bd daemon sync: 2026-01-12 21:01:29

.beads/sync_base.jsonl

@@ -22,6 +22,7 @@
 {"id":"nixos-configs-ny8","title":"Evaluate Flake Structure","description":"# Investigation: Flake Structure\n\n## Questions to Answer\n- Is flake.nix well-organized?\n- Are inputs minimal and up-to-date?\n- Is module composition clear?\n\n## Key Files\n- `flake.nix` (9.4KB) - Primary target\n\n## Approach\n1. Use `/humanlayer:research_codebase_nt` to analyze flake.nix organization\n2. Identify unnecessary inputs or outdated patterns\n3. Use `/humanlayer:create_plan_nt` to plan improvements if needed","status":"closed","priority":2,"issue_type":"task","created_at":"2026-01-10T10:08:22.006574928-08:00","created_by":"johno","updated_at":"2026-01-10T10:11:04.339971068-08:00","closed_at":"2026-01-10T10:11:04.339971068-08:00","close_reason":"## Flake Structure Evaluation Summary\n\n### Overall Assessment: Well-Organized\n\nThe flake.nix is reasonably well-organized for a personal NixOS configuration managing multiple machines across different platforms (NixOS, Darwin, Steam Deck).\n\n---\n\n### Inputs Analysis (11 inputs)\n\n**Essential Inputs (correctly configured):**\n- `nixpkgs` (25.11 stable) - Primary nixpkgs\n- `nixpkgs-unstable` - For bleeding-edge packages\n- `home-manager` / `home-manager-unstable` - Properly follows respective nixpkgs\n- `nix-darwin` - For macOS support, follows nixpkgs\n- `nixos-wsl` - For WSL support\n\n**Specialized Inputs (justified):**\n- `plasma-manager` / `plasma-manager-unstable` - KDE configuration\n- `jovian` - Steam Deck support (follows nixpkgs-unstable)\n- `beads` - Task management tooling\n\n**Custom/Private Inputs:**\n- `google-cookie-retrieval` - Personal tool from git.johnogle.info\n\n**Note:** All inputs properly use `follows` for nixpkgs deduplication - this is a best practice.\n\n---\n\n### Module Composition\n\n**Good Patterns:**\n1. **Role-based architecture** - Both system (`roles/`) and home-manager (`home/roles/`) use a role pattern with `mkEnableOption`\n2. **Machine separation** - Each machine has its own `configuration.nix` under `machines/\u003cname\u003e/`\n3. **Stable/Unstable separation** - `nixosModules` vs `nixosModulesUnstable` for different base systems\n4. **Platform separation** - `darwinModules` for macOS-specific configuration\n5. **Overlay pattern** - Clean overlay providing `pkgs.unstable` and `pkgs.custom`\n\n**Machine Coverage:**\n- 7 NixOS systems: nix-book, boxy, wixos, zix790prors, live-usb, nix-deck, john-endesktop\n- 1 Darwin system: johno-macbookpro\n\n---\n\n### Observations\n\n**Strengths:**\n1. Consistent structure across all machine definitions\n2. Home-manager properly integrated with `useGlobalPkgs = true`\n3. Custom packages accessible via `pkgs.custom`\n4. Flake apps for common maintenance tasks (update-doomemacs, upgrade, etc.)\n5. Compatibility shim for bitwarden-\u003ebitwarden-desktop rename\n\n**Minor Issues:**\n1. `wixos` and `zix790prors` include `inputs.home-manager.nixosModules.home-manager` twice (already in nixosModules)\n2. Description is generic (\"A very basic flake\") - could be more descriptive\n3. Some code duplication between nixosModules and nixosModulesUnstable overlays\n\n**Not Issues:**\n- Duplicate plasma-manager inputs (stable/unstable) are intentional for different nixpkgs bases\n\n---\n\n### Recommendations (Optional)\n\n1. **Low priority:** Remove duplicate home-manager imports in wixos/zix790prors\n2. **Low priority:** Update flake description to be more meaningful\n3. **Low priority:** Could extract common overlay logic to reduce duplication\n\nNo blocking issues found. The flake is well-structured for its purpose."}
