Fix golangci-lint errcheck warnings (~160 issues)

Running golangci-lint shows ~160 errcheck warnings for unchecked error returns.

Common patterns:
- t.SetEnvironment() return values
- os.WriteFile(), os.RemoveAll()
- MarkFlagRequired() on cobra commands
- Various manager methods

Run: golangci-lint run ./...

Could batch fix with:
1. Add explicit _ = for intentionally ignored errors
2. Handle errors properly where they matter
3. Consider adding //nolint:errcheck for cobra flag setup


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol: 2 completions (valkyrie gt-yd98 MQ, scrotus gt-mzal.1 boot proto). 8 polecats working.


Witness MVP: Automated Polecat Lifecycle

Implement the Witness agent - per-rig 'pit boss' that manages polecat lifecycles.

The Witness enables hands-free swarming by automating:
- Spawning polecats for ready work
- Monitoring worker health
- Processing shutdown requests
- Cleaning up worktrees when done
- Escalating stuck workers to Mayor

Without Witness, humans must manually spawn, monitor, and kill each polecat.

## Core Loop

```
while True:
  # Handle pending shutdowns
  for polecat in polecats where state == pending_shutdown:
    verify git clean
    kill session
    remove worktree
    delete branch

  # Spawn for ready work
  ready = bd ready --parent=<epic> if epic else bd ready
  for issue in ready:
    if active_workers < max_workers:
      gt spawn --issue <id>

  # Check worker health
  for polecat in active polecats:
    if stuck (no progress for 30 min):
      nudge or escalate

  sleep 60
```

## Blocking Bugs to Fix
- gt-dsfi: handoff deadlock
- gt-n7z7: refinery foreground race condition
- gm-c6b: mail coordination (town vs rig beads)


Test: New Router

Testing bd create for mail


Build activity stream component

Bubbletea component showing scrollable activity stream for a selected worker. Shows mutation events with timestamps, symbols, and issue titles. Displayed when user expands/selects a worker.


Merge: gt-5af.2

branch: polecat/Doof
target: main
source_issue: gt-5af.2
rig: gastown


Merge: gt-g44u.2

branch: polecat/Doof
target: main
source_issue: gt-g44u.2
rig: gastown


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 11: Routine


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 7: routine


bd sync --from-main: fresh sync from main branch

## Summary

Add `--from-main` flag to `bd sync` to pull fresh beads state from main branch.

## Use Case

When starting a patrol or fresh session, agent wants clean beads state:
```bash
bd sync --from-main    # Pull latest from origin/main, ignore local changes
```

## Behavior

1. Fetch origin/main
2. Reset local .beads/ to match origin/main
3. Rebuild SQLite DB from fresh JSONL

Useful for polecats/crew starting work to avoid stale state.


Add accounts.yaml config parsing to gt

Parse ~/gt/mayor/accounts.yaml with structure: accounts map (handle -> email, config_dir) and default field. This is the foundational config that other account features depend on. Location follows existing town-level config pattern in mayor/.

Implemented accounts.json config parsing with types, loader, validation, and tests


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 4: Stable


Design GGT prompt architecture

Audit PGT prompts and design canonical prompt system for GGT. Create docs/prompts.md with inventory, gap analysis, and Witness prompt design.


Molecule-based Witness Patrol

Wire up mol-witness-patrol as a tracking ledger for the Go-based witness.

## Key Insight

The molecule is NOT an executor - it's a **tracking structure**. The existing
Go code in internal/witness/manager.go continues to run the patrol loop.
The molecule instance provides visibility, audit trail, and polecat tracking.

## Current State

- Witness runs as Go code with direct patrol logic
- mol-witness-patrol and mol-polecat-arm exist as molecule definitions
- gt mol bond creates dynamic children
- No molecule tracking of actual witness operations

## Target State

1. When witness starts → instantiate mol-witness-patrol on its hook
2. When Go code discovers polecat → bond mol-polecat-arm child
3. When polecat completes/dies → close that arm issue
4. gt mol progress shows current patrol state
5. Molecule survives wisp burns via handoff bead

## Benefits

- Visibility: gt mol status gastown/witness shows active arms
- Audit: Each polecat inspection is a trackable issue
- Consistency: Same tracking model as polecats with molecules
- Progress: gt mol progress works for witness too

## Non-Goals

- NOT replacing Go code with Claude session
- NOT running molecule steps as prompts
- NOT requiring Claude for witness operation

CANCELLED: Wrong architecture. Go-based witness patrol with molecule-as-tracking-ledger is backwards. Claude session executes mol steps directly - the mol IS the executor, not bookkeeping. Also: subtasks were hallucinated as 'done' without actual code commits.


mol sling command: attach molecule to agent hook

Add `gt mol sling <molecule-id>` command to attach a molecule to the current agent's hook.

## Behavior

```bash
gt mol sling mol-witness-patrol
```

1. Find agent identity from cwd (witness, polecat, crew, etc.)
2. Find or create agent's handoff bead
3. Attach molecule to handoff bead (attached_molecule field)
4. Create root issue for this molecule instance
5. Instantiate molecule steps under the root

## Difference from mol attach

- `mol attach` attaches to an existing pinned bead
- `mol sling` creates a fresh instance for execution

## Output

```
🧬 Slung mol-witness-patrol on gastown/witness
  Instance: gt-xyz (9 steps)
  First step: inbox-check
```

## Implementation

- Reuse InstantiateMolecule from molecule.go
- Create wrapper issue for the instance
- Set attached_molecule on handoff bead


mol progress: track dynamically bonded children

Extend `gt mol progress` to show dynamically bonded children.

## Current Behavior

```
gt mol progress gt-abc
```

Shows progress through pre-defined steps from InstantiateMolecule.

## New Behavior

Also show dynamically bonded children:

```
📊 Progress: mol-witness-patrol (gt-abc)

  Steps (9):
    ✓ inbox-check
    ✓ check-refinery
    ✓ load-state
    ◐ survey-workers (bonded 3 children)
    ○ aggregate (WaitsFor: all-children)
    ○ save-state
    ○ generate-summary
    ○ context-check
    ○ burn-or-loop

  Bonded Children (3):
    ✓ arm-toast (5/5 steps)
    ◐ arm-nux (3/5 steps)
    ○ arm-furiosa (0/5 steps)

  Progress: 4/9 steps, 3 arms (1 complete, 1 in-progress, 1 pending)
```

## Implementation

1. Find children with bonded_to: <parent-id> in description
2. Recursively get progress for each bonded child
3. Aggregate into parent progress display


Witness: instantiate mol-witness-patrol on start

When witness starts, create a mol-witness-patrol instance and pin it to the witness hook.

## Changes to witness/manager.go

In Start() or run():
1. Check if patrol instance exists on hook
2. If not, call beads.InstantiateMolecule(mol-witness-patrol, handoffBead)
3. Store instance ID for later reference

## Hook Structure

The witness handoff bead gets:
- attached_molecule: gt-patrol-xyz
- attached_at: timestamp

## Idempotency

If patrol already exists (from previous session), reuse it.
Don't create duplicate instances on restart.


Witness: bond mol-polecat-arm when discovering polecat

When witness discovers a polecat during healthCheck(), bond a mol-polecat-arm child.

## Changes to witness/manager.go

In healthCheck() when iterating polecats:
1. Check if arm already exists for this polecat (arm-{name})
2. If not, call: gt mol bond mol-polecat-arm --parent=$PATROL_ID --ref=arm-{name} --var polecat_name={name} --var rig={rig}
3. Track arm issue ID in handoff state

## Arm Lifecycle

- Created when polecat first seen
- Updated as inspection happens (nudges, state changes)
- Closed when polecat cleaned up

## Deduplication

Check handoffState.WorkerStates[name].ArmID before creating.
Needs: gt-59zd.3


Witness: close arm when polecat completes

When witness cleans up a polecat, close its mol-polecat-arm issue.

## Changes to witness/manager.go

In cleanupPolecat():
1. Get arm ID from handoffState.WorkerStates[name].ArmID
2. If exists, call: bd close {armID} --reason='polecat cleaned up'
3. Clear ArmID from handoff state

## Arm Close Reasons

- 'polecat cleaned up' - normal completion
- 'polecat killed - stuck' - killed due to inactivity
- 'polecat killed - escalated' - killed after Mayor escalation

## State Update

The arm's description could be updated with final outcome before closing.
Needs: gt-59zd.4


mol progress: display bonded children in output

Extend gt mol progress to show dynamically bonded children.

## Current Output

Shows steps from original instantiation only.

## New Output

Also show bonded children:

  Bonded Children (3):
    ✓ arm-toast (closed)
    ◐ arm-nux (open)
    ○ arm-furiosa (open)

## Implementation

1. Query for children with bonded_to: {parent-id} in description
2. For each bonded child, show status (open/closed)
3. Optionally show progress through child's steps
Needs: gt-59zd.5


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 5: Quiet, all healthy


Deacon: Hierarchical health-check orchestrator

Replace daemon heartbeats with Deacon - an AI agent that keeps Gas Town running.

## Core Concept

The Deacon is a **Claude agent** (not just a Go process) that:
- Lives at town root in gt-deacon session
- Has its own mailbox (deacon/ identity in town beads)
- Is poked by a minimal Go daemon every ~60s (if idle)
- Monitors Mayor and Witnesses proactively
- Handles lifecycle requests (restart/cycle) from Mayor, Witnesses, AND Crew

## Architecture

```
Minimal Go Daemon (just watches Deacon)
         |
         v
     Deacon (Claude agent)
         |
    +----+----+
    v         v
  Mayor    Witnesses --> Polecats (Witness-managed)
    |         |
    +----+----+
         |
      Crew (lifecycle only, not monitored)
```

## Deacon Responsibilities

**Proactive monitoring:**
- Mayor health (tmux session, keepalive freshness)
- Witness health (tmux sessions, keepalive freshness)

**Reactive lifecycle:**
- Process restart/cycle requests from Mayor, Witnesses, Crew
- Kill session, create new, prime, verify startup

**Escalation:**
- Mail human (configurable) if issues can't be resolved

## Key Files

- ~/gt/DEACON.md - Role context
- ~/gt/deacon/ - State directory
  - heartbeat.json - Written each wake cycle (daemon checks this)
  - state.json - Health tracking, last scan results
- ~/gt/.beads/ - Town beads with deacon/ mail identity

## Wake Cycle

1. Write heartbeat (prevents daemon from poking)
2. Check mail (lifecycle requests)
3. Quick health scan (Mayor, Witnesses)
4. Process lifecycle requests
5. Remediate unhealthy agents
6. Update state

## Session Patterns

- Deacon: gt-deacon
- Mayor: gt-mayor
- Witness: gt-<rig>-witness
- Crew: gt-<rig>-<name> (e.g., gt-gastown-max)

## Relation to Policy Beads

Future: Deacon behavior configurable via policy beads (gt-3zw).
Initial implementation uses sensible defaults.


Create DEACON.md role context

Create ~/gt/DEACON.md with the Deacon's role context, wake cycle instructions, and command reference. Model after existing CLAUDE.md for Mayor.


Add gt deacon start/stop/status commands

Add CLI commands: gt deacon start (spawn gt-deacon session), gt deacon stop (kill session), gt deacon status (show health state). Similar to gt mayor commands.


Add deacon/ mail identity support

Ensure deacon/ works as a mail identity in town-level beads. Test with bd mail send deacon/ and bd mail inbox --identity deacon/.


Simplify Go daemon to Deacon-watcher

Refactor internal/daemon to only: (1) check deacon/heartbeat.json every 60s, (2) poke gt-deacon if stale, (3) restart Deacon and mail for help if very stale. Remove all lifecycle processing and agent poking.


Update lifecycle mail targets to deacon/

Update Mayor, Witness, and Crew handoff code to send lifecycle requests to deacon/ instead of daemon/. Update internal/cmd/handoff.go and related code.


Add Deacon heartbeat mechanism

Deacon writes deacon/heartbeat.json on each wake. Go daemon reads it to decide whether to poke. Add heartbeat read/write helpers.


Add crew session pattern to lifecycle handling

Update identityToSession and restartSession to handle crew patterns: gastown/max -> gt-gastown-max. Crew workers can request lifecycle but are not proactively monitored.


