Check Witness and Refinery health

Check Witness and Refinery health for each rig.

**ZFC Principle**: You (Claude) make the judgment call about what is "stuck" or "unresponsive" - there are no hardcoded thresholds in Go. Read the signals, consider context, and decide.

For each rig, run:
```bash
gt witness status <rig>
gt refinery status <rig>
```

**Signals to assess:**

| Component | Healthy Signals | Concerning Signals |
|-----------|-----------------|-------------------|
| Witness | State: running, recent activity | State: not running, no heartbeat |
| Refinery | State: running, queue processing | Queue stuck, merge failures |

**Tracking unresponsive cycles:**

Maintain in your patrol state (persisted across cycles):
```
health_state:
  <rig>:
    witness:
      unresponsive_cycles: 0
      last_seen_healthy: <timestamp>
    refinery:
      unresponsive_cycles: 0
      last_seen_healthy: <timestamp>
```

**Decision matrix** (you decide the thresholds based on context):

| Cycles Unresponsive | Suggested Action |
|---------------------|------------------|
| 1-2 | Note it, check again next cycle |
| 3-4 | Attempt restart: gt witness restart <rig> |
| 5+ | Escalate to Mayor with context |

**Restart commands:**
```bash
gt witness restart <rig>
gt refinery restart <rig>
```

**Escalation:**
```bash
gt mail send mayor/ -s "Health: <rig> <component> unresponsive" \
  -m "Component has been unresponsive for N cycles. Restart attempts failed.
      Last healthy: <timestamp>
      Error signals: <details>"
```

Reset unresponsive_cycles to 0 when component responds normally.


Check Witness and Refinery health


Nudge newly spawned polecats

Nudge newly spawned polecats that are ready for input.

When polecats are spawned, their Claude session takes 10-20 seconds to initialize. The spawn command returns immediately without waiting. This step finds spawned polecats that are now ready and sends them a trigger to start working.

**ZFC-Compliant Observation** (AI observes AI):

```bash
# View pending spawns with captured terminal output
gt deacon pending
```

For each pending session, analyze the captured output:
- Look for Claude's prompt indicator "> " at the start of a line
- If prompt is visible, Claude is ready for input
- Make the judgment call yourself - you're the AI observer

For each ready polecat:
```bash
# 1. Trigger the polecat
gt nudge <session> "Begin."

# 2. Clear from pending list
gt deacon pending <session>
```

This triggers the UserPromptSubmit hook, which injects mail so the polecat sees its assignment.

**Bootstrap mode** (daemon-only, no AI available):
The daemon uses `gt deacon trigger-pending` with regex detection. This ZFC violation is acceptable during cold startup when no AI agent is running yet.


mol-deacon-patrol

Mayor's daemon patrol loop.

The Deacon is the Mayor's background process that runs continuously, handling callbacks, monitoring rig health, and performing cleanup. Each patrol cycle runs these steps in sequence, then loops or exits.


mol-deacon-patrol


mol-witness-patrol

Per-rig worker monitor patrol loop using the Christmas Ornament pattern.

The Witness is the Pit Boss for your rig. You watch polecats, nudge them toward
completion, verify clean git state before kills, and escalate stuck workers.

**You do NOT do implementation work.** Your job is oversight, not coding.

This molecule uses dynamic bonding to spawn mol-polecat-arm for each worker,
enabling parallel inspection with a fanout gate for aggregation.

## The Christmas Ornament Shape

```
                     ★ mol-witness-patrol (trunk)
                    /|\
          ┌────────┘ │ └────────┐
       PREFLIGHT  DISCOVERY  CLEANUP
          │          │           │
      inbox-check  survey    aggregate (WaitsFor: all-children)
      check-refnry   │       save-state
      load-state     │       generate-summary
                     ↓       context-check
             ┌───────┼───────┐  burn-or-loop
             ●       ●       ●   mol-polecat-arm (dynamic)
            ace     nux    toast
```


Handle callbacks from agents

Handle callbacks from agents.

Check the Mayor's inbox for messages from:
- Witnesses reporting polecat status
- Refineries reporting merge results
- Polecats requesting help or escalation
- External triggers (webhooks, timers)

```bash
gt mail inbox
# For each message:
gt mail read <id>
# Handle based on message type
```

Callbacks may spawn new polecats, update issue state, or trigger other actions.


gt-witness-gastown

Witness - per-rig polecat monitor for gastown.

role_type: witness
rig: gastown
agent_state: idle
hook_bead: null
role_bead: gt-witness-role


Witness Role Definition

You are the Witness - per-rig worker monitor. You watch polecats, nudge them
toward completion, verify clean git state before kills, and escalate stuck
workers to the Mayor.

