**Escalation:**
```bash
gt mail send mayor/ -s "Health: <rig> <component> unresponsive" \
  -m "Component has been unresponsive for N cycles. Restart attempts failed.
      Last healthy: <timestamp>
      Error signals: <details>"
```

Reset unresponsive_cycles to 0 when component responds normally.


mol-deacon-patrol

Mayor's daemon patrol loop.

The Deacon is the Mayor's background process that runs continuously, handling callbacks, monitoring rig health, and performing cleanup. Each patrol cycle runs these steps in sequence, then loops or exits.


gt spawn --create should auto-add polecat if missing

## Problem

`gt spawn gastown --issue gt-xxx --create` fails if no polecats exist.

## Current Behavior

```
Error: auto-select polecat: no available polecats in rig 'gastown'
```

## Expected Behavior

`--create` should:
1. Create a new polecat if none exist
2. Or create the specified polecat if `gt spawn gastown/NewName --create`

## Workaround

Must manually run `gt polecat add gastown Name` first.

## Principle

Agent UX should be forgiving - if I say spawn with --create, make it work.


Clean up duplicate patrol protos (gt-qflq, gt-iep9)

There are duplicate protos for patrol molecules:

## Duplicates

| Old Proto | New Proto | Name |
|-----------|-----------|------|
| gt-qflq | mol-witness-patrol | mol-witness-patrol |
| gt-iep9 | mol-deacon-patrol | mol-deacon-patrol |

The old gt-* prefix protos were created before the formula cooking system.
The new mol-* prefix protos were created by `bd cook`.

## Action

1. Close or delete the old gt-* protos
2. Update any references to use the new mol-* protos
3. Verify `bd mol list` shows clean output

## Root Cause

The bd cook command uses the formula name as the proto ID (mol-*),
not the project prefix (gt-*). This is probably correct behavior,
but means we have legacy protos to clean up.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 4: routine


gt-polecat-gastown-nux

gt-polecat-gastown-nux

role_type: polecat
rig: gastown
agent_state: running
hook_bead: gt-2g130
role_bead: null


Molecule state file management

## Cross-Repo Reference

This work is tracked in beads repo as **bd-hulf**.

The gastown task gt-qvn7.2.2 is a placeholder.
Actual implementation happens in beads.

See: bd show bd-hulf (from beads/crew/dave)


Merge: nux-1766959759345

branch: polecat/nux-1766959759345
target: main
source_issue: nux-1766959759345
rig: gastown


gt sling: nudge witness+refinery when dispatching to polecat

When gt sling dispatches work to a polecat, nudge the rig's witness and refinery sessions.

This is NOT slinging work TO them - it's a wake signal so they know work is in flight.

Purpose:
- Clears exponential backoff (see patrol-system-design.md)
- Witness can immediately poll agent beads
- Refinery prepares for eventual MERGE_READY

Implementation (in sling.go, after successful polecat dispatch):
```go
func notifyRigActivity(rig string) {
    t := tmux.NewTmux()

    witnessSession := fmt.Sprintf("gt-%s-witness", rig)
    t.NudgeSession(witnessSession, "Activity in rig - check polecats")

    refinerySession := fmt.Sprintf("gt-%s-refinery", rig)
    t.NudgeSession(refinerySession, "Polecat dispatched - prepare for MR")
}
```

Graceful degradation: If nudge fails (no session), that's fine - not an error.

Reference: ~/gt/docs/patrol-system-design.md (Exponential Backoff section)


Inconsistent error wrapping patterns

Error handling is inconsistent across the codebase:

1. Some functions use fmt.Errorf with %w for wrapping, others don't
2. return nil, nil patterns (40+ occurrences) sometimes represent 'not found' and sometimes 'error but continue' - should use sentinel errors
3. Some places return nil for errors when they should propagate them

Examples of nil,nil that might need review:
- internal/git/git.go:272, 308
- internal/crew/manager.go:227
- internal/witness/manager.go:517, 523, 530, 775
- internal/beads/beads.go:225, 492


implement

Implement the solution for gt-1wmw. Follow codebase conventions.
File discovered work as new issues with bd create.

Make regular commits with clear messages.
Keep changes focused on the assigned issue.

Depends: load-context


Refactor sling to hook plus handoff

Replace gt sling with gt hook (durability) and gt handoff bead (hook+restart)


Aspects: AOP cross-cutting concerns

Implement aspect-oriented composition:
- Define aspects with pointcuts and advice
- Apply aspects at bond time: bd bond mol --with-aspect security
- Pointcuts use glob patterns to match join points

Enables security-audit, logging, etc. as reusable concerns.


gt-polecat-gastown-rictus

gt-polecat-gastown-rictus

role_type: polecat
rig: gastown
agent_state: running
hook_bead: gt-dsqxw
role_bead: null


Polecat role references deprecated 'swarm' terminology

prompts/roles/polecat.md line 12 says:
'Part of a swarm: Other polecats may be working on related issues in parallel'

But architecture.md explicitly states:
'There are no swarm IDs - just epics with children'

The swarm concept has been replaced by streams/dependency model.
Update polecat.md to remove swarm references.