Add human escalation configuration

Add overseer contact config to mayor/town.json. Deacon uses this for escalation when it cannot resolve issues. Support email and/or other notification methods.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 1: inbox empty, Mayor OK, 2 witnesses, 2 refineries healthy, no orphans


Merge: gt-99a

branch: polecat/Slit
target: main
source_issue: gt-99a
rig: gastown


Refinery Engineer: Role prompting and CLAUDE.md

Create refinery/CLAUDE.md with Chief Merge Engineer role context. Include:
- Role identity and responsibilities
- Decision authority (merge order, test frequency, binary rebuilds)
- Communication patterns (Witness, Deacon)
- Session lifecycle (handoff bead protocol)
- Key commands reference


Test Patrol for Bonding

Parent issue for mol bond CLI test


Polecat Arm (arm-toast)

Single polecat inspection and action cycle.

This molecule is bonded dynamically by mol-witness-patrol's survey-workers step.
Each polecat being monitored gets one arm that runs in parallel with other arms.

## Variables

| Variable | Required | Description |
|----------|----------|-------------|
| polecat_name | Yes | Name of the polecat to inspect |
| rig | Yes | Rig containing the polecat |

## Step: capture
Capture recent tmux output for toast.

```bash
tmux capture-pane -t gt-gastown-toast -p | tail -50
```

Record:
- Last activity timestamp (when was last tool call?)
- Visible errors or stack traces
- Completion indicators ("Done", "Finished", etc.)

## Step: assess
Categorize polecat state based on captured output.

States:
- **working**: Recent tool calls, active processing
- **idle**: At prompt, no recent activity
- **error**: Showing errors or stack traces
- **requesting_shutdown**: Sent LIFECYCLE/Shutdown mail
- **done**: Showing completion indicators

Calculate: minutes since last activity.
Needs: capture

## Step: load-history
Read nudge history for toast from patrol state.

```
nudge_count = state.nudges[toast].count
last_nudge_time = state.nudges[toast].timestamp
```

This data was loaded by the parent patrol's load-state step and passed
to the arm via the bonding context.
Needs: assess

## Step: decide
Apply the nudge matrix to determine action for toast.

| State | Idle Time | Nudge Count | Action |
|-------|-----------|-------------|--------|
| working | any | any | none |
| idle | <10min | any | none |
| idle | 10-15min | 0 | nudge-1 (gentle) |
| idle | 15-20min | 1 | nudge-2 (direct) |
| idle | 20+min | 2 | nudge-3 (final) |
| idle | any | 3 | escalate |
| error | any | any | assess-severity |
| requesting_shutdown | any | any | pre-kill-verify |
| done | any | any | pre-kill-verify |

Nudge text:
1. "How's progress? Need any help?"
2. "Please wrap up soon. What's blocking you?"
3. "Final check. Will escalate in 5 min if no response."

Record decision and rationale.
Needs: load-history

## Step: execute
Take the decided action for toast.

**nudge-N**:
```bash
tmux send-keys -t gt-gastown-toast "{{nudge_text}}" Enter
```

**pre-kill-verify**:
```bash
cd polecats/toast
git status                    # Must be clean
git log origin/main..HEAD     # Check for unpushed
bd show <assigned-issue>      # Verify closed/deferred
```
If clean: kill session, remove worktree, delete branch
If dirty: record failure, retry next cycle

**escalate**:
```bash
gt mail send mayor/ -s "Escalation: toast stuck" -m "..."
```

**none**: No action needed.

Record: action taken, result, updated nudge count.
Needs: decide

## Output

The arm completes with:
- action_taken: none | nudge-1 | nudge-2 | nudge-3 | killed | escalated
- result: success | failed | pending
- updated_state: New nudge count and timestamp for toast

This data feeds back to the parent patrol's aggregate step.
---
bonded_from: mol-polecat-arm
bonded_to: gt-5glf
bonded_ref: arm-toast
bonded_at: 2025-12-23T10:00:00Z


Merge: gt-3x0z.3

branch: polecat/slit
target: main
source_issue: gt-3x0z.3
rig: gastown

Source branch lost, work needs to be redone


Witness role describes incorrect commands

prompts/roles/witness.md line 44 shows:
  gt polecat list {{ rig }}

But polecats are worktrees managed by Refinery/Mayor's clone,
not a separate polecat manager. The witness shouldn't manage
polecats directly.

Review and update witness role to match actual architecture.

Invalid: gt polecat list and gt polecat remove commands exist and work correctly. Issue based on outdated code.


Polecat Arm (arm-toast)

Single polecat inspection and action cycle.

This molecule is bonded dynamically by mol-witness-patrol's survey-workers step.
Each polecat being monitored gets one arm that runs in parallel with other arms.

## Variables

| Variable | Required | Description |
|----------|----------|-------------|
| polecat_name | Yes | Name of the polecat to inspect |
| rig | Yes | Rig containing the polecat |

## Step: capture
Capture recent tmux output for toast.

```bash
tmux capture-pane -t gt-gastown-toast -p | tail -50
```

Record:
- Last activity timestamp (when was last tool call?)
- Visible errors or stack traces
- Completion indicators ("Done", "Finished", etc.)

## Step: assess
Categorize polecat state based on captured output.

States:
- **working**: Recent tool calls, active processing
- **idle**: At prompt, no recent activity
- **error**: Showing errors or stack traces
- **requesting_shutdown**: Sent LIFECYCLE/Shutdown mail
- **done**: Showing completion indicators

Calculate: minutes since last activity.
Needs: capture

## Step: load-history
Read nudge history for toast from patrol state.

```
nudge_count = state.nudges[toast].count
last_nudge_time = state.nudges[toast].timestamp
```

This data was loaded by the parent patrol's load-state step and passed
to the arm via the bonding context.
Needs: assess

## Step: decide
Apply the nudge matrix to determine action for toast.

| State | Idle Time | Nudge Count | Action |
|-------|-----------|-------------|--------|
| working | any | any | none |
| idle | <10min | any | none |
| idle | 10-15min | 0 | nudge-1 (gentle) |
| idle | 15-20min | 1 | nudge-2 (direct) |
| idle | 20+min | 2 | nudge-3 (final) |
| idle | any | 3 | escalate |
| error | any | any | assess-severity |
| requesting_shutdown | any | any | pre-kill-verify |
| done | any | any | pre-kill-verify |

Nudge text:
1. "How's progress? Need any help?"
2. "Please wrap up soon. What's blocking you?"
3. "Final check. Will escalate in 5 min if no response."

Record decision and rationale.
Needs: load-history

## Step: execute
Take the decided action for toast.

**nudge-N**:
```bash
tmux send-keys -t gt-gastown-toast "{{nudge_text}}" Enter
```

**pre-kill-verify**:
```bash
cd polecats/toast
git status                    # Must be clean
git log origin/main..HEAD     # Check for unpushed
bd show <assigned-issue>      # Verify closed/deferred
```
If clean: kill session, remove worktree, delete branch
If dirty: record failure, retry next cycle

**escalate**:
```bash
gt mail send mayor/ -s "Escalation: toast stuck" -m "..."
```

**none**: No action needed.

Record: action taken, result, updated nudge count.
Needs: decide

## Output

The arm completes with:
- action_taken: none | nudge-1 | nudge-2 | nudge-3 | killed | escalated
- result: success | failed | pending
- updated_state: New nudge count and timestamp for toast

This data feeds back to the parent patrol's aggregate step.
---
bonded_from: mol-polecat-arm
bonded_to: gt-5j2x
bonded_ref: arm-toast
bonded_at: 2025-12-23T10:00:00Z


Remove legacy .beads-wisp/ infrastructure

The wisp simplification (gt-fgms + bd-bkul) changed wisps to be just a flag on issues in the main .beads/ database. JSONL export filters Wisp=true issues. No separate directory needed.

But legacy .beads-wisp/ infrastructure still exists and should be removed:

## Gas Town (gt) cleanup:
- `internal/rig/manager.go`: Remove `initWispBeads()` call from `AddRig()`
- `internal/wisp/io.go`: Delete entire file (old abstraction layer)
- `internal/cmd/install.go`: Remove any .beads-wisp setup
- `docs/wisp-architecture.md`: Update to reflect 'just a flag' model

## Beads (bd) cleanup:
- `cmd/bd/doctor/wisp_check.go`: Remove WispExistsCheck, WispGitCheck, WispSizeCheck (check .beads-wisp dirs)
- Keep WispOrphansCheck and WispStaleCheck but rewrite to query main DB for Wisp=true issues

## Filesystem cleanup:
- Delete ~/gt/.beads-wisp/
- Delete ~/gt/gastown/.beads-wisp/
- Delete all per-rig .beads-wisp/ directories
- Remove .beads-wisp from .gitignore entries

## Verify:
- `gt mail send --wisp` still works (creates issue with Wisp=true in main DB)
- `bd sync` still filters wisps from JSONL
- `bd mol squash/burn` still work on Wisp=true issues

Removed legacy .beads-wisp infrastructure. Hooks now stored in .beads/, wisps are just Wisp=true flag on issues.

Additional finding: wisps ARE leaking into town-level JSONL (~/gt/.beads/issues.jsonl). Saw hq-3g9e and hq-94i with wisp:true in the file. The filtering works for rig-level beads but apparently not town-level. Need to investigate why town beads uses different export path.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 9: All agents healthy


Tech Debt: Code Review December 2024

Tech debt identified during code review on 2024-12-21. Contains 11 issues ranging from P2-P4 covering:

- Code duplication (manager creation boilerplate)
- Test coverage gaps (cmd 6.8%, mail 3.6%)
- Magic strings needing constants
- Error handling inconsistencies
- Large files needing splitting
- Unused code removal

Work through these incrementally to improve codebase maintainability.

Tech debt review complete for launch. Completed:
- gt-ai1z: Cycle detection in molecule deps
- gt-7sqi: Manager boilerplate refactoring
- gt-zhm5: Epic child filtering in Witness
- gt-xnql: Constants for magic strings
- gt-cvfg: io.Writer for refinery output
- gt-nz6t: Removed unused style helpers

Audited and closed:
- gt-2xsh: Silent error handling (patterns are intentional)
- gt-2n6z: Error wrapping (deferred to v0.2)

Deferred to post-launch:
- gt-480b: Test coverage (ongoing)
- gt-92of: Large file splitting (refactoring)
- gt-pbr3: Godoc comments (documentation)

Codebase is launch-ready.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol #15: Stable


Document how to configure a Gas Town Harness

Create docs explaining what a harness is (private repo containing GT installation with rigs gitignored), why you'd want one, and how to set it up with beads redirects


gt mail send: add stdin and file input support for complex messages

Current -m flag is fragile with multi-line messages containing backticks, quotes, or shell special chars. Add: 1) --stdin flag to read message body from stdin (heredoc-friendly), 2) -f/--file flag to read from file. This sidesteps shell quoting nightmares for handoff messages with code samples.


Test message

Testing GGT mail via beads


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 10: All healthy


Patrol step: check parked molecules for unblock

Add patrol step to Deacon for checking parked molecules:

```yaml
- step: check-parked-molecules
  action: |
    For each molecule with:
      - status: in_progress
      - assignee: null
      - has step with external: blocked_by
    Check if external deps are now satisfied.
    If yes: spawn polecat to resume the molecule.
```

This automates the resume process - no manual intervention needed when
upstream dependencies ship.