 {"id":"nixos-configs-pbk","title":"Evaluate Machine Configs","description":"# Investigation: Machine Configs\n\n## Questions to Answer\n- Are machine configs DRY (Don't Repeat Yourself)?\n- Are shared patterns extracted to roles?\n- Are hardware abstractions clean?\n\n## Key Files\n- `machines/*/configuration.nix` - Per-machine patterns\n- `machines/*/hardware-configuration.nix` - Hardware specifics\n\n## Approach\n1. Use `/humanlayer:research_codebase_nt` to analyze machine config patterns\n2. Identify repeated config across machines\n3. Use `/humanlayer:create_plan_nt` to plan extraction of shared patterns","status":"closed","priority":2,"issue_type":"task","created_at":"2026-01-10T10:08:24.907956263-08:00","created_by":"johno","updated_at":"2026-01-10T10:11:48.293696883-08:00","closed_at":"2026-01-10T10:11:48.293696883-08:00","close_reason":"## Machine Configuration Analysis Complete\n\n### Summary\nAnalyzed 8 machine configurations across different platform types:\n- **NixOS Desktop/Laptop**: nix-book, zix790prors, boxy, nix-deck, wixos\n- **NixOS Server**: john-endesktop (ZFS/NFS)\n- **NixOS Live USB**: live-usb\n- **Darwin/macOS**: johno-macbookpro\n\n### DRY Assessment: GOOD\nThe configuration is already well-factored with an extensive roles system covering:\n- `audio`, `bluetooth`, `btrfs`, `desktop`, `kodi`, `nfs-mounts`, `nvidia`, `printing`, `remote-build`, `spotifyd`, `users`, `virtualisation`\n- Desktop sub-roles: `x11`, `wayland`, `kde`, `sddm`, `gaming`, `steamos`\n\nMachine configs are concise (40-115 lines) and focus on machine-specific settings only.\n\n### DRY Violations Identified\n\n**Minor (Low Priority)**:\n1. **Boot loader** - `boot.loader.systemd-boot.enable = true` repeated in 5 machines. Could be a role option, but these are one-liners and machine-specific.\n\n2. **NetworkManager** - `networking.networkmanager.enable = true` in 4 machines. Could be part of desktop role default.\n\n3. **NVIDIA config duplication** - `hardware.nvidia` block duplicated in `zix790prors` and `wixos` with different values. The existing `roles.nvidia` only handles packages, not driver config.\n\n4. **Graphics enable** - `hardware.graphics.enable = true` in 2 machines with manual `enable32Bit`. Could be part of gaming role.\n\n### Hardware Configuration Assessment: CLEAN\nHardware configs properly use `nixos-generate-config` patterns. Notable improvements:\n- `nix-book` and `zix790prors` use the new `roles.btrfs` abstraction for filesystem management with deduplication and scrubbing\n- `nix-deck` uses Jovian modules for Steam Deck hardware\n\n### Recommendations\n\n1. **Extend nvidia role** - Move `hardware.nvidia` and `services.xserver.videoDrivers` config into `roles.nvidia` with options for open driver, power management, etc.\n\n2. **Add AMD GPU role** - Create `roles.amdgpu` for machines like boxy with AMD graphics config.\n\n3. **Consider boot role** - Could add `roles.boot` with common systemd-boot config, but benefit is marginal.\n\n4. **Network role optional** - Could add `roles.network` but current per-machine network config is appropriate for flexibility.\n\n5. **No action needed** - The current structure is already well-organized. The identified duplications are minimal and don't justify immediate refactoring.\n\n### Architecture Quality: HIGH\n- Clean separation: machine-specific vs shared roles\n- Roles are composable with sensible options\n- Hardware configs are properly isolated\n- Flake structure is well-organized with stable/unstable variants\n- Home-manager integration is consistent across machines"}