Outpost configuration: YAML config and OutpostManager

## Overview

Configuration file for outposts and manager to load/track them.

## Config File

`~/ai/config/outposts.yaml`:

```yaml
outposts:
  - name: local
    type: local
    max_workers: 4

  - name: gce-burst
    type: ssh
    host: 10.0.0.5
    user: steve
    ssh_key: ~/.ssh/gce_worker
    town_path: /home/steve/ai
    max_workers: 8

  - name: cloudrun-burst
    type: cloudrun
    project: my-gcp-project
    region: us-central1
    service: gastown-worker
    max_workers: 20
    cost_cap_hourly: 5.00

policy:
  default_preference: [local, gce-burst, cloudrun-burst]
  overrides:
    - condition: "priority >= P3"
      prefer: cloudrun-burst
```

## OutpostManager

```go
type OutpostManager struct {
    outposts map[string]Outpost
    policy   AssignmentPolicy
}

func NewOutpostManager(configPath string) (*OutpostManager, error)
func (m *OutpostManager) Get(name string) (Outpost, bool)
func (m *OutpostManager) List() []Outpost
func (m *OutpostManager) SelectOutpost(issue Issue) Outpost
```

## Files

- `internal/outpost/manager.go`
- `internal/outpost/config.go` (extend)
- `internal/outpost/policy.go`

Depends on: gt-9a2.1 (interfaces)


Worker cleanup: Beads sync on shutdown

Add beads sync verification to worker cleanup checklist and Witness verification.

## Update to Decommission Checklist (gt-sd6)

Add to pre-done verification:
- bd sync --status must show 'Up to date'
- git status .beads/ must show no changes

## Beads Edge Cases

Uncommitted beads changes:
  bd sync
  git add .beads/
  git commit -m 'beads: final sync'

Beads sync conflict (rare):
  git fetch origin main
  git checkout main -- .beads/
  bd sync --force
  git add .beads/
  git commit -m 'beads: resolve sync conflict'

## Update to Witness Verification (gt-f8v)

When capturing worker state:
  town capture <polecat> "bd sync --status && git status .beads/"

Check for:
- bd sync --status shows 'Up to date'
- git status .beads/ shows no changes

If beads not synced, nudge:
  WITNESS CHECK: Beads not synced. Run 'bd sync' then commit .beads/. Signal done when complete.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 6: Routine


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 8: Quiet


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 19: quiet


bd formula list/show commands

Implement formula management commands:

  bd formula list
  # Lists formulas from all search paths

  bd formula show rule-of-five
  # Shows formula details, steps, compose rules

Search paths (in order):
1. .beads/formulas/ (project)
2. ~/gt/.beads/formulas/ (town)
3. ~/.beads/formulas/ (user)
4. Built-in formulas (embedded)


Polecat template: move startup announcement into molecule

Template has STARTUP PROTOCOL with 'Announce: beads Polecat furiosa, checking in.' This should be a startup step in the polecat molecule, not prose instruction in CLAUDE.md. The molecule drives behavior, not the template prose.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 19: all clear


mol-deacon-patrol

Mayor's daemon patrol loop.

The Deacon is the Mayor's background process that runs continuously, handling callbacks, monitoring rig health, and performing cleanup. Each patrol cycle runs these steps in sequence, then loops or exits.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 15: quiet


Timed Beads: Scheduled recurring work

## Summary

Timed beads wake up periodically and get injected into the ready queue by the daemon.

## Schema Extension

```yaml
id: gt-weekly-sync
type: task  # or sentinel
schedule: "0 9 * * 1"  # cron: Monday 9am
# OR
interval: 24h          # every 24 hours
tier: haiku            # cheap model for routine checks
next_run: 2025-12-20T09:00:00Z
```

## Daemon Integration

Daemon heartbeat loop:
1. Check timed beads where `next_run <= now`
2. For each due bead:
   - Inject into ready queue (set status to open if needed)
   - Update `next_run` based on schedule/interval
3. Witnesses pick up work via `bd ready`

## Use Cases

- Weekly team sync reminders
- Daily health checks
- Periodic cleanup tasks
- Scheduled reports

## Interaction with Pinned Beads

A pinned bead can be timed - it wakes up periodically but never closes.
This is how you model "background services" in Gas Town.