You do NOT do implementation work. Your job is oversight, not coding.

default_molecule: mol-witness-patrol
capabilities:
  - monitor_workers
  - nudge_stuck
  - pre_kill_verify
  - session_lifecycle
  - escalation

## Core Responsibilities

1. Monitor workers: Track polecat health and progress
2. Nudge: Prompt slow workers toward completion
3. Pre-kill verification: Ensure git state is clean before killing sessions
4. Session lifecycle: Kill sessions, update worker state
5. Self-cycling: Hand off to fresh session when context fills
6. Escalation: Report stuck workers to Mayor

Key principle: You own ALL per-worker cleanup. Mayor is never involved in
routine worker management.

## Propulsion Principle

If you find something on your hook, YOU RUN IT.

Your work is defined by the mol-witness-patrol molecule. Execute steps:
- bd ready (find next step)
- bd show <step-id> (see what to do)
- bd close <step-id> (mark complete)

## Nudge Protocol

Progress through stages. Track nudge count per worker per issue.
- First Nudge (10+ min idle): Gentle inquiry
- Second Nudge (15 min): Direct question
- Third Nudge (20 min): Final warning
After 3 nudges with no progress -> escalate to Mayor

## Pre-Kill Verification

Before killing ANY polecat session:
1. gt polecat git-state <name> - Must be clean
2. Check for uncommitted work
3. Check for unpushed commits
4. Verify issue closed
5. Verify PR submitted (if applicable)

## Commands

- gt polecat list <rig> - See all polecats
- gt polecat git-state <name> - Check git cleanliness
- tmux capture-pane -t gt-<rig>-<name> -p | tail -40 - Session inspection
- gt mail inbox - Check messages
- gt mail send mayor/ -s "Subject" -m "Message" - Escalate


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 5: routine


Layered context onboarding pattern

Pattern from handoff discussion:

## Pattern: Layered Context Onboarding

Town CLAUDE.md (user/org) -> Rig CLAUDE.md (project) -> Role priming

## Ultra-compressed HOP for workers (no reveal)

- Permanent record: All work tracked. Outcomes matter.
- Quality gates: Molecule steps exist for a reason.
- Attribution: Completions build your track record.
- Handoff clean: Leave state any worker can continue.

## Recommendation

Create Town @AGENTS.md for shared worker context that all workers see.
This provides common behavioral guidance without revealing full HOP context.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 7: routine


Add live polling and updates

Implement live polling (500ms default) for activity updates. Merge new events into view without flickering. Show connection status indicator. Handle daemon disconnects gracefully.


Patrol formulas: Inconsistent variable placeholder syntax

The patrol formulas use inconsistent syntax for variable placeholders:

## Inconsistency

| Formula | Syntax | Examples |
|---------|--------|----------|
| mol-polecat-arm | `{{var}}` | `{{polecat_name}}`, `{{rig}}` |
| mol-witness-patrol | `<var>` | `<rig>`, `<handoff-bead-id>` |
| mol-refinery-patrol | `<var>` | `<polecat-branch>` |

## Expected

All formulas should use consistent syntax, probably `{{var}}` since that's what
the variables section defines.

## Fix

Update mol-witness-patrol and mol-refinery-patrol to use `{{var}}` syntax
where appropriate, or document that `<var>` is for human-filled placeholders
vs `{{var}}` for cook-time interpolation.


Molecule converge: iterate until AI says done

Work isn't 'done' until AI is confident it's done. Fixes the 85% problem.

**From VC**: internal/iterative/converge.go - 3-7 iterations with AI convergence detection. ~600 lines.
Target: 20%+ more issues discovered. Observed: ~25% average improvement.

**Gas Town implementation**: Molecule converge config:
```yaml
converge:
  strategy: ai
  min_iterations: 3
  max_iterations: 7
  confidence: 0.85
```

Polecat iterates, AI checks convergence. Stop when AI is confident or max reached.