 {"id":"nixos-configs-pea","title":"Consider removing unused vulkan-hdr-layer package","description":"From Custom Packages evaluation: vulkan-hdr-layer in packages/ appears to be unused anywhere in the configuration. Decide whether to remove it or document its intended use.","status":"open","priority":4,"issue_type":"task","created_at":"2026-01-10T10:31:26.59180827-08:00","created_by":"johno","updated_at":"2026-01-10T10:31:26.59180827-08:00"}
+{"id":"nixos-configs-q3y","title":"Fix kodi role appLauncherServer type error","description":"The kodi role has a type mismatch that breaks `nix flake check`:\n\n```\nerror: In module `machines/boxy/configuration.nix`,\nyou're trying to define a value of type `bool` rather than an\nattribute set for the option `roles.kodi.appLauncherServer`!\n```\n\nThis blocks CI from passing. The option definition in `roles/kodi/default.nix` expects an attribute set but `boxy` is passing a bool.\n\nBlocking: nixos-configs-2hq (CI enablement)","status":"open","priority":1,"issue_type":"bug","created_at":"2026-01-12T21:01:29.195402351-08:00","created_by":"johno","updated_at":"2026-01-12T21:01:29.195402351-08:00"}
 {"id":"nixos-configs-rrb","title":"Evaluate Cross-Platform Patterns","description":"# Investigation: Cross-Platform Patterns\n\n## Questions to Answer\n- Are Darwin/WSL/Steam Deck patterns consistent?\n- Is code reuse maximized across platforms?\n- Are platform-specific concerns properly isolated?\n\n## Key Files\n- Darwin machine configs\n- WSL machine configs\n- Steam Deck configs\n- Platform-conditional role patterns\n\n## Approach\n1. Use `/humanlayer:research_codebase_nt` to analyze cross-platform patterns\n2. Identify platform-specific vs shared code\n3. Use `/humanlayer:create_plan_nt` to plan better code sharing","status":"closed","priority":2,"issue_type":"task","created_at":"2026-01-10T10:08:26.316991479-08:00","created_by":"johno","updated_at":"2026-01-10T10:11:52.982340314-08:00","closed_at":"2026-01-10T10:11:52.982340314-08:00","close_reason":"## Cross-Platform Pattern Evaluation\n\n### Platform Overview\n\nThe repository supports **4 distinct platforms**:\n1. **NixOS** (primary): 6 machines (zix790prors, nix-book, boxy, wixos, nix-deck, john-endesktop)\n2. **Darwin/macOS**: 1 machine (johno-macbookpro/blkfv4yf49kt7)\n3. **WSL (NixOS-WSL)**: 1 machine (wixos)\n4. **Steam Deck**: 1 machine (nix-deck, using Jovian-NixOS)\n\n### Architecture Analysis\n\n#### Are Darwin/WSL/Steam Deck Patterns Consistent?\n\n**MIXED**: The patterns are partially consistent but have notable differences:\n\n**Consistent patterns:**\n- All platforms use home-manager for user configuration\n- All home configs import `./roles` (shared) + platform-specific base role\n- Use of `home.roles` option system across all platforms\n- Common `home.stateVersion = \"24.05\"` across all configs\n\n**Inconsistent patterns:**\n- WSL config embeds NVIDIA/graphics config directly rather than using a role\n- Steam Deck uses `nixosModulesUnstable` (different module set) vs stable for others\n- Darwin uses completely separate `darwinModules` with different role structure\n\n#### Is Code Reuse Maximized?\n\n**PARTIALLY - Rating: 7/10**\n\n**Good reuse:**\n- Home roles are well-factored - most roles work cross-platform\n- `base` role uses `pkgs.stdenv.isLinux` for conditional behavior\n- `emacs` role uses `pkgs.stdenv.isDarwin` to select macport vs standard emacs\n- `aerospace` role properly guards Darwin-only features with assertion\n- Shared wallpaper config across i3, sway, plasma-manager, sketchybar\n\n**Duplication found:**\n1. **roles/default.nix vs roles/darwin.nix**: ~50% duplicated code\n   - Both define: time.timeZone, environment.systemPackages, nix.