Part of cross-project dependency system.
See: docs/cross-project-deps.md

Depends on: gt-in3x (spawn --continue)
Priority: P3 (future automation, not required for launch)


Add 'wit' alias for witness command

ref works as alias for refinery, but wit doesn't work for witness. Add Aliases: []string{"wit"} to witnessCmd.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 12: All agents healthy


Update vision.md with proto/mol/wisp terminology

Update the Steam Engine Metaphor section to use consistent phase terminology:

Current (vision.md):
- Proto molecules = fuel (templates)
- Wisps = steam (transient execution traces)
- Digests = distillate (permanent records)

New terminology:
- **Proto** = crystal/solid - frozen template
- **Mol** = liquid - reified durable instance (tracked in git)
- **Wisp** = gas - ephemeral instance (evaporates after squash)
- **Digest** = distillate - compressed summary after squash

Key clarification needed:
- Proto → bond → creates either Mol (durable) or Wisp (ephemeral)
- The choice of Mol vs Wisp depends on --wisp flag
- Default is Mol (durable, recorded in main beads)
- Wisp lives in .beads-ephemeral/, squashes away

Already documented in vision.md and architecture.md


Shutdown request handler

Handle polecat shutdown requests:

When polecat runs 'gt handoff --shutdown':
1. Polecat sends mail to <rig>/witness requesting shutdown
2. Witness receives mail
3. Witness verifies:
   - Git working tree is clean
   - Work is submitted (MR exists or in queue)
   - No uncommitted beads changes
4. If clean:
   - gt session stop <rig>/<polecat>
   - git worktree remove polecats/<name>
   - git branch -d polecat/<name>
5. If not clean:
   - Send nudge back to polecat
   - Track retry count

Depends on fixing gt-dsfi (handoff deadlock).


Document session cycling protocol in all templates

Add explicit lifecycle request protocol to all agent templates.

## Problem
Templates mention 'request session refresh' but don't show HOW.
Agents don't know the protocol for requesting a cycle.

## Protocol to document
1. Write handoff mail to self (for continuity)
2. Set requesting_cycle=true in state.json
3. Send LIFECYCLE mail to deacon/:
   Subject: 'LIFECYCLE: <role> requesting cycle'
   Body: Reason for cycle request

## Templates to update
- prompts/roles/polecat.md
- prompts/roles/crew.md
- prompts/roles/witness.md
- prompts/roles/refinery.md

## Also add
- Example state.json location for each role
- When to request cycle (context full, work complete, etc.)
- What happens after (daemon kills, respawns, new session primes)

Updated crew and polecat templates with session cycling protocol. Patrol workers already had heuristics documented.


Preflight molecule: verify baseline health before work

Before assigning work, verify baseline (main branch) is healthy.

**From VC**: Self-healing state machine (HEALTHY → SELF_HEALING → ESCALATED). ~200 lines.

**Gas Town implementation**: Preflight molecule or refinery feature:
```yaml
preflight:
  gates: [test, lint, build]
  on_failure: create-fix-issue
```

Run at session start. If baseline broken, file a P0 fix issue and work on that first.

**Value**: Self-healing baseline. Agents don't start from broken state.

**VC lesson**: Prevents cascading failures. Agent shouldn't start work on broken code.


Review and audit all GGT beads

Thorough review of all filed beads in gastown GGT repo. Check for: consistency, completeness, correct dependencies, accurate descriptions, proper prioritization. Ensure beads are self-contained and dont rely on external docs.


Molecule Phase Terminology Documentation

Document the three-phase molecule lifecycle with consistent terminology:

## The Phases (States of Matter)

| Phase | State | Nature |
|-------|-------|--------|
| **Proto** | Solid/Crystal | Frozen template, static definition in catalog |
| **Mol** | Liquid | Reified instance, malleable, tracked in git (durable) |
| **Wisp** | Gas | Evaporates after squash, ephemeral orchestration |

## Documentation Gaps Identified

### High Priority
1. Update vision.md Steam Engine metaphor to use proto/mol/wisp terminology
2. Add lifecycle diagram: Proto → bond → Mol or Wisp → squash → Digest
3. Document Go types for phases (ProtoMolecule, etc.)
4. Document .beads-ephemeral/ structure and purpose

### Medium Priority
5. Update CLAUDE.md files (polecat, witness, refinery) with molecule workflow
6. Document bd mol bond/squash/burn CLI API with examples
7. Add polecat guide: Executing molecules and generating summaries

### Low Priority
8. Add terminology glossary to architecture.md
9. Create troubleshooting playbook for stuck molecules
10. Add reference diagrams for state transitions

## Current State
- architecture.md has good molecule basics but uses inconsistent terminology
- vision.md has Steam Engine metaphor (proto=fuel, wisp=steam, digest=distillate)
- molecules.md has detailed reference but needs phase clarity
- builtin_molecules.go has 8 molecules but no phase documentation in code

All children closed - documentation complete


Merge: gt-lnji

branch: polecat/nux
target: main
source_issue: gt-lnji
rig: gastown


Swarm: report generation

Generate markdown reports for completed swarms.

## Command
```
gt swarm report <swarm-id> [--save <file>]
```

## Report Content

### Header
- Swarm ID and title
- Created/completed timestamps
- Duration
- Rig name

### Task Summary
| Task | Assignee | Status | Duration |
|------|----------|--------|----------|
| gt-xxx | Toast | merged | 15m |
| gt-yyy | Nux | merged | 22m |

### Worker Contributions
- Commits per worker
- Issues closed per worker
- Lines changed (optional)

### Timeline
- Chronological events from events.jsonl
- Key milestones (started, first merge, landing)

### Issues Encountered
- Conflicts resolved
- Failed tasks (if any)
- Escalations

## Implementation
```go
func GenerateReport(swarmID string) (*SwarmReport, error)
func (r *SwarmReport) ToMarkdown() string
```

## Storage
- Save to <rig>/.gastown/swarms/<id>/report.md
- Or user-specified path with --save

## PGT Reference
gastown-py/src/gastown/swarm/manager.py generate_report()

## Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Markdown report generated
- [ ] Includes all sections above
- [ ] Auto-saved to swarm directory
- [ ] --save allows custom path


Test MR

test


Deacon primes pending workers instead of spawn nudge

## Problem

When gt spawn starts a polecat, it tries to send a nudge message immediately:
1. Starts tmux session with Claude Code
2. Waits 3 seconds (hardcoded)
3. Sends nudge via NudgeSession

But Claude Code takes 10-20+ seconds to be ready. The message arrives before
the prompt is ready, so it appears as part of the prompt string instead of
being executed.

## Solution

Move priming responsibility to the Deacon patrol cycle:

1. gt spawn: Mark polecat as pending_prime=true in state, return immediately
2. Deacon patrol: New step prime-pending-workers that:
   - Scans all rigs for workers with pending_prime=true
   - Uses WaitForClaudeReady() to poll for "> " prompt (already exists in tmux.go)
   - Once ready, sends gt prime + assignment nudge
   - Clears pending_prime flag

## Implementation

### spawn.go changes
- Remove the 3-second sleep (line 368)
- Remove the NudgeSession call (lines 375-383)
- Instead: Update polecat state with pending_prime=true

### Polecat state addition
status: assigned, pending_prime: true, issue: gt-xxx

### Deacon patrol addition
Add step between inbox-check and plugin-run:
prime-pending-workers: Check all rigs for workers marked pending_prime.
For each pending worker: WaitForClaudeReady(60s), then gt prime + nudge

### Benefits
- No race condition - we poll until actually ready
- Deacon already does health checks - priming is natural fit
- Works for polecats, witnesses, refineries, crew (unified approach)
- Timeout handling built in

## Depends on
- Existing WaitForClaudeReady() in tmux.go (lines 384-403)

Implemented: spawn no longer nudges, deacon patrol has trigger-pending-spawns step


Test Patrol Parent

Test parent for Christmas Ornament pattern


Test Polecat Arm

Test child for bonding pattern


Hook system for event extensibility

GGT needs hook system for extensibility like PGT.

## Event Types
```go
type Event string
const (
    EventPreSessionStart  Event = "pre-session-start"
    EventPostSessionStart Event = "post-session-start"
    EventPreShutdown      Event = "pre-shutdown"
    EventPostShutdown     Event = "post-shutdown"
    EventOnPaneOutput     Event = "on-pane-output"
    EventSessionIdle      Event = "session-idle"
    EventMailReceived     Event = "mail-received"
    EventWorkAssigned     Event = "work-assigned"
)
```

## Hook Configuration
File: .claude/hooks.json or .gastown/hooks.json
```json
{
  "hooks": {
    "pre-shutdown": [
      {"type": "command", "cmd": "./scripts/pre-shutdown.sh"}
    ],
    "on-pane-output": [
      {"type": "command", "cmd": "./scripts/activity-monitor.sh"}
    ]
  }
}
```

## Hook Types
1. **Command**: Execute external script
2. **Built-in**: Internal Go functions (pre-shutdown checks)

## Hook Interface
```go
type HookRunner struct {
    config *HookConfig
}

type HookResult struct {
    Success bool
    Message string
    Block   bool  // For pre-* hooks: should operation be blocked?
}

func (r *HookRunner) Fire(event Event, ctx *HookContext) []HookResult
```

## CLI Commands
```
gt hooks list [<event>]    # List registered hooks
gt hooks fire <event>      # Manually fire for testing
gt hooks test [--all]      # Validate hook config
```

## Integration Points
- internal/session/manager.go: Fire pre/post session hooks
- internal/mail/router.go: Fire mail-received hook

## New Package
internal/hooks/
├── types.go    # Event, HookConfig, HookResult
├── runner.go   # HookRunner, Fire()
└── builtin.go  # Built-in hooks (pre-shutdown checks)

## PGT Reference
gastown-py/src/gastown/hooks/

## Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Hook config loading from JSON
- [ ] Command hooks execute subprocess
- [ ] Pre-shutdown hook integration with session stop
- [ ] CLI for listing and testing hooks


Test Patrol Parent


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 2: Quiet cycle, all agents healthy


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol #4: Stable


gt rig shutdown: Gracefully stop all rig agents

Add 'gt rig shutdown <rig>' command to gracefully stop all agents in a rig.

Should:
- Stop all polecat sessions
- Stop refinery
- Stop witness
- Optionally wait for graceful shutdown with timeout


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 6: routine


Interrupt vs Queue mail semantics

Add priority/delivery semantics to mail messages.

## Semantics

| Type | Delivery | Use Case |
|------|----------|----------|
| Interrupt | tmux send-keys | Lifecycle, URGENT, stuck detection |
| Queue | Create message only | Normal mail, status, heartbeat |

## Implementation

- `bd mail send --interrupt` uses tmux send-keys notification
- Default is queue (agent checks with `gt mail check`)
- Urgent flag on messages for interrupt delivery

## Agent Side

- `gt mail check --quiet` - non-blocking check for queued mail
- `gt mail wait` - block until mail arrives (for idle agents)
- Heartbeats become queued, agent checks at natural breakpoints


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 14: All clear


Work on ga-rd4: Add gt polecat status command. Show detai...

Work on ga-rd4: Add gt polecat status command. Show detailed polecat status including current issue, session state, last activity time. When done, submit MR (not PR) to integration branch for Refinery.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 1: All healthy, no messages


bd create --dedup: semantic deduplication before issue creation

Before creating issue, check for semantic duplicates using AI similarity.

**From VC**: internal/deduplication/ - AI-powered batch comparison. ~300 lines.
VC had issue pollution problem: 438 issues with ~350+ spam because no early dedup.

**Gas Town implementation**: CLI flag on bd create:
```bash
bd create --dedup --title="Fix auth bug" --description="..."
```

Checks recent issues (7-day window) with AI similarity. If confidence >0.85, warns or blocks.

**Value**: Prevents pollution from parallel workers discovering same issues.

**VC lesson**: 115 issues filed in single day (Nov 2) because supervisor over-discovered without dedup. Rate limiting + dedup are essential.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 3: All healthy


Competing molecule instantiation mechanisms need resolution

Documentation describes 4 different molecule instantiation methods:
1. bd mol bond (beads-based, in molecules.md)
2. gt sling (proposed in sling-design.md)
3. gt swarm (implemented in code)
4. gt molecule instantiate (in architecture.md)

Role prompts use different methods:
- Deacon: bd mol spawn
- Refinery: gt mol bond
- Polecat: bd mol current

Need to:
1. Decide canonical mechanism
2. Update all role prompts to use it
3. Remove/deprecate alternatives
4. Update architecture docs

Superseded by gt-mbyy: comprehensive CLI API audit that covers molecule mechanisms plus full command structure review


mol-polecat-work

Full polecat lifecycle from assignment to decommission.

This proto enables nondeterministic idempotence for polecat work.
A polecat that crashes after any step can restart, read its molecule state,
and continue from the last completed step. No work is lost.