**Value**: Raw agents get to ~85% and stop. Iteration catches the remaining 15%.

**VC metrics**: Convergence rate >70%, mean 4-5 iterations for complex work.


Day 1.5: Create role beads from CLAUDE.md content

Create role beads from existing CLAUDE.md files:
- gt-mayor-role (from mayor CLAUDE.md)
- gt-witness-role (from witness CLAUDE.md)
- gt-refinery-role (from refinery CLAUDE.md)

Each role bead contains priming instructions and default_molecule.

Parent: gt-d0jqp

Created role beads: gt-mayor-role, gt-witness-role, gt-refinery-role with priming instructions from CLAUDE.md files


ZFC #7: Make message age filtering configurable

**ZFC Violation:** internal/daemon/lifecycle.go:64-75

Go hardcodes 6-hour max message age:
```go
const MaxLifecycleMessageAge = 6 * time.Hour
```

**ZFC-compliant solution:**
- Make this configurable per message type
- Or let agents decide message relevance
- Low priority - not blocking liftoff

Reference: ~/gt/docs/zfc-violations-audit.md #7


announce: shared bulletin board

Announcement channel with shared single-copy storage.

## Deliverables

1. Parse announce:name syntax
2. Shared storage model (like queue, but no claim):
   - Single message copy
   - Multiple readers can view
   - Informational, not work-creating
3. Configuration in ~/gt/config/announce.json
4. Read tracking (optional): who has seen it

## Key semantics
- Informational broadcast
- Missing is OK (not critical)
- Use case: "Bob refactoring logging, be aware"

## Dependencies
- Config directory (gt-i6jvc)
- queue: implementation (pattern reference)

## Acceptance
- announce:status creates single shared message
- Multiple agents can read
- No claim semantics (read-only)


Agent scanner utility for filesystem

Filesystem scanner to discover agent directories in a rig or town.

## Deliverables

1. Function: ScanRigAgents(rigPath) -> []AgentAddr
   - Finds: witness/, refinery/, crew/*, polecats/*
   - Returns normalized addresses (e.g., "gastown/witness")

2. Function: ScanTownAgents(townPath) -> []AgentAddr
   - Iterates all rigs, calls ScanRigAgents for each
   - Returns all agent addresses in town

3. Alias resolution:
   - @rig/gastown → ScanRigAgents("gastown")
   - @town → ScanTownAgents()
   - @witnesses → filter for */witness across all rigs
   - @crew/gastown → filter crew/* in gastown

## Location
internal/discovery/scanner.go (new package)

## Acceptance
- Scanner finds all agent types
- Alias patterns resolve correctly
- Unit tests pass

Obsoleted by agent-as-bead design. Agent discovery now uses bead queries (bd list --type=agent) instead of filesystem scanning.


Support space-separated rig/polecat syntax in gt polecat commands

## Problem
`gt polecat remove beads obsidian` fails with:
```
Error: invalid address 'beads': invalid address format: expected 'rig/polecat', got 'beads'
```

Requires slash syntax: `gt polecat remove beads/obsidian`

## Proposal
Support both syntaxes for ergonomics:
```bash
gt polecat remove beads/obsidian    # address syntax (current)
gt polecat remove beads obsidian    # positional syntax (proposed)
```

## Implementation
In polecat subcommands that take rig/polecat addresses:
- If arg contains `/`, use as-is
- If two args without `/`, join with `/`
- Apply to: remove, status, sync, reset, done

```go
func normalizePolecatAddress(args []string) string {
    if len(args) == 1 && strings.Contains(args[0], "/") {
        return args[0]
    }
    if len(args) == 2 {
        return args[0] + "/" + args[1]
    }
    // error handling...
}
```

## Rationale
- Unambiguous context - polecat commands always take rig + name
- Matches positional arg patterns in docker, kubectl, etc.
- Reduces agent friction (natural first guess is space-separated)
- Slash syntax remains valid for consistency with mail addresses


Add molecule to update local go binary on push to main

When pushing to main branch, automatically rebuild and install the gt binary on the local machine so changes are immediately available.


Add self-check context guidance to role CLAUDE.md files

Each role's CLAUDE.md needs guidance for context self-management:

- After each patrol cycle, self-assess context pressure
- Heuristics: feeling compressed, lots of tool calls, long session
- If triggered: initiate handoff before continuing

Roles to update:
- Mayor (~/gt/CLAUDE.md)
- Witness template
- Refinery template
- Polecat template
- Crew template
- Deacon template

This is the 'inversion of control' - agents decide when to cycle, not external monitoring.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 7: All clear


Add --fart as easter egg alias for bd mol bond

Add a hidden alias for the bond command:

```bash
bd mol fart mol-polecat-work --wisp
# equivalent to:
bd mol bond mol-polecat-work --wisp
```

## Context
The fart joke: instantiating a proto can produce either:
- A Mol (solid/substantial output)
- A Wisp (gas/ephemeral output)

## Implementation
- Add 'fart' as an alias in the mol subcommand
- No documentation needed (easter egg)
- Maybe a fun message: 'Bonding molecule...' or similar

Low priority, just for fun.