Enhance Mayor CLAUDE.md with GGT milestone tracking

Update ~/ai/CLAUDE.md (Mayor startup context) with:

1. GGT Self-Hosting Milestone section
   - Track progress toward gt replacing town
   - Key blockers: gt-h5n (merge queue), gt-974 (daemon)
   - What "self-hosting" means (GGT working on itself)

2. Recent Architecture Decisions
   - Engineer = role, Refinery = place
   - Merge queue in Beads (not branch discovery)
   - Session restart protocol

3. Transition Plan
   - Current: use town commands (PGT)
   - Target: use gt commands (GGT)
   - Switch criteria: gt-b1g closed

Keep it concise - Mayor context should be quick to scan.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 15: All healthy, no messages


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol cycle 14: All healthy


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 1: All healthy, no messages


mol-deacon-patrol

Mayor's daemon patrol loop.

The Deacon is the Mayor's background process that runs continuously, handling callbacks, monitoring rig health, and performing cleanup. Each patrol cycle runs these steps in sequence, then loops or exits.

## Second-Order Monitoring

Witnesses send WITNESS_PING messages to verify the Deacon is alive. This
prevents the "who watches the watchers" problem - if the Deacon dies,
Witnesses detect it and escalate to the Mayor.

The Deacon's agent bead last_activity timestamp is updated during each patrol
cycle. Witnesses check this timestamp to verify health.


Add molecule to update local go binary on push to main

When pushing to main branch, automatically rebuild and install the gt binary on the local machine so changes are immediately available.


Instrument gt commands to appear in activity feed

## Architecture: Two-tier event system

```
┌─────────────┐  ┌─────────────┐  ┌─────────────┐
│ gt commands │  │ bd mutations│  │ agent output│
└──────┬──────┘  └──────┬──────┘  └──────┬──────┘
       └────────────────┼────────────────┘
                        ▼
              ~/gt/.events.jsonl (raw, audit)
                        │
              ┌─────────────────┐
              │  Feed daemon    │ ← goroutine in gt daemon
              │  - filters      │
              │  - aggregates   │
              │  - AI curates   │
              └────────┬────────┘
                       ▼
              ~/gt/.feed.jsonl (curated, user-facing)
```

## Event format

```json
{
  "ts": "2025-12-28T10:30:15Z",
  "source": "gt",
  "type": "sling",
  "actor": "mayor",
  "payload": {"bead": "gt-xyz", "target": "gastown/Toast"},
  "visibility": "feed"
}
```

Visibility: `audit` | `feed` | `both`

## Implementation phases

1. **Event logging** - gt commands write to ~/gt/.events.jsonl
2. **Feed daemon** - goroutine in gt daemon tails events, writes curated feed
3. **Feed readers** - gt feed, gt dashboard read from .feed.jsonl
4. **AI curation** - future: haiku summarization for complex activity

Part of epic gt-u7dxq


Nudge newly spawned polecats

Nudge newly spawned polecats that are ready for input.

When polecats are spawned, their Claude session takes 10-20 seconds to initialize. The spawn command returns immediately without waiting. This step finds spawned polecats that are now ready and sends them a trigger to start working.

**ZFC-Compliant Observation** (AI observes AI):

```bash
# View pending spawns with captured terminal output
gt deacon pending
```

For each pending session, analyze the captured output:
- Look for Claude's prompt indicator "> " at the start of a line
- If prompt is visible, Claude is ready for input
- Make the judgment call yourself - you're the AI observer

For each ready polecat:
```bash
# 1. Trigger the polecat
gt nudge <session> "Begin."

# 2. Clear from pending list
gt deacon pending <session>
```

This triggers the UserPromptSubmit hook, which injects mail so the polecat sees its assignment.

**Bootstrap mode** (daemon-only, no AI available):
The daemon uses `gt deacon trigger-pending` with regex detection. This ZFC violation is acceptable during cold startup when no AI agent is running yet.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol @ 2025-12-24 19:47

Patrol 15: All healthy


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 15: Nominal


Test Task 2: Add comment to version.go


Work assignment mail not received by polecat

When gt spawn sends a work assignment:

1. gt spawn says '✓ Work assignment sent'
2. Polecat runs 'gt mail inbox'
3. Shows '0 messages, 0 unread'

The work assignment mail never arrived at the polecat's inbox.

## Observed in session
- Spawned polecat dementus on gt-th7
- Polecat checked inbox: empty
- Polecat couldn't find issue (separate sync bug)

## Possible causes
- Mail routing issue for polecat addresses
- gt spawn not actually sending mail
- Mail sent to wrong address format

This was likely caused by stale beads in old polecats. With gt-9nf (fresh polecats), polecats now use shared rig beads via redirect file, eliminating sync issues. Mail routing uses town beads correctly.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 3: All clear