Variables:
- gt-u2vg - The source issue ID being worked on


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 17: routine


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 14: Nominal


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 13: Nominal


Daemon should auto-start as part of town bootstrap

The Go daemon should be started automatically when the town boots up (mol-gastown-boot). Currently it requires manual 'gt daemon start'.

The daemon is critical infrastructure - it monitors the Deacon and nudges it when naked. Without it, the Deacon patrol loop doesn't run.


gt swarm: Not discovering tasks from epic dependents

gt swarm create/start shows '0 tasks loaded' even when epic has dependents.

Repro:
1. Create epic gt-hw6
2. Create tasks and add deps: bd dep add gt-xxx gt-hw6
3. gt swarm create gastown --epic gt-hw6 --worker Toast
4. Swarm shows 'Tasks: 0'

Expected: Swarm should discover tasks that depend on the epic.
Actual: Shows '(no tasks loaded)'


Implement gt harness create command

Add scaffolding command to create a new harness:
- gt harness create [path]
- Creates config/, mayor/, .beads/redirect (optional)
- Optionally initializes git
- Generates CLAUDE.md with Mayor role
- Could also offer a template repo alternative


Bug: LIFECYCLE messages use literal <rig> placeholder

Found stale LIFECYCLE messages addressed to @<rig>/witness instead of actual rig names like @gastown/witness. Template substitution not happening.

Examples found:
- gm-bay: LIFECYCLE: polecat requesting shutdown (to @<rig>/witness)
- gm-7du, gm-94e, gm-u5x, gm-89b: same issue

Fix: Ensure rig name is substituted in lifecycle mail templates.


Polecat mood command and status line display

CLI and status line support for polecat mood.

## CLI Command
```
gt polecat mood <name> <emoji>   # Set mood
gt polecat mood <name>           # Get mood
```

Sets GT_MOOD environment variable in the polecat's tmux session.

## Status Line Integration
Update runWorkerStatusLine() to read mood:
```go
mood, _ := t.GetEnvironment(session, "GT_MOOD")
if mood != "" {
    icon = mood  // Use mood emoji instead of default
} else {
    icon = AgentTypeIcons[AgentPolecat]  // Fallback to 😺
}
```

## Storage
Mood stored in tmux session environment (ephemeral, per-session).
No persistence needed - mood is reassessed each patrol cycle.

Depends on: gt-u818 (plugin system)


Deacon patrol: Janitorial cleanup patterns

Patterns discovered during town cleanup that could be automated in Deacon's patrol step:

## Stale Issue Detection

1. **Stale in_progress issues** - Issues marked in_progress for >N days without activity
   - Example: 9 issues in_progress, some likely complete
   - Action: Report list, optionally nudge assignee

2. **Duplicate issues** - Same title with different IDs
   - Example: gt-87jz and gt-qp2w both 'mol-witness-patrol'
   - Action: Flag for human review

3. **Orphaned issues** - Referenced in commits but still open
   - bd doctor already detects: 'hq-65jk (commit f9e9034d)'
   - Action: Report, suggest closing

4. **Stale test messages** - Messages with 'test' in title older than N days
   - Example: gt-54kn, gt-1ero, gt-nriy, gt-wrw2, gt-pnu4, gt-g1ud, gt-b5sh
   - Action: Auto-close or flag

## File System Cleanup

5. **Log file accumulation** - daemon.log and rotated .log.gz files
   - Found 8+ log files across rigs
   - Action: Rotate, compress, delete old (>7 days)

6. **Beads directory size** - Town .beads/ is 65MB
   - Action: Monitor growth, alert on threshold

## Database Health

7. **Legacy database fingerprints** - Older DBs without fingerprint
   - bd doctor warns about this
   - Action: Report, suggest migration

## Cross-Reference Integrity

8. **Gastown↔Beads issue sync** - Issues filed in wrong project
   - Example: gt-8tmz.* describes Beads work but no bd-* issues
   - Action: Detect cross-references, verify both sides exist

## Implementation Notes

These could be added to mol-deacon-patrol.formula.yaml as cleanup substeps:
- Daily: Log rotation, stale issue report
- Weekly: Duplicate detection, orphan check
- Monthly: Size monitoring, archive old closed issues


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol @ 2025-12-24 19:24

Patrol 8: quiet, 8 sessions healthy


Test Epic: GGT MVP Validation


Test Task 1: Add comment to gt.go


Test Task 2: Add comment to version.go


Test7

Test with fixed workdir


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol #13


detectSender() doesn't recognize crew workers

## Problem

`detectSender()` in mail.go only detects polecats, not crew workers.

## Current Code (line 445)

```go
// If in a rig's polecats directory, extract address
if strings.Contains(cwd, "/polecats/") {
    // extract rig/polecat
}

// Default to mayor
return "mayor/"
```

## Symptom

Emma (crew worker at `/Users/stevey/gt/beads/crew/emma`) runs:
- `gt mail inbox` → checks `mayor/` inbox (wrong!)
- Should check `beads/emma` or `beads/crew/emma`

## Fix

Add crew detection:
```go
// If in a rig's crew directory, extract address
if strings.Contains(cwd, "/crew/") {
    parts := strings.Split(cwd, "/crew/")
    if len(parts) >= 2 {
        rigPath := parts[0]
        crewName := strings.Split(parts[1], "/")[0]
        rigName := filepath.Base(rigPath)
        return fmt.Sprintf("%s/%s", rigName, crewName)
    }
}
```

## Also Check

- `gt prime` correctly detects role, so there may be another detection function that works
- Should unify detection logic


Update architecture.md: Engineer role and Beads merge queue

Update docs/architecture.md with recent design decisions:

1. Agent table: Change "Refinery" role to "Engineer"
   - Refinery = place/module/directory
   - Engineer = role (agent that works in the Refinery)

2. Merge Queue section: Document Beads-native model
   - MRs are beads issues with --type=merge-request
   - gt mq commands (submit, list, next, process, reorder)
   - Ordering via depends-on links

3. CLI section: Add gt mq commands

4. Key Design Decisions: Add decisions for:
   - #15: Merge Queue in Beads
   - #16: Engineer role (distinct from Refinery place)
   - #17: Session restart protocol for Engineer


gt mq list: doesn't show submitted MRs

After submitting MRs with gt mq submit, gt mq list gastown shows empty queue.

## Reproduction
1. gt mq submit --issue gt-h5n.5 --branch polecat/Scabrous
2. gt mq list gastown → (empty)
3. bd list --type=merge-request → shows the MR

## Expected
gt mq list should show submitted MRs

## MR example
gt-ts4u has rig: gastown in description, type=merge-request, status=open


Wire GT_ACCOUNT env var into spawn/attach

When spawning Claude Code (gt spawn, gt crew attach), check GT_ACCOUNT env var. If set, look up account in config and set CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR accordingly.

Implemented GT_ACCOUNT env var support with priority resolution


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 12: Routine


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 15: All healthy


implement

Implement the solution for gt-1wmw. Follow codebase conventions.
File discovered work as new issues with bd create.

Make regular commits with clear messages.
Keep changes focused on the assigned issue.

Depends: load-context


Patrols: Cyclic molecules for autonomous maintenance

## Vision

Patrols are **cyclic molecules** - workflow loops that give Gas Town its autonomous nervous system. While regular molecules are DAGs that terminate, patrols loop forever, performing maintenance tasks at varying cadences.

This is the "steam engine" of Gas Town: converting episodic Claude sessions into continuous autonomous operation.

## Core Concepts

### 1. Cyclic Molecules

Regular molecule:     A -> B -> C -> done
Patrol molecule:      A -> B -> C --+
                      ^             |
                      +-------------+

Patrols have a loop_to field specifying where to restart.

### 2. Cooldown-Aware Steps (Atoms)

Steps encode their own cadence. When patrol reaches a step:
1. Check: now - last_run > cooldown?
2. If yes: execute, update last_run
3. If no: skip (immediately close)

The patrol runner is simple - steps self-skip. Complexity distributed into atoms.

### 3. The Beacon

The heartbeat that fires patrol triggers:
- Internal ticker in Deacon (goroutine)
- Or external cron firing gt deacon tick
- Or mail-based triggers

Without beacon, nothing proactive happens.

### 4. Session Reset as Patrol Step

Connects to auto-handoff (gt-bcwn). Session reset is a patrol step, not a separate mechanism.

### 5. Multi-Role Patrols

Each supervisor has its own patrol:

**Deacon patrol:** health-check (30s), session-gc (5m), beacon-tick (10s)
**Witness patrol:** orphan-scan (10m), stuck-check (2m), molecule-progress (1m)
**Refinery patrol:** queue-check (30s), pr-status (1m), merge-ready (30s)

### 6. Cadence Tiers

- Critical (10-30s): Health checks
- Active (1-5m): Progress, nudges
- Maintenance (10-30m): Orphans, GC
- Periodic (1h+): Reports

### 7. Best-Effort Scheduling

Not real-time - more like cron. No hard deadlines. Catch-up, dont pile-up.
Priority preemption (mail interrupts patrol). Graceful degradation under load.

## Open Questions

1. State persistence: Beads (self-describing) or file (faster)?
2. Interruption: How does urgent mail preempt patrol?
3. Error recovery: Backoff? Escalate? Circuit breaker?
4. Coordination: Can patrols send mail to trigger other patrols?

## Related

- gt-bcwn: Auto-handoff (session reset is a patrol step)
- Molecule system (patrols extend molecules with loops)
- Deacon lifecycle management

## Metaphor

Claude was fire. Claude Code was steam. Gas Town is the steam engine. Beads is the train tracks.

The steam engine converts episodic combustion into continuous rotary motion.
Gas Town converts episodic Claude sessions into continuous autonomous work.

Design doc superseded by gt-rana (Patrol System implementation).


Fix failing beads tests: TestIntegration and TestPolecatWorkMolecule

Fixed test expectations for molecule counts and step names


Create mol-refinery-patrol with test failure gates

## Problem

The Refinery role lacks:
1. A formal patrol molecule (Deacon has mol-deacon-patrol)
2. Engineer identity/philosophy guidance
3. Structural enforcement of failure handling (not just documentation)

When tests fail during merge processing, the current guidance doesn't prevent 'disavowal' - noting a problem exists and proceeding without tracking it.

## The Structural Solution

Create `mol-refinery-patrol` with **verification gates** that make disavowal structurally impossible:

```markdown
## Molecule: mol-refinery-patrol

## Step: inbox-check
Check mail for MR submissions, escalations, messages.
Process any urgent items first.

## Step: queue-scan
Fetch remote, identify polecat branches waiting.
If queue empty, skip to context-check.
Track branch list for this cycle.
Needs: inbox-check

## Step: process-branch
Pick next branch. Rebase on current main.
If rebase conflicts: notify polecat, skip to next branch.
Needs: queue-scan

## Step: run-tests
Run go test ./...
Track results (pass/fail count).
Needs: process-branch

## Step: handle-failures
**GATE**: If tests passed, this step auto-completes.
If tests failed:
- Diagnose: branch regression or pre-existing?
- Branch regression → abort, notify polecat
- Pre-existing → EITHER fix OR \`bd create --type=bug\`
**VERIFY**: Fix committed OR bead filed before proceeding.
Needs: run-tests

## Step: merge-push
Merge to main (ff-only preferred).
Push immediately.
Delete polecat branch.
Needs: handle-failures

## Step: loop-check
More branches? Return to process-branch.
Otherwise continue to summary.
Needs: merge-push

## Step: generate-summary
Summarize cycle: branches processed, tests results, issues filed.
Needs: loop-check

## Step: context-check
Check context usage.
If high: write handoff, prepare for burn/respawn.
Needs: generate-summary

## Step: burn-or-loop
If context LOW and queue non-empty: loop (return to queue-scan)
If context HIGH or queue empty: burn and exit
Needs: context-check
```

## Implementation Tasks

### 1. Add RefineryPatrolMolecule() to builtin_molecules.go
- Copy pattern from DeaconPatrolMolecule
- Include all steps with proper `Needs:` dependencies
- Emphasize handle-failures gate in description

### 2. Update Refinery CLAUDE.md
Add sections:
- **The Engineer Mindset** (identity/philosophy)
- **The Scotty Test** (Would Scotty walk past this?)
- **Patrol Molecule** reference (mol-refinery-patrol)
- **Test Failure Protocol** (explicit decision tree)

### 3. Create prompts/roles/refinery.md
- Follow pattern of deacon.md
- Include patrol execution loop diagram
- Reference the molecule

### 4. Consider mol-witness-patrol
- Witness has detailed heartbeat protocol but no formal molecule
- Similar pattern could apply

## Why This Matters

GUPP: 'If you have work on your hook, you have to run it.'
The patrol molecule puts failure handling ON THE HOOK as a mandatory step.
You can't skip handle-failures to get to merge-push.
The structure enforces good behavior.