* settings\n   - Darwin lacks: i18n settings, xserver.xkb, openssh, emergency mode config\n   \n2. **Flake module lists**: nixosModules/nixosModulesUnstable/darwinModules have overlapping overlay configs\n\n3. **Home paths**: Darwin uses `/Users/johno` vs Linux `/home/johno` - handled correctly with mkForce\n\n#### Are Platform-Specific Concerns Properly Isolated?\n\n**GOOD - Rating: 8/10**\n\n**Well isolated:**\n- `home/roles/base-darwin` imports aerospace (Darwin-only)\n- `home/roles/base-linux` imports plasma-manager, i3+sway (Linux-only)\n- `aerospace` role has explicit Darwin assertion\n- System roles (audio, bluetooth, desktop, etc.) are NixOS-only in roles/default.nix\n- Steam Deck config imports `roles/desktop/steamos.nix` for Jovian integration\n\n**Could improve:**\n- WSL-specific config inline in machine config rather than a `wsl` role\n- NVIDIA config duplicated in wixos vs using roles.nvidia\n\n### Key Findings\n\n#### Cross-Platform Role Structure\n```\nhome/roles/\n  default.nix          -- Shared roles (imported by all)\n  base-darwin/         -- Darwin-specific (aerospace)\n  base-linux/          -- Linux-specific (plasma-manager, i3+sway)\n  aerospace/           -- Darwin-only with assertion\n  plasma-manager/      -- Linux-only (imported via base-linux)\n  i3+sway/            -- Linux-only (imported via base-linux)\n  [other roles]        -- Cross-platform\n```\n\n#### Platform Conditionals Found (4 instances)\n1. `packages/claude-code/default.nix:42` - autoPatchelfHook for Linux\n2. `home/roles/emacs/default.nix:23` - emacs-macport vs emacs\n3. `home/roles/base/default.nix:34` - randomizedDelaySec only on Linux\n4. `home/roles/aerospace/default.nix:116` - Darwin-only assertion\n\n### Recommendations\n\n1. **Extract shared system config**: Create `roles/common.nix` for settings shared between NixOS and Darwin (timezone, nix settings, base packages)\n\n2. **Create WSL role**: Move wixos NVIDIA/graphics config to `roles/wsl.nix` for reusability\n\n3. **Consolidate flake overlays**: The overlay configuration is repeated 3x - could extract to a function\n\n4. **Document platform matrix**: Add comments in flake.nix explaining which modules support which platforms\n\n5. **Consider conditional imports**: Some roles (desktop, communication) have Linux-only packages but no guards - could add `lib.optionals pkgs.stdenv.isLinux`"}
 {"id":"nixos-configs-tcu","title":"Add platform compatibility guards to cross-platform roles","description":"From Cross-Platform evaluation: Some roles like desktop and communication contain Linux-only packages but no guards. Add lib.optionals pkgs.stdenv.isLinux where appropriate to prevent issues on Darwin.","status":"open","priority":3,"issue_type":"task","created_at":"2026-01-10T10:31:29.864582809-08:00","created_by":"johno","updated_at":"2026-01-10T10:31:29.864582809-08:00"}
 {"id":"nixos-configs-tdf","title":"Add skill to import Gitea issues as beads","description":"Create a skill that imports open Gitea issues as beads, skipping those already imported","notes":"Technique from session:\n\n1. Use `tea issues` to list open issues (not curl)\n2. Use `tea issue N` to get full details\n3. Check existing beads with `bd list` to find already-imported issues\n4. Skip PRs that have bead IDs in title (e.g. '[nixos-configs-xxx]') or body ('Bead ID: xxx')\n5. For new issues, create bead with:\n   - Appropriate type (bug/feature/task based on issue content)\n   - Priority P2 default\n   - Notes containing Gitea issue URL\n   - Description from issue body\n6. Report what was imported vs skipped","status":"open","priority":2,"issue_type":"feature","created_at":"2026-01-10T12:29:28.686736386-08:00","created_by":"johno","updated_at":"2026-01-10T12:29:28.686736386-08:00"}