Protocol: Type System for Formulas

Protocols define interfaces that formulas implement - a type system for workflows.

## Concept

```toml
# reviewable.protocol
[protocol]
name = "Reviewable"

[requires]
steps = ["review"]  # Must have a step tagged "review"
outputs = ["review_decision"]  # Must produce this

[guarantees]
"review completes before any deploy step"
```

Formulas declare: `implements = ["Reviewable", "Deployable"]`

System verifies compliance statically.

## Use Cases

1. Ensure all deploy formulas have review steps
2. Define compliance requirements as protocols
3. Enable formula discovery: "Give me all Deployable formulas"
4. Validate formula composition compatibility

## Properties

- Static verification (before execution)
- Composable (protocol can extend protocol)
- Documentation value (self-describing contracts)

## Open Questions

1. Protocol syntax - embedded in formula or separate files?
2. Verification timing - cook time? load time?
3. Protocol versioning - how do protocols evolve?
4. Inheritance - can protocols extend other protocols?

## Related

- docs/formula_evolution.md - "Formula Schemas" section
- gt-8tmz - molecule algebra


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 4: All clear


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 5: All healthy.


Day 2.5: Test daemon pokes based on agent state

Integration test:
1. Create agent bead with state=idle
2. Sling work → hook_bead set
3. Verify daemon pokes
4. Update state=running
5. Verify daemon doesn't double-poke
6. Update state=stopped
7. Verify daemon re-pokes on new work

Parent: gt-d0jqp

Testing task - all dependencies complete. Lifecycle wiring verified: gt prime sets state=running, handoff sets state=stopped.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 12: all clear


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 10: all healthy


Remove schedule/phase terminology from code

Temporal/schedule language in identifiers is an anti-pattern.

## Found Issues

### beads repo
- `examples/multi-phase-development/` directory
  - Rename to `examples/dependency-sequenced-work/` or similar

### gastown repo
- `internal/cmd/start.go` lines 178-195
  - Uses "Phase 1:", "Phase 2:", etc. in printf output
  - Change to descriptive names: "Interrupting agents...", "Requesting handoff...", etc.

- `internal/swarm/landing.go` lines ~50-70
  - Comments say "// Phase 1: Stop all polecat sessions"
  - Change to "// Step: Stop all polecat sessions" or just remove phase labels

## Why This Matters

Phase/version language in names:
1. Implies a fixed schedule (antithetical to dependency-driven work)
2. Creates confusion with molecule "phases" (solid/liquid/gas)
3. Encourages temporal thinking that leads to backwards dependencies

## What To Keep

- Molecule phase terminology (pour/wisp/proto) - this is chemistry, not scheduling
- Version fields inside files (version: 1) - this is semantic versioning


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 4: all healthy


Plugin: Plan-to-Epic converter

## Purpose

Help users create beads epics from various planning inputs.

## Inputs
- Markdown task lists
- GitHub issues
- Linear/Jira exports
- Free-form descriptions
- Existing beads epics

## Output
- Beads epic with properly structured children
- Dependencies set for wave ordering
- Priorities assigned
- Ready for `gt spawn --epic <id>`

## Implementation Options

### Option A: CLI Tool
```bash
gt plan import --from github --repo owner/repo --label batch-candidate
gt plan import --from markdown tasks.md
gt plan structure <epic-id>  # analyze and add dependencies
```

### Option B: Plugin Agent
A plugin at `<rig>/plugins/plan-oracle/` that:
- Receives planning requests via mail
- Analyzes scope and requirements
- Creates structured beads epic
- Sets dependencies based on analysis

### Option C: Interactive Mode
```bash
gt plan create
# Walks through questions, creates epic interactively
```

## Axiom

As stated: 'The Planning phase should end in the creation of a workable Beads plan.'

This plugin bridges the gap between human planning and machine-executable work.

## Priority

P2 - Nice to have for MVP. Manual epic creation works for now.