## Related
- gt-7919: Fix failing beads tests (discovered during this session)
- mol-deacon-patrol (existing pattern to follow)
- docs/molecular-chemistry.md (chemistry concepts)
- docs/wisp-architecture.md (wisp vs mol decision)


Add await-work and plugin-run steps to mol-refinery-patrol

## Context

The mol-refinery-patrol needs two additional steps:

### 1. await-work (Decision Point)

Not just 'wait for signal' but a crossroads:
- Check for pending signals (mail, nudge, human)
- Check plugin gates (any plugins need to run?)
- Check maintenance schedule (daily/weekly due?)
- Evaluate context and decide next action

Position: Between burn-or-loop and inbox-check (the loop point)

### 2. plugin-run (Like Deacon)

Refinery needs plugin support for:
- **Monitors**: Flag PRs touching sensitive code
- **Gates**: Block merges under certain conditions
- **Schedulers**: Reorder queue based on priority/urgency
- **Maintenance**: Weekly cleanup, audits, stats
- **Audits**: Log merge statistics, track patterns

Position: After queue-scan, before process-branch

## Implementation

Update RefineryPatrolMolecule() in builtin_molecules.go to include:
- await-work step with decision tree
- plugin-run step with gate types

## Related
- gt-7920 (original mol-refinery-patrol)
- docs/deacon-plugins.md (existing plugin model)


Dynamic wisp modification: insert, reorder, bond mid-execution

## Vision

Wisps should be living documents that adapt mid-execution, not static scripts.

## Operations Needed

### bd mol insert
Insert a step into a running wisp:
```bash
bd mol insert <wisp-id> --after <step> --step 'security-gate: Review auth changes'
```

### bd mol reorder
Change step order in a running wisp:
```bash
bd mol reorder <wisp-id> --move process-branch --before current
```

### bd mol bond (to wisp)
Attach an entire molecule to a running wisp:
```bash
bd mol bond mol-weekly-maintenance <wisp-id> --after await-work
```

### bd mol skip
Skip a step (with reason):
```bash
bd mol skip <wisp-id> <step> --reason 'Queue empty, skipping summary'
```

## Use Cases

1. **Hotfix priority**: Reorder queue to process urgent MR first
2. **Security gate**: Insert review step when PR touches sensitive files
3. **Scheduled maintenance**: Bond maintenance mol on schedule
4. **Context adaptation**: Skip steps when they don't apply

## Why This Matters

Engine room problems emerge dynamically. The wisp's flexibility lets agents model situations as they evolve, not execute rigid scripts.

GUPP still applies: whatever's on your hook, you run. But the hook contents can adapt.

## Implementation

This requires Beads changes to support wisp mutation:
- Track step ordering in wisp storage
- Support step insertion/deletion/reordering
- Handle bond-to-wisp (spawn steps into existing wisp)
- Preserve audit trail of modifications


gt rig add / gt doctor: patrol awareness and wiring

## Problem

When a rig is installed or audited, we need to ensure all built-in patrols and role hooks are properly wired up.

## gt rig add Changes

When adding a rig, automatically:

1. **Create patrol molecules** for each role:
   - mol-deacon-patrol (town-level)
   - mol-witness-patrol (per-rig)
   - mol-refinery-patrol (per-rig)

2. **Set up hooks** that trigger patrols:
   - Deacon: daemon timer / heartbeat
   - Witness: daemon timer / polecat lifecycle events
   - Refinery: MR submission events / daemon timer

3. **Configure daemon** to manage these patrols:
   - Register patrol molecules in daemon config
   - Set up respawn behavior for each role

4. **Create plugin directories**:
   - ~/gt/plugins/ (town-level)
   - <rig>/plugins/ (rig-level, if needed)

## gt doctor Changes

Add patrol health checks:

### patrol-molecules-exist
- Verify mol-deacon-patrol, mol-witness-patrol, mol-refinery-patrol exist
- Check they parse correctly (valid steps, dependencies)

### patrol-hooks-wired
- Verify hooks trigger patrol execution
- Check daemon is configured to manage patrols

### patrol-not-stuck
- Detect wisps that have been in-progress too long
- Flag orphaned patrol molecules (no active session)

### patrol-plugins-accessible
- Verify plugin directories exist and are readable
- Check plugin frontmatter parses correctly

### patrol-roles-have-prompts
- Verify prompts/roles/*.md exist for each role
- Check they reference the correct patrol molecule

## Auto-fix

gt doctor --fix can:
- Create missing patrol molecules
- Wire up missing hooks
- Create plugin directories
- NOT restart stuck patrols (needs human decision)

## Related
- gt-7920 (mol-refinery-patrol)
- gt-7921 (await-work and plugin-run)
- docs/wisp-architecture.md


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 3: Routine


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 1: All clear - inbox empty, agents healthy, no orphans


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 9: All clear


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol #18: Stable


Document the Propulsion Principle

Write canonical documentation for the Universal Gas Town Propulsion Principle.

Location: gastown/mayor/rig/docs/propulsion-principle.md

Content:
- The One Rule (hook has work → work happens)
- Why it works (stateless agents, molecule-driven)
- The sling lifecycle diagram
- Agent startup protocol
- Examples and anti-patterns

This is foundational theory-of-operation documentation.

Documentation complete. Created docs/propulsion-principle.md covering the One Rule, sling lifecycle, agent startup protocol, and examples/anti-patterns.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 6: All healthy


Merge: gt-92l

branch: polecat/Ace
target: main
source_issue: gt-92l
rig: gastown


Ephemeral polecats: spawn fresh, delete on completion

## Design Decision

Switch from pooled/idle polecats to ephemeral model:
- Spawn creates fresh worktree from main
- Polecat requests shutdown when done (bottom-up)
- Witness verifies handoff, kills session, deletes worktree
- No 'idle' state - polecats exist only while working

## Rationale

1. **Git worktrees are fast** - pooling optimization is obsolete
2. **Pooling creates maintenance burden:**
   - Git stashes accumulate
   - Untracked artifacts pile up
   - Branches drift from main
   - Beads DB gets stale
3. **PGT sync problems** came from persistent branches
4. **Support infrastructure exists** - Witness, Refinery, Mayor handle continuity
5. **Simpler mental model** - polecat exists = work in progress

## Lifecycle

```
Spawn:
  gt spawn --issue <id>
  → Creates fresh worktree: git worktree add polecats/<name> -b polecat/<name>
  → Initializes beads in worktree
  → Starts session, assigns work

Working:
  Polecat does task
  → Pushes to polecat/<name> branch
  → Submits to merge queue when ready

Completion (POLECAT-INITIATED):
  Polecat runs: gt handoff
  → Verifies git state clean
  → Sends mail to Witness: "Ready for shutdown"
  → Marks itself done, waits for termination

Cleanup (WITNESS-OWNED):
  Witness receives shutdown request
  → Verifies PR merged or in queue
  → Verifies no uncommitted changes
  → Kills session: gt session stop <rig>/<polecat>
  → Deletes worktree: git worktree remove polecats/<name>
  → Deletes branch: git branch -d polecat/<name>
  → Optionally: Notifies Mayor of completion
```

## Key Insight: Bottom-Up Shutdown

**Old model (wrong)**: Top-down batch shutdown - "cancel the swarm"
**New model (right)**: Bottom-up individual shutdown - polecat requests, Witness executes

This enables streaming:
- Workers come and go continuously
- No "swarm end" to trigger cleanup
- Each worker manages its own lifecycle
- Witness is the lifecycle authority

## Implementation

1. Add `gt handoff` command for polecats to request shutdown
2. Modify gt spawn to always create fresh worktree
3. Run bd init in new worktree (beads needs initialization)
4. Add shutdown request handler to Witness
5. Witness verifies handoff, then cleans up:
   - Kill session
   - Remove worktree
   - Delete branch
6. Remove 'idle' state from polecat state machine
7. Simplify gt polecat list (only shows active)

## Impact on Other Tasks

- gt-17r (Zombie cleanup): Becomes trivial - orphan worktrees
- gt-4my (Worker health): Simpler - no idle/stuck ambiguity
- gt-f9x.5/f9x.6 (Doctor): Fewer states to validate
- gt-eu9 (Witness handoff): Witness receives polecat shutdown requests


gt mail send should tmux-notify recipient

## Problem

When mail is sent via gt mail send, the recipient session does not get a tmux notification. In Python Gas Town (PGT), mail delivery triggers a tmux display-message or similar notification so the agent knows mail arrived.

## Expected Behavior

When gt mail send <addr> is called:
1. Mail is delivered to recipient inbox
2. If recipient has an active tmux session, send notification
3. Notification should be visible (display-message or bell)

## Current Behavior

Mail is delivered but no notification. Agent has to poll inbox to discover new mail.

## Impact

- Agents miss time-sensitive messages
- Heartbeat pokes from daemon will not wake agents
- Coordination is slower (polling vs push)

## Implementation Notes

After successful mail delivery, check if recipient has active session:
- gt session list can identify active sessions
- tmux display-message or send-keys can notify
- Could inject a visible prompt like "[MAIL] New message from <sender>"

## Reference

Check PGT implementation for how it handles this.


mol-deacon-patrol

Mayor's daemon patrol loop.

The Deacon is the Mayor's background process that runs continuously,
handling callbacks, monitoring rig health, and performing cleanup.
Each patrol cycle runs these steps in sequence, then loops or exits.


Session pre-shutdown checks

Session stop should verify clean state before killing, like PGT.

## Pre-Shutdown Checks

### 1. Git Working Tree Clean
```go
func checkGitClean(clonePath string) error {
    // git status --porcelain
    // Fail if any output
}
```

### 2. All Commits Pushed
```go
func checkCommitsPushed(clonePath string) error {
    // git log origin/HEAD..HEAD
    // Fail if any unpushed commits
}
```

### 3. Assigned Issues Handled
```go
func checkIssuesHandled(polecat *Polecat) error {
    // If polecat.Issue != "", check if closed or reassigned
}
```

### 4. Beads Synced
```go
func checkBeadsSynced(clonePath string) error {
    // bd sync --status in clone directory
}
```

## Behavior on Failure
1. First attempt: Nudge worker to fix
2. Retry up to 3 times with delay
3. After retries: Escalate to Witness/Mayor

## Integration
Modify internal/session/manager.go Stop():
```go
func (m *Manager) Stop(polecat string, force bool) error {
    if !force {
        if err := m.runPreShutdownChecks(polecat); err != nil {
            return fmt.Errorf("pre-shutdown checks failed: %w", err)
        }
    }
    // existing stop logic
}
```

## Flags
- --force: Skip checks
- --grace-period N: Time to wait for fixes

## Dependencies
- Ties into gt-69l (hook system) - can be hook-based
- Ties into gt-f8v (Witness pre-kill verification)

## Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] Stop fails if uncommitted changes (without --force)
- [ ] Stop fails if unpushed commits
- [ ] Clear error messages with fix instructions
- [ ] --force bypasses all checks


gt mail: Cross-level routing is broken

**Problem:**
When Mayor (at ~/gt) sends mail to a rig worker (gastown/crew/max), the message lands in town-level beads (~/.beads/) but the recipient checks rig-level beads (crew/max/.beads/).

**Reproduction:**
```bash
cd ~/gt
gt mail send gastown/crew/max -s 'Test' -m 'body'
# Message goes to ~/gt/.beads/ with prefix hq-*

cd ~/gt/gastown/crew/max
gt mail inbox
# Does NOT see the message - it's looking in crew/max/.beads/
```

**Root cause:**
`findBeadsWorkDir()` walks up from CWD to find .beads. `Router.Send()` runs `bd create` in that directory. This means messages always go to the sender's beads, not the recipient's.

**Fix options:**
1. Route based on recipient address - if sending to rig/*, use that rig's .beads
2. Use a single shared beads database for all mail (simpler but less isolated)
3. Teach agents to check both levels (workaround, not fix)

**Related:**
- gt-ngu1: Pinned beads sorting (done but pointless if mail doesn't route)
- This blocks all cross-level mail functionality


HOP: Skill vectors on work items

Add skill embeddings to work items for capability-based matching. See ~/ai/stevey-gastown/hop/CONTEXT.md. Post-v0.1 work.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 14: All healthy, read Mayor handoff (info)


Refactor: Extract common manager creation boilerplate

Five nearly identical functions exist for creating managers:
- getPolecatManager (polecat.go:241)
- getSessionManager (session.go:183)
- getCrewManager (crew_helpers.go:44)
- getRefineryManager (refinery.go:116)
- getWitnessManager (witness.go:102)

All follow the same pattern: find workspace, load config, get rig, create manager. Should extract to a common helper that takes a factory function.

Extracted common getRig() helper in internal/cmd/rig_helpers.go, updated all 5 manager creation functions to use it


Default crew name should be something better than 'main'

When creating a new rig, the default crew worker name is 'main'. This is confusing since:

1. 'main' is also the git branch name
2. It doesn't convey that this is the user's personal workspace
3. Crew names should feel more personal/distinct

Consider alternatives like:
- 'home' - the user's home base
- 'desk' - their personal desk
- 'joe/max/etc' - actual name-based defaults
- Let user pick during rig init


README: Update Install section for homebrew/npm

README currently shows:
  go install github.com/steveyegge/gastown/cmd/gt@latest

But users will install via homebrew or npm. Update to show:
  brew install gastown
  # or
  npm install -g @anthropic/gastown

Also add prerequisites section (tmux, Claude Code CLI).

Updated Install section with prerequisites and future package manager options


Swarms of One: Lightweight single-worker task dispatch

Design and implement a lightweight pattern for firing off single workers to handle tasks without full swarm overhead.

## Context

Currently we have:
- town spawn: Creates a polecat in a rig with issue assignment
- Swarms (sw-*): Full lifecycle tracking with manifest, state, events, reports
- Ephemeral rigs (rig-*): Temporary worker groups for swarms

What's missing: A simple way to say 'fire off a worker to do X' without swarm ceremony.

## Design Questions

1. Should this be a new command like 'gt fire' or an option on existing commands?
2. Should single tasks still get swarm IDs (sw-N) for consistency/queryability?
3. Should it default to creating new workers or support --reuse for idle polecats?
4. How does this relate to crew workers (gt-cik)?

## Possible Interface

gt fire --rig gastown --issue gt-xyz [--prompt '...']
gt fire gastown/QuickTask --issue gt-xyz

## Related

- gt-cik: Overseer Crew (user-managed persistent workspaces)
- gt-kmn: Swarm System epic


Bug: MRs appearing in bd ready output

merge-request beads are showing up in `bd ready` output alongside actual work items.

## Problem
`bd ready` is meant to show work available for polecats to claim. MRs are internal workflow items processed by the Refinery, not polecat work.

## Example
```
| P1 | merge-request | bd-3zzh | Merge: bd-tvu3 |
| P1 | merge-request | bd-fcl1 | Merge: bd-au0.5 |
```

## Possible Fixes
1. **Filter by type** - `bd ready` excludes type=merge-request, type=gate, type=molecule
2. **Set assignee on submit** - MR assigned to refinery/ when created, so not 'unassigned'
3. **Set status=in_progress** - MR starts in_progress since it's queued for processing

## Related
- gate beads also showing (bd-hyp6, bd-wu62) - same issue

Fixed in beads commit 33105c96 - workflow types excluded from bd ready


Design: Swarm shutdown and worker cleanup

Design for graceful swarm shutdown, worker cleanup, and session cycling.

## Key Decisions

1. Pre-kill verification uses model intelligence (not framework rules)
2. Witness can request restart when context filling (mail self, exit)
3. Mayor NOT involved in per-worker cleanup (Witness responsibility)
4. Clear responsibility boundaries between Mayor/Witness/Polecat

## Subtasks (implementation)

- gt-sd6: Polecat decommission checklist prompting
- gt-f8v: Witness pre-kill verification protocol
- gt-eu9: Witness session cycling and handoff
- gt-gl2: Mayor vs Witness cleanup responsibilities

**Design complete.** Each subtask has full specification in its description.


mol-witness-patrol molecule definition

Create mol-witness-patrol in builtin_molecules.go.

## Steps (10 total)
1. inbox-check - Process witness mail (lifecycle, help requests)
2. load-state - Read handoff bead, get nudge counts
3. survey-workers - gt polecat list, categorize by status
4. inspect-workers - tmux capture-pane for each 'working' polecat
5. decide-actions - Apply nudge matrix, queue actions
6. execute-actions - Nudge, kill, or escalate as decided
7. save-state - Update handoff bead with new states
8. generate-summary - Summarize cycle for digest
9. context-check - Check own context usage
10. burn-or-loop - Squash wisp, then loop or cycle session

## Key Behaviors
- Uses wisp storage (.beads-wisp/)
- Reads/writes witness handoff bead for state persistence
- Progressive nudging (3 levels before escalate)
- Pre-kill verification before killing polecats

## Reference
- See prompts/roles/witness.md for protocol details
- See mol-refinery-patrol for similar structure
- Parent epic: gt-aqd8

Implemented mol-witness-patrol with 10 steps in builtin_molecules.go


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 8


gt spawn: Not injecting work instructions to session

gt spawn starts session but doesn't inject the issue assignment.

Repro:
1. gt spawn gastown/Toast --issue gt-2ux
2. Session starts but polecat just sees Claude prompt
3. No issue context injected

Expected: Polecat should receive issue details automatically.
Actual: Polecat sits at blank prompt, needs manual injection.


CLI: doctor diagnostics and auto-repair

GGT completely lacks the doctor command which is critical for debugging.

Required Commands:
- gt doctor [<rig>] - Run diagnostic checks
- gt doctor --fix - Auto-repair common issues

Checks to Implement:
Workspace Level: Config validity, Mayor mailbox, Rig registry
Rig Level: Git state, clone health, witness/refinery presence, beads sync
Swarm Level: Stuck detection, zombie sessions, heartbeat health

PGT Reference: gastown-py/src/gastown/cli/dashboard_cmd.py


mol-witness-patrol

Per-rig worker monitor patrol loop using the Christmas Ornament pattern.

The Witness is the Pit Boss for your rig. You watch polecats, nudge them toward
completion, verify clean git state before kills, and escalate stuck workers.

**You do NOT do implementation work.** Your job is oversight, not coding.

## The Christmas Ornament Shape

This molecule uses dynamic bonding to create inspection arms per-polecat:

```
                    ★ mol-witness-patrol (trunk)
                   /|\
            ┌─────┘ │ └─────┐
         PREFLIGHT DISCOVERY CLEANUP
            │       │        │
        ┌───┴───┐ ┌─┴─┐  ┌───┴───┐
        │inbox  │ │sur│  │aggreg │
        │refnry │ │vey│  │save   │
        │load   │ └─┬─┘  │summary│
        └───────┘   │    │contxt │
                    │    │loop   │
          ┌─────────┼─────────┐ └───────┘
          │         │         │
          ●         ●         ●     mol-polecat-arm (dynamic)
         ace       nux      toast
          │         │         │
       ┌──┴──┐   ┌──┴──┐   ┌──┴──┐
       │cap  │   │cap  │   │cap  │
       │ass  │   │ass  │   │ass  │
       │dec  │   │dec  │   │dec  │
       │exec │   │exec │   │exec │
       └──┬──┘   └──┬──┘   └──┬──┘
          │         │         │
          └─────────┴─────────┘
                    │
                 ⬣ base (cleanup)
```

## Phases

### PREFLIGHT (fixed steps)
1. inbox-check - Process lifecycle requests, help messages
2. check-refinery - Ensure MQ is alive and processing
3. load-state - Read persistent state (nudge counts, etc.)

### DISCOVERY (spawns dynamic arms)
4. survey-workers - List polecats, bond mol-polecat-arm per polecat
5. run-plugins - Bond mol-plugin-runner for each witness plugin

### CLEANUP (gate + fixed steps)
6. aggregate - GATE: WaitsFor all arms + plugins to complete
7. save-state - Persist nudge counts, action log
8. generate-summary - Create digest content
9. context-check - Check if context is high
10. burn-or-loop - Squash/burn wisp, then loop or exit

## Dynamic Arms

Each polecat gets mol-polecat-arm bonded as a wisp child:
- capture - Capture tmux output
- assess - Categorize state (working/idle/error/done)
- load-history - Get nudge counts for this polecat
- decide - Apply nudge matrix
- execute - Take action (nudge/kill/escalate/none)

Arms run in PARALLEL. The aggregate step waits for all to complete.

## Activity Feed

This design enables real-time visibility:

```
[14:32:08] + patrol-x7k.arm-ace bonded (5 steps)
[14:32:09] → patrol-x7k.arm-ace.capture in_progress
[14:32:10] ✓ patrol-x7k.arm-ace.capture completed
[14:32:14] ✓ patrol-x7k.arm-ace.decide completed (action: nudge-1)
[14:32:17] ✓ patrol-x7k.arm-ace COMPLETE
```

## Storage

- Wisp storage: .beads-wisp/ (ephemeral, gitignored)
- Persistent state: witness handoff bead (nudge counts, etc.)
- Digests: Squashed summaries in permanent beads

## Dependencies

- bd-xo1o: Dynamic Molecule Bonding epic (in beads rig)
  - bd mol bond with variable substitution
  - WaitsFor directive for fanout gates
  - Activity feed query

Labels: [template, christmas-ornament]


Add compaction recovery protocol to role templates

After context compaction (summarization), agents may be disoriented.

Add guidance to recognize and recover:
- 'If you feel you've lost earlier context or are disoriented, run: gt prime'
- 'This re-injects your role, current work, and pending messages'
- 'It's safe to prime multiple times - it just outputs context'

This is the fallback path when self-check is missed and compaction happens.
Compaction isn't catastrophic if priming is robust.


Review: Witness patrol template changes (gt-h1n5)

Polecat rictus implemented significant witness.md.tmpl changes: banners, wisp-based execution, handoff bead attachment, loop-or-exit, patrol summary. Review for correctness and consistency with deacon pattern.


Adaptive backoff for daemon heartbeat

Track agent responsiveness and adjust heartbeat frequency.

## Per-Agent State

```go
type AgentBackoff struct {
    BaseInterval    time.Duration  // 60s default
    CurrentInterval time.Duration  // grows when busy
    MaxInterval     time.Duration  // 10min cap
    ConsecutiveMiss int            // pokes with no response
}
```

## Strategy Options

- **Fixed**: Always 60s (current, simple)
- **Geometric**: 60s → 90s → 135s → 202s (factor 1.5)
- **Exponential**: 60s → 120s → 240s (factor 2, aggressive)

## Recovery

When agent responds (runs a command):
- Reset ConsecutiveMiss to 0
- Return to BaseInterval immediately

## Benefits

- Reduces noise for busy agents
- Saves resources during quiet periods
- Still catches stuck agents (max interval cap)


Add role-specific subcommands that delegate to core commands (agent UX)

## Problem

Agents naturally guess command patterns like:
- `gt witness nudge <polecat>`
- `gt polecat nudge <name>`
- `gt crew restart <member>`

But these don't exist - the actual commands are:
- `gt nudge <session> <message>`
- `gt polecat reset <name>`

This creates friction in agent UX. Agents shouldn't have to memorize the 'correct' command structure.