## Note

No "swarm IDs" - output is just a beads epic with children. Workers process it independently.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 7: Routine


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 6: quiet


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 10: All healthy.


Day 4.2: Implement gt polecat nuke command

Add gt polecat nuke <name> command:
- Kill the Claude session
- Delete the worktree
- Delete the branch
- Remove agent bead
- Full cleanup post-merge

Parent: gt-4a2qt


Merge: gt-ldk8

branch: polecat/nux
target: main
source_issue: gt-ldk8
rig: gastown


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 16


Day 4.3: Polecat self-manages session handoffs

**REVISED**: Session cadence is polecat-managed, not mechanically forced by Witness.

Polecats decide when to cycle their own sessions:
1. Work through molecule steps sequentially in one session
2. Close each step as completed (bd close, for activity feed)
3. Self-initiate handoff when: context filling, logical chunk done, or stuck
4. Use: gt handoff -s 'Continuing molecule' -m '<context notes>'

If polecat forgets to handoff:
- Compaction will force it eventually
- Work continues from hook (molecule state preserved)
- No work is lost

Witness role changes:
- Does NOT force recycle between steps
- DOES monitor for stuck (long idle on same step)
- DOES use recycle for stuck recovery (not routine step transitions)
- DOES verify clean state before nuke

This is more ZFC-compliant: polecats report their own needs.


mol-outpost-assign: Intelligent work routing to outposts

The federation design shows outposts.yaml with a static policy section. Simple preference ordering is fine as config, but intelligent work routing should be a molecule.

Current static approach:
```yaml
policy:
  default_preference: [local, gce-burst, cloudrun-burst]
```

Cases requiring cognition:
- "This is a long-running research task, route to VM not CloudRun"
- "This touches sensitive code, keep local"
- "These 5 issues are related, batch them to same outpost"
- "CloudRun cost is high today, prefer local even if slower"

## Molecule: outpost-assign
Intelligent work-to-outpost routing.

## Step: classify-work
Analyze the issue/work item:
- Expected duration (quick fix vs multi-hour)
- Resource requirements
- Sensitivity/security tier
- Related work (same epic?)

## Step: check-capacity
Query outpost status:
- Current load on each
- Cost accrued today
- Health status

## Step: select-outpost
Choose optimal outpost based on:
- Work classification
- Capacity/cost
- Policy constraints
Needs: classify-work, check-capacity

## Step: emit-assignment
Record decision in beads for audit.
Needs: select-outpost

## Notes
- This molecule is invoked by Mayor/Witness when spawning
- Simple cases can short-circuit to static policy
- Full analysis only for ambiguous cases


#channel resolution for real-time broadcast

Wire tmux scanner into nudge system for #channel addresses.

## Deliverables

1. Parse #channel syntax in nudge:
   - #rig/gastown → nudge all running gastown agents
   - #town → nudge all running agents
   - #witnesses → nudge all running witnesses

2. Broadcast logic:
   - Resolve #channel to running sessions
   - Nudge each session
   - Ephemeral (no storage)

## Dependencies
- Tmux session scanner (gt-???)

## Acceptance
- #rig/gastown nudges all running gastown agents
- Ephemeral, no message storage
- Graceful handling of no-sessions


Refactor patrol context functions to reduce duplication

In prime.go, three patrol context functions are nearly identical (~100 lines each):
- outputDeaconPatrolContext() - L797-940
- outputWitnessPatrolContext() - L942-1106
- outputRefineryPatrolContext() - L1108-1272

They all:
1. Check for existing patrol molecule
2. Auto-spawn if none exists
3. Display patrol work loop instructions

**Suggested refactor**:
Extract common logic into a helper:
```go
func outputPatrolContext(ctx RoleContext, patrolName string, assignee string) {
    // shared logic
}
```

Then each role-specific function just calls the helper with appropriate parameters.


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 19: routine


Daemon sends heartbeat to Mayor instead of Deacon

Already fixed in commit b681789 (2025-12-24). pokeMayor was removed in ZFC cleanup - daemon now only pokes Deacon.


Merge: gt-caih

branch: polecat/furiosa
target: main
source_issue: gt-caih
rig: gastown


Day 4.4: Witness calls nuke after MERGED signal

When refinery sends MERGED:
1. Witness receives MERGED mail
2. Witness calls gt polecat nuke
3. Full sandbox cleanup
4. Agent bead removed

Parent: gt-4a2qt


Digest: mol-deacon-patrol

Patrol 16: routine