## Proposal

Add subcommands to each role that delegate to core commands with argument reordering:

```
gt witness nudge furiosa "Start working"
  → gt nudge gt-gastown-furiosa "Start working"

gt polecat nudge gastown/furiosa "Check mail"
  → gt nudge gt-gastown-furiosa "Check mail"

gt crew nudge gastown/max "Wake up"
  → gt nudge gt-crew-gastown-max "Wake up"
```

## Benefits

1. **Discoverable**: Agents explore `gt witness --help` and find nudge
2. **Lenient**: Multiple valid ways to express the same intent
3. **Role-contextual**: Commands under the role namespace feel natural
4. **Extensible**: Pattern works for future subcommands (status, reset, etc.)

## Implementation

Each role command (witness, polecat, crew, refinery) gets thin wrapper subcommands:

```go
// In witness.go
witnessCmd.AddCommand(&cobra.Command{
    Use:   "nudge <polecat> <message>",
    Short: "Nudge a polecat (delegates to gt nudge)",
    RunE: func(cmd *cobra.Command, args []string) error {
        session := formatSession(rig, args[0])
        return runNudge(session, args[1])
    },
})
```

## Future Candidates

Other subcommands to add as role-specific aliases:
- `gt polecat status <name>` (already exists, good pattern)
- `gt witness check <polecat>` → trigger a manual check
- `gt refinery merge <mr-id>` → process specific MR
- `gt crew send <member> <message>` → mail to crew member


CLI: plugin commands (list, status)

Add gt plugins <rig> to list plugins and gt plugin status <name> to check plugin state. Simple directory scan of <rig>/plugins/.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 13: All healthy


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol @ 2025-12-24 19:28

Patrol 18


Pinned Beads: Ongoing concerns and anchors

Pinned beads represent persistent concerns that do not close traditionally. Stay out of bd ready. Examples: Monitor production, Weekly syncs. Implementation: pinned: true field on bead.

Superseded by gt-h6eq (Pinned beads architecture implementation)


gt mail send: --priority flag should work like bd mail send

UX inconsistency: gt mail send passes flags that bd mail send doesn't support.

## Root Cause

router.go line 42 passes `--priority` to bd:
```go
args = append(args, "--priority", fmt.Sprintf("%d", beadsPriority))
```

But `bd mail send` only has `--urgent` (boolean), not `--priority`.

## Fix Options

1. Add `--priority` flag to `bd mail send` (preferred - more expressive)
2. Change router to only use `--urgent` when priority=0

## Also Affected

- `--type` flag (line 46) - bd mail send doesn't have this
- `--thread-id` flag (line 51) - bd mail send doesn't have this
- `--reply-to` flag (line 56) - bd mail send doesn't have this

The router assumes bd mail send has features it doesn't have.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 11: All healthy


Comprehensive help text and examples

Improve help text with examples and cross-references.

## Improvements

### 1. Examples Section
Add to Long description:
```go
var spawnCmd = &cobra.Command{
    Long: `Spawn a polecat with work assignment.

Examples:
  gt spawn gastown/Toast --issue gt-abc
  gt spawn gastown --issue gt-def          # auto-select polecat
  gt spawn gastown/Nux -m "Fix the tests"  # free-form task`,
}
```

### 2. Cross-References
Reference related commands:
```
See also:
  gt polecat list    List available polecats
  gt session attach  Attach to spawned session
```

### 3. Flag Descriptions
More detail on flags:
```go
cmd.Flags().StringVar(&issue, "issue", "",
    "Beads issue ID to assign. The polecat will work on this issue.")
```

### 4. Common Workflows
Add workflow docs to gt --help:
```
Common Workflows:
  Start a swarm:
    gt swarm preflight
    gt swarm create gastown --epic gt-abc --worker Toast --worker Nux --start
    gt refinery start gastown

  Check status:
    gt status
    gt swarm status <id>
```

## Files to Update
All internal/cmd/*.go files

## Acceptance Criteria
- [ ] All commands have Examples
- [ ] Related commands cross-referenced
- [ ] Flags have detailed descriptions
- [ ] Root help shows workflows


Town Doctor molecule for harness health checks

Create a Town Doctor molecule that any Gas Town agent can run to diagnose and repair harness issues.

## Concept

Instead of just `gt doctor` as a CLI command with hardcoded checks, create a **molecule** (checklist workflow) that:
- Any agent (Mayor, Witness, Polecat) can instantiate
- Walks the agent through diagnostic steps
- Agent uses judgment to fix issues found
- Works as a structured troubleshooting guide

## Why a Molecule?

1. **Agent-driven**: The agent running it becomes "the doctor" temporarily
2. **Extensible**: Add new checks by updating the molecule, not code
3. **Contextual**: Agent can reason about issues, not just run scripts
4. **Self-healing**: Agent can fix problems it finds, not just report them

## Proposed Checks (molecule steps)

1. Verify harness structure (mayor/, .beads/, CLAUDE.md exist)
2. Validate config files (town.json, rigs.json parse correctly)
3. Check beads health (bd doctor, redirect validity)
4. Verify git state (clean working tree, proper remotes)
5. Check rig integrity (each registered rig exists, has config.json)
6. Validate agent clones (mayor/rig/, refinery/rig/ exist and are valid)
7. Check for orphaned worktrees/branches
8. Verify daemon state (if running)

## Integration

- `gt doctor` could instantiate the molecule for the current agent
- Or agent can run `bd ready` and pick up doctor tasks when prioritized
- Results logged to beads for audit trail

## Related

- gt-cr9: Harness Design & Documentation (completed)
- Molecules design in architecture.md


Update Deacon template to emphasize staying in ~/gt/deacon directory

The Deacon template should instruct the agent to stay in ~/gt/deacon/ as much as possible, and always return there after any excursion. This prevents issues with identity detection (mail, mol status) which depend on cwd.


Work on ga-p6r: Add handoff protocol to spawn priming. En...

Work on ga-p6r: Add handoff protocol to spawn priming. Ensure polecats receive handoff context when spawned. When done, submit MR (not PR) to integration branch for Refinery.


Plugin/molecule catalog integration design

Two currently independent systems:
1. Disk-based plugins (~~/gt/plugins/) - Deacon patrol extensions
2. Molecule catalog (protos in beads) - bd pour/wisp/bond

Investigate integration points:
- User-contributed molecules bonded to catalog
- Dynamic molecule attachment during execution (e.g., 'attach security sniffer because we noticed condition X')
- How plugins could contribute protos
- How protos could trigger plugins

Not blocking launch. Future design investigation.


Enhance Mayor CLAUDE.md with GGT milestone tracking

Update ~/ai/CLAUDE.md (Mayor startup context) with:

1. GGT Self-Hosting Milestone section
   - Track progress toward gt replacing town
   - Key blockers: gt-h5n (merge queue), gt-974 (daemon)
   - What "self-hosting" means (GGT working on itself)

2. Recent Architecture Decisions
   - Engineer = role, Refinery = place
   - Merge queue in Beads (not branch discovery)
   - Session restart protocol

3. Transition Plan
   - Current: use town commands (PGT)
   - Target: use gt commands (GGT)
   - Switch criteria: gt-b1g closed

Keep it concise - Mayor context should be quick to scan.


Molecule Algebra: Work Composition DSL

Implement the molecule algebra - a declarative language for composing, transforming, and executing structured work. Enables mechanical composition without AI.

The Three Phases: Rig → Cook → Run

- **Rig**: Source-level composition (formula YAML with extends/compose)
- **Cook**: Instantiation (formula → proto → mol/wisp)
- **Run**: Execution (agents complete steps)

Two Composition Operators:
- **Rig** operates on formulas (source level)
- **Bond** operates on artifacts (protos, mols, wisps)

Key components:
- Formulas: YAML source with composition rules (.formula.yaml)
- Cook: Pre-expand macros/aspects to flat proto
- Phase verbs (pour, wisp)
- Bond: Artifact-level polymorphic composition
- Composition operators (sequence, parallel, branch, loop, gate)
- Advice operators (before, after, around - Lisp style)
- Expansion operators (macros like Rule of Five)
- Aspects (AOP cross-cutting concerns)

See docs/rig-cook-run.md for the lifecycle spec.
See docs/molecule-algebra.md for full algebra specification.
Example formulas in .beads/formulas/


Phase verbs: pour and wisp commands

Implement the phase transition verbs:
- bd pour <proto> - instantiate as persistent mol
- bd wisp <proto> - instantiate as ephemeral wisp
- Update bd mol bond to inherit phase from target

These replace the current --wisp flag with cleaner verb semantics.

Already implemented: bd pour, bd wisp create, and bd mol bond with phase inheritance all work correctly


Rename Engineer in Box to Shiny

Rename mol-engineer-in-box to mol-shiny (or just 'shiny').

Mad Max reference - the canonical 'right way to engineer'.
Update all references in docs and code.


Rule of Five expansion template

Create rule-of-five as an expansion template:
- Jeffrey's discovery: agents converge in 4-5 iterations
- Template expands any step into 5-pass refinement
- draft → refine-1 → refine-2 → refine-3 → refine-4

First example of a macro-style expansion proto.

Already implemented: rule-of-five.formula.json exists, bd cook expands correctly (verified with shiny-enterprise)


Formula parser and YAML schema

Implement formula parsing from YAML:
- Define YAML schema for .formula.yaml files
- Parse steps, compose rules, vars
- Support extends for formula inheritance
- Validate formula structure

Schema should support:
- formula: name
- description: text
- version: number
- type: workflow|expansion|aspect
- vars: variable definitions
- steps: step definitions
- compose: composition rules

**Beads issue: bd-weu8**


bd cook command: Formula to Proto

Implement the 'bd cook' command that transforms formulas into protos.

Usage: bd cook <formula-file> [options]
       bd cook .beads/formulas/*.formula.yaml

Process:
1. Parse formula YAML (uses formula parser)
2. Resolve extends (formula inheritance)
3. Expand macros (expansion rules)
4. Apply aspects (cross-cutting concerns)
5. Generate flat proto bead

Output:
- Creates proto bead in .beads/ with mol-prefix
- Proto has all steps pre-expanded
- Proto is ready for pour/wisp instantiation

**Beads issue: bd-wa2l**


bd formula list/show commands

Implement formula management commands:

  bd formula list
  # Lists formulas from all search paths

  bd formula show rule-of-five
  # Shows formula details, steps, compose rules

Search paths (in order):
1. .beads/formulas/ (project)
2. ~/gt/.beads/formulas/ (town)
3. ~/.beads/formulas/ (user)
4. Built-in formulas (embedded)

Implemented bd formula list/show commands


Formula cycle detection during cooking

Detect and error on circular extends chains during bd cook. E.g., if formula A extends B extends A, cooking should fail with clear error message pointing to the cycle.

Implemented: cycle detection now shows full chain (cycle-a -> cycle-b -> cycle-a format)


Prevent aspect self-matching (infinite recursion)

Aspects should only match original steps, not steps inserted by the same aspect application. Document this and implement guard during cooking. Without this, a pointcut like *.implement that inserts security-prescan could match its own insertion infinitely.

Self-matching prevented via originalIDs guard in ApplyAdvice. Test added.


Max expansion depth limit (default 5)

Add maxExpansionDepth config (default 5) to prevent runaway nested expansions. This still allows massive work generation but with a safety bound. Note: distinguish compile-time cooking (produces proto with placeholders) vs runtime cooking (produces mol with real issue IDs). Compile-time is for modeling/estimation/contractor handoff.

Implemented: DefaultMaxExpansionDepth=5 constant, depth tracking in expandStep, error on limit exceeded


Cooking metadata: source tracing

Add source_formula and source_location metadata to cooked steps so you can trace a step in a proto back to its origin formula. Useful for debugging complex compositions.


Meta-formulas: formula generators

Support meta-formulas that generate multiple formulas from a template. Example: multi-lang-shiny that generates shiny-go, shiny-python, shiny-typescript from a for-each loop over languages. Enables DRY formula libraries.


Advice operators: before, after, around

Implement Lisp-style advice operators for molecules:
- before(target, step) - insert step before target
- after(target, step) - insert step after target
- around(target, wrapper) - wrap target with before/after

Support glob patterns for targeting (*.implement, shiny.*, etc).

Implemented advice operators: before, after, around with glob pattern matching


Formula inheritance trees for organizational policies

Support organizational formula hierarchies where teams extend a company-base-formula. Each team can add required aspects (accessibility audit for frontend, SQL injection scan for backend). Enables policy enforcement across an organization.


Conditional aspects (feature flags)

Apply aspects conditionally based on environment or config. Example: apply security-audit only when env.SECURITY_SCANNING == enabled. Adds 'when' clause to aspect composition.


Review dimensions as aspects

Refactor code-review molecule to use aspects for each review dimension (security, performance, accessibility). More flexible than current pluggable molecule approach - add/remove checks by composing aspects.


Compile-time vs runtime cooking

Distinguish two cooking modes: 1) Compile-time: produces proto with variable placeholders, for modeling/estimation/contractor handoff. 2) Runtime: produces mol with real issue IDs. Compile-time lets you pre-decompose work for untrusted executors or planning purposes.


Document Rig/Cook/Run lifecycle

The rig-cook-run.md spec is written. Propagate terminology to all relevant docs: - molecule-algebra.md (done) - molecular-chemistry.md (done) - vision.md (done) - propulsion-principle.md - sling-design.md - Any agent templates that reference cooking/instantiation

Updated propulsion-principle.md, sling-design.md, molecules.md, and architecture.md with Rig/Cook/Run lifecycle terminology


Implement bd bond command for artifact-level composition

Implement the artifact-level bond operator distinct from source-level rigging.

Bond accepts:
- Formula names (cooks inline to ephemeral proto, then bonds)
- Mol IDs (existing liquid work)
- Wisp IDs (existing vapor work)

See molecular-chemistry.md for the full bond table semantics.

**Updated 2025-12-25**: With ephemeral protos (gt-4v1eo), bond takes formula names directly and cooks inline. No pre-cooked proto beads.


Direct formula-to-wisp instantiation (skip proto)

For massive ephemeral workflows (e.g., million-step Towers of Hanoi), allow:

bd wisp towers-of-hanoi --var disks=20

This would cook + wisp in one step, never materializing the proto. Useful when:
- The proto would be huge (1M+ steps)
- The work is ephemeral (wisp, not mol)
- You don't need the intermediate artifact

Implementation: streaming cook that emits directly to wisp storage.

Related: towers-of-hanoi.formula.yaml demonstrates the use case.

Superseded by gt-4v1eo - ephemeral protos is now the general approach, not a special case for large workflows


Computed range expansion (for-each over expressions)

Support for-each expansion over computed ranges, not just static lists:

for-each:
  var: move_num
  range: "1..2^{disks}"  # Computed at cook time

This enables formulas like Towers of Hanoi where the step count is a function of input variables. The range expression is evaluated during cooking.

Related: towers-of-hanoi.formula.yaml demonstrates the need.
Depends on: gt-8tmz.8 (Runtime dynamic expansion)


Formula error handling and recovery

Specify how cooking errors are reported and recovered:
- What happens when extends chain is broken (missing formula)?
- What happens when aspect pointcut matches nothing?
- What happens when expansion produces invalid structure?
- Graceful degradation vs fail-fast semantics
- Error metadata in cooked protos

Deferred: post-launch polish


Formula versioning and migration strategy

Define how formula versions are managed:
- What does the version field mean? Semver? Integer?
- When a formula changes, what happens to existing protos?
- Do protos track their source formula version?
- Migration path: old proto + new formula = ?
- Backwards compatibility guarantees (if any)

Deferred: post-launch polish


Expansion operators: expand and map (macros)

Implement macro-style expansion operators:
- expand(target, template) - apply template to single step
- map(molecule, template) - apply template to all matching steps

Templates use {target} substitution for step references.
Rule of Five is the canonical example.

Expansion operators working - fixed dependency updates after expansion, fixed formula files schema


Proto debugging and inspection tools

Proto debugging and inspection tools.

With ephemeral protos (gt-4v1eo), this becomes:
- `bd cook <formula> --dry-run` - preview cooked output without persisting
- `bd cook <formula> --json` - output proto as JSON for inspection
- `bd cook <formula> --graph` - visualize step DAG

No persistent proto beads to inspect - formulas are the source of truth.


Formula validation specification

Complete validation rules for formulas:
- Required vs optional fields
- Valid step ID patterns
- Valid pointcut glob syntax
- Variable reference validation
- Compose rule ordering constraints
- Type-specific validation (workflow vs expansion vs aspect)

Deferred: post-launch polish


Consolidate molecular-chemistry.md with rig-cook-run.md

Merge rig-cook-run.md into molecular-chemistry.md as the canonical chemical algebra spec:
- Rig/Cook/Run as the lifecycle backbone
- Full generation graph: Formula → Compound Formula → Proto → Mol/Wisp
- Bond table at artifact level (symmetric)
- Rig operator at source level
- Unified vocabulary
- Archive or redirect rig-cook-run.md

Consolidated rig-cook-run.md into molecular-chemistry.md. Updated all references.


Map expansion should match nested child steps

Fixed in beads commit de1a9559 - map rules now use buildStepMap to match nested children


Expansion var overrides not implemented


Inline step expansion (Step.Expand field)


Validate expanded step IDs are unique


Support nested expansion formulas


Fanout gate: waits-for children aggregation

Formalize the fanout gate pattern where a step waits for all dynamically-bonded children.

## Current State

Formulas already use this pattern informally:

    step: aggregate
    waits_for: "all-children"

But it is not in the algebra spec or implemented in the cooker.

## Proposed Syntax

    step: aggregate
    needs: [survey-workers]
    waits-for: children-of(survey-workers)

Or simpler:

    step: aggregate
    needs: [survey-workers]
    waits-for: all-children

## Semantics

- Step cannot start until ALL children of the referenced step have completed
- Children are dynamically bonded via for-each (gt-8tmz.8)
- This is the "aggregation" half of the Christmas Ornament pattern
- If no children were bonded, the gate passes immediately

## Use Cases

**Witness Patrol:**
- survey-workers bonds N polecat-arms
- aggregate waits for all arms to complete
- Then proceeds to save-state

**Refinery Patrol:**
- Less common (sequential processing), but useful for parallel test runs

## Relationship to gate

This is a variant of gate where the condition is "all children complete" rather than
an arbitrary expression. Could be implemented as:

    gate:
      condition: "children-of(survey-workers).all(status == complete)"

But dedicated syntax is cleaner for this common pattern.

## Dependencies

- Depends on gt-8tmz.8 (for-each creates the children)
- Depends on gt-8tmz.4 (gate infrastructure)


Control flow: loop, gate, branch

Implement control flow operators for the molecule algebra.

## Core Operators

| Operator | Syntax | Purpose |
|----------|--------|---------|
| loop (fixed) | loop: { count: N, body: [steps] } | Fixed iteration |
| loop (conditional) | loop: { until: COND, max: N, body: [steps] } | Bounded conditional iteration |
| gate | gate: { before: step, condition: COND } | Wait for condition before proceeding |
| branch | branch: { from: step, steps: [a,b,c], join: step } | Parallel paths that rejoin |

Conditions evaluated mechanically (step status, output fields) per gt-8tmz.7.

## Design Review (2025-12-25)

Analyzed patrol patterns (witness, deacon, refinery) to verify these constructs
can express real Gas Town workflows. Key findings:

### Insight: Patrol Loop is OUTSIDE the Algebra

The daemon respawns patrols. Each formula describes ONE cycle. This means:
- Formulas don't need "infinite loop with burn-and-respawn"
- loop is only for **inner loops** (refinery's per-branch processing)
- "burn-or-loop" = complete cycle; daemon decides next action
- Context cycling is external, not algebraic

This significantly simplifies the algebra.

### Gap: for-each is Missing

The current proposal doesn't include for-each, but it's essential for patrol patterns:

| Pattern | Use Case |
|---------|----------|
| Witness survey-workers | For each polecat, bond an arm (parallel) |
| Refinery process-branch | For each branch in queue, run merge pipeline (sequential) |
| Deacon plugin-run | For each plugin where gate open, execute |

Proposed syntax:

    for-each:
      collection: "survey-workers.output.polecats"
      bond: mol-polecat-arm
      vars:
        polecat_name: "{item.name}"
      parallel: true

This overlaps with gt-8tmz.8 (runtime dynamic expansion). Decision needed:
- Include for-each here as control flow, OR
- Ensure gt-8tmz.8 covers these patterns adequately

### Gap: waits-for Gate Variant

The "fanout gate" pattern (aggregate waits for all dynamically-bonded children)
needs formalization:

    step: aggregate
    waits-for: children-of(survey-workers)

Currently exists in formulas as waits_for: "all-children" but not in the algebra spec.

### What This Covers

With these operators (plus for-each), patrols become fully expressible:

**Witness Patrol:**
- for-each polecat -> bond mol-polecat-arm (parallel)
- gate with waits-for: all-children for aggregation

**Refinery Patrol:**
- for-each branch -> process pipeline (sequential)
- gate for test verification before merge

**Deacon Patrol:**
- for-each plugin -> execute if gate open
- Simple sequence otherwise

### Scope Decision

**Option A**: Implement loop, gate, branch now. Track for-each and waits-for separately.

**Option B**: Expand scope to include for-each and waits-for formalization.

Recommendation: Option A - implement core constructs, create child issues for gaps.

Implemented loop, branch, and gate operators. Added LoopSpec, BranchRule, GateRule types. Created controlflow.go with ApplyLoops, ApplyBranches, ApplyGates. Wired into cook.go. All 11 tests pass.


Aspects: AOP cross-cutting concerns

Implement aspect-oriented composition:
- Define aspects with pointcuts and advice
- Apply aspects at bond time: bd bond mol --with-aspect security
- Pointcuts use glob patterns to match join points

Enables security-audit, logging, etc. as reusable concerns.

Aspect composition implemented: compose.aspects field, applied during cooking. Demo: shiny-secure.formula.json


Selection operators: glob, filter, children

Implement selection operators for targeting:
- step(id) - specific step
- glob(pattern) - pattern match (*.implement)
- filter(predicate) - status/output predicates
- children(step), descendants(step) - tree traversal

Used by advice, expansion, and aspects for targeting.

Core selection operators implemented: MatchGlob (glob patterns), MatchPointcut (type, label), MatchAnyPointcut. Advanced operators (filter, children, descendants) can be added as needed.


Condition evaluator for gates and loops

Implement mechanical condition evaluation:
- step.status == 'complete'
- step.output.field == value
- children(step).all(status == 'complete')
- file.exists(path), env.VAR

Keep decidable: no arbitrary code, bounded evaluation.

Implemented condition evaluator in beads formula package


Runtime dynamic expansion (for-each)

Implement runtime expansion for discovered work (the for-each construct).

## Syntax

    step: survey-workers
    on-complete:
      for-each: output.polecats
      bond: mol-polecat-arm
      vars:
        polecat_name: "{item.name}"
        rig: "{item.rig}"
      parallel: true  # or sequential: true

## Design Context (from gt-8tmz.4 review)

This is **control flow**, not just expansion. It affects execution order:
- for-each with parallel: true = concurrent child execution
- for-each with sequential: true = ordered child execution

Key patrol patterns that require this:

| Pattern | Use Case |
|---------|----------|
| Witness survey-workers | For each polecat, bond an arm (parallel) |
| Refinery process-branch | For each branch in queue, run merge pipeline (sequential) |
| Deacon plugin-run | For each plugin where gate open, execute |

## Relationship to gt-8tmz.4

gt-8tmz.4 implements loop, gate, branch (static control flow).
This issue implements for-each (dynamic control flow over runtime-discovered collections).

Together they cover the full control flow needs for patrol formulas.

## Implementation Notes

- Bonds N instances based on step output
- Christmas Ornament pattern: fanout from single step to N parallel children
- Pairs with waits-for gate (gt-8tmz.38) for aggregation
- Collection must be iterable (array in step output)
- Each iteration gets item, index, and parent context in vars

Implemented schema, validation, and parsing for on_complete/for-each. Runtime executor integration (detecting step completion, bonding molecules, parallel/sequential execution) will be handled when the patrol executor is implemented.


gt sling --on flag for wisp scaffolding

Add --on flag to gt sling for applying forms to existing work:
  gt sling shiny gastown/Toast --on gt-abc123

When --on is specified, implies --wisp (scaffolding existing work).
The form shapes execution of the target bead.

Implemented --on flag for formula scaffolding